6 ms·
>) For niche channels, like my own, it can be easy to have the views but difficult to have the subscribers. These two should not be tied together for purposes o
by mc32 9y ago
>) For niche channels, like my own, it can be easy to have the views but difficult to have the subscribers. These two should not be tied together for purposes of monetization.
I completely agree.
I've saved hundreds of dollars [and time] on car maintenance/repairs and plumbing by watching some guy or gal on youtube with very specific information (for a given make/model/year) for example.
I hope these kinds of instructional videos get a reprieve because many many people use them and save tons of money and time [finding manuals and reading them is arduous].
This could be a terrible loss for some audiences as well as the creators who get compensated, slim as it may be.
- Nition 9y agoHonestly I think people will keep making those sorts of videos anyway. We never get paid anything for posting on Stack Overflow or Hacker News yet here we are. And YouTube had lots of good videos before it had monetisation.
- mc32 9y agoPerhaps. I think there are people in places [even in the US] where money goes further for whom a dozen dollars here, a dozen dollars there from different uploads made it worthwhile for them. I hope you are right, but I fear we might lose some great contributors.
- Scoundreller 9y agoI guess Google will have the data to know for sure. But will they backtrack if they’re wrong, or just accept it as collateral damage?
- eqtn 9y agoIf they do, then that is great. Since there is no compensation from youtube, these creators should upload the content to a bunch of online streaming platforms.
- yAnonymous 9y ago>We never get paid anything for posting on Stack Overflow or Hacker News yet here we are. Speak for yourself.
- eropple 9y ago> We never get paid anything for posting on Stack Overflow or Hacker News yet here we are. About 30% of my consulting revenue last year came directly from "I saw you on Hacker News and--". It is rather harder for a car mechanic to do that.
- AJ007 9y agoRight, but if even 5% of car mechanics were making Youtube videos only a few would still be able to make a meaningful amount of money off of them. A car mechanic capable of adapting to a new technology early, and building an audience off of that is more than just a car mechanic. If you benefit from a disruptive technology, you can't expect the "new normal" to persist indefinitely. The ride certainly may not be free or easy, but it would be abnormal for it not to change. This whole thing seems very reminiscent of SEO about a decade ago. It was still fairly new and thousands of people built incomes and entire businesses with employees around it. In some cases a search algorithm update wiped out all of their audience. Of course, in nearly every case those impacted immediately blamed Google. When something is fairly new, the first movers often get outsized benefits. You have less competition which makes the ability to both capture and monetize an audience easier. As the market matures more competitors appear. If the pie doesn't grow as fast as the new competitors arriving, all participants earn less profits. The results of what Google/Youtube is doing now is just bringing the same effects early. The future of Youtube producers will consist of less search visibility combined with ad revenue divided more ways. 15+ years of double digit only advertising growth has gone a long way to mask the audience problem (and when it ends it is going to result in massive changes to Google.)
- munificent 9y agoWould you still be here or on StackOverflow if you knew that some of the contributors were "gold members" who got directly paid while you didn't? We participate in these places for the intangible rewards and one of those, I believe, is feeling that we are helping to foster an egalitarian community. When the community is explicitly tiered and money-based, is that still something people will want to chip in to out of the goodness of their hearts?
- sillysaurus3 9y agoSure, but why does youtube need to care? From their perspective, those videos probably aren't helping their bottom line. It might be better if they weren't uploaded in the first place: Less disk space used, no need to index them, etc. (I echo your agreement, for what it's worth.)
- mc32 9y agoI do believe you are right. The ROI on these videos for YT, is likely very minimal, given opp cost. On the other hand, it creates awesome goodwill.
- Scoundreller 9y agoAnd how much does a cursory Manual review cost? Econ 101 is that you should match marginal cost to marginal revenue. YT is leaving money on the table here.
- Scoundreller 9y agoThey're profitable videos to advertisers. You always end up buying a part or tool (or new car? Muffler fix video --> Check out the new Tesla). Often paying a premium to get the part tomorrow. The manual review shouldn't take more than 7 seconds.
- dagw 9y agoSure, but why does YouTube need to care? Those videos get me to YouTube in the first place. Once there they can try to get me to watch 'better' videos and the videos I do watch gives them lots of useful information about me that they can sell to advertisers.
- darepublic 9y agoThese videos get me to youtube, but I only watch them, I don't watch segments of Jimmy Kimmel like a chump. Also: adblocker.
- mfrommil 9y ago
- cloudwalking 9y ago99% of the affected channels make less than $100 per year. I don't think most of these types of videos are made with a plan to make money. I think people like making videos explaining things they understand.
- manmal 9y agoExactly. If they care about monetization, they would sell merchandise or use Patreon or similar.
- gm3dmo 9y agoI've gone with patreon to support smaller channels, 1 to 10 dollars each, budget 20 dollars a month. Mentions among creators drives me to new channels and I add to Patreon.
- Macha 9y agoThe TOS bans patreon etc. links unless you meet monetisation requirements: https://www.polygon.com/2017/9/28/16380186/youtube-patreon-demonetization-policy https://www.polygon.com/2017/9/28/16380186/youtube-patreon-d...
- sundvor 9y agoHa. That's gold.
- gkya 9y agoIf you have a following in Patreon or any other similar platform, it shouldn't be that hard to jump ship and start uploading somehwere else. Any serious internet publisher should have at least one alternate channel for followers. I'd go with Twitter and a newsletter, so if YouTube decides to screw me, I can tell people "hey, I'm moving to [random platform here]". Patreon allows you to communicate with your followers too, so going, you can take your actual contributing followers with you wherever you want (theoretically).
- 9y ago
- someone454 9y agoI agree. I have found a lot of value in channels with very niche information on a wide variety of topics.