4 ms·
Great. /s I published ONE video about how to easily fix a head-scratching computer hardware problem, because there isn't any other guide on it. I get about 10
by Scoundreller 9y ago
Great. /s
I published ONE video about how to easily fix a head-scratching computer hardware problem, because there isn't any other guide on it.
I get about 1000 views a month, tons of thank yous and make a few dollars.
Because I won't get 4000 hours of watch time[1], and nobody will subscribe, I'll get squat.
And zero motivation to publish more videos.
The next time I figure out a life-trick[2], I won't bother.
Who subscribes to videos about fixing stuff anyway?
[1] Don't you hate those videos that are 5x longer than necessary? WHY ENCOURAGE THAT?
[2] That fancy French mustard you bought? Don't bother with your hands. You'll need to use a corkscrew to open it.
- dmix 9y agoWhat's the motivation here then? To stop paying money to one-hit wonders and funnel it only to the professional/serious content producers? I don't really understand why that'd be necessary. Youtube makes some strange choices with their monetization. I really wonder why they are so obsessed with finely controlling who can profit from producing good content on their platform. Why not let a) the users and b) the advertisers decide this? Who is losing out here, absent their preemptive interventions? If they keep this up it might highly incentivize a decentralized video platform with a built-in monetization scheme.
- notatoad 9y agoAs a guess, they are moving to implement a much more stringent manual review of monetized channels, and the change to the eligibility criteria is an effort to reduce the number of monetized channels to a number that's more feasible to review. But if that's the case, I wonder why they don't just say it. >Why not let... the advertisers decide this? The advertiser's have been pretty clear they want YouTube to be the content police. That's what the big advertiser revolt a few months ago was about.
- shostack 9y agoThat's an interesting take when you start factoring in the broader landscape. Video is no longer about just the short form, and increasingly attention is pulled away from Youtube by services like Netflix, Amazon Prime, and FB's video play. I wonder how much video CPMs (particularly mid-roll) and the premium big brands are willing to pay plays a role in this vs something like a desire to growing engagement. If you incentivize creators to attract subscribers, and you have more direct ability to control messaging channels to subscribers as a platform, you might gain some levers in driving revenue that may not have existed or had as large an impact before. You also nurture desirable user-base behaviors.
- Scoundreller 9y agoJust multi-tier it. You can pay more if you only want your ads against thoroughly vetted content. Or pay less if you don't care. Less video to bid against will raise ad costs for everyone.
- Scoundreller 9y agoNo idea. I just met their new criteria for 10000 views before monetization, which should mean I've already been vetted? Does a company like Google really need human review on videos? With 10k views, their AI/ML should detect what's risky content or not based on what they know about users. Here's a great video that we'll see less of: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDB2QVEuy60 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDB2QVEuy60 A well-produced 36 second video on replacing your Corolla's brake light, rather than a 5 minute video going blah blah blah. And I'll never subscribe.
- intended 9y agoAgain that level of AI/ML means being able to state what the intent of a comment or document is. If we ever get close to that point, that programs can reliably mark something as "risky" content, human thought is in big trouble. "Risky" material is subjective. Something even humans can't make out reliably very often. I think, this is the result of the tech firms putting content creators of old out of business, but not investing in the necessary editorial power, subscribing instead to the "wisdom of the crowds" school of thought. They have not paid for (and will not be able to afford) the distributed human editorial power which was lost.
- Scoundreller 9y agoIt doesn't need to be perfect, just reliable enough to determine what needs more thorough review. A 2 minute video titled "How to fix your computer's _______", that is linked from fixit forums, that is universally liked with comments stating "Wow, that worked, thanks!" shouldn't even need human review to determine risk. The comparison alone to other videos with similar characteristics should do it.
- intended 9y agoHow, all human activities have adversarial components to it- especially when there’s a financial pay off involved. People will just got the comments. And that’s over the naturally noisy data set of human behavior. Not to mention cultural norms across all nations in the world - I know many Indian user forums where even mildly helpful or unhelpful videos/posts will receive “thank you, could you help with...” posts.
- pero 9y ago> What's the motivation here then? I'd guess it's some sort of legal/accounting move, something beneath the surface. Doesn't really make much sense otherwise.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoThe motivation is obvious when you look at it from youtube's perspective. They do not value content creators much, but they lick the boots of advertisers. They want to create a system that is as smooth for advertisers as possible, regardless of the impact on any other aspect of the platform. They want to reduce the risk of bad PR (which causes advertisers to run away). All they care about is the product of eyeball counts and ad impressions yielding dollars, they don't understand at all the goose that lays the golden egg or how easy it is to kill it.
- dingaling 9y ago> And zero motivation to publish more videos. Why not? You're posting on HN without financial reward.
- Fuckthisboard 9y agoThe reward of being down voted by you cunts you mean?
- piyush_soni 9y agoWhich takes a lot less effort than creating, editing, post-processing and uploading videos.
- gkya 9y agoSome months ago when Alan Kay did an AmA, I asked a question to him and got answered. A CS star from thousands of kilometers apart. I can "bump into" many domain experts hereabouts. People like Walter Brigt are regularly posting, and I, as a hacker that's aiming to do humanities in academia as his professional career, it's incredibly exciting to have the chance to interact with this sort of people. I don't think one needs further rewards, and otherwise he is plain greedy as fuck.
- arca_vorago 9y ago"Don't you hate those videos that are 5x longer than necessary? WHY ENCOURAGE THAT?" From googles perspective it's because they don't care about the user, and are cowtowing to the advertisers. Longer videos mean more ads, which means more $$$. I wish google had never bought youtube... I knew they would ruin it eventually. I think the real discussion here though is more meta than just google... we have allowed advertisers to gain way too much power on the internet, and if we aren't careful they will ruin us just like they did newspapers. This isn't just advertisers though, this is the general business model of internet companies. Here is the pattern: 1) Create cool new thing, with no ads, no tracking. Users love it and it spreads like wildfire. 2) Slowly boil the frog. Start tracking users and selling user data to third parties, justified under esoteric EULAs and TOS. Start small, unobtrusive ads. 3) Make the ads more prominent, more frequent, and harder to skip/ignore. 4) Allow your platform to be used as a corporate promotion tool that's more like sockpuppet central than regular advertising. Bots talking to bots, subtle corporate products in memes, etc. 5) Now that you have completely aliented the userbase, now is the time to ramp up all of the above and then go public, ride the boom wave up, and at peak sell a massively overvalued company to some dumbass group/company/people, run away with the cash, and take video of your product as it burns to the ground. The users will stick around until someone else starts at 1 and does the same thing but under a different name.
- corobo 9y ago> I wish google had never bought youtube... I knew they would ruin it eventually. If Google hadn't bought YouTube, YouTube would no longer exist.
- Goladus 9y agoReally? I would find that story interesting reading if you'd be willing to share.
- magila 9y agoThere's not really that much to it. Pre-acquisition Youtube was burning through cash at a rapid and increasing rate. There was clearly no way they were going to find a revenue source which would even come close to covering their operating expenses. Google was one of only a few companies who were willing and able to keep Youtube going as a loss leader.
- yAnonymous 9y ago>The next time I figure out a life-trick[2], I won't bother. Your motivation for uploading that one video was money? Just wondering, because if that was the case I'd expect you to have more than one video. And 1000 views a month is nothing. Certainly not enough to expect any kind of worthwhile revenue.
- mrweasel 9y agoI doubt that your video is making Youtube any money with a 1000 views a month on a niche subject. Yet they let you stay on their platform, for free. Most videos like yours aren't made to make $2 extra each month, they're made because people wanted to share the information. Youtube provides a platform, allowing people to distribute videos, for free. The most prolific content producers are given a cut of the profit, or make their advertising deals.
- piyush_soni 9y agoThey 'let us stay' because they're net profitable by that video being there, not out of charity. For some in poor countries, those extra $2 a month do matter.
- beokop 9y agoYou can’t have it both ways. YouTube is providing a free video hosting service, something that is way more valuable for the creator (poor country or not) than $2/month.
- throwaway7312 9y agoWhen I was in business school, we had a case study of a large supermarket chain that carried 18,000 or so different items per store. The management team wanted to save on cost and narrow down to just the essentials the chain's customers bought. So they did an analysis and determined that only 6,000 or so of the products they carried sold in any significant amount. The other 12,000 were niche items that sold in small quantities and made little money. Before they nixed the other 9,000 products though, the company decided to make one additional analysis, of who bought what in what combination. And it discovered all those little items were being bought in small quantities by people who bought large quantities of the big items. The analysis further determined that if the supermarket nixed those 9,000 niche products, it would no longer be the "one stop shop" for its customers. Those customers would only be able to buy some of what they needed at the supermarket, and would need to buy the rest elsewhere. If a competing supermarket carried all of what a customer needed, that customer would eventually learn to do all his shopping at that supermarket to save the hassle of needing to journey to 2+ places to get what he needed. After this final analysis, the supermarket chain decided to keep almost all the products it kept on its shelves, eliminating only 200 or 300 products, instead of 9,000. It was not so much that the supermarket was very nice and charitable to niche spices and exotic Asian sauces and imported curries and whatnot. Rather, it was that the supermarket realized that if its customers could not find everything they wanted on its shelves, they would eventually find everything they wanted on a competitor's shelves instead. In YouTube's case, no good competitor presently exists. But a big part of the reason why is because YouTube has sucked all the oxygen out of the video hosting and streaming niche by being a one-stop shop. If it stops being that, there will be a lot more oxygen in that niche again. (that said, I do not think demonetizing videos with low view counts / subscriber numbers constitutes injecting oxygen back into the market. "Not letting" niche video creators user their platform, however, probably would)
- balls187 9y ago> Who subscribes to videos about fixing stuff anyway? Me. I subscribed to a few DIY home repair channels, plus a channel on modding a Mark7 Golf R.