32 ms·
The brains of jazz and classical pianists work differently
- itaris 9y agoThis makes sense, one is far more focused on precise articulation of a prepared score, while the other is focused (in large part) on improvisation.
- Tycho 9y agoYeah, the opposite conclusion would have been much more surprising.
- wickawic 9y agoI would also say that in Jazz the rhythm of the music plays an outsized role as compared to classical. If you don’t “swing”* you can’t play with anyone and certainly can’t play jazz. On the other hand, classical musicians care about dynamics and tone in a way that doesn’t register wth Jazz musicians. Neither way is better, but they are almost like opposite approaches to music. *By swing I mean more than just syncopate with the rest of the band. “To swing” in a jazz context means to be able to play exactly in time with the rest of the band, except when you don’t (but you are in control). A very confused concept, read wikipedia for more info. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swing_(jazz_performance_style) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swing_(jazz_performance_styl...
- itaris 9y agoVery true that rhythm plays a huge role in jazz. Although, I'm not sure that I agree that dynamics and tone aren't as important in jazz.
- beat 9y agoTone isn't that important in jazz. Hence, the importance of the saxophone, an instrument rightly reviled in classical music for mostly sounding awful. I'm only half joking here. I'm a guitarist, and was having a conversation with a trumpet-playing friend once. I was talking about the technical struggle of legato playing at speed, something hard for trumpet players as well, but easy for saxophones. My friend was like "Yeah, but they have to play the saxophone". Few players can get a beautiful sound out of it, and only after years of struggle. Brass and guitars, on the other hand, have naturally beautiful tone, and are easy to get to sound nice. The importance of melody over tone, and the melodic advantages of the saxophone, explain its popularity in jazz.
- yesenadam 9y agoYou don't like the sound of saxophones? Wow. Well, everyone has their own sound on saxophone, 'the sound of saxophones' doesn't mean much. Not sure why you think trumpet is vastly easier to get a beautiful sound from than saxophone. That's silly. The importance of melody over tone? Wow, never heard of that. All you say sounds like you are judging jazz by classical (I imagine) criteria, and of course it doesn't do well.
- beat 9y agoIt's my observations as a jazz musician and a tone nerd. The buzzy, shrill reed sound of the saxophone is difficult for the ear. Trumpets are much closer to the human voice. I've come to prefer saxophonists who revel in the ugliness of its tone, and push its other forms of expressiveness - not just melody, but the marvelous squawky tones only a saxophone can make. (That said, I'm a huge fan of modern master Kamasi Washington, who has a luscious tone.) Look at it another way... would you rather listen to doves, or geese? Tonal beauty is objective.
- yesenadam 9y ago(Tries not be be snarky) You didn't respond to any of my points. Why don't you start playing trumpet, see for yourself how 'easy to get to sound nice' trumpet is. Everything you say seems wrong to me, except when you say what you like.
- beat 9y agoLike Dizzy Gillespie once said, "None of them blow easy". Yes, it's difficult to get good tone out of trumpets. Or violins, or guitars, or drums, or any other instrument. But assuming a skilled player, the tone of trumpet is more appealing to our ears than the tone of saxophones. It's ultimately easier to have nice trumpet tone than nice saxophone tone. Doves vs geese (or more correctly, elephants vs geese). I've put in a couple of solid decades trying to improve my tone, and practice regularly to work on tonal issues. I appreciate the difficulty that any instrument represents.
- wickawic 9y agoOh I totally would argue that position. (I am much more familar with jazz than classical). My main argument would come from how the two camps tend to practice. Generally jazz musicians will learn the 'changes' (key changes, common chord progression shapes) to a song, and the melody if it has one. At that point they start improvising. If they are really good their improvisation will include dynamic shifts and they will have good tone, but that tone may clash with other instruments. A jazz player will often learn a song before knowing in what arrangement they will be playing, and will play the same song in many different arrangements. On the other hand, classical music has tone and dynamics written into the score itself. The entire point of the conductor is to anthropomorphize these features of the music, so you know when she is flailing violently you should play differently than when she is shushing you. Additionally, the tone/timbre of the whole piece is set in stone by the composer; A classical orchestra would never think it was ok to let the flutes take a melody written for the trumpets, etc.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agoyes. for those confused- where you put things relative to the metronomic beat (center of the beat) matters hugely. depending on styles and settings, bass will be slightly ahead, drums behind, guitar right on top etc. its cruical to hear everyone else in the band the way they hear themselves, relative to the beat. otherwise people think they are being rushed or dragged and it just doesnt congeal. and the feeling when it congeals is like being weightless, its truly great. it may sound trivial to the uninitiated, but its maybe the most important thing for bands, at least in my experience
- beat 9y agoSome of my best music lessons were around rhythm. Early on as a musician, I spent time playing reggae, with a bassist who wanted a guitarist, and was willing to put up with my innocence. He taught me a beat isn't an exact point in time, but rather sort of a region of probability, where sound is more or less likely to occur. Notes can begin or end at any point in a beat. The difference between reggae and ska is largely that in reggae, guitars and snare drum happen late in the beat, and in ska, it happens early. The former sounds languid, the latter frenetic. Same chords, same tempo, same "beat". The other great lesson came from the jazz/rock drummer, Steve Smith. He describes "swing" as the simplest possible polyrhythm - a diminishment of three against two. Once you have three against two, you can start stripping out duplicates, until your down to ding ding da-ding ding da-ding ding... sound familiar? You get a strong backbeat (2 and 4), and an anticipation note at the very end of a bar before starting the next. Now, that anticipation note can be shifted earlier or later within its own beat, making things tighter or looser. That's swing.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agowell there is one rub with swing which is that at faster tempos i think alot of people imply it less with note length and more with strong-weak dynamic, since its kind of hard when you are at 280+ to really keep the triplet legit. for drums i guess think of the "mueller stroke". angelo debarre is a counter example i guess, he still uses triplet like eight notes at crazy tempos, but for the most part i think people dont do that.
- Mediterraneo10 9y ago> I would also say that in Jazz the rhythm of the music plays an outsized role as compared to classical. If you don’t “swing” you can’t play with anyone and certainly can’t play jazz. A great deal of European jazz (represented by, for example, ECM) does not have have the concept of rhythmic swing. Unfortunately, there’s a tendency to talk about jazz as if the genre is purely the music of the New Orleans-Chicago corridor in early 20th century America, and jazz now has far too many subgenres in order for a claim about one to hold true for others. (Even improvisation is no longer de rigeur, and an artist may well perform from a written score.)
- wickawic 9y agoI'm really interested in that. Do you have any songs/records in mind? Googling 'ECM Jazz' doesn't seem to bring up a wealth of relevant results.
- Mediterraneo10 9y agoECM has recently become available on streaming platforms, but the label acts quite aggressively against YouTube uploads of its music, so you’ll either need to use a streaming service or seek out the physical disc. However, I think that releases on the label like the Christian Wallumrød Ensemble’s The Zoo is Far or Vassilis Tsabropoulos’s Archirana would serve as good examples (just two among myriad) of how certain forms of jazz exist quite apart from traditional American expectations.
- yesenadam 9y agoWell, they don't use the word jazz. It's Manfred Eicher's German label. Keith Jarrett, for example, has released dozens (100+, I imagine) of recordings on ECM.
- Mediterraneo10 9y ago> It's Manfred Eicher's German label. ...which since the 1970s has had a huge amount of Norwegian and Swedish (and more) musicians recording for the label, and recording sessions are often held in Oslo or Lugano. German headquarters, but more than just a German label.
- stuffedBelly 9y agowhenever I need to explain swing, I refer people to some Texas shuffle playing from SRV. Not jazz per se, but most of his blues rhythmic playing accentuates swinging quite a lot.
- tunesmith 9y agoIt almost seems as if what they're really testing is the difference between practice and performance. Some of jazz is actually making a mistake "work" for you by how you recover. (It's a myth that jazz improvisers always know what they're about to play.)
- maldusiecle 9y agoI wonder how this applies to pianists who excel at both classical and jazz--Keith Jarrett, for example.
- ta76567656 9y agoOr to classical organists, one of the few classical specialties that has preserved improvisation as a major part of their skillset. (In the times that classical music was composed, musicians were encouraged/expected to be able to improvise. E.g baroque & classical period concertos where the cadenza was essentially an empty space in the sheet music that meant "improvise here". Some of Handel's organ concertos have no second movement written down because he would just improvise.)
- devnonymous 9y agoNot sure whether parent is deliberately trolling but literally, the first two words of the article are Keith Jarrett. The statement describes how it applies to his music.
- kleer001 9y agoThey probably just didn't bother reading the article. A sin I often fall to, so...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- maldusiecle 9y agoYou're right, I replied before clicking the link. Couldn't find a delete button, so I'll let it stand.
- SwellJoe 9y agoThe mention of Jarrett in the article is what led to me asking throughout the article, "But what about musicians who are famously accomplished at both?!" They quoted Jarrett but didn't really expand on it, other than to use it as an argument from authority in support of what they think their study means about how the brains of musicians work. The study included people who aren't at all like Jarrett (they are either/or musicians, while Jarrett is a both and then some musician), so the quote felt vaguely forced into place.
- djtriptych 9y agoThis is amazing. I'm a classical guitarist and pianist (not any good, but it's very clearly the way I'm oriented). Jazz just seems to escape me, although I work much harder at it.
- darethas 9y agoWithin my own self, I have a dichotomy. When I am on the piano and reading from sheet music, I feel "classical." I am a bit more deliberate and I stumble a few times. When I am on my guitar, I mostly play by ear and feel. I throw on a backing track and just improvise the entire time. Anything accidental slips I have get incorporated into what I am playing. I have tried to reverse the two (play classical guitar, and improve piano) and I simply cannot, or I look like an absolute beginner.
- dahart 9y agoDepends a bit on what you're trying to do, but jazz requires a lot more theory up front in order to be good at it. It might be extra difficult to approach jazz as a classical musician, to try and use the same tools and techniques. There might be ways to think about jazz that make it a lot easier for you, if you are interested. One of the things that has really helped me with jazz is going through the older standards and singing the voice line while comping the chords on the guitar. Not only is it super fun to play and sing at the same time, but it gives a much better understanding of why the chords are there and what they're trying to do.
- hprotagonist 9y agoFamously, violinists have over-represented left hand non-thumb fingers in right motor cortex: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18028115 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18028115 Plasticity is normal.
- Meerax 9y agoConservatory grad here. I used to joke with fellow music majors when one of us would do something particularly clumsy that it was very ironic since we were essentially majoring in hand-eye coordination. This study is news to me, thank you for sharing.
- jawilson2 9y agoHmm...but most of the required fine dexterity is in your non-dominant hand. I wonder if some right-handed brain real estate is being repurposed for your left hand (if you are a righty).
- InitialLastName 9y agoThis is something many people think, but isn't necessarily true. Yes, the left hand fingering requires dexterity, but the dynamics, timing, and much of the tone come from very fine movements of the right hand. If you think about the bow as a lever, tiny movements at the fulcrum make enormous differences to the forces applied in the middle or at the end. So there's less finger motion, but more fine adjustment happening at the right hand than many people think.
- hmahncke 9y agoRight brain controls left hand (the brain brain is weird that way) so the dexterity required for fingering in the left hand is governed by plasticity and over-representation in the right brain.
- jawilson2 9y agoRight, but there is also a lot of evidence (or at least it looked like there would be when I was in the field 5+ years ago), that it isn't that simple, and there is also considerable ipsilateral motor control in the cortex as well. This would make sense for activities that require coordination between both hands, so that, in the motor cortex, we wouldn't have the case where "the right hand doesn't know what the left hand is doing." So, if there is MORE coordination required than in a typical cortex, maybe non-coordinated tasks become clumsier? I have no idea. Maybe musical people tend to spend less time doing non-musical athletic things, and aren't as graceful? Maybe both, or something else? Sounds like a cool imaging project for a neuroscience or BME grad student.
- hathawsh 9y agoI especially appreciate pianists who seem to bridge this divide. Jon Schmidt of the Piano Guys seems to be able to fluidly combine classical style and jazz improvisation in the same song. Check this out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZPSV78iQxg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZPSV78iQxg I saw them perform the song live and he (they) really did switch styles without missing a beat.
- jrowley 9y agoHere's a nice example from jazz bassist Ray Brown & guitarist Laurindo Almeida: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUzknDfC_eQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUzknDfC_eQ They created a beautiful medley of Moonlight Sonata by Beethoven and the jazz standard, Round Midnight by Thelonious Monk
- jacquesm 9y agoCheck out Friedrich Gulda (he's both a classical and a jazz pianist as well as a composer). https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=friedrich+gulda https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=friedrich+gulda
- joebergeron 9y agoIf anyone is interested in exploring this style of music in more depth, I recommend looking into "Third Stream" music. It's meant to be a sort of fluid combination of both jazz and classical styles, and is often pretty interesting. There's a whole lot of things that third stream music /isn't/ (and famously, a list that attempts to define the genre in terms of what it's /not/ supposed to be), and as such, many people who try to write third streammusic end up creating music that's a lot less subtle. It's not really my cup of tea (more of a jazz guy), probably because there isn't a huge repertoire of third stream music out there, but it's definitely worth checking out if you think you might be interested.
- tunesmith 9y agoMy college degree was in classical piano, while I've mostly emphasized pop and jazz since then. I honestly don't really understand the study they're writing about here, but I have to say I don't really identify with Keith Jarret's quote here. Jazz is just another way to do music and it requires a different way of thinking, but I've never really looked at it as requiring any kind of "rewiring" or context shift. In general when playing classical I miss the playfulness and individuality of jazz, and when playing lead sheets I miss the narrative sweep of classical music. At least with my pop songwriting I can try to bring in a little of both.
- dahart 9y ago> Jazz is just another way to do music and it requires a different way of thinking, but I've never really looked at it as requiring any kind of "rewiring" or context shift. They're using overly dramatic language like "rewiring" to talk about a different way of thinking. Of course it's a different way of thinking, classical is performance, and jazz is improv. Nobody would be surprised if they said that doing dishes vs differentiating polynomials used different parts of the brain, but somehow it's supposed to be news that classical and jazz music do.
- cma 9y ago>They're using overly dramatic language like "rewiring" to talk about a different way of thinking. I don't see the word rewiring or rewire anywhere in the article.
- dahart 9y agoThanks, yes, the article doesn't use that word specifically. I quoted the parent comment. The article, and especially the headline, does use somewhat misleading language (as both @tunesmith's comment and the very top comment here is pointing out, among others) that is trying to imply that the brains of these two types of musicians is fundamentally different, e.g., "their brains started to replan the actions faster than classical pianists" and "their brains showed stronger awareness of the fingering". The language is implying a rewiring, and objectifying the brains of different musicians as being static and responsible for the difference, rather than talking about the plasticity of the human brain and the learned differences between wildly different tasks.
- randomdrake 9y agoStudy: Musical genre-dependent behavioural and EEG signatures of action planning. A comparison between classical and jazz pianists Citation: Bianco, R., Novembre, G., Keller, P.E., Villringer, A., Sammler, D., Musical genre-dependent behavioural and EEG signatures of action planning. A comparison between classical and jazz pianists, NeuroImage (2018). Link: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.12.058 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.12.058 DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.12.058 Abstract: It is well established that musical training induces sensorimotor plasticity. However, there are remarkable differences in how musicians train for proficient stage performance. The present EEG study outlines for the first time clear-cut neurobiological differences between classical and jazz musicians at high and low levels of action planning, revealing genre-specific cognitive strategies adopted in production. Pianists imitated chord progressions without sound that were manipulated in terms of harmony and context length to assess high-level planning of sequence-structure, and in terms of the manner of playing to assess low-level parameter specification of single acts. Jazz pianists revised incongruent harmonies faster as revealed by an earlier reprogramming negativity and beta power decrease, hence neutralising response costs, albeit at the expense of a higher number of manner errors. Classical pianists in turn experienced more conflict during incongruent harmony, as shown by theta power increase, but were more ready to implement the required manner of playing, as indicated by higher accuracy and beta power decrease. These findings demonstrate that specific demands and action focus of training lead to differential weighting of hierarchical action planning. This suggests different enduring markers impressed in the brain when a musician practices one or the other style. Highlights: • Real-time imitation of piano chord sequences with unexpected harmony or manner. • Genre-specific strategies at high (harmony) and low (manner) levels of planning. • Jazz pianists revised harmony faster (earlier negativity) at the cost of manner. • Classical pianists had conflict in harmony (frontal theta) but excelled in manner. • Focus of practice may cause enduring brain marks at different action control levels.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agoi feel like you can get a little bit of insight in to this if you arent a musician: imagine the difference between having a conversation with a friend (jazz) and reciting a piece of literature (classical). this is a borderline heinous simplification, but just imagine where your mind goes for each. you relax and let the thoughts flow in the first, you probably dont think very tangibly about diction. in the second you focus and probably think about the actual act of speaking more
- ndr 9y ago"When the scientists asked the pianists to play a harmonically unexpected chord within a standard chord progression..." Can someone ELI5 (and essentially never played) what they mean by harmonically unexpected chord within a standard chord progression? edit: formatting
- jrowley 9y agoOne easy case can be attributed to the improvisational nature of jazz - it is hard for the average listener to predict where a solo is going, how a pianist is going to voice their changes with their left hand while operating in another separate but related space with their right hand. I can't speak to to technical strictly music theory definition of jazz, especially given that jazz now is really just an umbrella for myriad sub-genres, but from my experience the beauty of jazz is that the resolution is not predictable, and more often than not it may make one feel vulnerable, or sad. See classics like Miles Davis, Bill Evans, or for someone alive today, Dr Lonnie Smith.
- savanaly 9y agoThese [0] are examples of chord progressions. In other words, progression means nothing more than a series of chords. A "harmonically unexpected chord" would be if the chord progression was playing out and a chord you wouldn't normally hear was inserted. That's it. Musicians, especially those focused on classical music, are so used to the standard chords that it feels really weird to play a "wrong" chord progression. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9YS3YvtY8-E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9YS3YvtY8-E
- thesephist 9y ago(gross oversimplification of music theory follows:) You've probably heard of complementary colors and the color wheel in the context of art. The idea there is (afaik) that some colors are thought to go "better" together and they're used more often together to create certain effects that seem more naturally fitting. If nothing else, there are color pairs used often together, by convention. Music has a similar construct in chord progressions. Chords (combination of pitches played simultaneously) sound as if they "naturally progress" from one to another when played in certain orders. For example, lots of pop songs will use a I-vi-IV-V progression over and over again, because 1) it's conventional and popular and 2) it sounds "natural" i.e. like it belongs together, the same way some colors might to an artist. What they mean here by _harmonically unexpected chord within a standard chord progress_ is that they started with a standard, conventionally popular progression of chords, then (I assume) replaced one (or more) of the chords that follow that progression with one that doesn't, which creates a feeling of dissonance since they aren't supposed to belong together, classically speaking. Hopefully this is an adequate portrayal -- not trained in theory, just a casual songwriter.
- stuffedBelly 9y ago> For them it is about playing pieces perfectly regarding their technique and adding personal expression. Therefore, the choice of fingering is crucial. Jazz pianists, on the other hand, concentrate on the "What". They are always prepared to improvise and adapt their playing to create unexpected harmonies I minored in music at college and studied both jazz and classical composition/theories. One key takeaway I had from my education is that notes that may considered to be dissonant in classical music are in many cases acceptable in jazz, given the chordal context and how a player chooses to resolve it as progression goes. I'd even expand a bit further and say that not only musician's brains work differently, but also brain activities of the audiences might differ when listening to jazz and classical pieces. Typically a classical audience might be a bit uncomfortable hearing a dissonant note and treat it as a "wrong note" while a jazz audience might think a dissonant note as being temporarily "out of box" to create tension and expect it to be resolved later.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agogood point. what constitutes a mistake is very different in each genre. and YES, there are mistakes is jazz.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoOnly if the "mistake" wasn't afterward incorporated into the improvisation does it become an actual mistake.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agothere lots of ways to recover, and varying degrees of mistakes, sure.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agobut after "recovering", what would have been a mistake is no longer a mistake.
- asdffdsa321 9y agoI really dislike these kinds of headlines not because they are obvious (jazz and classical require different kinds of thinking), but because they make it easy to jump to the conclusion that the ability to play classical or jazz or xyz is dependent on the physical nature of the brain. From there all sorts of erroneous arguments stem from the "fact" that "oh I'm just not wired to play xyz"instead of the reality that it takes consistent work in a style to understand that style better. Basically the whole nature vs nurture argument, except that people tend to worry about nature rather than work on nurture.
- fossuser 9y agoI agree and it also seems like the truth is probably the opposite of what people are likely to take away. Loosely, when you train a neural net repetitively in one way it adapts in order to be better at solving that specific case. While there may be some variation in initial conditions it seems likely that a lot of the variance is a result of the training itself.
- dahart 9y agoLike all types of publication, exaggerating and glamorizing academic research results is good for funding, because it works. The title "different tasks utilize the brain in different ways" might be just way too obvious and boring, so they have to spice it up and dramatize it. I'm not sure it's possible or realistic, but I'd love to know what sorts of things we can do as a society or a species to make it so that clickbait ceases to be effective. I remember reading about a language that was designed to make it impossible to exaggerate or lie. It didn't work, but it's an interesting idea!
- dizzystar 9y agoPretty much this. I think that what you get into and decide to master is more a foundation of what you grew up listening to than what you're brain is innately wired to do (if that even has meaning). I think that jazz is one of those genres that, to be legit, you had to have grown up in the culture where those dominate. While people who didn't grow up around jazz can mimic it, it's not quite the same. For this reason, I think jazz has a bit of mystique around it that other genres of music do not. This isn't only for jazz, but several other genres of music as well.
- colordrops 9y agoIs no one going to point out the fact that Miles Davis is not a pianist?
- beat 9y agoHe was a keyboardist, though. His post-1970 live output is filled with him playing organ, often to set the harmonic context and direction for the rest of the band, as he was doing full-band improvisation at that point.
- colordrops 9y agoOK fair enough, but was he really the right choice for the title of the paper?
- beat 9y agowell, how many jazz musicians can most non-jazz people even name? Miles, maybe Louis Armstrong, maybe Duke Ellington. If they'd said "Cecil Taylor", who'd have recognized him?
- colordrops 9y agoThelonius Monk, Bill Evans, and Herbie Hancock are all nearly household names. Yes, not as famous as Miles Davis, but up there.
- devnonymous 9y agohttps://www.google.ie/search?q=miles+davis+piano https://www.google.ie/search?q=miles+davis+piano Miles Davis was a Jazz musician. Classically trained. He was /also/ a pianist.
- yesenadam 9y agoMiles playing piano on Sid's Ahead.[0] Sounds good too! Very hip. And there's this insanity[1]. The first time I heard it I thought "OMG who's the organist? That's amazing!!"[1] All keyboards on that are Miles I believe. [0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tPZaVUvRpcs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tPZaVUvRpcs [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mrjFtbGKqFk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mrjFtbGKqFk
- Bizarro 9y agoI remember reading a book decades ago about how people that play musical instruments tend to be good programmers. It might have been Jeff Dunteman's Assembly Language Step by Step, but not sure. But that always stuck with me, and makes a lot of sense considering patterns and preciseness that you need when playing piano or some other instrument.
- dharma1 9y agoJazz piano: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y8HzMEwobvM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y8HzMEwobvM Classical piano: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-rywN8MoiEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-rywN8MoiEk
- dharma1 9y agoNo huge surprises here - classical training focuses on playing a piece exactly as the notation goes + personality on tone, emphasis of notes, tempo. When playing a classical piece (in typical classical training) you don't generally start dicking around reharmonising it, changing voicings or playing an improvised solo. Jazz charts (and training focus) looks very different - basic chord structure and the main melody is written down, everything else is up to you - chord voicings, on-the-fly reharmonisation, improvised solos. It's a different type of training and thinking. Of course these are the "textbook" or cliche interpretations of classical and jazz music. Classical and jazz are very broad, ultimately meaningless terms, and many musicians have experience playing a wide variety of music.
- uf 9y agoI think you are oversimplifying this. Many classically trained pianists are excellent at improvisation. Wagner, Beethoven, Mozart were respected pianists. Wagner wrote the Hollander by improvising on the piano reciting the lyrics. Beethoven was feared by other pianists for his level of skill at improvisation. Mozart improvised most of his piano sonatas as far as I remember. Gould made a recording of Strauss songs I think. The singer said in an interview, that Gould just started to improvise in Strauss' style and harmonics (Strauss is pretty damn difficult). Contemporary pianists often know both. Anecdotal evidence: A colleague of mine from music university studied classical piano and was a regular at jazz clubs in Dusseldorf. It is very interesting to see differences in brain structure from classical to jazz pianists. Maybe a hint at how (muscle-)memory and motion planning is stored? A hint at how volatile brain structure is? It would be interesting to see, if e.g. a classically trained pianist switching to jazz exclusively also has a significant restructuring of his brain. Edit: Now that I've read the article and the abstract of the paper (the paper is behind Elsevier's paywall), I understand that jazz pianists are quicker at planning new movements (a.k.a. Chord progressions) with the downside of making making more mistakes, while classically trained pianists are slower here, but faster at recognizing and repeating unlearned ("unusual") finger movements. Would be interesting to see a comparison to pianists doing both jazz and classical music.
- uf 9y ago
- MandieD 9y ago“Similar to research in language: To recognise the universal mechanisms of processing language we also cannot limit our research to German." As an American living in Germany who taught English between IT jobs, I’ve come to describe spoken English as playing jazz, and German as performing classical music. Sure, you can put some personal touches on spoken German, and new expressions do crop up, but there’s a lot more latitude for improvisation in English, and the catchy improvisations are more likely to be picked up by other English users and become part of the language. I thought this was my bias as a native speaker of English and very academic learner of German, but my German colleagues agree with the comparison.
- chopin 9y agoAs a german native speaker I'd tend to disagree with this. German for example has a lot more leeway for word order in its grammar than English.
- craigsmansion 9y agoI agree with you. Thanks to a multitude of cases in German one can jumble words around without losing their intended function within a sentence. English can be more fun because of the inherent ambiguity, but any parallels to jazz and classical music are a little far fetched.
- Stratoscope 9y ago> there’s a lot more latitude for improvisation in English Lately I've been hanging out on the English Language Learners Stack Exchange. It can be a discouraging place. Too many people answer simple questions with complicated explanations of English grammar, when the real question they should answer is "How can I say this the way a native speaker would?" An example: https://ell.stackexchange.com/questions/152764/is-this-sentence-correct-make-vs-made/152787 https://ell.stackexchange.com/questions/152764/is-this-sente... OP wanted to know if this sentence was correct: "Your kindness has (and will continue to) made a difference." The top-voted answer explains that "This sentence is an attempt at parallelling, where a sentence branches into two or more parts. In this case, it also rejoins at the end. The parallelled part must join on to the common part in the same way." And that's just the beginning. The answer goes on to explain about "eliminating the duplicated word sequences" and finally arrives at this sentence: "Your kindness has made, and will continue to make, a difference." That's grammatically correct, but hardly any native English speaker would ever say or write it. In fact, someone commented that the sentence "sounds more German than English to me." My zero-rated answer was "I like to find the simplest way to say things. You can thank a person for their past, present, and future kindness all at once: 'Your kindness always makes a difference!'" I don't care much about the votes, I'm just a bit sad that so many of the high-rated answers on ELL seem to answer the technical questions of grammar instead of helping people sound like native English speakers.
- partycoder 9y agoJazz includes a big deal of improvisation (real-time composition within certain theme) whereas classical music decouples composition from performance.
- bluetwo 9y agoI'm going to assume you would find the same difference between bus drivers and race car drivers. Airline pilots and fighter pilots. Poets and video gamers. Olympic triathletes and combat soldiers. Yoga practitioners and boxers.
- stuffedBelly 9y agoBut how they differ could be an interesting subject.
- yesenadam 9y ago>half of them were specialized in jazz for at least two years, the other half were classically trained Two years only? Uh..wtf. I didn't read the original paper, but that sounds ridiculous. Why not compare them with people who'd been playing, nay, specializing in, classical for 'at least two years'. Oh, because that would be ridiculous.
- stuffedBelly 9y agoIf someone is classically trained prior to studying jazz, 2 years is rather reasonable to pick up given they might already be well versed in basics such as proficiency in certain instrument(s), fundamental theories, sight reading, ear training, etc.
- yesenadam 9y agoWell, it doesn't sound reasonable to me. 2 years sounds like 'pretty much total beginner' level. No-one will be a good jazz player after so little time, and I doubt their brains would be those of jazz musicians with decades of experience either.
- stuffedBelly 9y agoI recently attended a Joey Alexander concert at SFJazz and was amazed how mature his playing is at his current age, given my standard of 'good musician' is rather high as a professionally trained jazz musician myself. He started playing jazz at age of 6 and started performing professionally when he was 9. I agree that people need SOME time to learn the ropes but with proper training, 2 years is enough to be good. Note that proper training doesn't mean practicing certain technique, scale or etude hundreds of times. Nowadays there are systems designed over the years by schools such as Berklee effective enough to make someone a good jazz musician within 2 years, similar to many athlete training systems. No system can make legends, but decent musicians for sure.
- yesenadam 9y agoNice to at last read someone making sense on this page. :-) Ok, but 1 child prodigy learning in 3 years (?) hardly disproves my point. Also, I don't believe in "proper training". I believe in learning from the recordings of the greats, and from playing music with people. Sounds like that's how Joey Alexander learnt[0]. I believe that, like many things, jazz can be learnt but not taught. Someone trained in some system will sound like the music equivalent of the academic artist - expert at following someone else's rules, but nowhere as an artist. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joey_Alexander https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joey_Alexander edit: Most people who go to Berklee are already pretty good when they get there, aren't they? Hardly starting from scratch.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cgy1 9y agoHere's a (apocryphal) story about legendary classical pianist Vladimir Horowitz meeting legendary jazz pianist Art Tatum: http://www.classicalmusicblogspot.com/horowitz-and-tatum-when-jazz-met-classical/ http://www.classicalmusicblogspot.com/horowitz-and-tatum-whe...
- m3kw9 9y agoI actually appreciate Jazz more than classical, and I’m sure I can play Jazz if i put my mind to it. Would that make my brain work differently before I even play jazz?
- vixvax 9y agojazz players use more the ear, the classical more the eye
- 8bitsrule 9y agoTo the extent that classical training is about 'flawless performance' and jazz 'training' is about 'fluid improvisation', in my experience these are very different skills. The question is: how does such a study decide whether the 'brains ... work differently' because the tasks are so unalike, or because the brains themselves are somehow different. Another question is proficiency: clearly 'virtuoso' pianists are different from 'amateurs' on both sides of the aisle. Are the brains of the 'virtuosos' more 'different'?
- squarefoot 9y agoI don't know how relevant this could be, but anyway, when I was like 11 or 12 there was this school mate of me who was a gifted classical pianist: he already played concerts at that age and apparently had its future already planned. Now one thing I recall vividly: at a friends party after playing some incredible piece of classical music he was asked to play some famous top-chart pop tunes and he failed completely: he was literally paralyzed for not having a sheet of what he was asked to play. This reinforced my belief that classical musicians are trained to be perfect executors but lack a lot in creativity, or perhaps players with these characteristics are more attracted by the more formal world of classical schools.
- quadrangle 9y agoBad headline: "Miles Davis is not Mozart" Besides being trivially true, MOZART WAS A MASTER IMPROVISOR!! Classical musicians were great improvisors for generations… until the late 19th century boon of the symphony orchestras and all these conservatories focused on getting musicians to follow the notes perfectly and watch the conductor and ignore creativity. In the 20th century, improvisation was rubbed out of classical music. Today's classical pianists are pathetic improvisors. But don't think Mozart or Beethoven or Bach etc. were like that. They were much more like the jazz pianists. This study is mostly just further proof of the tragic impoverishment of classical tradition over the last few generations.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- llamaz 9y agoThere is a strong tradition of classical improvisation too - check out Alma Deutscher's youtube videos
- dgsb 9y agoThe piano is an illusion used to make us believe that playing jazz and classical music is the same activity.
- ramijames 9y agoLast night my wife and I were talking and it turns out that my inability to "get" music comes from me not being able to listen to the music side and the words side of a song simultaneously. Is there anyone else out there like this?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]