8 ms·
You're essentially paying people to dig holes and fill them back in again. Modern agriculture is a highly skilled job done with millions of dollars of capital
by bryanlarsen 9y ago
You're essentially paying people to dig holes and fill them back in again. Modern agriculture is a highly skilled job done with millions of dollars of capital equipment. Unskilled laborers are more hindrance than help, and will be sent off to the "back 40" to indulge in mindless busywork.
And you expect people to get "Social responsibility, sense of purpose, community, meaningful ways to spend their time" from that?
Meaningless jobs invariably turn into that special sort of hell you get when your ability to do politics and to step on the guys below you are much more important than any actual skill or ability.
- codingdave 9y agoModern agriculture is more varied than that. There are large scale farms with minimal unskilled work, yes. But there also is plenty of harvesting work still done by unskilled migrant workers, especially in Florida and the Southwestern USA.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoIn my opinion, people will get more "Social responsibility, sense of purpose, community, meaningful ways to spend their time" playing Call of Duty all day under some sort of BI program than they would from a UBJ job.
- maemilius 9y agoMan, you'd think - with all that extra time on their hands - they could pick a good game to play. :P
- Covzire 9y agoThat seems a bit ridiculous. Being paid UBJ to clean highways, with incentives to be on time and not miss days would vastly improve one's health and build effective job and time management skills, something that playing video games all day wouldn't.
- geezerjay 9y agoWho the hell wants to clean highways for a living? Isn't it used as a punishment for some offenses?
- jotm 9y agoVideo games are a social life killer, unless you're already good at socializing. Nothing comparable to being forced to go out and actually socialize, whatever the circumstances.
- crdoconnor 9y agoSome holes that were dug with an agency designed explicitly to give job guarantee in the 1930s: * Triborough Bridge * Griffith observatory in LA * LaGuardia * LAX Is this really worse than those market-driven jobs created to harass people to pay debts, build McMansions where nobody wants them or create social networking sites for dogs?
- bryanlarsen 9y agoEvery body you add to such a project today would cost well over $100K per body. Not only are you paying the worker, you need a manager for that worker, a manager for the manager. And then you'd have to pay more because unskilled labour today would slow the project down significantly. The alternative is UBI, which should cost under $20K per body, and would give people an alternative to accepting a BS market-driven job just to put food on the table.
- crdoconnor 9y agoEven if we accept your figures (personally I find them dubious), the cost of paying UBI to everybody will outweigh the cost of paying for JG for the minority actively seeking work unless more than 1 in 5 are actively seeking.
- notahacker 9y agoDifference is that a "basic job" costs up to $100k per head for the number of people who need money enough to be willing to dig a hole all day for it. Let's be generous and assume that's all 4.3% of the working age population registered as unemployed and actively looking for work in the UK, even though some of the might be more disinclined to register as looking for work if they were required to accept work digging holes. So taking your unusually high staff cost ratio of 5x salary, that's $100k per head for 4.3% of the working age population. UBI might only cost $20k plus admin costs per recipient, but as you're paying it to well over 20x as many people it's well over 4x the cost. And you don't get the hole... I'm not convinced Basic Job programmes are a fully scalable welfare replacement, or that agriculture or construction work would be a particularly good focus for a more limited workfare programme, or that advocates of such ideas have necessarily considered the risk of crowding out paid work at proper salaries, but the idea that indiscriminately doling out money to people irrespective of whether they've indicated they might want it is cheaper than welfare state alternatives is palpably false.
- simonsarris 9y ago> like Switzerland, where 55% of farmer income comes from the state Paying half of farmer's wages to make small scale farming more tenable and accessible is not digging holes and filling them again. In New England, there are lots of hobby farmers who would love to do it full time but cannot support themselves + a few employees to scale it into a full time thing. This might not create farmers from scratch where there are none, but it could make New England farmers + farms more like the Swiss: Small scale but still viable, distributed, and well, subsidized.
- meri_dian 9y agoSo you're digging 55% of a hole. In order to subsidize someone's hobby.
- simonsarris 9y agoIn the same way that a startup incubator subsidizes hobbies, yeah.
- meri_dian 9y agoStartup incubators provide private investment with the hope of future return that covers their initial investment. That is a sustainable business model. Continuous subsidy - using public funds - of an activity that will not generate profit and overall return is not sustainable.
- s73ver_ 9y agoIt's only sustainable if you can pick winners.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sshumaker 9y agoYou’re missing the point. This article is proposing an alternative to UBI, where you are just giving no strings $$$ handouts to all citizens. Clearly basic jobs won’t be as efficient at producing e.g. agricultural products as the free market. But that’s not the goal with UBI or UBJ - it’s to deal with societal inequality in a world where increasingly most jobs are eliminated and those who control capital (the robots) have 100% of the wealth and everyone else is starving. That is the world many feel we are heading towards. There is a good track record of government jobs programs during times of severe unemployment, e.g. the Great Depression: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_Conservation_Corps https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_Conservation_Corps One advantage UBJ over UBI has is that it is something you can transition into; it doesn’t require a societal level disruption to put into practice.
- nopinsight 9y agoHow about necessary and meaningful jobs, like taking care of the elderly who do need help in their household, or building accommodations for and helping the homeless? The number of elders will only increase in most of the world over the next few decades and no automation could replace the human touch, or even physical dexterity, in the near term. Granted the people performing the job would need training and perhaps some supervision from professionals, but much of the work requires the skills like empathy and physical agility that most humans are endowed with (despite being left dormant from lack of practice by some). The same sorts of skills are needed as part of a program that would be useful for mitigating the homeless problem as well.
- crdoconnor 9y agoThis was actually done in Argentina (it was called plan jefes e jefas). Then they converted it into a basic welfare scheme with no requirement to do the jobs (which was mostly stuff like "help the infirm and elderly"). The majority of people continued turning up to work afterwards because they found it intrinsically rewarding.
- nopinsight 9y agoThat's very interesting. Do you have any good links? Also curious why they converted it to no requirement?
- crdoconnor 9y agoThis has all the details: http://www.levyinstitute.org/pubs/wp_534.pdf http://www.levyinstitute.org/pubs/wp_534.pdf They didn't realize that it would be so popular with women. I believe they withdrew it because government thought that the program was providing jobs to women who should be at home instead of working.
- quantumofmalice 9y ago> How about necessary and meaningful jobs, like taking care of the elderly who do need help in their household, or building accommodations for and helping the homeless? I would prefer that families provide these services (and, therefore, the state focus on the formation of strong families). The market is too brutal for most of this work and the state, in addition to general incompetence, lacks the moral authority to do so, especially when hard decisions must be made (e.g. when homelessness is driven by mental illness.) Pay a stable, living wage to build strong families, allowing one person to stay at home and provide for the domestic economy in a sphere they have natural authority in.
- jly 9y ago> Modern agriculture is a highly skilled job done with millions of dollars of capital equipment. Unskilled laborers are more hindrance than help, and will be sent off to the "back 40" to indulge in mindless busywork. I think the point being made in the original post is that modern agriculture has a lot of problems and this is a way to address some of those. Producing local foods in a sustainable way requires more labor and a more distributed structure, with many more individuals involved directly in the process. Market gardeners around the world produce high quality foods without millions of dollars of equipment. Anyone can be taught enough to be highly useful in this role.
- bilbo0s 9y agoJust as someone who's had to do the whole Farmer's Market thing for a while, (on the Capitol Square in Madison Wisconsin), I think I should point out that many many organic farmers do indeed use some fairly high tech tools and techniques to simplify the work. Different producers are using everything from the ultra high tech sort of "farm in a shipping container" systems inside of an area like Madison, to greenhouses that integrate natural climate control techniques out in places like Verona or Sun Prairie area, to gps assisted tilling out in areas like Spring Green. I think people would be surprised at how high tech agriculture has become. The original poster is correct when (s)he asserts that there would not be much meaningful work for an unskilled laborer in most sectors of modern agriculture. But that's not a bad thing, that's a good thing.
- jdietrich 9y agoThe unskilled work that does exist in agriculture is highly seasonal - mainly picking and processing fruits and vegetables that are too fragile for machines to handle. You might be able to find jobs for a couple of hundred thousand people during the peak of the harvest, but what do you do with them for the other nine months of the year?
- stcredzero 9y agoModern agriculture is a highly skilled job done with millions of dollars of capital equipment. Unskilled laborers are more hindrance than help, and will be sent off to the "back 40" to indulge in mindless busywork. Subsistence farming that's augmented to produce a little surplus can be an only somewhat skilled job that can be done by everyone with relatively little capital. Pre-potato famine Irish peasants and many pastoral peoples throughout history demonstrated that subsistence farming can be done for basically nothing. Unskilled laborers are more hindrance than help, and will be sent off to the "back 40" to indulge in mindless busywork. If granted land, such unskilled laborers could probably satisfy most of their needs. The Pareto principle would rear it's ugly head again, and the top 20% of such farmers would out-produce and could be paid to "redistribute" food. From the article: From some psychologists’ points of view, one of the worst things you can do to someone who is suffering from addiction or loss of hope is to give them no-strings-attached money, when what they really need is regularity and the responsibility that comes from having a purpose, even if its simply a job or a station. Another thing that the an early 1800's Irish model might indicate, is that such a model might have serious problems. There is a far cry between the culture of German expatriate famers or the self-reliant farmer of colonial New England on the one hand and the early 1800's Irish peasant from the same time. Huge social problems accompanied the potato famine Irish diaspora. Up to and including unimaginable squalor, neighborhoods where sewage and garbage sat stagnant and out in the open, where police were afraid to travel in groups of less than 6, and the rule of law was abridged by shadow criminal/terrorist governments that could even conduct their own trials and executions. From the article: This is not the kind of thing you can catch with a UBI pilot, but it is the kind of thing that you can answer by asking a more obvious question: Are wealth and poverty inter-generational? Of course they can be. As a society, we should be careful to not put a system in place that accidentally entrenches poverty when the initial goal was to alleviate it. A child growing up in a Basic Job household almost certainly has a better shot at life than a child growing up in a UBI household, with parent(s) who might have never worked. The article might be putting the cart before the horse. People who have been given the right human capital through their culture can pull themselves up in a few generations. (This is the case for Chinese immigrants all over the world throughout history.) People who do not have that human capital must then gain it through a process of cultural transmission or assimilation. This assimilation does not have to be complete, and the group can still retain their cultural heritage and distinctiveness. Again, the story of the Irish diaspora is a good model for this. The power of culture is tremendous, and the cultural transformation will not be easy.
- vanderZwan 9y agoSo make it Universal Basic Jobs and Education. Education needs massive reform as well anyway.
- neilwilson 9y agoWhat you are doing is giving up your time for others. If you don't do that then unsurprisingly the farmers will use the increased productive technology to stop working on Tuesday rather than working the rest of the work to keep you in 'leisure'. Ultimately you don't know how to farm, so you need the farmers working a full week. Adam Smiths rules of specialisation still apply. You need to give up your time so those you rely on to produce stuff will give up theirs. Or they won't bother.
- markshead 9y ago> Modern agriculture is a highly skilled job done with millions of dollars of capital equipment. While there is definitely truth in this statement, there is still a spectrum of work to do on modern farms and plenty of it isn't highly skilled. This is especially true on farms that are optimized for high margin vs. volume. For example, organic or local farm to table places.