4 ms·
The problem is that you cannot simply ship a not "absolutely perfect" plane. Or, actually, it's not a problem but a blessing given that there were no commercial
by mschuster91 9y ago
The problem is that you cannot simply ship a not "absolutely perfect" plane. Or, actually, it's not a problem but a blessing given that there were no commercial flight related fatalities in the USA in 2017 (per http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-aviation-safety-20180102-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-aviation-safety-201801...).
No doubt: Without the drastic levels of regulation the FAA (and JAA) impose on civilian flight, fatalities would be orders of magnitude higher.
- theGimp 9y agoCheap shot, but I'll take it. All 14 days of 2018? :)
- civilitty 9y agoIt's actually been six years of no fatalities.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThe article said in 2017, probably a typo on the poster's side. The article is about Trump trying to take credit for this (as he always does), when it is actually the 6th straight year without fatalities. Politically speaking, we are living in dark times even if aviation is super safe.
- mschuster91 9y ago> probably a typo on the poster's side. Yep, blaming this typo on a severe undercaffeination. > Politically speaking, we are living in dark times even if aviation is super safe. The interesting question is: given the political climate (and especially the President's habit of "getting rid of rules"), how long will aviation stay super safe?
- usefulcat 9y agoReliability is one measure of 'perfection' for an aircraft (and certainly a very important one), but it's hardly the only one that matters, especially when viewing said aircraft as a product that is competing with other similar products.
- andrewjl 9y ago2017 also saw no commercial flight related fatalities worldwide, in large part due to the NTSB (and it's non-US equivalents) process of getting the root cause of each crash and putting in place systems or procedures to eliminate that particular failure domain.
- rdtsc 9y agoI have heard of that applied to software development - when a bug happens there two bugs effectively to fix: the bug itself and the reason the bug slipped past testing and QA.
- andrewjl 9y agoDefinitely. Mature (in terms of process, not age) companies realize this and design planning, update, post-mortem processes accordingly.
- notatoad 9y agoThe 787s had a bad habit of catching on fire in midair shortly after they first launched, and they seem to have been fairly successful since then. Like any other industry, airlines have a wide gulf between "absolutely perfect" and "good enough".
- cc439 9y agoThere's "perfect" as in "perfectly reliable and perfectly safe" and "perfect" as in "we achieved every last design goal regardless of other factors". That last part is where Airbus may have missed the mark as design goals such as the A380's high floorspace to seat ratio were great decisions given its intended market (long haul flights, customers like space on long haul flights) also led to a less-than-optimal passengers per flight to operating cost per flight ratio in a market where hub to hub demand is declining. It also led to a low maximum takeoff weight for the size of its floorplan, making it useless as a freight/cargo aircraft, the one niche where the ancient 747 still reigns as king of the skies. A more robust design intended to hold more passengers would have also allowed it to carry more cargo which may have saved the program considering how expensive 747s are to operate.