5 ms·
This is a particularly egregious example of the pop-sci genre "making things sound more mysterious than they really are". How does light choose the fastest path
by jerf 9y ago
This is a particularly egregious example of the pop-sci genre "making things sound more mysterious than they really are". How does light choose the fastest path to its destination when light can't "choose"? Well, we could hypothesize light is conscious and is making globally-optimal calculations, or we could just observe that if you work through the wave equations on what waves do when encountering a speed change, that's what happens. It so happens that solution also matches how to get to the eventual point in the shortest time, but that adds an unnecessary concept of "intention to arrive at a given point". Light has no such preference or intention, it just arrives where it arrives.
We could hypothesize dogs are working out calculus problems, or we could just hypothesize that the dog tried it one way, then another, and eventually over the course of its lifetime works out how to get to the ball the most quickly, which in comparison to the difficulty of manipulating all of its dozens of muscles to perform the running optimally in the first place is a frankly insignificant challenge. Or, to put it into a human reference frame, we do not do calculus problems to catch things. We "just" catch them. Neurons are built to solve this problem.
We could hypothesize that the ants have a simple pheromone-based optimization system that naturally mathematically converges on the same solution as Snell's Law when, after all, faced with the same problem, but... uh... actually it's not at all clear to me how the article manages to make this sound mysterious after what is a fairly effective solution to the problem. If nothing else, the ants taking the most optimal path will make more to-and-from trips than other ants, thus laying thicker trails; that plus an initial shotgun approach are adequate to explain.
This is particularly egregious since none of the math here is very complicated, and it is completely unsurprising that when the same problem is given to several optimizing agents in several domains that the same solution pops out. There is not very many bits of information in this problem.
- whatshisface 9y agoThere is a small problem with your explanation: refraction can happen with single photons, which means that the "minimum path length" rule continues even as the wave formulation breaks down. If you say "the photon travels along all paths at the same time, finally choosing one path to have 'really' gone down," then you have to explain how it was able to move faster than light to collapse down to the single point where you found it on your camera's sensor. There is indeed a mystery here. In fact, since the only option I know of that eliminates spooky FTL signalng and spooky hidden (unobservable) mechanics has spooky alternate universes, I feel safe in concluding that at least one spooky thing has to be happening, even though we don't know which one it is.
- jules 9y agoYou're describing quantum mechanics, but the phenomena here are classical. There is no mystery with Fermat's law, even if you do not accept wave optics and want a theory of light particles. At each instant in time a light particle can determine how its trajectory will bend based on purely local information. The bending of light is determined by the local variation in the index of refraction. Snell's law is what you get if the index of refraction jumps discontinuously. This is analogous to how in classical mechanics the trajectory of a particle is determined by the local variation in the potential energy function (or more generally, the Lagrangian), and how a particle's trajectory has a kink if the potential energy has a discontinuous jump. The particle bounces back if the jump is too high, which corresponds to reflection of light.
- whatshisface 9y agoWell, here's why I wanted to bring up QM: the principle of least time is really most at home in geometric optics where beams of light are arrows and everything is steady-state. In that view, things are indeed nonlocal: I can alter the arrows drawn for a beam of light going from A to B by doing something over at point C. Wave optics would understand this as interference, but if we insist that we want to keep the arrows then we have to introduce the path integrals. Essentially, geometric optics lets us draw arrows and assert refraction, QM lets us draw arrows and derive refraction, but wave optics doesn't really involve arrows at all.
- jules 9y agoThings aren't nonlocal in geometrical optics though. Something happens at C at the instant in time when the particle is at C. You can start a ray at any point in any direction, and just follow a straight line until you hit something. Then you determine what happens next based on local information at that point, and you continue. Ordinary tennis balls have the same property that the path from A to B can be altered by putting a wall at C. By the way, wave optics is already QM in some sense. Maxwell's equations are the analogue of the Schrödinger equation for light. Geometrical optics is the analogue of classical mechanics.
- 9y ago
- ohtwenty 9y agoThe last bit is what got me too---pheromones are pretty simple to understand, really. you drop 2 ants, one walks 30 cm and another walks 10 cm. the one that walked 10 cm will be back sooner, can signal where he went, and others can follow his (fresher) pheromones. Why is this mysterious?
- paulcole 9y ago> This is a particularly egregious example of the pop-sci genre This is the model of Nautilus, Quartz, and a bunch of other online publications. It's fun to read so what's wrong with it?
- jules 9y agoOn the one hand, I like that they're doing old physics. There is a tendency to do only cutting edge physics such as modern quantum mechanics research, particle physics, even string theory. There is little chance to convey an accurate understanding of this to a layperson. Every part of physics was at the cutting edge at one point in time. The physics that is now hip will be old in 100 years, and it will be no longer interesting for science journalists. Celestial mechanics, classical optics, classical electrodynamics were at the cutting edge some time ago, and they're still super interesting. They also have the advantage of being thoroughly understood, so there's a chance to convey genuine understanding. In that sense, this article is great: it truly explains Fermat's principle as a physics college student would learn it. It would be even greater if it had more physics and less metaphysics. On the other hand, would that have reached the front page of HN? Probably not.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoBecause it is dull, long winded and misleading. Perhaps it is fun for people who like being misled?
- epicide 9y agoThis was my thought. I think the article reads almost like a children's Did You Know? kind of book: it presents the problem and just enough background information to understand it, then leaves the mystery for the reader to go and find out more. I could see the argument that there is a fine line between leaving a bit of mystery and just plain lazy writing.
- xaedes 9y ago> then leaves the mystery for the reader to go and find out more. When the reader is interested by the mystery and really goes to find more on his own, isn't that wonderful?
- pqh 9y agoExcept "why does Snell's law over a continuous gradient effect the path of shortest time?" is equivalent to asking "why is the universe quantum?" It's plenty bizarre that electricity follows the path of least resistance, light the shortest path, etc.
- gryfft 9y agoBizarre in comparison to what?
- pqh 9y agoLet me put it this way: never have I heard an explanation in terms of classical mechanics. In my intuition, the billiard ball model of physics makes perfect sense. But a current taking the path of least resistance really seems like it "knows" the best way. And it's amazing.
- tannercollin 9y agoThat's a misconception. Electricity takes ALL paths in amounts proportional to each path's conductance. If you have a 1000 Ω path and a 10 Ω path (in parallel), current will go through both paths. However, much more current will go through the 10 Ω path. The current through each path ends up being the voltage applied across the path, divided by its resistance.
- planteen 9y agoYep. Came here to say exactly this (electricity takes all paths) and then saw your reply.
- ewjordan 9y agoYou're definitely correct, this article overhypes the mysteriousness. It's a shame, though, and a missed opportunity to go deeper, because it is a surprising fact that almost all of physics is most elegantly expressed in terms of least action principles, where it really does seem like the universe conspires to minimize some quantity. In classical physics, the Lagrangian formulation is merely useful for some calculations, and can be fairly viewed as a mathematical trick that is equivalent to using Newton's law directly; similarly in E+M it's a compact and often useful way to express Maxwell's equations, but not particularly fundamental. When you reach quantum field theory, though, it's all but impossible to do anything without a Lagrangian/action, and theories are almost always described in that form. String theories are the same. General relativity is not always presented that way, but gravitational dynamics are stunningly simple in that form: in a vacuum, nature abhors curvature. Principles of least X are fascinating and incredibly useful, and the ex-physicist in me believes that they describe the actual universe so concisely that they are truly fundamental in some sense. But you have to really dig in to get any sort of appreciation for that, and I agree that this article didn't go anywhere near deep enough.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoThats pretty interesting.. I wonder though - Does the universe seem to prefer minimizing some quantity, or do human brains gravitate towards theories that identify quantities that are minimized/maximized? Couldn't physical theories be expressed in many different ways, maybe with completely different fundamental concepts than mass/energy etc? Where the theories describing nature would not be so clean?
- Retra 9y agoThat's the same thing here, though, since physics is a scientifically descriptive endeavor. Our conceptualization of the universe is limited by our perception of it, and thus the whole idea of "what the universe does" is fundamentally entangled in what we see it doing and how we can talk about it. So that the universe "optimizes" something must be true, given that only one past is observed. It has to have been optimizing for the past that we see. (It is perhaps more remarkable that we can make accurate predictions of the future, but this more or less seems to be a side-effect of optimization requiring some notion of continuity.) Our descriptions of nature are clean because they are based on observations of the past, which are the exact phenomena the universe appears to be optimized to produce. All other possible results are merely counterfactuals in our brains, and having those encoded in our theories would make them noisy and inaccurate. (And the best evidence for such counterfactuals being 'real' does exactly this by introducing quantum indeterminacy into the theory.)
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y ago> We could hypothesize dogs are working out calculus problems, or we could just hypothesize that the dog tried it one way, [...] Or, to put it into a human reference frame, we do not do calculus problems to catch things. We "just" catch them. Neurons are built to solve this problem. But the point remains that you are solving a calculus problem. I mean, I agree that some of this is over-hyping things, but I think it is actually a really important realization that a lot of people are lacking, often because they are stuck in some completely nonsensical notion of dualism, that your body does a lot of computation. Just because you are not consciously manipulating numbers does not mean you aren't computing the trajectory of your arm and the necessary activation of muscles to execute that trajectory. It's not that thinking is a prerequisite of computation, but rather computation is a prerequisite of thinking. Your arm doesn't catch a ball by thinking, but rather your arm catches the ball by computation--just as your brain thinks by computation.
- Nomentatus 9y agoIt's been found that to catch a fly ball (as pros do) your brain has to solve (approximately but accurately) a third-degree calculus equation, and does.
- pqh 9y agohttp://www.icr.org/article/plants-math-ration-food-use/ http://www.icr.org/article/plants-math-ration-food-use/ This is a really cool example of plants using math too.
- rdiddly 9y agoYeah it's almost akin to asking "If I put hot coffee in a thermos, the thermos keeps it hot, but if I put cold lemonade in there, the thermos keeps it cold. How does the thermos know the difference? Well because quantum, that's how!"
- knodi123 9y ago> Well, we could hypothesize light is conscious and is making globally-optimal calculations, or we could just observe that if you work through the wave equations on what waves do when encountering a speed change, that's what happens "Explanations exist; they have existed for all time; there is always a well-known solution to every human problem — neat, plausible, and wrong." - H L Mencken
- jerf 9y agoWell, quantum mechanical explanations for why light refracts may be in some sense wrong, since we know QM still hasn't been harmonized with relativity very well, but "neat" and to some extent "plausible", definitely not, at least by the person on the street's standard. I suggest you think a bit more before you fling a quote at somebody as if it's the last word on a topic; at the very least you should make sure it is actually applicable to the topic at hand.
- knodi123 9y ago> I suggest you think a bit more before you fling a quote at somebody I suggest you think a little more before sanctimoniously talking down to people. I was making a supportive reply, in agreement with what you wrote. > at the very least you should make sure it is actually applicable to the topic at hand. It is perfectly applicable. Light "being conscious and making decisions" is a neat explanation, but wrong.