9 ms·
The "Drug Trafficking Organizations" are the cartels. It is important to remember they don't exist to traffic drugs, they exist for the top leader(s) to obtain
by tomrod 9y ago
The "Drug Trafficking Organizations" are the cartels. It is important to remember they don't exist to traffic drugs, they exist for the top leader(s) to obtain and maintain power, like a state-in-waiting. As other activities become more profitable, they switch over to those. Marijuana loses its profitability, they can switch to other drugs, guns, smuggling, "coyotes", or legitimate enterprise.
This is what unfettered capitalism (anarcho-capitalism) looks like. I like capitalism, generally, but divorcing morality (or, alternatively, failing to separate socially-contracted power to coerce action) from economic gain results in the violence and brutality.
- sigstoat 9y ago> This is what unfettered capitalism (anarcho-capitalism) looks like. I like capitalism, generally, but divorcing morality (or, alternatively, failing to separate socially-contracted power to coerce action) from economic gain results in the violence and brutality. no. the cartels are what you get when you actively block organizations that are serving huge needs (recreational drugs), from access to peaceful means of conflict resolution and contract enforcement. (and worse, you've got governments regularly going in and attempting to destabilize the cartels with force, so that even if they wanted to build up more peaceful resolution mechanisms, they'd be punished for doing so.)
- eric_h 9y ago> no. the cartels are what you get when you actively block organizations that are serving huge needs (recreational drugs), from access to peaceful means of conflict resolution and contract enforcement. That’s how cartels get power in the first place, but once they’re there, they’re in the business of preserving revenue streams and territory and thus power. Once they’re large enough, their raison d’être is no longer simply fulfilling a market need but maintaining and expanding revenue and power, creating market need as required to keep the machine running (e.g. protection rackets)
- ryan_j_naughton 9y agoHere is an example of that with avocados: [1] http://www.foxnews.com/world/2017/11/03/mexican-cartels-extorting-avocado-producers-raises-price-guacamole-report-says.html http://www.foxnews.com/world/2017/11/03/mexican-cartels-exto... [2] http://www.newsweek.com/cartels-kidnap-avocado-farmers-696301 http://www.newsweek.com/cartels-kidnap-avocado-farmers-69630... [3] https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2016/7/12/1546610/-Avocados-and-the-Mexican-Drug-Cartels https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2016/7/12/1546610/-Avocados...
- RickHull 9y ago> That’s how cartels get power in the first place, but once they’re there, they’re in the business of preserving revenue streams and territory and thus power. An anarchocapitalist would note that this is straight out of the statist playbook. What distinguishes cartels from roving bandits that pivot to stationary? It's hard to lay the blame for this on capitalism per se.
- simplemath__ 9y ago>What distinguishes cartels from roving bandits that pivot to stationary? You're asking the wrong question, I think. The 64 trillion dollar question, IMO: "what allows market incumbents to remain stationary" The 'blame', as ever, lies in human frailty. Avarice and greed. Alternatively, you could look at avarice and greed as malformed extensions of self-preservation instinct. Bad actors are omnipresent and relying on market forces to expel them from markets is like trying to pray cancer away.
- geezerjay 9y ago> You're asking the wrong question, You only say that because you don't like the answer, as it demonstrates that statist barriers on the market are the true causes of this problem, and a free market economy would render this issue entirely moot. As the history of all communist states demonstrate, state-impose barriers to market creates all sortes of economical,social and criminal problems. Drug trafficking is one of them.
- Spooky23 9y agoHow do you explain the historical abuses of power and nasty behavior of the companies that produce things like bananas and pineapples?
- sigstoat 9y ago"abuses of power and nasty behavior" ... "produce things like"... how is this "question" supposed to be addressable? how would you defend the historical abuses of power and nasty behavior by government? there's a lot more democide to answer for than there are murders by malign corporations.
- Spooky23 9y agoI’d suggest that you spend 10 minutes to familiarize yourself with what companies like Standard Fruit Company and United Fruit did in Central America. Their behavior, from undermining the local government to monopolizing trade to death squads is all activity consistent with what the cartels have done. Cartels have better margins, but bananas were pretty deadly. The point is in reference to your extremist position that if only drugs were not contraband and subject to the rule of law, you wouldn’t have the cartels. That position Has been demonstrated many times to be incorrect. Using the Central American model, you can also contrast with Costa Rica, where there is a stable government and the rule of law is more mature.
- adventured 9y ago> I’d suggest that you spend 10 minutes to familiarize yourself with what companies like Standard Fruit Company and United Fruit did in Central America. The problem is you're contrasting an extremely isolated example versus the millions of corporations that have existed, with many thousands of those corporations having had immense scale, against centuries of vast war, slaughter, repression and genocide by governments resulting in the direct murder of over a hundred million people. That's the parent's very clear point.
- Symmetry 9y agoIf they're truly profit-maximizing they're already exploiting other drugs, guns, smuggling, "coyotes", or legitimate enterprise as hard as they can already and we should expect them to lose money if one of the markets they work in goes away.
- tomrod 9y agoDiseconomies of scale and scope can prevent action in each of these industries, in a static analysis. It may prove to be more profitable to focus on a single industry (e.g. marijuana) than seeking at the present moment to dominate or even enter other industries (e.g. opiods) until market conditions change. As things evolve, they may naturally enter other industries. Heck, even become legitimate. EDIT: Fixed second paragraph.
- QAPereo 9y agoOrganized crime has typically been highly diversified, and it seems odd that the most successful organized criminal organizations would ignore those opportunities. Typically so-called vice crimes such as illegal prostitution and gambling are the base of the pyramid, with protection rackets, violence for hire, and whichever dugs are in demand. Human smuggling is another source of income, although I don’t know much about those practices in the Americas.
- Symmetry 9y agoSure, but I'd expect that there's some agent already in those niches and that agent would have experience new agents would lack. Then, uh, non-linear returns to expertise at violence do complicate the issue in ways I can't predict but the empirical observation that violence has gone down would tend to support the the observation that profits have done down and argue against the idea that marijuana cartels are now violently displacing heroin cartels.
- tomrod 9y agoOne complicating factor is that the cartel can't use the traditional monetary system (as I understand it), thus allowing a quick pivot of assets (as they pull their money out from under their mattresses). Hence, if they _do_ decide to enter an industry, then can enter quickly, pay high wages, get a foothold, then undercut the existing market. Much like Google, Apple, and other tech companies with massively large cash piles they sit on.
- clavalle 9y agoI don't think morality has much to do with it. Taking violence out of transactions by simultaneously making the consequences of violence very expensive and the alternatives to violent dispute resolution relatively inexpensive is what makes non-violent markets work. But I agree: a market in violence rather than a People controlled, pre-agreed upon rules-based government monopoly on violence would lead to and an explosion of cartel-like violence in many more arenas. I just think it is because we make it relatively cheap in that scenario rather than any kind of moral coupling.
- tomrod 9y agoI don't disagree here. My point was more along the lines of the power brokers coupling coercive force with economic gain, which a strict morality would (in my view) speak against. But yes, the argument against the nature of the cartels does not require moral arguments.
- cname 9y agoI'm not sure how you can say hierarchical organizations that use violence/coercion are in any way anarchist. Anarcho-capitalism requires voluntary engagement in a system of contracts and so forth. (Whether that could actually work in the real world is debatable but beside the point.)
- losteric 9y agoAren't consumers technically voluntary, if we assume no one's getting addicted to heroin at gunpoint?
- tomrod 9y agoMost of the time. Some counterexamples exist (e.g. buy from the limited healthcare options available to you or be fined [via tax]).
- losteric 9y agoIn general, sure, but the context of this thread is drug cartels. Their unregulated businesses use capital to aggressively expand into other markets, destroy competition, and oppose democratic regulations - behaving similarly to legal capitalist corporations. Though, granted, they conquer with guns and gangsters instead of legal loopholes and lawyers.
- matt4077 9y agoYou're using different meanings of the word 'anarchy': 2. (uncountable) Anarchism; the political theory that a community is best organized by the voluntary cooperation of individuals, rather than by a government, which is regarded as being coercive by nature. 3. (countable) A chaotic and confusing absence of any form of political authority or government. 4. Confusion in general; disorder.
- cname 9y agotomrod used the term "anarcho-capitalism", which is a specific strain of political anarchy, and that is what I was responding to.
- michaelchisari 9y agoMarijuana loses its profitability, they can switch to other drugs, guns, smuggling, "coyotes", or legitimate enterprise. Not disagreeing with your larger point, but the fact of the matter is that it's a lot harder to sell people meth, coke, heroin, etc. than it is to sell people pot. If coca cola were made illegal, something that is bad for you by many metrics but hardly life destroying, people are not going to switch to hard liquor in the same way. Kidnapping, hard drugs, smuggling, all of these are sources of income, but they're dwarfed by pot sales. The hope is that the cartels can only maintain the empires they have with a huge money maker like marijuana, and without it, they may get more desperate and expand the worst of their operations, but they will still shrink in their influence, power, geography and labor force.
- unfunco 9y ago> it's a lot harder to sell people meth, coke, heroin, etc. than it is to sell people pot. Only the first time. Then the opposite is true.
- dwaltrip 9y agoOP clearly meant in aggregate.
- freeflight 9y agoOn what basis are you making such a statement? Afaik many people use meth for performance enhancement and as a cheaper alternative to coke, heroin mostly comes in with people who've built up an opiate addiction through prescription opiates and a cheap escapist solution. Add in a generally very crappy living situation, where these substances are used as means of escapism from reality, and most of the habit boils down to all kinds of circumstances, but very rarely to this urban myth of "it's just so addictive that you can't stop after the first time", as most of it has to do with building habits on top of an already destructive lifestyle. Case in point: I've done meth and coke more than once, and never did I feel the need to "keep on doing it due to withdrawal". If anything, the side-effects of something like meth make it very unpleasant to regularly use due to being physically and mentally very taxing. That's why I don't think there's some kind of "large untapped market" for substances like these. Most people are still rational actors and if otherwise content and happy with their life won't start with destructive behavior on the sole basis of a substance being "super addictive".
- ianamartin 9y agoOh fuck off. What are you even on about? You think drug cartels are diversified investment portfolios? Ones that can just sub one illegal commodity for another? You're out of your fucking mind. And if you can't tell how out you are from the first line, you can tell when you assign a moral aspect to the things you don't like. Jesus, you're a piece of work.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yodon 9y agoYour post feels way out of character both for HN and for how you’ve interacted with others here on HN in the past - it seems like there must be more going on behind that post than your readers are able to intuit from your anger. Can you elaborate a bit more?
- dang 9y agoPosting like this will get you banned on HN, regardless of how wrong someone else is. You may not owe that person better, but you owe the rest of us much, much better, if you want to keep commenting here. I'm going to put this down as an isolated lapse, but please take the spirit of this site to heart and don't do this again. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- godelski 9y agoYou can't just substitute things and expect them to keep the same market. This is because DEMAND is part of a market force. The demand for pot is substantially higher than the demand for other drugs (like cocaine, heroine, etc), guns, coyotes, etc. If a commodity can no longer be (near) monopolized into their share of the market, then demand does not magically grow for other commodities. Sure, they can pivot strategies (which costs significant amounts of money) and adapt new commodities and services to match market demands, but this does not mean that they have the same profits. If they truly are already profit maximizing (to the best of their abilities), then they are already are servicing the markets with the highest demands. Which then if you remove their ability to service their market with the highest demand, you also remove the profit of that market. To generate their current revenue (with loss of the pot market) they would need to generate more demand in their other markets (advertising), find a new market with large enough demand (innovation), or service a lot of niche markets. tldr: - Demand exists for commodities. - Different commodities have different demands. - Shifting suppliers of a market does not generate new demand in different markets for the original supplier.
- tomrod 9y ago> You can't just substitute things and expect them to keep the same market. Of course not. What we face is an organized, unregulated, lawless group of dangerous criminals who find one of their primary income sources dwindling. I did not intend for my original point to debate foundations of economic theory, only to point out that they are likely to continue diversifying their product -- apparently they are switching to avocados and old-fashioned mob shakedowns, as per another comment on this thread.
- ThomPete 9y agoSmoking pot is a victimles crime. So if you want to debate morals then making it illegal to sell and thus allow for the tens of thousands of innocent victims who get killed by the powerful cartels in the name of the War on dugs is the most immoral action a government can do.
- tomrod 9y agoWe absolutely agree on this. The legality, politics, and forcefulness of this aren't binary objects. The War on Drugs more or less enables the cartels. The War on Drugs resulting in an avenue for the founding and persistence of the cartels does not absolve the cartels of their brutality, however. That was my initial point, so apologies if it didn't communicate well.
- Gibbon1 9y ago> "coyotes" Reminds me and makes me think, the human smuggling business must be taking big hit since illegal immigration is way down since 2007. Course maybe people fleeing central/South America makes up for some of that.
- pedro_hab 9y agoWow, the state deems drugs to be illegal, but anarcho-capitalism is to blame somehow. A lot of people here are so steadfast to the bigger state idea that they see it everywhere as a solution even when it's the cause.
- Dirlewanger 9y agoA key difference: Most Western corporate entities aren't physically dismembering their competition. Even in the early days of modern capitalism (late 1800s), that wasn't a thing.
- jacoblambda 9y agoThey also don't have a choice of whether or not they can operate legally so they might as well go all in on crime. While cartels do lots of horrible things, if you had to operate with the constant threat of having all your assets seized and receiving a life in prison, would you operate as peacefully as possible or would you act to instill fear in those that wronged you and/or threaten your way of life. If the products that the cartels distribute were legal, most cartels likely would either be those western corporate entities or wouldn't exist.
- Alfredo123 9y agoThat argument can always be extended and said that few people will always do bad things that hurt society irrespective of whatever. The only problem with your reasoning is that you see all the bad things as something that have same profit-risk ratio. Human trafficking is not just a variation of drug trafficking but is a completely business. As different from Netflix and Facebook though for an outsider both of them look like internet companies. Legalizing things that people want and does not create victims eliminates less risky options for the cartels.
- CyberDroiDT 9y agoAnother whack opinion from Hacker News, coming off as facts. Get a clue.
- vxxzy 9y agoI wouldn't call it "unfettered capitalism". The fact remains that the these organizations are exploiting a law against a certain substance. A law that was initially put in place due to "moral" concerns.
- DickingAround 9y agoWhat a strange claim about 'capitalism'. This is the opposite of regular or even anarcho capitalism; this is a capitalism where you select out for anyone able to do other trades or generally comply with social norms. Cartels and this kind of behavior don't happen because it's an ultra-free market or something. It happens because regular capitalists aren't participating in that market. What an absurd claim to paint capitalism as bad because the drug war is producing bad players. The exact opposite is true; the players in the current drug war is a perfect example of why this needs to be a freer market.
- romwell 9y agoDo we see a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman in the wild? "Of course this is not a failure of Capitalism. No True Capitalists would do such a thing. What you need is more Capitalism to solve this problem."
- zappo2938 9y agoI've heard of people who worked for the Italian mafia during the 80s and 90s who now own coal mines and other natural resources in Africa which they ship to China. They are completely legal in the eyes of the United States government. They stored their money hidden overseas and eventually invested it overseas.
- BurningFrog 9y agoThese cartels sound like super agile organizations that can execute any possible business plan, in any industry, legal or illegal. In reality, of course, no such super-organizations exist. If and when the industry they have a comparative advantage in disappear, so will the organizations.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoPlease note that your "unfettered capitalism", divorced from morality exists here only in the context of a moralistic, outright ban on trade. So lets fight that daemon capitalism by freeing trade! If these marijuana results show that reducing prohibition removes a revenue stream from the crime lords, then we can expect ending prohibition will hit them even harder. Perhaps enough to relly reduce lawlessness in Mexico as well as the US. It's tautologically true that organised criminals will always do criminal work is profitable; but they gangs can be small or large, powerful or weak. It seems they are powerful in Mexico because prohibition cedes most of the US drug market to them.
- conanbatt 9y agoAkin to saying Blockbuster doesnt need VHS, they can diversify into media.. If they lose half their income they lose more than half their power. I have no doubt that economics is the fastest way to reduce drug trafficking.
- DanielBMarkham 9y ago"...they don't exist to traffic drugs, they exist for the top leader(s) to obtain and maintain power, like a state-in-waiting..." I've been thinking about this for a day, and it's bugging me. I think the problem here is that this a true statement, yet it is also an incomplete statement. The ways that it is incomplete are important. This is like saying that startups exist solely to make their founders into successful businesspeople. Well, yes, but there are a ton of folks who want to be successful that don't end up that way. So sure, if you ask the top guys at the cartel why they're in it -- they're in it for power. But there's a huge sorting and filtering function the market does that's not included in this observation. Routes and methods that work great for cocaine don't work so well for people. Government officials that might be bought off with money siphoned off from huge flows can't be paid off if the flows aren't that great. In short, it makes it appear as if cartels only exist based on the will of the cartel leader. That's whack. I don't have any other comments about your analysis, but that was bugging me. I wish things were simple enough that it was just a matter of focusing on a few powerful men with large egos. It is not.
- SE4L 9y agoCartels exist to make money. The criminal element is not created by unfettered capitalism, it is created by prohibition. Prohibition is what raises the risk level to the point where people who are willing to break the law are able to demand a high enough price to make it worthwhile. If you compare the impact of the drug war with alcohol prohibition, the similarities are hard to miss.
- Houshalter 9y agoThis is not anarcho-capitalism. Libertarians are extremely protective about the right to bear arms for good reason. Mexico has very strict gun control and this is the result. Anarcho capitalism would look more like this: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/07/world/americas/mexico-state-corruption.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/07/world/americas/mexico-sta... The population organized an armed militia and kicked the cartels and government out. They are funded by local orchard owners. Who now have the most power and keep things in order. So it's not really libertarian, but it sure is a lot more stable than what was before. There's other examples in Mexico. Mormons that have established colonies there. And sneak in weapons to defend themselves and successfully fended off the cartels: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LpIyaIHsJbc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LpIyaIHsJbc