11 ms·
Cherry’s new switches may help bring mechanical keyboards to more laptops
- tristanj 9y agoThin laptops won't be getting this tech. These switches are still thicker than an entire macbook pro.
- hs86 9y agoThis seems to be only a smaller red switch (linear, no tactile feedback) with a translucent casing for those 'gaming' laptops. I don't think that this will bring a (clicky,) tactile MX switch to thin and light ultrabooks which are (imho) more suitable for coding.
- bergie 9y agoI've been looking for low profile switches to built a mobile version of my Atreus keyboard. Nice to see Cherry entering the game. Kailh has more options, including tactile https://www.novelkeys.xyz/product/kailh-low-profile-switches/ https://www.novelkeys.xyz/product/kailh-low-profile-switches...
- brokenmachine 9y agoThe problem with those Kailh is getting keycaps. At least the cherry one will be compatible with MX keycaps, although I don't know where you'd get low-profile ones from. Hopefully they're available as spare parts soon. As an ergodox user, I'd also be really interested in a mobile low-profile Atreus, but I need more keys, at least like an Atreus64.
- isr 9y agoThere's an atreus62 variant available (I have one, love it). You can order the components (or prebuilt models) from profetkeyboards.com Personally, I shift the letter keys out to the sides by 1, so the pinky's only have 1 column to deal with, and there 2 extra rows in the middle. This also has the effect of rotating the wrists outwards even more - comfy! As it turns out, I don't even need the full 62 keys (and have even pulled 8 keycaps off!). Depending on your preferred layout, you might also get away with <60 keys. But a low-profile variant would be nice :)
- brokenmachine 9y agoOops, I actually meant atreus62. But maybe an atreus64 would be better (if it existed) because I would like some more thumb keys like my ergodox.
- kraptor 9y agoCherry has had low profile switches for a long time, though they are far from common. https://deskthority.net/wiki/Cherry_ML https://deskthority.net/wiki/Cherry_ML I have one G84 and it's nice and "silent". But it's a pain to find compatible keycaps: https://deskthority.net/wiki/Cherry_G84_series https://deskthority.net/wiki/Cherry_G84_series
- JoshTriplett 9y agoPersonally, I really like short-throw keys on a keyboard, with less key travel. Whenever I find myself using a thicker, mechanical keyboard, it feels wrong somehow, and I don't enjoy typing on it. At my desk, I use a USB version of the same laptop keyboard and mouse that's on my laptop: https://download.lenovo.com/km/media/images/PD026745/tp_compactusb_kb_0b47190.jpg https://download.lenovo.com/km/media/images/PD026745/tp_comp...
- ginko 9y agoDo you press the keys all the way down on those thicker mechanical keyboards? Because it doesn't actually take that much key travel for a key press to register.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoNo, I don't, and I don't press the keys all the way down on a laptop keyboard either. You quickly get used to how much force you need to make the key register.
- mcbits 9y agoI've used a mechanical keyboard for a couple years. Yes, there is a 1-2 mm buffer zone after the keypress registers. No, it's not practical to manually stop and reverse within that zone consistently while typing at a fast speed. I would even say it's unsafe due to the extra tension in the wrists needed for that kind of precision. But it is possible to just type a little softer and reduce the noise of the "clack" as well as wrist tension.
- JohnBooty 9y agoYes! If one's typing "correctly" on a mechanical keyboard, they would hear/feel the click and very little clack -- otherwise they're jamming the keys down with more force than needed. Of course, some people enjoy mechanical keyboards simply because they just like... jamming the keys down as hard as possible and hearing loud noises, I support? And we all do that sometimes, I guess. But... that is definitely not the point of those mechanical keys.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoCouldn't haptics (and taptics) be used to augment a keyboard with better feedback and a feeling of travel and bounce back without an actual physical switch?
- QAPereo 9y agoGood mechanical switches have a kind of mechanical haptic feedback that lets you know with a click, that your keystroke has registered, without bottoming out the key.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoRight. I wonder if travel can be eliminated even further with vibration-based, rather than actual mechanical, feedback.
- DavidBuchanan 9y agoI performed an experiment based on this idea - I wired up a clicky relay to the numlock LED (via a transistor), and glued it to a decent Dell keyboard. Then, I rigged up a python script to toggle the numlock led on each key press/release event. Honestly, typing experience wasn't too different to a real mechanical keyboard.
- applecrazy 9y agoThat sounds pretty expensive, IMO. There would need to be one motor for each key that's isolated so only one key vibrates. And on top of it, it would be a pretty big keyboard too. If somebody has done this before, I would love to try such a keyboard.
- wallacoloo 9y agoI'm not sure if you can get enough force from them, but maybe a piezo crystal under each key could provide localized feedback more economically and with less space requirement.
- Jetroid 9y agoMechanical Keyboards have always been a curse in disguise for me. Sure, the feedback is nice but the 'click' sound is very distracting and breaks my flow. It's even worse when a coworker/housemate/other person has one. I swear that sound is not impeded by walls.
- phonon 9y agoThere are none-clicky mechanical switches too. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherry_(keyboards) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherry_(keyboards) Look at the column "Clicky".
- zitterbewegung 9y agoYou can get quieter switches. Or even put a silencer on them (basically plastic rings).
- vlunkr 9y agoNot really silencers.. they dampen the sound a bit. There’s still a click.
- zerokernel 9y agoWhether there is any click depends very much on the switch.
- Fnoord 9y agoMy partner has the same, she hates my mechanical keyboards (mainly a Razer BlackWidow Ulimate Stealth). However she's sensitive to sounds in general (we suspect its part of a form of autism for which she'll get psychologically tested this year). It was an important factor of the decision to skip the MBP 2016, forcing me to go with a 2015 version instead. However, it is possible to make the sounds less severe by touching them lighter. And on the Razer device these are Cherry MX Black with silencer. There's Cherry MX Brown if you need a more silent switches. If it was my choice, I'd use Cherry MX Blue (or, well, Green, as it resembles the old IBM keyboard the best)... Personally, the sound of keyboards doesn't bother me (though I wonder the effect on TEMPEST). I just get annoyed by sounds from mobile phones in general. Especially if it keeps occurring all the time while the user is using the phone. Pointless IMO. "Look at me, I'm popular." I find it rude when people cause noise in public (such as a restroom, or a train/bus), be it they're on the phone or having a phone which generates noise. The exception I got to that is children. I have compassion for children, tho its the parents who should solve the problem that isn't always practical.
- walterbell 9y agoGoldTouch has a folding mobile ergonomic keyboard in USB and Bluetooth versions, relatively silent full-size keys with tactile feedback, 2.7 mm key travel, 45g activation. They have been around for a while and began with desktop keyboards. https://www.amazon.com/Goldtouch-GTP-0044-Mobile-Keyboard-USB/dp/B00DT73FVM https://www.amazon.com/Goldtouch-GTP-0044-Mobile-Keyboard-US... https://deskthority.net/wiki/Goldtouch_Adjustable_Keyboard https://deskthority.net/wiki/Goldtouch_Adjustable_Keyboard
- npunt 9y agoI have one and these are pretty good, but I wouldn't say the keys have an amazing feel - its more the form factor and tenting that I like about this keyboard. The goldtouch keys are a bit wobbly vis-a-vis the new apple desktop (not MacBook) keyboards with butterfly switches, which are quicker to type on.
- gaius 9y agoI felt the first twinges of carpal tunnel back in the day but switching to a Cherry keyboard cleared it right up. Now I wouldn’t use any other.
- bpicolo 9y agoYeah, I find I tend to hit the keys much less hard
- mmjaa 9y agoThe best thing to do to deal with carpal tunnel is to change your keyboard out every few months. It doesn't matter if its Cherry or whatever - simply don't use the same keyboard for longer than 3 - 4 months. (This is just my personal experience. 30 years ago I was diagnosed with carpal tunnel, and I change my keyboard every 6 months. Never had it since!)
- jazoom 9y agoIt's more likely you're just conscious of your hand posture now.
- helpComputer 9y agoSuppose that's true. The prescription of changing keyboards every X months to help stay conscious of hand posture would make sense.
- jazoom 9y agoSure, but it's a bit much to say something like this, don't you think? >The best thing to do to deal with carpal tunnel is to change your keyboard out every few months. N=1. Expensive solution. More likely alternative explanations.
- mmjaa 9y agoExpensive really? I beg to differ - far cheaper than any of the other options, such as physical therapy, drugs, etc. Sometimes the simplest solution is the best one.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoStill waiting on the wireless mechanical keyboards :-).
- tjoff 9y agoThere are quite a few on the market.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI see that I am a bit behind in that two (Velocifire, and RK) seem to have actually mechanical wireless keyboards (I found that when looking for them that often a chiclet style would be advertised as 'mechanical' while still just being a squish dome type) I've ordered one of each from Amazon to see if they can replace my current daily driver which is the Corsair.
- kraptor 9y agoThere are, and very cheap too: https://www.amazon.com/RK-Bluetooth-Wireless-Mechanical-Keyboard/dp/B0746NHTLK/ https://www.amazon.com/RK-Bluetooth-Wireless-Mechanical-Keyb...
- therealmarv 9y agoMeanwhile we have the keyboard of the new Macbooks. Get as loud as mechanical keyboards with no tactile fisher price feeling. And we should not even start of talking about durability.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tristanj 9y agoThat's not a fair comparison. These keyboard switches are far too huge for thin laptops. The whole thickness of a macbook pro is 20% thinner than just one of these switches.
- 6t6t6t6 9y agoI may be weird, but I have a 2017MBP and I love the keyboard.
- therealmarv 9y agoWell I hate them when coworkers are using them in a shared environment.
- megaman22 9y agoThe great thing about mechanical keyboards, for me, is that almost all of them are full-size, and are laid out according to the traditional old IBM PS/2 design. For me, that form factor is important, because I have big hands with sausage fingers. The mechanical switches, in and of themselves, are less important than sturdy construction and consistent layout. I've never had two laptops with the same keyboard layout, and seen some downright-boneheaded ux decisions - my current work machine puts the power button inline in the top right, where you expect a delete button to be.
- stevebmark 9y agoThere's nothing I love more than coworkers whose keyboards are louder than someone speaking with intensity. I definitely don't want to break their keyboards over their monitors in any way. It's definitely not as annoying as people who play music on speakers in public places and have no sense that there are other people around. I'm so happy this definitely not terrible technology is coming to laptops so I can endure this happily when someone on the plane next to me is typing.
- ZenoArrow 9y agoCherry makes "silent" mechanical keys, they could probably do the same with laptop keys as well: https://youtu.be/fH8pzisjF-U?t=2m45s https://youtu.be/fH8pzisjF-U?t=2m45s
- stevebmark 9y agoYou Keep Using That Word, I Do Not Think It Means What You Think It Means
- ZenoArrow 9y agoDo you understand what is meant when a word is enclosed in double quotes? Furthermore, you suggested the sound of the keys was an issue, the point I'm making is that you can get mechanical keys that are not significantly louder than chiclet keys. Do you understand now?
- strictnein 9y agoI have a keyboard that uses those. They're definitely not "silent".
- ZenoArrow 9y agoNote that the word silent is in double quotes. This implies you're not meant to take it literally.
- pasbesoin 9y agoI'm using a Thinkpad T430, at the moment. I can live with the chicklets, although the surface on these is a touch too slippery for me -- my fingers too easily find the edges of the keys, upon occasion. However, the frustrating part is that some keys occasionally fail to register. Left shift being one of them; some of my ampersands turn into sevens (and, it just dropped the n in "into") -- particularly frustrating when I mean to background a command. The "God we all miss them", "real" keyboard on my W520 does not exhibit this. This T430 does have the backlit keyboard; I understand it's from the parts supplier (I forget which, offhand) that tends to have more "wobble" in their keys. That may be part of it. People focus SO much on the internals of these machines. For fuck's sake, start by putting good keyboards and displays in them. I don't care how fast it runs, if it's a pain to use and its ergonomics slow me down. I don't mind "cheaper", "thinner", "cooler" (style), whatever laptop designs. I DO mind the trend towards that being the only thing I can buy. I don't have a T25, yet, but I may. And I hope there's a T26 or whatever they call it, and so on. (And then, I'll dream about an open BIOS and a machine that is really mine, in terms of its computational functionality.)
- pimeys 9y agoI'm just like you, I prefer a good keyboard, mouse and screen over lightness and thinness. That's why I went with the T25 instead of waiting for the 8th gen Intel's last year. Good keyboard, a minimal window manager and I'm the most efficient. But I think we're in minority.
- tomxor 9y agoIs the travel comparable the rubber-dome spring based ones in most laptops? (excluding apple's latest obscenity of course). I like the short travel and low force of most laptop keyboards but I really hate the flimsy spongeyness of them... they aren't proper switches like cherries so they have a tendency to be wobbly, inconsistent and spongey. Over time this gets worse. I'd really like it if I could keep the low travel and low force but have it smooth consistent and non-spongey.
- neves 9y agoI have 4 broken and beloved Model M keyboards that I can't throw away. Which Cherry switches would make feel like I were using one of them?
- kraptor 9y agoYou need Cherry greens modded with 95g springs... or just buy an Unicomp :)
- ksec 9y agoOn the Topic of Keyboard, Dell has a new Keyboard on its new XPS 15 called Maglev, using magnet instead of switches, which said to allow the thinness of MBP keyboard while still giving some key depth. I cant wait to see how that turns out.