6 ms·
> There was no need for this new internet censorship law at all, for they could've just started applying existing hate speech laws.
The new law (NetzDG, roughl
> There was no need for this new internet censorship law at all, for they could've just started applying existing hate speech laws.
The new law (NetzDG, roughly "network enforcement act" [1]) was intended to facilitate applying existing laws against illegal content, by mandating that every site with > 2 million users needs to have a clear procedure for reporting illegal content.
Unfortunately, there are only fines for failing to delete obviously illegal content and none for just deleting everything that is reported and not obviously legal. The law makes provisions for handing over tricky cases to an external agency, but expected the companies to jointly set it up themselves ("regulated self-regulation"), which they didn't do; likely because the people checking reports at such an agency are legally mandated to be competent.
[1] https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/netzdg/BJNR335210017.html https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/netzdg/BJNR335210017.html
But there always was a very clear procedure for reporting illegal content: You visit your local police station and tell them.
This is for prosecution. The removal of such speech is a civil suit. Facebook/Twitter might have taken a post more serious when the police came and asked questions, but then, they might not. And prosecution might not what a victim was after, as this involved being part of a legal case where your stance is weaker than that of the claimed perpetrator (as it is a penal case then).
And that never went anywhere, because Facebook disobeyed even court orders. They never replied to judges. They never took down posts a court had ordered them to.
The NetzDG is bad law, and will probably be repealed before the Constitution Court rules it unconstitutional.
But it was a reaction to social networks disobeying the law. An overreaction, yes, but a reaction.
I wish it were more commonly known in libertarian and net freedom circles that the pendulum swings both ways. After excesses in one direction it will swing far into the other direction.
Maybe keep that in mind when pursuing extreme goals at any cost, instead of find8ng a middle way that works for everyone.
I think the NetzDG is crap and won‘t stay for long. But I also think that Facebook and Twitter deserve all this pain.
Well, sure, but it didn't go nowhere because a clear procedure for reporting didn't exist, but because the law was not enforced and maybe because some pieces necessary for successful enforcement were missing (which the NetzDG adds, in addition to all the crap that privatizes the law enforcement).
Really, I don't see many people in "net freedom circles" who object to forcing Facebook to delete illegal posts. The objection is rather to (a) deleting stuff instead of prosecuting the perpetrators, (b) hiding (censoring) stuff that's still there, and (c) making parties other than the judicial system responsible for limiting speech.
But, yeah, sure, I don't care about Facebook or Twitter either.
The thing missing for enforcement was Facebook respecting our laws. They simply said „none of our officers is living in Germany, so fuck off“. Now we‘ve added a way to make them hurt. Financially.
And I see virtually everyone in the net freedom circles objecting to FB deleting illegal posts. Because our laws are unjust, you see. Only American laws count.
We really need to teach Facebook, Twitter, Uber, AirBNB and all those companies some manners and respect for our society.
>> We really need to teach Facebook, Twitter, Uber, AirBNB and all those companies some manners and respect for our society.
As a German, let me tell you that this sounds absolutely ridiculous, arrogant and hubristic. You want your German Extrawurst. We're not "one society", not everyone agrees with the tons of laws and regulations we have (mostly on account of special pleading and lobbyism).
German users came to Facebook and Twitter first, not the other way around. These are not German companies, they don't need to operate out of Germany, so why should they have to follow our every law? If anything, you'd be "teaching" them not to bother with Germany, because it's too much of a pain in the ass.
I would have no problem with them deciding it‘s not worth the trouble and banning German users.
I have a problem with how they want to make money here, but illegally.
And yes, I want rules to be decided democratically. Not by „what does hardwires think about it?“.
>Unfortunately, there are only fines for failing to delete obviously illegal content
This is not the case, there is no fine for failing to delete obviously illegal content.
This is correct and unfortunately it has been twisted so much through public debate that nobody believes it. The fines are for systematically ignoring that law, not for singular mistakes they make.
Okay, rereading the law, the fine is for not making a process available that guarantees (among other things) that obviously illegal content is deleted or locked within 24 hours unless a different deadline has been negotiated for that specific content.
The effect is the same: the easiest way to implement the requirements in the law is to default to deletion.
>The new law (NetzDG, roughly "network enforcement act" [1]) was intended
Intent never matters. What matters is what happens in reality. The road to hell is paved by good intentions.
> You want your German Extrawurst.
Now, that is an interesting interpretation of the rule of law if I have ever seen one!
So, in your opinion, having to follow the laws of a country you visit or that you do business in is somehow illegitimate because it's an Extrawurst? Is it your expectation that the US will apply German law to you when you visit the US?
> These are not German companies, they don't need to operate out of Germany,
Well, true?
> so why should they have to follow our every law?
Because they do operate in Germany?
> If anything, you'd be "teaching" them not to bother with Germany, because it's too much of a pain in the ass.
So, we shouldn't apply laws because that could be teaching people to not bother with Germany? So I suppose you think we shouldn't apply laws at all, then? It's not like Germans couldn't end up learning that they should leave the country if they have to follow laws, is it?
>> Now, that is an interesting interpretation of the rule of law if I have ever seen one!
That isn't an "interpretation of the rule of law", that's a response to the bold statement that "We really need to teach [...] all those companies some manners and respect for our society".
Yes, we can introduce all sorts of stupid laws to make foreign companies do as we please or have them leave. No, we're not "teaching" them "manners and respect" for our society. We killed millions of people, not even a hundred years ago, but now we're the paragons of virtue? Give me a fucking break...
>> Because they do operate in Germany?
Clearly whatever they did was legal in however way they operate "in Germany", or there would have been a German court case.
> Clearly whatever they did was legal in however way they operate "in Germany", or there would have been a German court case.
Actually, what they did was not legal. Not appearing in court when a judge orders you to is not legal. It just so happens that it's not enforcable when the person ordered to appear happens to be in a different country. In order to limit the negative effects of this illegal behaviour, now more of their behaviour has been made illegal in such a way that if they don't follow those rules, it can actually be enforced.
> We killed millions of people, not even a hundred years ago, but now we're the paragons of virtue?
I don't see how this was relevant in any way to the discussion. What happened 100 years ago should of course be considered in discussions and in the law-making process today and it should not be forgotten, so that it will not repeat. But it isn't fair to still judge people born in a country where some of their grand(grand)parents did bad things.
>> But it isn't fair to still judge people born in a country where some of their grand(grand)parents did bad things.
I'm not doing that. I'm pointing out that it is laughable to believe that German society could "teach our manners and morals" to the "foreigners" conducting business here.
The German society didn't create Nazism out of nothing, the (repressed) superiority complex is still very strong, only now the schizophrenic strategy is to appear like we're the best at "being good humans" instead of outright conquest. Our society is as pathological as it ever was, we have no business teaching anyone.
It sounds like your argument is 'people should ignore our laws against hate speech because we're the people who brought about WW2 and the holocaust, so you shouldn't trust us on this stuff.'
Of more simply 'ignore laws that aim at preventing a repeat of a crime because of the commission of that crime.'
¯\(°_o)/¯
I'm sorry, your analysis is incorrect.
I'm not talking about this fantastic new hate-speech law per se, I'm talking about the broader attitude in Germany where we just expect foreign business to gratefully deal with all of our bullshit, because we really are a bunch of narrow-headed cultural hegemonists.
Imagine if Turkey asked Facebook to enforce Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code. The reaction in Germany would be widespread ridicule, probably by some of the same people that demand this new law enforced because it's German law.
> The POINT is that the parent claimed Facebook is acting illegally, my point is they were not!
Except they weren't? Not respecting the law is not the same as acting illegally. If a Chinese manufacturer exports toxic food to Germany, is that illegal (according to German law)? For all I know, it's not. Does that mean that they are respecting German food safety regulations? No. Would it still be a problem if Chinese manufacturers exported toxic food to Germany? Yes. Does the fact that exporting toxic food to Germany is not illegal mean that it's not legitimate for Germany to try and find ways to prevent export of toxic food to Germany using its legal system?
> Even if something is illegal in Germany, you can not enforce German law on every company that stands to profit from a German audience.
Well, true? How is that relevant to Facebook, say? As far as I know, Facebook is not every company?
> Therefore, if you want to use German law to "teach" those companies, you're out of luck.
So, you are saying the German legislative effort known as NetzDG is not having any effect on how Facebook behaves?
> As a German myself, I am very glad about this, because (for example) I don't have to wait until 10PM and verify my identity to consume government-sanctioned pornography, as German law would require.
So, because you disagree with a specific law, you think the German state should not enforce any laws on foreign corporations? Because you think that German limits on porn are idiotic, you think an American bank defrauding German customers should not be held accountable, say?
> You don't see a lot of people asking for respect and enforcement of those laws, yet as soon as it comes to "hate speech" the nanny-state-conformists come out of the woodwork...
Which has what to do with whether laws should apply to foreign companies exactly? Are you seeing a lot of people asking for enforcement of porn laws against German companies?
> The porn law applies in the same way that the hate speech laws apply, insofar as they're dealing with German "customers".
I'm not sure it does, but in any case: Is it really a good state of affairs that it's enforced selectively-ish? It's not exactly protecting the constitutional rights of porn stars and porn producers in Germany, is it? Sure, overall, it might be better that at least foreign porn is accessible unrestricted than none at all, but is that an argument for selective enforcement, or not rather against restrictions of porn?