8 ms·
To be honest, these days I think if we want a proper OS and if we want the incentives of the vendor to align with ours, we need subscription OSes. Right now we
by oblio 9y ago
To be honest, these days I think if we want a proper OS and if we want the incentives of the vendor to align with ours, we need subscription OSes.
Right now we have:
* Android - basically ad supported, therefore misaligned incentives
* iOS/macOS - locked into Apple hardware
* Windows - old school licensing until 10, with the problems they mentioned for Vista; new licensing which seems to be more like Android adware
A cheap yearly subscriptions would realign the incentives: I am the client, I want frequent feature updates, I want fast security updates, I want to be the client and not the product, I don't want the company to go under or force development teams into stupid feature development or release trains cause they need to make sure there's a revenue stream.
Basically I pay them for providing timely security and regular feature updates, preferably in an incremental fashion.
Everyone who's not happy with this can either lock themselves into hardware (Apple) or go DYI, basically, with Linux/BSD or just accept that being tracked isn't that bad (Android).
I'd be really sad if the anti-tracking forces within the Windows division lose. There has to be a better revenue model than tracking users and providing ads, somewhere.
- xorcist 9y agoThere's nothing DIY about a ready made Linux distribution such as the Fedora Desktop. As long as you don't fiddle around too much under the hood, and don't insert random commands in places because someone on the Internet told you to, things will Just Work like nothing else. There's something to be said to having the developers actually caring about making a useful computer without allowing the marketing department to take charge. Don't try to run it on some unsupported hardware (including outside "third party drivers"), anything bog standard Intel based will do, and you'll be absolutely fine.
- oblio 9y agoThe OS itself is not that DYI, even though I don't like being constrained in hardware terms. Let's say that I get over that. Then the DYI part begins, at least for me. I like AAA games, almost none of the games I play are available on Linux (primarily Blizzard games). A lot of desktop apps I like or need are not on Linux, etc. In any case, let's just say I used to have a Linux site and forum back in 2007 or so, I'be been through the Linux evangelism cycle a few times. For many people, such as myself, Linux desktop is acceptable but not the best option. And for a reasonable price I'd rather have the best option for me, personally.
- mcny 9y ago> I like AAA games, almost none of the games I play are available on Linux (primarily Blizzard games). A lot of desktop apps I like or need are not on Linux, etc. I don't have any first hand knowledge about the AAA gaming industry but from what I understand, the studios offload a lot of the work to the GPU manufacturer (nVidia most likely) who then "fixes" the bugs in what they call a graphics driver. I think this is the main problem. The so called graphics drivers do too much work and games don't pull their own weight.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoThat's certainly a problem, but that's not why games aren't being ported to Linux, in my opinion, it's that A) the user base isn't large enough to bother in many cases (these same companies often release terrible Windows ports for more or less the same reason) and B) It's a pain in the ass for a multitude of reasons not the least of which is that the Linux community thinks it has a great development environment but it doesn't (at least for Destktop stuff).
- pbhjpbhj 9y ago>that's not why games aren't being ported to Linux // What's weird to me is that a lot of games will run on Linux, eg via WINE (PlayOnLinux) say but the companies then appear to be hostile to users doing that. I used to play a load of the Tom Clancy games on WINE [single player], but then Origin messed with something, maybe their cheat system, making it no longer work on Linux. So now I don't buy games from Origin any more and stick with Steam. It's not just "not ported to", game companies seem actively hostile to [paying!] Linux users, I don't know if MS pay them to be like that or what their motivation is?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoI think you're reading too much in to it. They just don't want to have to support WINE users and have their brand associated with their problems.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago> There's nothing DIY about a ready made Linux distribution such as the Fedora Desktop. Until you want to change something. It is trivial to target a single use case and make it easy with Linux (most of the time) or almost any other OS, but that isn't what we want from Desktop OS, we want flexibility so we can conform it to our workflow, and Linux Desktop is absolutely terrible at that because it's become a giant Rube Goldberg machine of schizophrenic and often half-thought out components written with the idea that they're in a multiuser server environment but pretending they were designed for personal desktops. If someone built a new, joy to work with and develop for, userland on top of the Linux kernel that wasn't oriented towards the idea that the system is a multi-user network server in 1983, I would subscribe the hell out of it (though in my opinion it had better be open source regardless). As a side project, I'm actually playing with concepts in this vein, but I'm really not that good a developer and don't have a lot of time to devote to it, it's just that no one else is doing it.
- swiley 9y agoIf you want to change something then run an OS that's built with the expectation that you change things (Alpine, Gentoo etc.)
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoThey aren't any better because they still use all the same software and follow all the same broken paradigms.
- swiley 9y agoNo they don't? Alpine uses the BusyBox deamons (initd, evdev etc.) And Gentoo uses openrc. Both of these are much easier to tweak than systemd. Same for the network manager replacements and so on. Different distros (that aren't just modified Debian or redhat) can differ by quite a lot.
- majewsky 9y ago
- kowdermeister 9y agoI'm using Win10 for years now and never noticed any ads. I don't think the Android comparison really stands.
- oblio 9y agoI did notice a subtle ad on a coworker's laptop once. I am a bit afraid of what happens if their Windows revenue goes down. Also, they do operate on the other spectrum of this continuum, Windows 10 collects a lot of data, for what I presume is user tracking for ads & co.
- barrkel 9y agoI noticed ads on the lock screen when it was set to Windows Spotlight.
- tinus_hn 9y agoIt’s full of ads for Edge, OneDrive, Office and some more of their own services, and then it’s automatically installing and wasting the space you paid for on Candy Crush and other games, even if you tune the Start Menu so you don’t see the tiles. I understand that you don’t see it if you don’t look but you certainly are paying for it.
- sparcpile 9y agoFor my home PCs, I purchased the MS Action Pack subscription so that I could install Windows 10 Enterprise LTSB and not get ads and Cortana. With it and ClassicShell, it serves me nicely. I prefer my FreeBSD box running Motif as my daily driver though.
- sydd 9y agoI don't think Windows or Android are adware. They are "carrier" products, free but MS/Google can decide what services to bundle, and this is where they get the money (=app store, having Office preinstalled). So it's a much less obstrusive than adware which lives from constantly showing you ads like websites
- pjmlp 9y agoFor some strange cultural reason now computer bundles of yore are considered ads. http://www.amigahistory.plus.com/a500batman.html http://www.amigahistory.plus.com/a500batman.html Back then they were Packs, now in digital format they are ads.
- oblio 9y agoOk, maybe not direct adware, but more like light spyware and "carriers", as you said. They bundle services, including data collection, so that they can turn you into the product. Microsoft less so, but and I hope they stop this trend they started.
- pjmlp 9y agoGoogle started it, not Microsoft.
- oblio 9y agoI meant the trend started in the company/in the Windows division.
- pjmlp 9y agoNo, Google was tracking users long before Microsoft. It is not Microsoft that tracks me whenever I am, unless I disable the settings in play services, and even then I am not sure. It is not Microsoft that sells an OS whose premise is that all my data lives on their servers. It is not Microsoft that created an office suite that hides my data behind servers, with access to everything I might create with those applications. Buddling software with the computer being bought was already a thing in the 8 bit era, with C64, Spectrum, MSX and Atari packs.
- ferongr 9y agoMy Android device shows me no ads.
- oblio 9y agoThat's cause Android pushes Chrome and Google Search and Gmail and... you get it, the whole data collection and ad serving mechanism provided by Google. I bundle telemetry/data collection with ads for my post since in the end they're just different ends of the same continuum.
- ferongr 9y agoDon't move the goalposts from "ads" to bundled apps. Furthermore, the "data collection" would be the same whether I accessed those services from my GNU/Linux desktop or Android device so I don't understand where you're going with that claim.
- Sylos 9y agoWell, the apps do. And Google has unfortunately forgotten to give you the tools to block those from doing that by not giving you ways to block internet access.
- ferongr 9y agoTalk about moving the goalposts. Regardless, simple hosts-based adblocking works well on Android.
- Sylos 9y agoNo point in leaving the goal posts where they are when they don't reflect the goal: Not having ads in your face all the time. Hosts-file-based blocking requires Root, which Google has also practically cut off from end-users. Yes, the manufacturers can give you root, so clearly it's their fault, but Google doesn't implement user access control, making Root extremely insecure on Android.
- bambax 9y ago> I am the client, I want frequent feature updates, I want fast security updates Oh God no. I am the client, I DO NOT want frequent feature updates, or any update at all, except important (life-threatening) basic security patches. I want things to NOT CHANGE ever, esp. the UI and the way to do basic tasks.
- oblio 9y agoDo you know of any GUI OS that actually works like that? I'd rather have frequent small changes than Big Bang changes...
- xiphias 9y agoIt was funny when I first read that a big color palette change that the Chrome team wanted to do was split to multiple releases so that people don't notice the change in any single release.
- ryukafalz 9y agoAnything with XFCE - you'd probably do well with Xubuntu. This is XFCE in 2003: https://cdn.xfce.org/about/screenshots/4.2-3.jpg https://cdn.xfce.org/about/screenshots/4.2-3.jpg This is XFCE today: https://cdn.xfce.org/about/tour/4.12/xfwm4-tiling-small.png https://cdn.xfce.org/about/tour/4.12/xfwm4-tiling-small.png
- ufo 9y agoDunno if XFCE qualifies for "frequent small releases" though :)
- mrisoli 9y agoWhat you want is a Rolling Release Distro, like Arch or Gentoo, then you can add whatever GUI you want on top of it, I like XFCE as a sibling comment mentioned.
- ufo 9y ago
- cirgue 9y agoSubscription incentives only work in the favor of users with viable competition and low switching cost. Neither condition exists right now for businesses or the overwhelming majority of home users.
- jpeloquin 9y agoHow much do you think such an OS could be sold for? For me, Windows wastes about 2% of my time per year (mostly due to Windows update). From a business perspective, that might justify a $10k expense to recover that lost productivity. From a personal perspective, I would pay $500 to recover that time for my own use. No idea if there's enough like-minded people to make a new OS profitable, though. The sticking point is that to recoup time lost to Windows the new OS would have to completely replace Windows, which means being able to run key Windows-only business software (SolidWorks, etc.). Maybe it makes more sense to just support Wine instead of reinventing the OS.
- user5994461 9y agoWhat makes you think the new OS won't waste more than 2% of your time?
- jpeloquin 9y agoI am optimistic that it's possible to do better because: (a) I'm only counting time as "wasted" if I'm forced to fix something the OS broke with no action on my part, or if I'm forced to wait for it to do something that I did not ask for. E.g., watching Windows apply updates on boot is wasted. Adjusting keybindings to suit my preferences is not wasted. This isn't a high bar to clear. (b) Design choices, not physical or logical restrictions on what's possible, cause most of this waste. E.g., the choice to have Windows update do substantial work during reboot and to reset user settings (such as HKLM and HKCU keys) is an unforced error. It's demonstrably possible to do better: Linux Mint updates apply in the background, don't lengthen boot time, and leave existing settings unchanged. (c) If the new OS is worse than the current choices, I just don't use it. The time a new OS wastes is in all cases ≤ 2%. Building a new thing that fails hurts a lot, of course, but being a customer is easy.
- mnm1 9y ago"I am the client, I want frequent feature updates, I want fast security updates, I want to be the client and not the product, I don't want the company to go under or force development teams into stupid feature development or release trains cause they need to make sure there's a revenue stream." You just described at least a dozen Linux and BSD distributions. They fit every single one of your points and are free.
- jenscow 9y agoI mostly agree. Basically, you want Ubuntu/Mint/Fedora, but the last time you used one of them was 10 years ago. I needed to escape Windows as soon as I installed the Windows 8 preview, and realised Microsoft's incentives where going against mine. (and don't talk to me about lock-in or software unavailability, I had a 20 year career of MS tech)