5 ms·
Unfortunately the recommended behavior is to be "difficult". Trying to somehow state your own rights, demand that officers perform searches in accordance with l
by alkonaut 9y ago
Unfortunately the recommended behavior is to be "difficult". Trying to somehow state your own rights, demand that officers perform searches in accordance with law etc. - which is "being difficult". If you are on your way to a great holiday, important meeting etc, you aren't going to risk it. Because anyone "being difficult" will be detained or rejected. So I'll just fold and give them my password. And they know this.
The only time I'd even hesitate to trade my precious time for my integrity is if I actually had something to hide, unfortunately. Which just reinforces their assumption that anyone not immediately unlocking their device to let them read your business docs or see your kid photos - must be hiding something.
- tomalpha 9y agoThis. Being "difficult" might be an option for US citizens, but if you're a visitor you're really only going to have a choice between cooperating and being refused entry. If you're refused entry you'll have a much harder job returning.
- gcb0 9y agothat's what they want you to belive. and it saddens me that they are achieving their goals. as an immigrant, I have always opted out of the scanner with undocumented effectiveness and undocumented health effects with no consequences other than a pat down.
- tomalpha 9y agoI (think I) get the point you're making and I broadly agree, but in the immigration case (on the way in to the country, rather than the way out) it's more than what they want you to believe: it's what they can and do enforce. For good or ill. And there's very little that you can do about it other than decide to not travel to the USA. This link[0] is admittedly an advert for legal services, but there are a couple of interesting snippets in there such as: > ... if you have been refused entry into the United States at any point in the past, even for an expired passport, the previous denial is reasoning enough for future denial. IANAL but my understanding is that for non-residents there's no legal obligation to admit you outside of maybe some of the international refugee conventions (which are unlikely to apply). The law is deliberately discretionary. A refusal to admit can be based purely on "suspicion". You can imagine a CBP officer finding you suspicious (rightly or wrongly) because you refuse to hand over your passwords even if they don't have a legal right to force you to hand them over. They can simply offer you a choice of handing them over or going home. To be clear: I'm not advocating for this state of affairs, but it does appear to be the case. [0] https://www.visaplace.com/blog-immigration-law/denied-entry-to-the-us/denied-entry-airport/ https://www.visaplace.com/blog-immigration-law/denied-entry-...
- 282883392 9y agoAre Airport Body Scanners Safe? (Time, 2017) [http://time.com/4909615/airport-body-scanners-safe/ http://time.com/4909615/airport-body-scanners-safe/]
- gcb0 9y agothe article have one person who agrees it is insecure and another who claims it to be safe without absolutely no information whatsoever. specially nice is the quotes: "and something you experience so infrequently, even if you’re a regular flyer—that you don’t have much to worry about." such a glorious logical falacy. or they dont know what infrequent and/or regular means. and yet, the author saw it proper to publish twelve quotes from that person with unbased, uncontested positive remarks. great journalism.
- piva00 9y agoWanting to preserve my privacy is very different from having something to hide. I don't want border officers looking into my personal pictures that might have nudes from my girlfriend, fiddling around conversations with friends with jokes about drugs, conversations with my girlfriend about her mental health, same with some other close friends. Those are private things, not necessarily harmful or criminal but things I surely don't want to be sharing with random people making decisions about entering a country. Unfortunately the effect on me is a full deterrent: I have the money, time and desire to visit more parts of the US. I have been to San Francisco, Los Angeles and New York for vacations once and would love to go back to the West Coast and check out national parks like Redwood or Yosemite but I really can't be arsed to be "digitally frisked" around, the world is huge and I can afford to go to other places.
- alkonaut 9y ago> Wanting to preserve my privacy is very different from having something to hide. Absolutely agreee. But as long as the only people who argue their privacy actually are those that have something to hide, the two will eventually be conflated. And the way they implement this is by giving a lot of wiggle room for border staff to implement these terrible laws. > I don't want border officers looking into my personal pictures that might have nudes from my girlfriend, fiddling around conversations with friends with jokes about drugs, conversations with my girlfriend about her mental health, same with some other close friends. I don't want that either. I don't think anyone wants this. The bottom line is: all you can do, at least as non-citizen, is a) don't visit or b) comply with whatever stupid laws there are, including complying with officers that don't follow the law. Because if you want to enter you do as they say.
- batmenace 9y agoTheres another case, though. Some people have no choice but to be "difficult". Consider, for example, a lawyer from an international firm travelling with company devices, which have on them privileged information that can under no circumstances be disclosed. These kinds of people have no choice but to be "difficult".
- letsgetphysITal 9y agoThose people don't carry that data with them, if they're competent or have competent IT staff. They have already configured VPNs with 2FA, burner laptops and mobile devices, or simply mail the devices via registered post to the hotel and have them picked up there. Device moving through the mail system don't get seen by the border grunts.
- actionowl 9y ago> Those people don't carry that data with them You've made a great point here. What criminal is also going to carry their incriminating data with them? This isn't an effective policy. What problem does it actually solve?
- ben_w 9y agoMost people, I think, don’t follow strict digital security/hygiene policies, nor understand them. That includes me, even though I try to be good. (I will not give specific details because two of my three memorable errors are currently covered by NDAs, and the third is personal).
- jstanley 9y agoRight, but they don't need to investigate most people. They need to investigate people who are motivated enough to... well, I'm not sure what. Cross borders while possessing illegal data? But anyway, the people who are motivated enough to do it can easily circumvent it. The only people harmed are innocents.
- bambax 9y agoAs the saying goes, I don't have "anything to hide", and kind of don't care being searched. However I would never give my password to anyone. As a matter of principle, giving out your password is like betraying yourself. Granted, I've never been asked, so I'm not sure what amount of pressure / threats I can withstand. I hope it's a lot, because asking someone for his password is insane and despicable.
- gcb0 9y ago> The only time I'd even hesitate to trade my precious time for my integrity is if I actually had something to hide I honestly can't tell if you are trolling, I missed the irony, or you are really as dense as a badly trained racist border office (which thankfully is not all of them)
- alkonaut 9y agoCompletely not trolling, nor ironic. Now: I’ll be very clear that I don’t agree with these policies. They are terrible. And obviously if I had anything sensitive I wouldn’t travel with it in the first place! But if I landed in Miami tomorrow for a holiday and someone asked me to unlock my phone so they could look around - would I? Yes! Because I know that not doing it leads to somewhere worse. The point I was trying to make was that I don’t have the luxury of standing up for principles at the US border. Best case it will take a few hours of me being difficult while my family waits. Worse case I’m on a plane home again. So the end result is that if I’m reluctant to show device data at the border, it’s because I realized that something on my device would be found a more serious issue than my refusal to show it. Do not take my previous post as me subscribing to some form of “it’s no problem if you have nothing to hide”. That’s not what I was saying. It is a problem, and I just don’t have a choice.
- zbentley 9y agoWell put. Consider also the situation of people who are traveling to the US for business, and for whom it is a requirement that they travel there. Not only would being difficult subject them to a potentially-huge short-term monetary loss (lost sales contract, for example), but it might also wreak long-term financial and reputational havoc on them if they lose their job or are blackballed by their company for being someone who "can't travel without getting law enforcement involved". That, again, is what the people authoring and enforcing these policies count on. The power dynamic is almost entirely against travelers. All the solutions are so radical as to be unfeasible in the short term (remodel international transit authorities; move business out of the US; remodel businesses to not require travel, etc.).
- _jal 9y agoThen, bluntly, you have made your choice. Those unwilling to stand up for themselves can't expect anyone else to stand up for them.
- alkonaut 9y agoExactly. I can't afford to stand up for my ideals at the border. I expect people (including myself) to stand up for these things, just not at the border. My main way of disagreeing with policies like this is to simply skip any travel to the US. I can't vote, but I can vote with my wallet. But basically saying that people should either accept that their expensive holiday (or job) might go down the toilet, or they have no principles - is a bit much to expect I think.
- zbentley 9y ago> people should either accept that their expensive holiday (or job) might go down the toilet, or they have no principles That is exactly the situation and there is no easy way out. There are solutions, but they are long-term and often unfeasible.
- _jal 9y agoI'm not talking about your (or anyone else's) principles. I can't see into anyone's heart or mind. I'm talking about revealed preference, more than anything else. Yes, fighting is risky and unpleasant. It always is. You make your choice and live with the result.
- newfoundglory 9y agoThat sounds pretty judgmental, especially since I suspect there are human rights threats around the world that you (and everyone else) are not fighting either.
- _jal 9y agoYou can take it how you like. I'm simply stating the obvious. But this particular variation "you're a hypocrite for spending energy on X when there's so much Y in the world" argument was weak when it was first trotted out and hasn't aged well. Worse, the argument is an irrelevant red-herring when talking about choices an individual makes about their own reactions to their own rights being encroached in day to day life. Nobody complains that someone who fights back at being mugged isn't also fighting spousal abuse in $far_away_land.
- smcl 9y agoPersonally I'm just gonna skip the USA altogether for holidays and work - the world is pretty huge and full of interesting places. I know it's not an option for US citizens and it's a shame for the rest of us but I've decided it's not worth it.
- throwaway7312 9y agoUS citizen here. Haven't visited the US in years. Myriad reasons why, but the CBP policy is part of it. Just don't like the idea of people demanding I let them go through my stuff, but also don't like the idea of sitting around for 8 or 9 hours or having my machine confiscated if I won't give up the password, either. I should also note that at least as a US citizen, having traveled through some 40 or so different countries, US customs is the third most unfriendly customs I have traveled through. Only ones worse for me have been Canada (last trip to Canada was likely the last I will make after my last customs experience there) and Czech. I feel much more comfortable visiting supposedly authoritarian countries than I do the United States.
- smcl 9y agoI’ve heard Canada was bad from a few different people, that’s so surprising! Czech Republic is an odd one, I’ve not had any problems personally and I’ve flown in and out of Brno and Prague a few times (though I prefer Vienna). Mind sharing what happened, purely to satisfy my curiosity? I had a weird issue when one customs guy was trying to tell me that I reported my passport missing a year prior, and he got extremely frustrated that I couldn’t understand what everything was saying. Nothing came of it, it was just a few confusing minutes with an obviously flustered person who was refusing to believe my Czech was as terrible as it was.
- singingboyo 9y agoAs a Canadian: what's bad about Canadian customs/border crossings? Can't say I've ever had a problem, but then I'm also a citizen, which may make things different.