5 ms·
Google is in a tough spot with this. On the one hand they sincerely want to increase diversity because increasing the pool of candidates means there are more c
by mc32 9y ago
Google is in a tough spot with this.
On the one hand they sincerely want to increase diversity because increasing the pool of candidates means there are more candidates to choose from. Also, having more women see technology as a career path is a good thing for the American workforce --it strengthens it.
On the other hand, there are some who then see this initiative to begin their crusades for diversity in their vision. That is, it ends being a means to enrich the pool of applicants but rather a means to play favorites and push agendas. That's to say Google wants to increase women in the workforce but they do not want to make men "unwanted".
I have known people there and I am told that the generalities that we hear that conservatives tend to stay quiet and that one side of the political spectrum in encouraged while the other is shunned is true.
Beside that, this person left voluntarily, they did not get fired despite their attempts to re-start contentious conversations management had sought to regain control over.
By the way, overlooked in all this is the overrepresentation of non-American citizens in the companies, with respect to wanting the companies to reflect the Am pop at large. And, who cares about that stat. I mean, they contribute a whole hell of a lot. Yet, you see, people only care about _their_ interpretation of what is acceptable diversity and unacceptable diversity figures.
- arduanika 9y ago> the overrepresentation of non-American citizens in the companies, with respect to wanting the companies to reflect the pop at large Or underrepresentation, depending on whether you're talking about the US pop or world pop. Or the population of countries where Google is not firewalled, and hence is the dominant gateway to the internet there.
- seanmcdirmid 9y ago> Or the population of countries where Google is not firewalled, and hence is the dominant gateway to the internet there. I'm sure Google has many Chinese employees as well.
- mc32 9y agoNo one ever, ever talks about int'l workforce representation at Toyota or Lexus or Huawei, or Samsung, or Kubota, or you know Petroleum from the ME. Never. This is only brought up as a distraction from the fact that they are overrepresented with respect to their numbers in America and as participants in the American workforce. Aside from that, it's no country's responsibility to provide gainful employment to non-nationals.
- thedevilslawyer 9y agoNo one ever has, doesn't mean no one ever should.
- mc32 9y agoInteresting... So, you know, you mean Google should hire representatively for Texas, Florida, Indiana, etc., cuz you know, their workforce should represent essentially "their customer base". And while they are at it, why not make them hire representatively amongst conservatives and liberals?
- paulddraper 9y agoI don't think anyone expects a company to hire differently than the population of their location. Offices in Japan will be mostly Japanese, offices in England will be mostly English, offices in India will be mostly Indian, etc.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoYes (Japan), most definitely not (England), yes (India). Assumes we are talking about tech of course, England has more diversity than the USA in that area, especially in London.
- paulddraper 9y agoNot sure what you mean. England is 91% white, 5% Asian, 4% other. I would expect workforces in England to follow those trends. London is 60% white, 13% black, 7% Asian, 7% Indian, 13% other. I would expect workforces in London to follow those trends. That anyone would expect a workforce to reflect world numbers rather than local ones is very odd.
- dagw 9y agoOP said English, not white. From a nationality point of view London is one of the most diverse places around.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoParent said English. Also, tech != everything else. Tech workforces don't necessarily follow the demographics of the places where they are located.
- skydv 9y agoDiversity means quotes must be filled on colored and women, if a white guy is better, he can go fuсk himself because a colored or a women is required to fill quotes. What a world...
- lostlogin 9y agoI think you mean quotas. And the method you suggest is probably the worst way of achieving diversity, there are others. Perceiving white males to be hard done by is amusing.
- gaius 9y agoPerceiving white males to be hard done by is amusing. Here’s what you don’t get: none of these groups are homogeneous. It is perfectly plausible for a “white male” manager to discriminate against a white male Worker if that manager is incentivised to do so, either explicitly or implicitly. I mention in another comment an example of Google systematically attempting to disempower Workers (for which members of the boss class gave those bosses a mere slap on the wrist) Class trumps race, gender, age, anything else when analysing anything from a company to an entire country.
- kaffee 9y agoBoardroom gender quotas are being adopted by more and more countries. There's little evidence that this has proved harmful, modest evidence that it has helped company performance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_representation_on_corporate_boards_of_directors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_representation_on_corpo...
- skydv 9y agohaven't you read manifesto? that's wtf is going on there, white male can't get a job if quota for colored and women is not filled
- bobdole1234 9y agoYou think Google is going to just let work go un-done because they don't have a diverse candidate in the role?