5 ms·
This seems speculative and it effectively posits a worst-of-all-worlds situation resulting - one if which the UK is half inside the single market. Half inside
by Nursie 9y ago
This seems speculative and it effectively posits a worst-of-all-worlds situation resulting - one if which the UK is half inside the single market.
Half inside such that it allows the flow of goods (the UK is a net importer) but not services (which we net export). This would be untenable, worse than a no-deal situation. And the basis of this speculation is that the EU is holding all the cards. I'm really not convinced this is true.
The article reads a little bit like a remain fantasy - Brexit will be a disaster and then people must come around to my way of thinking! The problem with that analysis is that in your way of thinking it was likely unimaginable that the Brexit vote would go through in the first place. And then we heard that no PM would ever actually action it, and then that no Parliament would allow it. None of which has really panned out.
--edit-- I'd love to reply to more of the comments below, but I appear to be rate-limited. Never mind then...
- Xylakant 9y agoSo far negotiations have shown the EU holds most of the important cards. The UK caved in on any negotiation demand. It’s a fascinating view from Germany: The UK threatens “No Deal”, the EU informs companies that “No Deal” is a possible outcome and plans contingencies, informs companies that they should too, UK now complains that EU threatens companies. UK says “Out means out”, EU prepares to move EU institutions abroad, UK complains about EU moving institutions abroad. I’m also puzzled what’s supposed to happen with such important stuff as rules and agreements for importing nuclear materials for powerplants (currently regulated via Euratom), regulations regarding medicine/medical treatment (currently also handled on a european level) and all of that stuff. Which other option does the UK realistically have for those things other than just accept the EU rules? Any producer for anything that wants to export to the EU will have to abide by EU rules anyways. Will there be a UK and a EU edition of things? All of this could be solved with sufficient time, but triggering article 50 was akin to holding a loaded gun to your head and saying “if you don’t do what I want at the end of the next two years, I’ll pull the trigger.”
- pbhjpbhj 9y ago>Which other option does the UK realistically have for those things other than just accept the EU rules? // I'm not sure if it was a main driver but the powers that are pushing this whole thing behind the scenes clearly have realised the opportunity to subtely rewrite a lot of regulations/legislation to prefer their interests. The "sovereignty" part of Brexit is playing out as taking power from a more socialist and green EU and giving it to the hidden capitalist interests behind the Tories. The incredible sleight-of-hand has been getting the working classes to vote for something that could then be twisted to be so highly detrimental to them. Anyway, to your question about industry regulations: safety, food standards, and environmentalism costs money. Companies within the EU trading block will sell the stuff that meets the regulations, UK will get to have cheap stuff that breaks easily and no longer have the 2 year 'warranty', or the restrictions on unfair business practices - UK companies will try and foist our lower standards on whoever we can fool in to it, eg with promises of "foreign aid" that end up in developing world officials bank accounts. Bonus, the workers making the stuff will get paid less, have less job security, less rights. Double bonus, UK environment will be open for capitalists to fuck up if they want to make a quick buck.
- alkonaut 9y ago> I’m also puzzled what’s supposed to happen with such important stuff as rules and agreements for importing nuclear materials for powerplants (currently regulated via Euratom), regulations regarding medicine/medical treatment (currently also handled on a european level) and all of that stuff. Obviously there are already emergency plans to set up massive bureaucracies to replace the european ones. Just like there are enormous customs stations being built at the channel tunnel, the construction of which started the day after the election. Or it isn't. Because in the end the sheer enormity of the task probably is too much to take in, and even the slightest risk that all of this will somehow "go away" or "be delayed" means politicians aren't really ready to start burying billions of pounds in these projects. And the deadlines creep ever closer. This at least leads me to think that the outcome of theis "first brexit" negotiaion will be that the Brexit proper will happen in X years. The UK will keep paying nearly all of what it's paying PLUS costs to move EU things from Britain to the rest of europe. The bargaining space is the rebate the UK had before brexit, that is, the EU could possibly concede to let the UK "only" pay what it used to, and not significantly more.
- 627467 9y agoI'm curious: what are the cards UK is holding?
- Nursie 9y agoTrade with one of the world's larger economies. There is clear mutual interest in continuing trade on an open basis. I'm not saying the EU is not in a stronger position, nor am I trying to make any claims that Brexit is good or bad, nor that it is being pursued competently by the current government (far from it). But the assessment of the process as being entirely one sided seems to me to be simplistic.
- 627467 9y agoThe EU is more than an economic union. In fact, economic integration was/is only one of the strategies to foster lasting European stability, peace and path towards harmony among warring neighbours. To face these negotiations only on the basis of economic gains/lost is ignoring the political and less tangible goals of the union.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoBut lack of war in Europe is costing us so much in lost revenue for UK arms manufacturers!
- oblio 9y agoNot to rain on your parade, but the last "European" war almost bankrupted the UK. And back then European countries didn't have nukes while the UK still had an empire. I know you're being sarcastic :)
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoMy point was indeed to highlight the EU as a source of peace/stability. But, excess profit taxes are a thing, used to prevent the perverse incentives of capitalism during wartime. Bankrupting the country and bankrupting corporate interests are different things.
- dx034 9y agoIsn't a Canada-like solution exactly what current negotiations appear to work towards? Barnier presented a slide with options for the UK and a free trade agreement like with Canada was the only one that doesn't violate red lines set by the UK government. Such a free-trade agreement would allow most goods to flow relatively freely but doesn't have any provisions for services.
- Xylakant 9y agoThe Canada solution would take services off the table and that would hit London hard hard.
- dhoulb 9y agoYeah this seems like the most reasonable option. Even not having service trade isn’t a great disaster. Companies with sizeable EU revenue can just set up a European subsidiary (in Ireland, etc) to conduct business in Europe from the UK (or anywhere). (Though I accept it’ll be a pain for e.g. finance companies which the EU requires to be based within the EU,) Startups eespecially aren’t held back by these rules right now, they just sell everywhere in USD (and at some point when they’re big enough create an EU subsidiary). The goods thing would be a real issue, if everything on supermarket shelves became 1.5x as expensive. So as long as that’s solved it’ll be fine.
- tobltobs 9y ago> Though I accept it’ll be a pain for e.g. finance companies which the EU requires to be based within the EU What kind of services does the UK export which do not fall into the finance category?
- collyw 9y agoAs a Brit working in Europe, one year and a half after the announcement I have absolutely no idea what is going to happen. It makes sense to at least know what the worst possible scenario is. We have a Prime Minister who was against Brexit pushing for a hard Brexit. An opposition leader who is for Brexit. An uninformed public who were blatantly lied to (350 million a week to the NHS). The whole thing is an absolute shambles.
- stevekemp 9y agoI'm in much the same position. Working for a UK-company, getting paid in UK pounds sterling, but living in Europe. The whole thing is farcical, and I can only imagine it will become increasingly so as we near the deadline. I hope the UK changes its mind, but even if they do too many things will have been broken in the process.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIs Corbyn for Brexit? He campaigned against it all around the country before the referendum. Can anyone provide anything close to a first hand source?
- matthewmacleod 9y agoYes. Corbyn has been a long-term left-wing Eurosceptic, who opposed membership of the EC in 1975 and acted consistently with that view until the recent referendum. While his public statements during the referendum supported remaining in the EU, I would argue that the general consensus among most of the "remain" campaigners was that his support was lukewarm at best (e.g. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-politics-eu-referendum-36506163/corbyn-i-m-seven-out-of-10-on-eu http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-politics-eu-referendum-36506...). In reality, the Labour Party membership are broadly not Eurosceptic, and it's my view that Corbyn mostly has to toe a non-too-Eurosceptic line, especially given the support he has among generally pro-EU young people that brought him to power in the first place. At present, the Labour Party's position on Brexit is hopelessly muddled, something along the lines of "We don't want to remain in the single market but we kind of want something maybe sort of similar". There is no discussion about remaining in the EU. I'm sorry I can't provide you with a much better source at the moment, but it's more complex than a quote saying "I love Brexit".
- alimw 9y ago> The article reads a little bit like a remain fantasy - Brexit will be a disaster and then people must come around to my way of thinking! The article makes its prediction based on higher rates of death in old people.
- north_east_dev 9y agoWhich is pretty stupid tbh. You could look at the results of the original Europe referendum in the 70's and say that of course as the old die off, the Remain will just grow and grow. And then we got Brexit. People's opinions change as they age.
- moomin 9y agoWhich, given the state of the NHS, means the Conservative party are literally eroding their own base.