10 ms·
Death by Derivatives
- skrebbel 9y ago> Indeed, the string of early derivative traders taking their own lives grew long enough that one writer gave it a name: the “crimson thread of suicide.” I fear the day that Bitcoin & friends come crashing down.
- jstanley 9y agoDuring the 2014 crash there were details of suicide hotlines pinned to the top of r/bitcoin
- loooooooooooool 9y agoIf I'm still here... :(
- amelius 9y agoA more ironic title would be "Death by Securities".
- jstewartmobile 9y agoIf you haven't yet, read his story on Colonel Sanders. You can thank me later. https://www.damninteresting.com/colonels-of-truth/ https://www.damninteresting.com/colonels-of-truth/
- goldenkey 9y agoThat was an awesome read. Never knew the Colonel was a real person. A little sad how they managed to screw him over with no stock considering he founded the company. Good news though as of late, is that KFC is going back to its roots: http://www.bizjournals.com/newyork/news/2016/04/04/kfc-redo-stores-return-to-colonel-chicken-method.html http://www.bizjournals.com/newyork/news/2016/04/04/kfc-redo-... Might have to try it again :-)
- dsacco 9y agoThat was a nice read. I like these pieces about the historical context of financial instruments. > Michael Lewis details one such practice in his book Flash Boys, where market makers use superior networking technology to change the market price of a security after a customer sees it and places an order, forcing them to trade at an inferior price. This is a potentially misleading description of HFT algorithms. HFTs cannot see a customer’s order before it executes on an exchange. They cannot “jump in front of” an atomic order. HFTs only have insight like this at the inter-exchange level, i.e. in latency arbitrage. But by default a customer’s order won’t be routed to multiple exchanges unless there is insufficient liquidity to complete the order on the first exchange (which, if that’s routine, means you’re likely an institutional customer). Alternatively, if they submit several orders, HFTs will (logically) adjust their prices in response to the new order book activity, which would result in price slippage for the customer.
- cryptonector 9y agoHFTs == market makers. You need market makers in order to have a functioning, liquid market. Absence of market makers -> higher volatility. Market makers can lose a lot of money under certain market conditions. Their profit margins are rather small. Market makers are practically heros.
- vinceguidry 9y agoIt's a bit naive to equate the two. Plenty of strategies can be found that leverages high transaction speed and volume that aren't market making. What defines market making is the fact that you buy and sell the same commodity at the same time, taking advantage of the spread to make money. Two other rapid transaction arbitrage strategies involve market manipulation, in which trades are placed that are designed to fool other trading algorithms into believing that the price is going to move a certain way, and statistical arbitrage, which searches for temporary price differentials across exchanges. Neither of these two strategies create liquidity on the market, that is, offers more opportunities for anyone who wants to buy or sell to do so. Instead they seek to create, and/or exploit opportunities.
- kleiba 9y agoDamn, I clicked on the link thinking it would be an article on murderous calculus...
- sp332 9y agoWell here's the first related joke that came to mind: https://www.reddit.com/r/Jokes/comments/2o1rsw/a_calculus_joke/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Jokes/comments/2o1rsw/a_calculus_jo...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Synaesthesia 9y ago> The scale of today’s derivatives market is almost too vast to comprehend. It’s measured in trillions of dollars. Traders, aided by the most sophisticated software money can buy, place bets — billions per second — on the future prices of every manner of stuff. My grandpa can’t comprehend how bitcoin has “created value out of nothing” but really the finiancial world has been doing it for ages.
- KaiserPro 9y agoEven earlier is the first bank. At first they were just a safe place in which to store your valuables (basically they were goldsmiths renting out vault space) Then someone (I think dutch) realised that most of the time people kept there cash in one place. Which meant that instead of raising money explicitly for lending, they could "double enter" the cash, which meant any deposits to the bank were lent out immediately.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoI'm not an expert on such things, but I think it was earlier than the Dutch. It was the Italians, in the 1200s.
- madengr 9y agoI thought it was the Knights Templar. You'd deposit your money (with them in Europe) before your pilgrimage, then redeem it later (from them in the Holyland). Kept you from getting robbed along the way. They became pretty savy with banking, and the aristocrats and church did not like that, so killed them all.
- KaiserPro 9y agoAhh, you might be right, it rings a bell
- golergka 9y agoIn one case, "nothing" is decentiralized, secure and anonymous (not linked to real-life credentials) transactions, in another, it's risk management - but any way, it's far from "nothing".
- matt4077 9y agoIt's funny how people consider government intervention and centrally managed economies to be terribly inefficient, yet nonody counts the collective revenue of financial institutions as (at best) a necessary inefficiency of a market-based system. Same for advertisement, deadweight loss, artificial scarcity etc. It's pretty obvious that free markets (with a few guardrails) work better than anything else we've tried so far. Yet there's so much overhead spent on managing the system, one wonders how anything ever gets done...
- runeks 9y agoFinancial institutions are not a product of the free market — they are heavily regulated by government. On top of that, the currency that has been given legal tender status by government, and the currency used as the basis for calculating capital gains tax, just happens to be issued by the central bank that’s willing to monetize the government’s debt. What a peculiar coincidence.
- mcguire 9y agoFinancial institutions are a product of the free market, but are heavily regulated ("heavily?") by the government because humans are congenitally incapable of failing to avoid moral hazards.
- Retric 9y agoFinancial institutions predate government regulations. Their general role is cash flow management (ex: Loans) or risk mitigation (ex: Insurance).
- runeks 9y agoYou’re right. I should have written “contemporary financial institutions”.
- lodi 9y ago> ...the collective revenue of financial institutions as (at best) a necessary inefficiency of a market-based system. This doesn't make sense. If every dollar of their revenue created more than a dollars worth of value for the rest of the economy, then it's a net win. To put it in a different way, consider the economic losses if you couldn't get cheap mortgages, loans, etc. from financial institutions.
- wyager 9y ago> The scale of today’s derivatives market is almost too vast to comprehend. It’s measured in trillions of dollars. The commonly stated notional value of the derivatives market is sort of a nonsense number. It’s based on (very roughly speaking) the number of derivatives contracts times the value of their underlyings. This means that if you had, let’s say, a billion binary contracts that paid out one cent if Apple was above $180 in one month, this would have a notional value of like $175B, even though the maximum amount of money that changes hands is $10M and the market value of the contracts is even less than that. I looked actual estimated market value of all derivatives contracts a while back and it was something like 1.5% of the stated notional value. It’s still really big, but iirc substantially smaller than “normal” investments like stocks and commodities. Not saying the article’s wrong, it is indeed trillions of dollars even after accounting for this. Just an interesting thing that isn’t usually mentioned.