4 ms·

They absolutely have the right to refuse to cooperate with the Chinese government, its called refusing to do business in China.

by msh 9y ago

seanmcdirmid 9y ago
Who is "They"? If it is "Tim Cook", then Tim Cook has the right to be CEO and do business in China, or get fired. If you mean Apple stock holders, I'm sure they wouldn't be happy about taking a huge hit on their second or (at times) first largest market. Would you be willing to slice your retirement savings in half for this?
- msh 9y ago
  Google pulled out of China, so some times companies put principles before short term profit. Something Tim Cook have claimed apple also does, but apparently not in regards to China.
  - seanmcdirmid 9y ago
    Google wasn't making > 25% of their money in China. I applauded Google's move when they did it back then (and I worked down the street from their Wudaokou office), but it is completely obvious why Apple, as a public company who makes a lot of money in China, can't pull out now.
    - bitmapbrother 9y ago
      Your comment just proved his point that Apple puts their Chinese profits over their user's privacy. What percentage of Google's profits would come from China had they stayed there and acquiesced to the government demands? 15%? 20%? I wonder how much profit Google has missed out on by not doing business in China.
      - seanmcdirmid 9y ago
        It isn't there choice! Apple isn't a person, you have to understand that. Apple is your retirement fund or whatever investment, its a public company. Tim Cook can either say "I want us to be in China" or he can leave, because no sane board is going to let him stay and say otherwise. Blame capitalism, blame human desire for money, whatever, but don't blame the company for choosing the only option it had. Google didn't miss out on much at all, it was clear way before they pulled out that they wouldn't be allowed to go very far in search. Also, Google only pulled out of search in China, they actually still do plenty of business in China.

They absolutely have the right to refuse to cooperate with the Chinese government, its called refusing to do business in China.

by msh 9y ago

They absolutely have the right to refuse to cooperate with the Chinese government, its called refusing to do business in China.

seanmcdirmid 9y ago

Who is "They"? If it is "Tim Cook", then Tim Cook has the right to be CEO and do business in China, or get fired. If you mean Apple stock holders, I'm sure they wouldn't be happy about taking a huge hit on their second or (at times) first largest market. Would you be willing to slice your retirement savings in half for this?

msh 9y ago
Google pulled out of China, so some times companies put principles before short term profit. Something Tim Cook have claimed apple also does, but apparently not in regards to China.
- seanmcdirmid 9y ago
  Google wasn't making > 25% of their money in China. I applauded Google's move when they did it back then (and I worked down the street from their Wudaokou office), but it is completely obvious why Apple, as a public company who makes a lot of money in China, can't pull out now.
  - bitmapbrother 9y ago
    Your comment just proved his point that Apple puts their Chinese profits over their user's privacy. What percentage of Google's profits would come from China had they stayed there and acquiesced to the government demands? 15%? 20%? I wonder how much profit Google has missed out on by not doing business in China.
    - seanmcdirmid 9y ago
      It isn't there choice! Apple isn't a person, you have to understand that. Apple is your retirement fund or whatever investment, its a public company. Tim Cook can either say "I want us to be in China" or he can leave, because no sane board is going to let him stay and say otherwise. Blame capitalism, blame human desire for money, whatever, but don't blame the company for choosing the only option it had. Google didn't miss out on much at all, it was clear way before they pulled out that they wouldn't be allowed to go very far in search. Also, Google only pulled out of search in China, they actually still do plenty of business in China.