3 ms·
A better solution is aggressively fining absentee landlords who don't take care of their property and placing a lien on the property if they don't pay the fines
by astura 9y ago
A better solution is aggressively fining absentee landlords who don't take care of their property and placing a lien on the property if they don't pay the fines. Replacing landlords who don't care to do the upkeep with low income homeowners who can't afford the upkeep is absolutely not a solution.
- MattyRad 9y agoThe article mentions gated communities... that means there's an HOA right? Are these absentee landlords just ignoring the fines? Would there be any consequence of ignoring an HOA fine? I'm not a homeowner so my knowledge of HOAs and their role is very limited.
- astura 9y agoI don't know if gated communities have an HOA by definition but if you don't pay money you owe to your HOA depending on laws of the state and HOA agreements, they could put a lien on your property as well. However, it's possible to have an HOA that just doesn't give a shit and does no enforcing. It's already illegal to not do certain maintenance on your house (blight, etc.) especially if you have tenants living there. (tenant protection laws) So enforcement is the key.
- emodendroket 9y ago> I don't know if gated communities have an HOA by definition Almost every new/private development (as opposed to houses built along public roads or something) has one. That's how the resources to build up the common area are marshaled.
- astura 9y agoYeah, I know. I think of the definition of "gated community" as a little squishy so I wasn't sure of absolutes. Now that I think about it more though, the "gate" part pretty much necessitates private roads as public roads would be open to the public. Kinda feel silly, "public" is in the name.
- nradov 9y agoHOAs essentially operate similar to governments in that regard. The HOA can fine owners for failing to comply with community rules, place a lien on the property if they don't pay, and eventually get a court judgment to foreclose on the property and sell it to pay the debt. But that process typically takes years. And it's a huge hassle and expense for the HOA, so most will let things slide for a long time before taking the nuclear option.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoYou are exactly right, but I will add those fines eventually DO get paid. The HOA bill keeps increasing until it could be tens of thousands of dollars. When the landlord eventually sells the property the HOA is then able to get payment from the new buyer before the former owner receives the funds. Since legal action is so expensive, this is almost always how the HOA eventually gets their money. Of course if the bill goes over 30k, then it might be worth their time to go through litigation to get their money.
- emodendroket 9y agoAn HOA can eventually put a lien on your home and repossess it if you fail to pay their fines.
- trentnix 9y agoFine them all you like - the result of this will be less affordable housing. Landlords who don't want to invest in or can't afford the upkeep will simply sell to someone who will. And with that investment comes a more attractive property which commands a higher rent. And that means the housing becomes less affordable for the low-income renters.
- grogenaut 9y agoYou must live in SF or on a coast to think there is an infinite pool of richer tennants that you could upgrade and sell to.
- trentnix 9y agoWell it's what's happened here in Dallas. Housing is cheap in areas nowhere wants to live whether that be because of location or blight or demographics. It doesn't matter. It's more expensive in places where everyone wants to live. Improving housing makes that housing more attractive. There's no escaping the economics of it no matter how hard you govern it.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoSo a major city with a strong economy has a stronger housing market than a suburb in the middle of nowhere with a weak economy? Shocking.
- jimmywanger 9y agoZoning laws are mostly to blame for lack of affordable housing. That, and the usage of houses as an investment. When you spruce up a house, that attracts different renters. The other renters will take up housing otherwise they wouldn't have bothered with, and it goes on down the ladder. The argument that market rate housing causes lack of affordable housing is just not true. Look at San Francisco. They have strict zoning laws, laws against construction of market rate housing, and rent control laws. Is it a paradise for low-income renters?
- southphillyman 9y ago