9 ms·
Chatbots be they voice or text face the same user interface problems that old school command-line interfaces did 20 years ago before windowing GUIs came about.
by tootie 9y ago
Chatbots be they voice or text face the same user interface problems that old school command-line interfaces did 20 years ago before windowing GUIs came about. When you start up, you're faced with a void. it's extremely difficult to convey to users what the acceptable entry points are and how to phrase them to get what you want. The inputs are far more generous than classic command-line world, but it's still vague enough to induce paralysis in end users. If I have a bunch of pull-down menus with clear directives on what I can and can't do, I'm going to be productive much more quickly.
- nothis 9y agoThere's a few things glossed over that I don't think AI can solve. For example, if I want to deliver flowers, I kinda want to chose what they look like and how do you do that without, essentially displaying a website with images which would turn it into a glorified google search. If I want a restaurant recommendation... it basically opens yelp and tells me the first hit. And I kinda want to see pictures of the place and read reviews, otherwise what's the point of searching at all? You can reduce it to a flow of information. And chat is not always the best way to convey that information.
- ryanianian 9y agoI think you missed the point. The point isn't chat == text-only, it's that chat == natural-language-style UX. This could well be augmented with images (like is with Siri). Basically "is there a button to do what I want" versus "do I indicate what I want in a human-ish way" - imho that's the defining feature of a "chatbot", not that it's text-driven per se.
- sampl 9y agoI don’t think an AI assistant and visual feedback like google search are mutually exclusive at all. Imagine a fashion designer having a chat with a human assistant. The designer might tell them a kind of shirt they want to use for a shoot, and if it’s not obvious what to buy the assistant will come back to them with a list of options (pictures of each on a piece of paper, for ex). The designer can ask questions about each one, ask for different shirts, and simply speak when they decide: points “this one”. This all seems very doable with current AI assistants. Google for ex already has results from recent voice searches waiting for you on your phone.
- tootie 9y agoI have never had much use for AI assistants except using Alexa on my FireTV. I can press a button on the remote or app to start it listening, give it some keywords to search and get results on screen to scroll through and click on. Now that I can direct those voice searches to a browser, it's even better.
- colechristensen 9y agoIf you have a real person as an assistant, and you ask them to buy flowers for somebody, you also don't get to pick exactly what they look like ... unless you ask them to facilitate that with pictures or descriptions. Real AI would be fully capable of doing this just as well as a person, but it would take a lot more "intelligence" than currently exists.
- michaelt 9y agoThe real difference is human assistants are paid well to act as their principal's agent. If a PA had a choice buying a nice bunch of flowers or a weedy bunch with a $5 kickback, they'd be dumb to take the kickback and risk their job. But if I ask Facebook/Google/Amazon to order some flowers for me, why _wouldn't_ they monetise it? Gotta pay for those tens of thousands of engineers somehow.
- achamayou 9y agoBecause you won't be doing it again if they mess it up?
- dwaltrip 9y agoIdeally. It's possible that the Google business machine might not do a superb job collecting and synthesizing the vast number of these very fine-tuned details and pieces of feedback, at least at this early stage. This is something a good personal assistant can do easily. Though eventually AI will gain those capabilities, one way or another.
- bluGill 9y agoWhen I want to deliver flowers I want $x worth of flowers to arrive, avoid roses - make sure this poem I wrote is on the tag. I don't care what they look like, any flower is the same (except my wife doesn't like roses much) - the important part is the flower came with a poem. If we had a secretary (think 1950 when they were common) doing this job mine would choose something nice, yours would come back with your choices. Either way flowers would arrive. Your secretary would probably learn your preferences eventually and soon come with one picture for final approval (which would be right). Mine would remind me a week before our anniversary to start working on the poem. Both perspectives are correct. There is no reason an AI couldn't handle both, and every reason they should - but of course it will be years (at best) before they do. The first time the AI comes with "I found these flowers, see the pictures [on whatever screen is handy]". I respond with "whatever, just pick something", and the ai decides to not bother asking again. I'm depending on the AI flower ordering algorithm to not make a bad choice - making me happy is harder than making you happy.
- Ajedi32 9y agoI think the ultimate goal is to make the "acceptable entry points" so numerous and the variety of acceptable wordings so broad that you can approach the assistant with pretty much any goal you have in mind and it'll walk you through how to accomplish that. Imagine if this was a realistic conversation with an assistant: > "Hey Google, I'd like to order a pizza." > "Sure, what kind?" > "Let's see... cheese, pepperoni, sausage... and maybe some green pepers?" > "Alright. What size?" > "Hmm, so I need to feed 4 people..." > "Sounds like a large?" > "Sure, let's go with a large." > "Alright. There's a Dominos nearby, I can order that for $8.99." > "Sounds good." > "Alright, I've ordered your pizza. Expected delivery in 15 minutes." No need for the human to understand what the "entry point" is, because you can approach the assistant with pretty much _any_ entry point and it'll give you a useful response. We're still not there yet, unfortunately, and I think it'll be quite a while before we are.
- 8ytecoder 9y agoWell, on the other hand in a GUI - in pretty much a single page - I can see all options I have, all sizes, their exact price ...etc. With CMD and chatbots there's always the FOMO. "What if there are other options I haven't considered?". Humans like to be in control.
- mrisoli 9y agoExactly, I prefer using a GUI over calling over the phone for delivery because I might have communication or listening issues with the person on the other side of the phone. The same thing happens for McDonald's and other places replacing cashiers with touch-screen terminals, not only I am sure of how the system understood me, I can easily navigate the several options without annoying an employee with dozens of questions, going from that to conversational UI is a step back in the wrong direction.
- funkymike 9y agoI have an example that illustrates this. Just this morning I stopped at McDonald's for breakfast. I gave my order, they entered it, and it showed up correctly on the screen at the drive through. However, the order taker read back something completely different (than what they just entered). Since I saw that the order in the system was correct I ignored that and simply said "sure that's right." This is why I prefer an interface that bypasses the human order taker. They may say one thing and do another. Even in my case, they may have then thought "well he confirmed what I just said back, and that doesn't match what the screen shows, so I'll fix it to match what the customer agreed to." Then I would have the wrong order. That can't happen if I interact directly with the order system.
- colechristensen 9y agoThat is a good analogy. Chat bots are on a spectrum between command line and a real human assistant. If I hire an assistant, I probably don't need a manual telling me how to interact with them. A command line is pure mystery. I might be stretching a bit for the metaphor, but the difference is how well they understand human language. A commandline requires, essentially, learning a new language in order to converse with a computer. A human only requires a small amount of learning in getting the social dynamic relationship right. Chat bots, virtual assistants, etc. are all pretending to be much closer to the human side of language understanding than they are and they won't be all that useful until they make quite a bit of progress. (and actually I would appreciate a much more commandline-like interface with a voice assistant for now because I'd bet it would be much more likely to give me what I want)
- tenaciousDaniel 9y agoIt's like going into a restaurant and asking for a menu, only for the server to respond with "we don't even need menus, you can order whatever you like!"
- funkymike 9y agoReally, it's that there is a menu, but they won't show it to you, only tell you when you ask for something they won't serve. "What would you like to eat today?" "A bacon cheeseburger with cheddar, with lettuce, ketchup, and onions. Fries on the side." "Sorry we don't offer fries with our burgers. What could I get you instead?" "I see french fries at the next table!" "Oh, you asked for fries, not french fries. Sure, we can do french fries. What would you like for your side?" "... I want french fries." ... It's not actually true that any input is accepted. Pretending that it is just creates frustration.
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoJust like in the real world, Burger King won't actually let you Have It Your Way, or they'd give me a nice burger that's not overcooked dressed with avocado slices, jalapenos, a thick spread of blue cheese and some strong mustard, in a whole wheat sourdough bun that's not so artifical that it reverts back to dough under compression.
- lkozma 9y agoThat's a great observation. There was a _very long_ but funny and insightful article expanding on this issue, calling such interfaces "hubristic": http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.de/2009/07/wolfram-alpha-and-hubristic-user.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.de/2009/07/wolfram-...
- danso 9y agoI don't think chatbots have to necessarily be a "void". Most of the ones I've seen are on support pages -- such as Microsoft's Virtual Assistant: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us https://support.microsoft.com/en-us Screenshot: https://imgur.com/a/Nh0Nn https://imgur.com/a/Nh0Nn Anyone who is dealing with this chatbot is probably aware of its main scope -- to provide tech support/answers. Look at the example prompt that is given: e.g.: Reset my Microsoft account password How try to find that on the Microsoft Support page as it is: https://imgur.com/a/D0GaL https://imgur.com/a/D0GaL My first instinct is to do a Ctrl-F for "password" or "security"; the first term brings nothing, the second term brings up topics about viruses and ransomware. Even if you realize that you have to go to the "Microsoft account help", you still won't find it. Right now, there's a link for "How to reset your Microsoft account password" but only under the subhed of "Trending topics" -- and I would have never found it if I didn't use Ctrl-F. And past research has found that the vast majority of Internet users do not know how to use Ctrl-F [0] (and I bet it's much worse today, given how most people now just use phone browsers). Of course the smart thing to do is to use the Search box at the top of the support page -- in fact, I wouldn't even use that because I just use Google for everything, even for finding Stackoverflow answers. But I'm guessing most people don't. I'd argue that the average user, unlike most anyone who even knows what a command-line interface is, does not care about an interface having "acceptable entry points". And in many such cases, it may be near impossible to design an interface for such users, whose needs and means of expressing them are infinite. For example, I know that if I can't login to my Microsoft account because my cookies expired and I forgot my password, that I should be searching for "reset microsoft password", or even, "reset microsoft live password". However, I bet there are a lot of people who will state this: my email doesn't work or i cant see my email The chatbot helpfully provides a list of options, including "Signing in to Outlook.com", but just in case, options like "Unable to send email". If you search for "my email doesn't work" using the support.microsoft.com search bar, you get a list of Google-like listings pointing to the answers.microsoft.com forums, for topics like "Why doesn't my Hotmail work any more?" I guess there's no reason why the support searchbar couldn't be tweaked to return the kind of options that the chatbot does, but the chatbot has one key advantage: there's always a "None of the above" option, which takes you to a secondary list of options. This kind of funnel IMHO is way more useful/comfortable than a search interface, in which it's not clear whether you need to rewrite your query, or keep paging through pages of increasingly irrelevant or confusing search results. Theoretically, the chatbot funnel gets better at funneling people, based on analysis of past users' paths through the decision tree. But even a very dumb bot that doesn't intelligently respond has one more advantage: if you hit "None" a few times in succession, you'll be given a link to "Talk to a person", which signals to the user that, "OK, you win, no need to keep trying search queries, let's get you some human help". That signal doesn't exist in a traditional webpage or search interface, so the risk is that the user keeps searching the pages in vain until they get so pissed off they just give up. Not everyone has the wherewithal to demand manual help. [0] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2011/08/crazy-90-percent-of-people-dont-know-how-to-use-ctrl-f/243840/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2011/08/crazy...
- ashelmire 9y agoThis isn't the issue that's addressed by the article. It's another issue entirely. In fact, the article seems to suggest not that users were paralyzed, but that users were overactive and expected too much.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y ago> "it's extremely difficult to convey to users what the acceptable entry points are and how to phrase them to get what you want." Reminds of those text input adventure games like King's Quest, where you had to figure out a valid verb + noun combination to use.
- stuartd 9y agoThat is very true, and it's something we've struggled with on our bot, but there's also a collorary - every time you add a feature, you have to add UI for it which adds complexity and can have support costs - I have heard anecdotally that when banking apps add a new feature they get a spike of support requests asking "what is this new xyz…?"
- csujoy 9y agoPull down menus are already being used to replace chatbot experience and is used by millions daily on high-traffic websites. Check out https://airim.co https://airim.co