6 ms·
The ozone layer is healing
- moreless 9y agoNot to be a sceptic, but how reliable are these measurements?
- kaybe 9y agoVery reliable. There was/is a lot of dedicated funding for this issue and so we have dedicated satellite instruments and people working on them. Ozone is comparatively easy to measure due to its super strong and clear absorption coefficient. Stratospheric changes are both slow and on larger spatial scales, making satellite resolution perfectly sufficient.
- oblio 9y agoWe should be thankful there's no big CFC lobby, I guess? :)
- adrianN 9y agoWe should be thankful to the chemists that came up with substitute refrigerants that break down in the lower atmosphere and don't kill the ozone layer. Just like the discovery of oil saved the whales.
- NLips 9y agoAt the moment I'd just say the discovery of oil has deferred the whales' demise.
- dalbasal 9y agoThis. What got us (is getting us) out of the ozone mess (the climate change of my childhood) was technology and alternatives. No one had to revert to an icebox, or take any steps back in terms of what they consume. In policy terms, it was (mostly) relatively simple stuff. It was mostly bans, not theoretically sophisticated policy of taxes, subsidies, traceable credits and such. If I was king of the world, I’d think of carbon a similar way. Try to gradually ban carbon fuels, as soon as viable alternatives make this feasible. It seems we are nearing that stage for both electricity grids and cars. Forget about sophisticated economic interventions (I’m dubious of the economics of these anyway). Just change to an apples-to-apples alternative asap, with a focus on the ‘p.’
- jjeaff 9y agoA carbon tax seems like more of a simple solution than: >Try to gradually ban carbon fuels, as soon as viable alternatives make this feasible.
- dalbasal 9y agoCarbon tax (as well as the caps, subsidies, tradable credits and such that form parts of the plan) are more complicated, I think. Riskier too. Also, the economic reasoning is (IMO) flawed because in the absence of a viable alternative, we know fuel consumption decreases very, very little with increased costs (that affect poorer people more). If a viable alternative exists, we know that bans work well (e.g. CFCs) and leave less room for policy corruption. The key is viable alternatives. Without them, either policy will probably fail.
- ams6110 9y ago"as soon as" will be a long time. There is nothing viable on the horizon to replace carbon fuels in many applications. The energy density of batteries is still far lower than oil.
- adrianN 9y agoIf we wait until carbon free replacements naturally displace fossil fuels we won't be able to limit global warming to two degrees. Immediate, massive action is necessary to reach that goal. And unfortunately climate change is not something that easily reverts itself like Ozone depletion. A large part of the atmospheric carbon stays there for thousands of years. I'm no expert, but to me a steadily increasing tax on carbon fuels seems like the simplest and best method to incentivize innovation. You can even incentivize capture technologies by providing a negative tax for all carbon that is safely put back in the ground. By taxing carbon that is pulled from the ground positively and carbon that is put back negatively you indirectly subsidize climate friendly technology without prescribing the shape of the solution.
- dalbasal 9y agoI’m not sure what you mean by “naturally.” I’m not proposing no interventions, just simple ones like bans. For example, EVs are starting to look like a viable apples-to-apple alternative across vehicle types. This is partially driven by subsidies and consumer action, but mostly it’s just technology. With the current pro-environment policy approach, we subsidise them (tax exemptions) at a decreasing rate (until it becomes too expensive because there are lots of EVs), along with some other “interventions” from a complex portfolio of policies. I am saying, do the opposite. (1) Pick winners. (2) Subsidise/tax at an increasing rate (or some other transitional plan). (3) Plan for a near term ban.
- jcadam 9y agoThe crap they came up with to replace CFCs in albuterol inhalers doesn't work. If the ozone layer is healing, can me and my fellow asthmatics get our actually-working inhalers back, please? Well, it's not all bad - the new inhalers meant new patents and did away with generic, affordable asthma meds for a couple of decades. So, if you're a pharmaceutical company, I guess that's a win?
- JoBrad 9y agoMy wife’s inhaler seems to work. Can you provide a little more context?
- jcadam 9y agoI suppose they 'work', however, the HFA inhalers are simply not as good as the ones they replaced (around 2008 or so, if memory serves). They clog easily (Nothing like needing a puff and getting nothing), almost seem to have a mild constricting effect before the albuterol kicks in (and it's not as quick as it should be), and some people react badly to the sulfates (not me, thankfully). I'm fortunate in that I don't need my inhaler much since I moved to the Florida coast (I think the moist, salty, clean air blowing in from the Atlantic helps). Whenever I have to go to a major city I'll have trouble, though.
- badosu 9y agoFrom the wikipedia article[0]: > Civil society including especially NGOs, played critical roles at all stages of policy development leading up to the Vienna Conference, the Montreal Protocol, and in assessing compliance afterwards.[64][65][66][67] The major companies claimed that no alternatives to HFC existed.[68] An ozone-safe hydrocarbon refrigerant was developed at a Hamburg technological institute in Germany, and in 1992 came to the attention of the non-governmental organization (NGO) Greenpeace. Greenpeace was given the patent, called it "Greenfreeze," and left the patent as open source.[69][70] The NGO then worked successfully first with a small and struggling company to market an appliance beginning in Europe, then Asia and later Latin America, receiving a 1997 UNEP award. It describes how well it was adopted worldwide, except for the US, then: > In the U.S., however, change has been much slower. To some extent, CFCs were being replaced by the less damaging hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs), although concerns remain regarding HCFCs also. In some applications, hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) were being used to replace CFCs. HFCs, which contain no chlorine or bromine, do not contribute at all to ozone depletion although they are potent greenhouse gases. The best known of these compounds is probably HFC-134a (R-134a), which in the United States has largely replaced CFC-12 (R-12) in automobile air conditioners. In laboratory analytics (a former "essential" use) the ozone depleting substances can be replaced with various other solvents.[76] Chemical companies like Du Pont, whose representatives even disparaged Greenfreeze as "that German technology," maneuvered the EPA to block the technology in the U.S. until 2011. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ozone_depletion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ozone_depletion
- ams6110 9y agoThere are plenty of good, non CFC refrigerant gases. You just need something that will liquify under moderate pressure. Propane/isobutane (aka camping gas) works, in fact it's a poor-mans gas to use to recharge old R-12 systems in cars that haven't been converted. Unfortunately it's quite flammable so leaks can be a concern. Others, e.g. ammonia, work well but are toxic. Good, stable, non-flammable, non-toxic refrigerants are not that common. Some automakers are trying using CO2 but that requires much higher pressures.
- QAPereo 9y ago
- juliangamble 9y ago> The lead author of the study, Susan Strahan, an atmospheric scientist belonging to NASA’s GSFC (Goddard Space Flight Center) in Greenbelt, Maryland explained that it can be clearly observed that the chlorine level near the ozone layer is coming down while reducing the amount of depletion in the ozone. Quibble: Is it actually 'healing' if the depletion rate is decreasing? The hole in the ozone is still getting bigger. It's just getting bigger at a slower rate. (I realise that this is the title the article uses - but I believe it is incorrect). (This is a particular issue in Australia - we have increased occurrence of skin cancer due to this.)
- toomanybeersies 9y agoI think that the article is possibly just poorly written. According to Wikipedia, the ozone levels stabilised in the 90's, and started to recover in the 00's: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Ozone_hole_recovery.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Ozone_hole_recovery.jpg I'm led to believe that the ozone layer depletes and regenerates in cycles, and what the article is highlighting is that the amount that is depleted in a depletion cycle is lower.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoOzone is created by extreme events during lightningstrikes and reduced by it reacting/beeing bound otherwise. So yes, there is a natural cycle, with slight variances around the norm. I cant wait to see my bosses eyes- when i expand this theory of irresponsibility for everything upon bugs. There is a natural occurance rate of bugs and a natural error rate in software. To try and meddle with it- or to blame developers for it, is just plain wrong and nearly as insane as environmentalism. Sometimes in the morning, you can smell it in the air- the distinct taste of lazy.
- bluejekyll 9y agoI disagree with this analogy. As software engineers become more experienced, they start avoiding patterns or obviously flawed software constructs which they recognize as potentially creating bugs in the future. Things like marking fields of objects final/const, requiring immutability of objects, reduce bugs interior to objects. Immutable objects also reduce multithreading issues. That’s one pattern that can be used to reduce common bugs. Nature doesn’t do this. For example: Southern California has a fire season (natural) followed by a wet season (natural) which tends to cause sever mudlides. These natural processes never learn from experience that large fires before the rain is more destructive (I know I’m stretching here and fires would be smaller if we didn’t put down the small ones initially). My point is that humans, software engineers included, learn from past mistakes. Ideally we improve from those, not just throw our hands up and say bugs are a “natural” result of the software development process. Software will always have bugs, but ideally you as an engineer never make the same one twice (with the exception of off by one errors ;)
- scadge 9y agoI hate this magazine narrative style, where each consecutive paragraph or two tell totally the same but in different words and referring to another Mr. or Ms. Scientist. The whole article could easily be 10 times shorter. But the news is good.
- imron 9y agoJust like highlander II predicted!