7 ms·
Copyright should be abolished. As it stands, copyright serves little positive social purpose. The overwhelming majority of creators get paid little if anything
by pmoriarty 9y ago
Copyright should be abolished.
As it stands, copyright serves little positive social purpose. The overwhelming majority of creators get paid little if anything for their
work, and still there is a glut of content. So there should be no fear of the world losing lots of great content if there was no copyright.
Most of the benefit of copyright is reaped by the middle men, who profit off the work when the creatives that made it have long ceased to do
so (if they ever did). Abolishing copyright will thus mostly affect these middle men, and have little effect on content creation itself.
Those creatives that still want to get paid in a copyright-free era can find business models that don't rely on copyright, like performances,
donations, or kickstarter-like models where one is paid for future work.
- sschueller 9y agoI find it fascinating how the industry is so powerful that when you watch a Hollywood film in a foreign country you are shown a message which threatens with jail time for recording video and or audio.
- strictnein 9y agoThat warning is before the film in the US as well. It's just part of the film. Unless we're talking about in theaters? Because it doesn't show up there.
- danbolt 9y agoIn Japan I saw it before a movie and they had these caricatures telling you not to record. It was a wolf in sheepskin! https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nT7ijnOHEDs https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nT7ijnOHEDs
- marcosdumay 9y ago> which threatens with jail time Enforced by none else than the FBI.
- rayiner 9y agoPlenty of content producers make money. Sure it’s the companies that employ the artists that make the most money, but that’s a general feature of our economy, not anything unique to copyright. I think Netflix is a huge vindication of copyright. It started out as a middleman simple peddling other people’s content. But copyright forced them to start producing their own content, and they’ve turned television on its head as a result. It’s probably s bigger change in the TV market than cable studios. The thing about copyright is that it’s existenxe isn’t preventing the alternative models you’re talking about. Unlike any other form of property, copyright covers an individual’s own creations. Owning land is staking claim to something that existed for eons before you were born and will exist for eons after you’re dead. But copyright is over something unique you brought into the universe. With recording and distribution being so cheap, nothing prevents creatives from giving away their work and making money on their own unique contributions with performances or Kickstarter. But people want AAA production values. Just like how Kickstarter can’t raise enough capital to design and build something with mass market appeal like a MacBook Pro, it’s not suitable for making something like the new Star Wars movie. (Which I refuse to watch because blockbuster movies are dreck, but the public wants what it wants.)
- agmcleod 9y ago>I think Netflix is a huge vindication of copyright. It started out as a middleman simple peddling other people’s content. But copyright forced them to start producing their own content, and they’ve turned television on its head as a result. Really? They make license agreements with the content/copywright owners in order to stream it. It does break apart the idea of using a single copy and lending it to someone though. I thought they were investing in their own content in order to attract more users, and improve the overall offering.
- rayiner 9y agoNetflix realized that they couldn’t just be a distribution platform because content owners could build their own. They were forced to invest in making their own content because that was a competitive advantage its competitors couldn’t duplicate as easily. Which is exactly the point of copyright. More content was created because Netflix couldn’t simply get away with distributing someone else’s content and nothing more.
- libertymcateer 9y agoWithout copyright protection, copyleft open-source licenses are unenforceable. You are basically saying all software should be MIT licensed.
- TheDong 9y agoWhat's he's advocating is all software being public domain, not MIT. Copyleft licenses could be potentially be replaced by viral contracts... but frankly, I'd take the tradeoff of no copyright and no copyleft over the hellish system of copyright we have now.
- nv-vn 9y agoThere's no incentive to make a movie if it will never make any money. Without copyright, anyone can purchase it once and give it away for free or sell each copy for $0.01 and undercut all competition. Digital content takes X amount of work and then allows it to be duplicated by creating infinite copies. If someone can infinitely copy your work, you will never get paid for that X amount (or make any profit). While I don't strongly support current IP law, getting rid of it isn't the solution. It's like having an economy based on fake money, after a very short period of time the money becomes worthless (except here the money = work).
- TrinaryWorksToo 9y agoWhat's wrong with that? The price to the first person would go up astronomically and they would get all the rights to resell it. It would be the difference of getting paid 10k upfront or 10k over the course of royalties. You would have incentive to make new works.
- pluto9 9y agoThe price to the first person would go up astronomically and they would get all the rights to resell it. How would they enforce their (exclusive) right to resell it? The first person to whom they sell a copy could then give away more copies for free.
- TrinaryWorksToo 9y agoI guess I could have been clearer. there is no exclusive resale right. I meant because the lack of rights, there would be competition to drive down distribution costs. The idea is that the first purchaser pays full price to be able to know what the item is, as the idea is otherwise a secret. Consumers could then pay content creators directly to generate the content, rather than going through a publisher. There could be demand to have a distribution network that is up to date.
- chriswarbo 9y ago> There's no incentive to make a movie if it will never make any money. > Without copyright, anyone can purchase it once and give it away for free or sell each copy for $0.01 and undercut all competition. That's not a problem if the creators were paid to make the movie. The parent mentioned several mechanisms to do this. It's not hard: after all, that's how basically all industries have worked since forever. Anecdotally: half of the jobs I've had were producing private, in-house software; I got a regular wage for doing this, since the companies found such software useful. No need for copyright. The other half were paying me to produce FOSS which, once it was written, we wanted people to copy and spread for free, since that would gain us more attention (and potential customers for our related services). Again, no need for copyright (although some were strong copyleft, with network-use clauses)
- WhitneyLand 9y agoDo you like to read? If you listed your top 20 books, by whatever criteria you choose, were any of them popular? Would you feel good if under your system, the donations or other alternate payments ended up in the author’s rewards being cut? What if they were cut in half? Or even became negligible, because I don’t see any guarantees prescribed. This is not just about Taylor Swift (no offense if you are a fan). We’re talking about works that can change lives, inspire people to do great things, even change the course of history. The system has been abused and distorted. However I don’t see how that can make us sure the best solution is to throw the baby out with the bath water.
- rexpop 9y agoIt seems to me you're the one conflating the baby of art with the bathwater of copyright.
- WhitneyLand 9y agono, throwing the whole concept of copyright out instead of thinking of ways to improve the system.
- Chardok 9y agoI am honestly sick of hearing "but no one will create anything without copyright" as if money was the sole motivator that made doing anything worthwhile. To be fair, I think copyright has its place as a minimal safeguard for artists' work, but in its current form it is entirely too aggressive and lasts way beyond its scope should cover. Copyright should not be reason to send SWAT raids to people's homes, just as much as it should not cover 70 years after the artists' death. I am certain that if we seriously rolled back copyright, our art would still thrive, albeit perhaps less AAA content.
- Crespyl 9y agoI generally try to be aware of copyright enforcement related issues, but haven't heard of SWAT operations in direct response to copyright incidents. Is there a source you can link, or were you just exaggerating for rhetorical effect?
- ABCLAW 9y agoThe Kim Dotcom raid was fairly public knowledge at the time it occurred. I'd start there. Not quite to the level of actual SWAT operations, but far more common are Anton Piller orders. These orders are still used with decent frequency in IP cases because the evidence in question is often easily destroyed and the cases are often existential-crisis-level disputes for one or both parties.
- Chardok 9y agoKim Dotcom raid video is here - https://www.theguardian.com/technology/video/2012/aug/08/kim-dotcom-raid-police-mansion-video https://www.theguardian.com/technology/video/2012/aug/08/kim... RIAA SWAT Raid in Atlanta - http://www.nytimes.com/2007/02/18/magazine/18djdrama.t.html http://www.nytimes.com/2007/02/18/magazine/18djdrama.t.html Those are the two biggest ones I can think of, but both are examples of literal deadly force used for copyright violations.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 9y ago
- cuckcuckspruce 9y agoCapitalism should be abolished. As it stands, capitalism serves little positive social purpose. The overwhelming majority of laborers get paid little if anything for their work, and still there is a glut of production. So there should be no fear of the world losing lots of great production if there was no capitalism. Most of the benefit of capitalism is reaped by the middle men, who profit off the work when the laborers that made it have long ceased to do so (if they ever did). Abolishing capitalism will thus mostly affect these middle men, and have little effect on labor itself. Those laborers that still want to get paid in a capitalism-free era can find business models that don't rely on capitalism, like the military, collective farming, or secret police-like models where one is paid for future work.
- beisner 9y agoYour last paragraph doesn’t follow from your first three.
- dalbasal 9y agoThere's a tendency to think of copyright mostly in money terms. For the big earners like disney, and certainly for most of the middlemen you mention it is mostly money. For some creators though, it's different. I heard George RR Martin comment on this once. Tolkien's family (according to GRRM) did a great job guarding and protecting his works. He's horrified at the thought of a descendent making selling Targaryan cream buns or allowing shitty derivative novels. That isn't a money concern, but it is a property rights concern of sorts. In any case, I think the sorts of right GRRM feels are his could still be preserved, without keeping all copyright the same.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> He's horrified at the thought of a descendent making selling Targaryan cream buns or allowing shitty derivative novels. That isn't a money concern, but it is a property rights concern of sorts. I get the desire to rule from beyond the grave, but do not believe it is a legitimate property right.
- namlem 9y agoCopyright should be returned to its original term of 28 years after date of creation.