7 ms·
The headline is wrong. SpaceX says their mission (launch of the payload) was a success. The Northrup Grumman payload is responsible for the rest of the mission.
by Robotbeat 9y ago
The headline is wrong. SpaceX says their mission (launch of the payload) was a success. The Northrup Grumman payload is responsible for the rest of the mission. SpaceX are literally only allowed to talk about their own rocket, since it's a classified mission. But the rocket made it to orbit and the upper stage deorbited in the same place as planned according to other observers.
Oh, and because it's a classified mission, we don't even know if the mission was INTENDED to stay in orbit. For all we know, it was a test of a reentry vehicle of some type. Additionally, off-the-record sources may just as well be lying about the result of the mission as they would be risking jailtime to leak results to reporters. This is a classified mission, no one is going to risk their job and their freedom just to make Andy Pasztor better able to troll SpaceX (which he has a long history of).
They may even be paid to intentionally spread misinformation (anonymously, so it can't be traced back) about the mission in order to protect the secrecy of the payload.
Additionally, SpaceX is continuing Falcon Heavy processing without skipping a beat, rolling out the vehicle just hours after mission completion. If there was a failure, there would be a stand-down to determine the cause before continuing.
.
.
EDIT: I should point out that Northrop actually provided the payload adapter and handled integration: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=43976.msg1738401#msg1738401 https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=43976.msg1...
- katastic 9y ago>Oh, and because it's a classified mission, we don't even know if the mission was INTENDED to stay in orbit. More like, it intentionally sent "something" into de-orbit so it's not clear whether there's something up there or not
- api 9y agoThere seems to be an active astroturf campaign against SpaceX and Tesla.
- hobofan 9y ago"After enough time every circlejerk comes with its equal and opposite circlejerk in the opposite direction" - Cyber-Newtons' Third Law ------- On a more serious note: I don't think that there is some significant astroturfing going on. Both companies built a very shiney (and possibly over-inflated) PR image for themselves, with a zealot following, which is bound to annoy some people at some point. Those people than take any chance of a slip-up to try to make that PR bubble pop.
- AdamJacobMuller 9y ago> Additionally, SpaceX is continuing Falcon Heavy processing without skipping a beat, rolling out the vehicle just hours after mission completion. If there was a failure, there would be a stand-down to determine the cause before continuing. I keep coming back to this part of your comment and I think its the most useful piece of non-classified data we have. Lots of possibilities of what happened here, for sure. The one sure conclusion we can draw from this is that SpaceX does not think the Falcon 9 failed. If they thought that there was an issue with the Falcon 9, you're correct that that would have caused a stop of the Heavy launch. Now, its possible SpaceX is wrong and there was an issue with the Falcon 9, its possible there was an issue with the payload or the payload separation or even possible that there was no issue at all. With all of the classified information on this one, we probably won't know for sure in our lifetimes but we can say one thing for sure. The people who do have access to the classified information do not think there was an issue of enough magnitude to delay the Falcon Heavy launch and I think that speaks volumes. If the mission had failed I think we would see at least a brief pause, even if SpaceX quickly decided that the failure was not theirs and continued. The fact that they are pushing on leads me to lean strongly in the direction of the mission actually being a success.
- gozur88 9y agoI would agree, except there's no customer for FH. Even if there's some small chance the 2nd stage will fail, a test of the three core first stage makes sense. Having said that, I would be very surprised to find there was a failure of SpaceX hardware in the Zuma launch.
- samcat116 9y agoFAA won't let them launch if theres any possibility of a known issue. Even if there isn't a customer for this FH mission, FAA still has to certify the flight.
- AdamJacobMuller 9y agoThey wouldn't risk Elon's roadster. More seriously, even just the PR cost and the actual cost would prevent them from launching.
- grecy 9y agoThe headline on the website of a major Australian newspaper right now [1] is: "Elon Musk's satellite 'disaster'". "Expensive mistake: An expensive and highly secret satellite is missing after being launched by Elon Musk's SpaceX" How the heck are we allowing reporters to "report" like this? Utter nonsense, and millions of people read this newspaper every day and assume they are being told facts. [1] http://heraldsun.com.au/ http://heraldsun.com.au/
- kk_cz 9y ago> How the heck are we allowing reporters to "report" like this? It's the price we pay for freedom of press and expression. The alternative is screaming "fake news" everytime a journalist makes a mistake. Normal distribution applies in every profession, not all journalists are great
- rcMgD2BwE72F 9y ago> It's the price we pay for [x] Is this actually inevitable? Why and why should you pay this much? grecy asks "How the heck are we allowing" and you reply "just pay because the only other choice is [unacceptable alternative]". This does drive the price up, doesn't it? How does that help?
- wiz21c 9y agoPlus : >>> not all journalists are great The paper was written by a journalist, proof read by another one, reviewed by the editor. There's no price to pay for intended click bait.
- kk_cz 9y ago> The paper was written by a journalist, proof read by another one, reviewed by the editor. This used to be the norm, I agree. Modern technology did wonders to streamline the publishing process. :)
- kk_cz 9y ago
- JohnJamesRambo 9y agoWhat you are saying seems preposterous and fails Occam's Razor badly. It seems you and many others in this thread can't accept that maybe SpaceX is fallible and can make mistakes and you are formulating fantastic conspiracy theories to support your view.
- andygates 9y agoAye, but their second stage and payload delivery have been fiercely reliable. That the client had a custom adapter seems perfect occam-bait in this case.
- JohnJamesRambo 9y agoOk so they have been fiercely reliable, so what? Fiercely reliable is not infallible. Then it is more likely that SpaceX is going along with a cover-up and the black eye and tarnished image coming from the loss of a billion dollar payload just to help out their customer's secrecy? That seems even more unbelievable and complicated than equipment failure.
- _Tev 9y agoHow does SpaceX get tarnished reputation out of this? Anyone who follows spaceflight at all recognizes their behavior as confirming "rocket operated nominally" scenario. Their FH introduction and previous failures (or even found pre-launch issues) show they are not afraid of standdowns/delays for the sake of future missions assurance.
- JshWright 9y agoSpaceX has never hidden their failures. SpaceX says the rocket performed "nominally" (aerospace speak for "it worked just fine"). You believe SpaceX is lying about that?
- samcat116 9y agoSpaceX has no reason to lie about this. If they were caught lying then it would do irreparable damage to their reputation as a launch provider.
- JshWright 9y agoSpaceX's President released a statement that the rocket 'did everything right' and that they are proceeding with the rest of their launch manifest as planned. https://twitter.com/pbdes/status/950731941149626368 https://twitter.com/pbdes/status/950731941149626368
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- joering2 9y ago> They may even be paid to intentionally spread misinformation (anonymously, so it can't be traced back) about the mission in order to protect the secrecy of the payload. Tinfoil hat squeezing too tight? A billion dollar for a way to find out internal mole? Think not. Honestly, I don't fear AI coming and enslaving humans, like Musk claims... I fear Musk sending these secret satellites that are paid by with my tax dollars.