12 ms·
CEO of porn cryptocurrency disappears with investor money
- xiphias 9y agoWonder what he's doing with the money...
- pbiggar 9y agoI consider every ICO to be a scam and that this sort of thing will become par for the course, with basically every speculator in the space losing money - except those who manage to trick main street investors to cash them out. However, this is weird: “Within hours they refunded me ethereum with a dollar amount equal to what I had contributed in early September, but since the coin has more than tripled in value since then, they kept the rest of my contribution, essentially stealing quite a lot of money from me.” Yeah, that's bullshit. They owe you your money back, they don't owe you the gains that you would have gotten if you had speculated in Ethereum instead.
- empath75 9y agoWell, they’re making the argument that if they ‘invested’ ethereum that they should get the same amount of ethereum back, not dollars.
- cryptoz 9y agoWhat gains? 1 eth is 1th, there are no gains there. They took something like 1 eth from this person, and gave back .3 eth. That's stealing. (numbers not to scale)
- pbiggar 9y agoWhat was the price tag in? If the price tag was $1, they owe $1. If the price tag was 1 eth, they owe 1 eth. [edit: I've changed my mind. They bought an asset for $x in USD, they are owed $x in USD]
- CoryG89 9y agoApparently this is an ERC-20 token on the Ethereum blockchain, which means it is (probably) purchased using ETH.
- pbiggar 9y ago"Purchased using" is not the same as "price tag in". If I'm in the US, and I buy something from the UK, I would have paid GBP. My refund would be expected in GBP and they are not responsible for the currency fluctuations in between.
- cortesoft 9y agoIt was in eth, which is the problem. They invested one eth, and got back .3 eth.
- pbiggar 9y agoIf that's the case, then yeah, they got ripped off, and they can and should go to court to get it back. Do you know where this was posted? I'd love to read the wording.
- BWStearns 9y agoIt seems like the scam went like this: make ICO, invest all the money in ETH. If ETH spikes by the time you are required to perform, you refund with the now appreciated ETH at $ prices and call it good. Otherwise you go ahead with your shitty coin and just deal with investors being mad that they didn't become billionaires. Edit: so if that is indeed the scam then essentially the claim of wanting the returns on ETH is saying that the mark deserves them because the gains were ill gotten via transferring the risk to the mark.
- pbiggar 9y agoGood point. Yet another reason to stay the fuck away from this space.
- BWStearns 9y agoThis also makes me wonder about another "scam". * Buy some of coin X * Use that to buy some cash equivalent good that has a return policy (longer the better) * If X appreciates by the time the return policy is up, you return the goods, collecting the gains. * If X depreciates you sell the goods for cash in USD which likely won't have varied much in the intervening time. * Repeat, and you will have effectively captured 100% of the increase of X while completely derisked.
- asperous 9y agoNo one will return you the original number of BTC for refunds for this reason. But if they did then this would work.
- cortesoft 9y agoThey should return the currency you used to invest with, though, right? I mean, if I invest 100 US dollar in something, I expect 100 US dollars back if it is returned. You can't say "Well, when you invested, $100 was worth 100 euro, but now you can buy 100 euro for only $10, so here is $10. Look, you can still buy the same amount of euros, so the value is the same!" If they invested 1 eth token, give them back 1 eth token.
- debacle 9y agoThat's a drastic overstatement on the value of eth as a currency.
- adventured 9y ago> They should return the currency you used to invest with, though, right? Depends on the contract potentially. It's why most larger business arrangements that could even possibly include such a refund (as part of the contract), will have specifications covering that. I'm curious what was in their agreement, if anything. For example, if it had a clause that allows for returning the dollar invested sum. A court will usually find against you if you repay in a debased currency or similar however. If I tried to repay a loan, with no contract, in Venezuelan bolivars based on their former value on the date of the origination of the loan five years ago, that wouldn't get anywhere in a court of law, you'd lose easily.
- mancerayder 9y agoExcept in the US these are not currencies officially. All indications are that they're going to view these as securities.
- palakchokshi 9y agoNo sorry if you consider ETH to be a currency and payment was made in that currency then repayment is expected in that currency. Let's say you borrow US$1000 from a friend. That $1000 would have bought 1000 candies when you borrowed that money. One year later 1000 of the same candies costs $800 because the USD became stronger. You cannot repay your friend with 1000 candies and say you are good. You took $1000 and your friend wants $1000, not something that was equivalent to $1000 at the time you borrowed the money.
- pbiggar 9y agoI agree conceptually: if both sides consider the transaction to in ethereum-denominated currency, then there is a logical argument to what you said. But legally, ETH is not a currency. If they take this to court, the court will award the original USD price. They bought an asset worth $x. They are owed $x. When we get away from this funny money "we're inventing currencies" bullshit, there is a law of the land. An asset was promised, and they are owed the value of that asset when purchased, in USD.
- SaltyBackendGuy 9y agoExactly, what if ETH dropped to 1$? I am sure they would want their USD back.
- palakchokshi 9y agoAgreed. Like I said IF you consider ETH a currency. If you don't then that's an argument against all cryptocurrencies in general.
- eganist 9y agoCorrect, and the USG does not. IRS guidance calls all cryptocurrencies property.
- palakchokshi 9y agoI'm not a fan of cryptocurrencies myself but I am trying to argue the spirit of the transaction which considered ETH as a currency. Legally I am with you 100% that the investors are out of luck. That's the price of "investing" in a highly speculative vaporware "currency".
- debt 9y agoLast I checked AWS doesn't accept crypto. You can't eat crypto can you? So how was this person expected to build anything using literally only Ethereum(in compensation and in expenses)?
- Axsuul 9y agoYou exchange Ethereum for fiat currency.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoWhy can't etherium just be used for each new application instead instead of creating a new ICO for every new application?
- adventured 9y agoBecause the new token is part of the scheme (scam?). It's a core componetent of the inducement, people think/hope they're getting in extremely low on the next moonshot.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoIn that case, I would trust new coin apps more if they just used etherium.
- quickthrower2 9y agoYep you get your money back. Denominated in Zimbabwe dollars.
- derefr 9y ago> Yeah, that's bullshit. They owe you your money back, they don't owe you the gains that you would have gotten if you had speculated in Ethereum instead. Consider the equivalent situation in ForEx terms: you pay a Mexican company $10 USD for a product, and then, six months later—when the value of USD/MXN has gone up—you ask for a refund. You'd expect back $10 USD, right? Not some amount of USD equivalent to the amount of MXN $10USD would have bought six months ago. In this case, they paid in in ETH. So you'd expect that ETH in at point-of-sale, would equal ETH out at point-of-refund. That would be giving the investor their money back—money denominated in ETH.
- CPLX 9y agoDepends on where you are. If all the described events happened in Mexico then you'd get back pesos. If all that stuff happened in the US you'd get back dollars. If you had a contract that specified different and it was legally sound then that's what you'd do. That's how this works. You can call things currencies but that doesn't make it so, the legal system is an arm of he state, and states have one kind of currency, they get to decide what it is, and the they have guns and jails if you don't like it.
- derefr 9y ago> If all the described events happened in Mexico then you'd get back pesos. If all that stuff happened in the US you'd get back dollars. Say I'm dealing with a subsidiary of a Mexican corporation that operates in the US. They ask for payment in MXN, but both they and I know they're going to send it to their parent corporation, converting it to MXN in the process. They and I also know that, to get the refund, they'll have to pull MXN out of their treasury and convert it back to USD. But I still did pay USD to the subsidiary—my card didn't automatically convert USD to MXN to pay them or anything. I would expect, in this case, that my refund should happen from the subsidiary, and should be the original USD I transferred, even if that now costs them more to convert back than it was worth going in. However, I would also expect that if the corporation entered bankruptcy, and was unwinding its debt obligations, then I, as a creditor, would probably only see the current MXN value of the parent corporation's liability to me. (Or rather, the subsidiary—who owes me the money—would unwind with no assets held to pay out, so I would then sue the parent corporation for said assets, and end up with MXN.)
- mancerayder 9y agoHowever, this is weird: “Within hours they refunded me ethereum with a dollar amount equal to what I had contributed in early September, but since the coin has more than tripled in value since then, they kept the rest of my contribution, essentially stealing quite a lot of money from me.” Yeah, that's bullshit. They owe you your money back, they don't owe you the gains that you would have gotten if you had speculated in Ethereum instead. I agree. If it had gone down instead of up, he'd have kept his trap shut on this matter instead of being upset.
- paulie_a 9y agoEvery ico is a scam at this point and I have no expectations that will change. ICO has the reputation of ponzi
- alexnewman 9y agoI intend to prove you wrong... next week
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bhouston 9y ago> I consider every ICO to be a scam I agree. I wonder if the average take of each new ICOs is decreasing as awareness of then generally being scams increases?
- philipodonnell 9y agoThe fun thing is, everyone here is calling this a scam, and while its clearly not what the investors intended, being able to park crypto funds in a way that is indexed to a specific USD amount is a legitimate service that has value: see the idea (but not the execution) behind Tether. If he had just come out and said 'give me Ethereum and I'll give it back in 6 months at the same USD exchange rate' there are a non-zero number of people who would have taken him up on that, maybe even paid for the service.
- raiyu 9y agoIf you went to a Seed fund and tried to pitch them your idea (whitepaper) with no working prototype 99 out of 100 times you wouldn't get any funding. After you have your MVP then they will start asking you for traction. Again 98 out of 100 times not getting any funding. Here you can raise a tremendous amount of capital, given that the majority of seed rounds are $500k-$3MM, and with an ICO entities are raising tens of millions of dollars to build something that again has no actual working mvp to show usage. Doesn't really seem like a sound investment ;) Tokens have already been in use for a long time with chat sites, I suppose if one of them decided to re-create their tokens on the blockchain and offer an ICO they could make more money during this period than actually operating their service. At least that would have some basis in reality in that there is an existing site that is generating revenue, profit, and visitors.
- Alex3917 9y ago> Doesn't really seem like a sound investment. You're conflating the economics of currencies with the economics of companies.
- paulgb 9y agoIt seems to me like the whole value proposition of ICOs is getting people to think of a currency as equity in a company.
- pbiggar 9y agoI agree. But is explicitly not that. Often your currency is backed by nothing at all, with no potential for it to even be worth anything.
- Alex3917 9y ago> Often your currency is backed by nothing at all, with no potential for it to even be worth anything. If enough people make Pascal’s Wager, then god effectively exists.
- 9y ago
- tudorw 9y agoWhile economics teaches us that past performance is not an indicator of future performance it concurrently teaches us that history is the only clue we have as to the future so, what follows is a fictional rewrite of a not so distant history; Maybe it's canals, not tulips... "For each cryptocoin, a unique software protocol and accompanying network was necessary to enable its implementation, and as people saw the high incomes achieved from sales to fiat currency, mining and transaction fees, coin proposals came to be put forward by investors interested in profiting from coins, at least as much as by developers seeking to facilitate egalitarian movement of financial value and flexible independent storage of wealth. In a further development, there was often out-and-out speculation, in which people would try to buy coins in a newly created coin simply to sell them on for an immediate profit, regardless of whether the network was ever profitable, or even built. During this period of "coin mania", huge sums were invested in coin infrastructure, and although many schemes came to nothing, the coin system rapidly expanded to nearly 4,000 coins in everyday circulation." Inspired by the original; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_British_canal_system#18th_century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_British_canal_s... For each canal, an Act of Parliament was necessary to authorise construction, and as people saw the high incomes achieved from canal tolls, canal proposals came to be put forward by investors interested in profiting from dividends, at least as much as by people whose businesses would profit from cheaper transport of raw materials and finished goods. In a further development, there was often out-and-out speculation, in which people would try to buy shares in a newly floated company simply to sell them on for an immediate profit, regardless of whether the canal was ever profitable, or even built. During this period of "canal mania", huge sums were invested in canal building, and although many schemes came to nothing, the canal system rapidly expanded to nearly 4,000 miles (over 6,400 kilometres) in length.[1]
- FabHK 9y agoA difference being that one can easily make a use case for multiple canals, but I find it harder to see a case for multiple digital currencies.
- tudorw 9y agoI don't agree, if it gets to the point where multiple currencies are exchangeable independently (Swap protocol for example) then I can see a use for different variations that have different properties, you may choose one that offers the highest security model and most stable price for savings and another that allows for fast transactions with a reduced security model. It's all gone a bit crazy recently and it's hard to see through the noise, but I do believe that something will come of this technology!
- Hasz 9y agoIs this even remotely surprising to anybody? All these ICOs are pump and dump schemes at best. This guy just seems to have ditched the formalities and simply stolen the money.
- cheez 9y agoI used to get downvoted for sharing that thought :)
- wildflowero 9y agoThe forces of nature at play.
- Hasz 9y agoIf it's any consolation, I did too.
- starpilot 9y agoWell, Quantstamp is backed by YC, so perhaps not "every."
- zebraflask 9y agoColor me shocked (not that shocked). On its face . . . just the idea . . . how could anyone look at that one, out of all of the ICOs out there, and not think twice before sending in their money?
- jessaustin 9y agoSome people, uhhh, really like porn.
- EGreg 9y agoCan't there be an ethereum contract that refunds everyone their money after 12 months if they don't receive the token?
- quickthrower2 9y agoThere could be. How does this help though? He'd send you a worthless token.
- jhwang5 9y agoI think the issue here was that original investors got a cold feet and tried to get a refund, then the ICO sponsor balked.
- krisives 9y agoDoes the original contract published include that provision? If not it would require the contract holder (developer) to modify the code.
- junkscience2017 9y agothe people who were dumb enough to give him $25 million deserved to be scammed
- Ralz 9y agoCan we put the FMtokens cryptocurrency name in the title? This may scare people who invested in other adult entertainment coins such as SpankChain (https://spankchain.com/ https://spankchain.com/)
- jpatokal 9y agoIf you invest in something called "SpankCoin", I think getting occasionally spooked by titles is going to be the least of your worries...
- abrkn 9y agoYou'd be surprised. Bitfinex has added the "SPANK" token of "SpankChain" to its markets[1] [1] https://www.bitfinex.com/t/SPK:USD https://www.bitfinex.com/t/SPK:USD
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- indescions_2018 9y agoThe real tragedy here is that an instant, anonymous, feeless, global cryptocurrency would form the absolute ideal medium of exchange between online sex workers and their patrons. Sites such as ManyVids, et al. probably see on order of $100K per week in transactions. Although the cryptocurrency community may balk at the association. The benefits of decentralization in this particular milleu are self-evident. Its possible it may even become the driver of significant transaction volume growth!
- dna_polymerase 9y agoIt really would make a perfect fit. Then again site owners might face legal challenges as there would be no age verification built into the payment system. I guess there is still space for a player in that market.
- jhwang5 9y agoUnless the token / currency is purchased with cash, or using something like Monero, then you don't have the benefit of anonymity with cryptocurrencies. All payers can be traced back to some fiat account.
- perlgeek 9y agoI agree, but that crypto currency would also need to be somewhat stable in price, and easy to spend (or exchange for cash).
- krylon 9y agoWhen I saw the headline, I thought it was satire. It happens at a disturbing rate these days. Is it just me growing old(er), or is the world really becoming more and more unreal?
- debacle 9y agoSome sliver of it, to be sure, but most people don't know what a bitcoin is.
- the_stc 9y agoThis is why we are not launching our ICO until after we have a working service. We are raising some money in a pre-ICO (Series A) but given the scams, we felt it was best to deliver before going public. Of course, we are not a typical ICO. We are selling an unregulated security: equity in our company and we will pay dividends. We are only going this route because we are an extrajurisdictional company and traditional fundraising is incredibly difficult for such a setup.
- wpietri 9y agoIsn't "extrajurisdictional company" a contradiction in terms? A company is a legal vehicle, which requires laws, which requires jurisdiction. Without a legal company, it would seem that under the law you are just some individuals conducting business. Is that not the case?
- the_stc 9y agoA company is a group of people operating together. That is what our company is. We are not incorporated in any jurisdiction.
- jhwang5 9y agoSo your team members all work remotely in different countries?
- michaelchisari 9y agoThat is perilously naive.
- the_stc 9y agoHow so? I am aware that if our opsec fails, a creative prosecutor will have no shortage of options to go after me with. It won't shut down the operation because a successor will restore from backups and move on. But it will make me unhappy.
- 9y ago
- notadoc 9y agoThe rampant scam ICOs, nonsensical coins, and other funny business surrounding the cryptocurrency scene is practically begging for regulators to barge in.
- jhwang5 9y agoYet they haven't, despite the fact that this phenomenon has persisted for over a year. Either 1) regulators see some practical difficulties in enforcing regulation, or 2) there is some counter-incentive / counter-pressures / lobbyists forces out there deterring regulatory action. I wouldn't be surprised if these scams are allowed to go on for another year.
- krisives 9y agoI'm not surprised. Two out of five of the top coins by market capitalization right now are fake crypto-currencies. Cardano literally doesn't exist at all yet and is a white paper and Ripple to be considered a crypto-currency requires a serious stretch of the imagination. Neither are mineable. Also we are approaching $2 trillion USDT floating around.
- puranjay 9y agoThe number of ICOs I see being advertised all around the internet, all with the familiar marketing gimmicks ("coin for marijuana! celebrity founder!") makes me doubt pretty much every ICO. I'm yet to see a single real-world use case for crypto. Pretty much everything is hinged on the "promise" of crypto. BTC itself seems to have zero momentum in actually implementing it for payments. All the stories I see about it are about its price as an asset.
- pscsbs 9y agoI think FileCoin is pretty interesting, and actually based on the economics of scarcity (file storage) thereby providing some concrete value.
- b0rsuk 9y agoI see an analogy with prostitution: prostitutes get away with a lot of cheating, because their customers are embarrassed to report anything (except perhaps in countries where it's fully legal). Therefore, a good rule of thumb is: the more embarrassing a service is, the more cheaters it will support.
- dmix 9y agoQuite the opposite plenty of escorts get fucked around. That’s why they developed market solutions such as screening clients and widely used black lists .
- b0rsuk 9y agoI don't think this is mutually exclusive. Both parties cheat, because the topic is awkward and not treated seriously, especially in more conservative states.
- dmix 9y agoTrue, I can't edit my comment, but yes it happens both sides. The nature of markets forced to be black. It's not mutually exclusive in any black market, both sides have to have self defensive tactics outside of the state.
- arisAlexis 9y agothat's what risk/reward ratio means. no scams = 2%. high scam potential means 20000%. every investor (should) knows that
- kensai 9y agoNobody saw that cumming! >_<