5 ms·
Sorry, why should that matter? Google doesn't trust you to honor your advertising contract because you didn't in the past and they know it because they literal
by ajross 9y ago
Sorry, why should that matter? Google doesn't trust you to honor your advertising contract because you didn't in the past and they know it because they literally caught your fraud themselves.
You seem to be arguing that a technicality should allow you to use other ad mechanisms, but that's not how real work risk analysis (or morality!) works.
You get the same treatment from banks: default on one loan and they'll tell the others (via credit reporting agencies), because that information is something they need to make good business decisions.
- mattzito 9y ago> You get the same treatment from banks: default on one loan and they'll tell the others (via credit reporting agencies), because that information is something they need to make good business decisions. At least in the US, negative events on your credit report disappear after 7 years.
- ceejayoz 9y agoThere's more than just a credit report involved, though. There might be a ChexSystems report that trips you up, for example.
- megy 9y agoTry going to the same bank you defrauded and getting a loan?
- dazc 9y agoTrue. The statute of limitations (or whatever the consumer credit regulations equivalent is called?) doesn't extend to what individual organisations already know about you.
- thomasahle 9y agoActually, loans are a good example, since there is a very clear path to making things good again. Typically this involves 10 years of trouble, but that is still better than being completely in the darkness as you slowly get cut off from more and more services (as Google expands.)
- ucaetano 9y agoNo really, it would be the same if after the fraud, Google told Facebook, Amazon, etc. about you and they rejected your business. If you commit fraud against a bank, I find it highly dubious that such bank will ever accept your business again, even if others do (after a decade).
- jonny_eh 9y agoPeople change, learn, and grow. We need to be able to forgive people, from time to time, as a society.
- ajross 9y agoCompletely agreed. But I don't see how that's relevant to the grandparents argument that adsense fraud shouldn't affect Youtube ad revenue. I mean, extending your point: does the grandparent sound appropriately contrite to you? If you read that comment and had to decide whether or not to sign an ad service contract, would you? Edit to be even clearer: OkGoDoIt literally describes the fraudulent theft of hundreds of dollars as a "silly freshman experiment"! Is that a situation you think Google should be required to forgive?
- jonny_eh 9y ago> Is that a situation you think Google should be required to forgive? Required? No. Appropriate? Yes
- brewdad 9y agoSo because an 18 year old made a poor decision, he should forever be barred from monetizing an online presence?
- dazc 9y agoNo, because there are plenty of other ways of doing this that don't require forgiveness from an organisation he's previously tried to screw over.
- prepend 9y agoThere is no valid alternative to YouTube as far as similar content creation monetization. YouTube is by far the monopoly with over 50% on creator content. It’s possible, but won’t have the same reach. Best bet would be switching to content type specific platforms like twitch.
- 9y ago
- zmmmmm 9y ago> Google doesn't trust you to honor your advertising contract because you didn't in the past When this kind of logic gets sufficiently lazy it becomes discrimination. Because it simply is not true that something someone did 20 years ago as a teenager is a good predictor of their behavior as a mature adult now. Applying that logic is essentially a lazy heuristic by a company that can't be bothered to do anything more than the most shallow fraud analysis. In the case of Google, which has such deep knowledge of its users and such a robust data analysis competency it is particularly egregious. They could probably figure out in a few seconds that this person is not really a high fraud risk. They simply don't care to bother doing so.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]