5 ms·
In what way is Bitcoin inflationary?
by adventured 9y ago
In what way is Bitcoin inflationary?
- Klathmon 9y agoThe current amount of bitcoin in existance is increasing at a rate of 12.5 every 10 minutes.
- adventured 9y agoThat's meaningless. The actual action of bitcoin against anything in the economy leads to zero net inflation. There is no wealth / money / assets being created or destroyed by Bitcoin going up or the coin count increasing. There's no scenario where Bitcoin can reach into the economy without transiting through something, in which case there is a swap and no new value is created. Want to take a loan against your bitcoins? The entity doing the loaning gets your coins if you default. Nothing new has been created, you swap positions. Want to sell your bitcoins? The buyer swaps positions with you, no new wealth has entered the economy. The buyer holds your former position, and you hold the eg USD or Euro currency. Want to direcly trade a house for bitcoins? (leaving off any taxes, fees, etc for this purposes) You swap positions with the seller. They get your bitcoins, you get the house. Nothing new has been added or removed from the economy. New wealth is created almost exclusively via productivity increases, not by two people trading objects $1 for $1 back and forth.
- Klathmon 9y ago>There is no wealth / money / assets being created or destroyed by Bitcoin going up or the coin count increasing. That's false. There is electricity being spent, and the security of all transactions before the current block being further secured by each new block. you might not think it's a valuable thing, but many others do, and you can't just discount it as not existing because you don't see the value. Just like how you might not see the value in videogames, or shitty daytime TV, but that doesn't mean it's worthless, just that it's not something you value. Bitcoin is a service that allows trustless transactions, and that service costs in the form of electricity usage.
- adventured 9y ago> you might not think it's a valuable thing, but many others do, and you can't just discount it as not existing because you don't see the value. I never said any such thing at all. I never said Bitcoin wasn't worth anything, in fact everything I said implies that people were obviously willing to swap / trade etc. with it (the implication is that it's worth something). I said Bitcoin does not involve the creation of any new value (as in, any net new value). It doesn't. When you seek to utilize Bitcoin, all instances involve value swapping, not net new value creation. If you mined 1,000 Bitcoins, for you to enter them into the economy you must swap them against something else, for example $USD currency (or a car or a house, whatever). Nothing new is generated in that process, you're swapping positions. I get the 1,000 coins, you get the $USD which I was just holding. That's why Bitcoin is clearly a value store. Electricity cost, which you mention, over time ends up being a small fractional cost, little different than the existing transaction fees. As each coin is not mined over and over again, per unit of activity the electricity cost of each coin averaged plunges over time (eventually becoming insignificant given numerous years). Not to mention, most bitcoins were not mined at a meaningful electricity cost, which dramatically dilutes the whole as well.
- Klathmon 9y agoFor starters... >Electricity cost, which you mention, over time ends up being a small fractional cost, little different than the existing transaction fees. As each coin is not mined over and over again, per unit of activity the electricity cost of each coin plunges over time (eventually becoming insignificant given N years). That's not true. Because in order to spend the transaction, it must be mined again. The amount of electricity cost of each coin doesn't plunge, it increases with each transaction, and stays the same if the "coin" doesn't move. At a point in the future no new bitcoin will be created, and at that time the only incentive to mine will be transaction fees which will pay for the electricity cost of the continued mining for validating transactions. It's not an insignificant cost, it's the only significant cost. >When you seek to utilize Bitcoin, all instances involving value swapping. By that definition all physical mining doesn't create any value, since people are just "swapping" their currency for whatever you dug out of the ground. And please don't say that it's different because it's "physical". You seem to be hung up on the "swapping" aspect, which I never said was the "value add" of bitcoin, it's not, you are correct that simply trading bitcoin doesn't add anything of value. But transacting bitcoin does, it provides the value of enabling trustless transactions quickly and without any "gatekeeper". Edit: I think I just realized the problem. Your definitions only make sense if you mine the coin once, then trade it off the blockchain forever (as in physically or virtually sending the bitcoin keys to someone else in return for some kind of good or service). That's not how most people use bitcoin, and doing it that way removes all of the benefits and "value add" that I talk about, and indeed is just a store of value at that point. So you are correct, but if you transact bitcoin in the blockchain, suddenly it becomes something more than a store of value, it provides value. It provides security, trustless transactions, immutable history, and more.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> The current amount of bitcoin in existance is increasing at a rate of 12.5 every 10 minutes An increasing monetary base and deflation are not mutually exclusive. They tend to go hand in hand, but not always. Bitcoin's monetary base is increasing, i.e. there are more units today than there were yesterday. It is also deflating, i.e. one Bitcoin today is worth more than one Bitcoin yesterday. (More precisely, one unit of real goods or services are worth fewer Bitcoins today than they were yesterday.)
- Klathmon 9y ago>It is also deflating, i.e. one Bitcoin today is worth more than one Bitcoin yesterday. But that's explicitly false, especially today (what with bitcoin being down 14% over the last 24 hours). And there was a period of bitcoin's history of about 3 years where the value of one bitcoin was dropping day after day. Does that mean bitcoin was inflationary during that time? I just can't see that as being a useful definition.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Does that mean bitcoin was inflationary during that time? Just because something is volatile doesn't mean we can make no useful statements about its trend. If you're re-evaluating your purchasing and investing activity on a day-to-day basis then yes, the day-to-day price level change is relevant. (There are corporate treasurers who worry about 30-day price level changes.) > I just can't see that as being a useful definition. I agree. For an asset as volatile as Bitcoin, the terms "inflationary" and "deflationary" are largely meaningless. It won't be used as a currency because it's volatile, not because it's deflating. Still, between "inflationary" and "deflationary" Bitcoin has (a) spent more days deflating than inflating and (b) deflated over its long run to date. It is more correct to say Bitcoin is deflationary than anything else.
- Klathmon 9y ago> It won't be used as a currency because it's volatile, not because it's deflating. Again, I disagree. It's volatility wasn't a major problem in the past, and I believe it will begin to mellow out as time goes on. Bitcoin just went through an unprecedented amount of growth over 2017, as the market matures and more liquidity is introduced the price will (hopefully) stabilize. >Still, between "inflationary" and "deflationary" Bitcoin has (a) spent more days deflating than inflating and (b) deflated over its long run to date. It is more correct to say Bitcoin is deflationary than anything else. But isn't that true of any asset? Go back far enough and they all start at 0 and are worth something today.
- rtkwe 9y agoUsually it's by the extremely narrow definition that more BTC is still being minted via block rewards.