9 ms·
Game Critic Uses Workaround for YouTube's Copyright (2016)
- digi_owl 9y agoCopyright was hatched back when the act of copying was laborious and mechanical, meaning that the copier likely had deep pockets and financial backing (and there were few of them in the neighborhood). This logic falls flat when we get a device that is basically built for copying, the computer. A major part of how it operates is to copy data in and out of memory. Anyways, even before the computer various nations had exceptions in place for copying between friends and relatives. This because even policing the likes of cassette based copying was virtually impossible without a permanent copyright cop in every home. These days however said copyright cop is being implemented in the form of DRM and the kind of content fingerprinting talked about in the article.
- qubex 9y agoSince when have computers been “basically built for copying”? Computers are designed for computing, from the Turing Machine onwards storage and duplication have merely been instruments and steps (respectively) towards achieving universality. The idea of a computer as a communication device came relatively late in the game (most of Shannon's Information Theory's applicability to computation was to infra-computer communication between circuits, or transmission “down time”, meaning storage and delay loops), and not to intra-computer communication. Yes, modern computers are effective communication devices and the idea of networking has become almost indelibly welded to the idea of computation, but on a theoretical level they are absolutely distinct, and it's probably an accident of history that the two concepts ended up entwined. That's why there's lambda calculus for making statements about computing and pi calculus for making statements about process communication.
- pdkl95 9y ago> Since when have computers been “basically built for copying” Digital computers (i.e. Shannon's Information Theory) was a solution for the S/N getting worse every time the signal was amplified. Shannon's solution of digital circuits allowed information to be copied without the limit. An important consequence of this was the marginal cost for copying information falling very close to zero. Or, stated in economic terms, information ws no longer scarce. > computer You're using a very narrow definition of "computer". Colloquial use of the word obviously includes a variety of technologies and concepts - such as Shannon's digital circuits - not just model of computation (Turing or otherwise). > modern computers are effective communication device You don't even need to consider {,inter}networking; the modern devices commonly called "computers" spend most of their time managing data. Very little time is spent doing any actual computation. I recommend this[1] lecture by Feynman, where he explains how what we call "computers" are are really closer to a filing system that stores and copies data (including the store program and most of the mechanics of computation). [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKWGGDXe5MA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKWGGDXe5MA
- qubex 9y ago> You’re using a very narrow definition of ”computer” Yes, I am, and that’s because I have a mathematical background. I’m quite comfortable in my knowledge that the common-parlance item is actually a ’computer’ as I intend it (narrowly) fused with a communicator that allows it to internetwork with other similarly compound devices.
- aisofteng 9y agoThe point is that to produce content requires investment and/or valuable skill. You've clearly never had a livelihood that depends on knowledge, experience, or skills that took you years to develop and then has someone copy it and profit from it. That's what copyright is for.
- jonny_eh 9y agoThis should be labeled as 2016 content.
- teej 9y agoThe timing of this article is important to note because Youtube has since put in place major revisions to their monetization policies known colloquially as “Adpocalypse” that may impact the strategy.
- jackvalentine 9y agoJim's strategy isn't about getting youtube monetization though - it's about avoiding others monetizing the videos (which has not changed in adpocalypse as far as I can tell). His income stream is pateron iirc.
- ukulele 9y agoTL;DR: guy splices random scenes into his videos that are owned by multiple large corporations so that the firms fight each other over royalties. Is this a "Brilliant Workaround"? I report, you decide.
- dilap 9y agoClever, at least.
- personjerry 9y agoAFAIK the author of this article, Patricia Hernandez, is known for her clickbait
- kevingadd 9y agoYou're incorrect, look at her publication history. Just skimming the headlines (and examining the text of the longer-form articles) makes it pretty clear that the stuff she writes for them isn't clickbait. Some of it is brief summaries, but that's what happens when you're handling news for a games site. Lots of brief bits of information end up summarized because that's what your readers want.
- philtar 9y ago> Five Reasons I Like Fortnite BR Way Better Than Battlegrounds Her latest article. A bunch of her other articles are like that as well. I believe that you are the incorrect one here.
- mikestew 9y agoThe article delivered what the headline promised (and was pretty spot on, but I prefer Fortnite myself). How is that clickbait? Have you considered that the word does not mean what you think it does?
- lozenge 9y agoListicle and clickbait isn't the same thing. That headline probably describes the article very well.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- code4tee 9y agoGoogle’s engine also doesn’t seem to understand basic copyright law. Simply having a brief clip of someone else’s content doesn’t, under many ‘fair use’ cases, constitute a copyright violation. The whole system is also grossy a “guilty until proven innocent” setup. There’s little penalty for people just putting out bogus claims so content creators tend to get flooded with “content claims” even when a 2 second human review clearly shows the claim to be bogus (see earlier posting about guy’s white noise video getting slammed with content claims). Google’s crappy AI tech combined with crappy policies are creating a living hell for many content creators. Of course here Google is basically just making up its own laws for their own world. As a private platform they can basically do whatever they want. Does that violate their “don’t be evil” mantra? We report, you decide.
- JosephHatfield 9y agoHere's an exercise for the reader. Record a short video of anything, and ensure that the soundtrack is of you playing random notes on any instrument of your choosing. Then, upload the video to YouTube, and count the number of minutes before you receive the inevitable copyright infrignement claim.
- AckSyn 9y agoYou're not joking either. Mine was 15 minutes and timing it wasn't even a goal of mine. Automated systems like that shouldn't be allowed.
- Twirrim 9y ago> Google’s crappy AI tech combined with crappy policies are creating a living hell for many content creators. Unfortunately, as I understand it, they're somewhat forced to by US law and the quirks of safe harbor provisions, by which they have to show that they've done everything they reasonably could to stop infringement. The law in this case is focussed heavily on the copyright holders, and end user experience doesn't even enter in to it. If they don't respond quickly and effectively to copyright infringement, they lose their safe harbor protections and become liable for the copyright infringement themselves as well. The whole Content-ID stuff came out from the "Viacom vs Youtube" court case, and while the case came out in Google's favour the writing was clearly on the wall. Putting in Content ID ensured that Google stopped being sued by every major copyright holder and their mother. It sure sucks for end users, the system is god awful, but I'm not convinced Google has any real choice here.
- Feniks 9y agoIt's not YouTube's copyright. I know humans like things simple and easy to blame but I'm getting tired of it. YT is shit now because the internet is no longer the Wild West. Don't like it go change the law.
- DanBC 9y agoContentID isn't an implementation of US copyright law. For example, ContentID doesn't allow Fair Use. People are complaining that US copyright law gives them rights, and those rights are blocked by Google's lousy algorithms.
- stordoff 9y agoIt goes beyond that though - occasionally even when you have the explicit rights to use a piece of content, YouTube will prevent you from doing so. Comparatively rare to, e.g., not allowing for fair use, but it does happen.
- pdkl95 9y agoIt's not just fair use. Some people actually license music either direct from the musician or through a licensing service. Sometimes years later the video that used the music gets a copyright claim from someone else besides the actual musicians that wrote, performed, recorded, and licensed the song. Sometimes it's about a different version by a cover band, sometimes it's a business that blindly uploads their entire catalog into ContentID, sometimes it's a scammer uploading literally everything to they can hoping to get free ad revenue from whatever ContentID randomly selects.
- pault 9y agoIronically, trying to play the embedded video throws an error saying the content is owned by WMG and can't be viewed outside of YouTube.