3 ms·
> Earth will be fine I'm so tired of hearing this empty phrase being used. Sure it was fun as a punchline but move along already. It's such a derailment of the
by worldsayshi 9y ago
> Earth will be fine
I'm so tired of hearing this empty phrase being used. Sure it was fun as a punchline but move along already. It's such a derailment of the discussion. It doesn't state what we mean by "earth" - is it the rock, the ecosystem, life itself? And it implies that the "earth" that is fine is the one that we actually should care about. I have no idea, because the way it's used is not really falsifiable and it's not really anything but a rhetorical trick.
- throwaway9990 9y agoNot sure why you're tired of it since I haven't heard this argument used much. Regardless, when I say Earth, I mean the rock and likely ecosystems that currently exist and might develop on it. I think these things cannot be easily separated that's why Earth is used.
- srdev 9y agoIt’s used in nearly every climate change discussion. Its not particularly profound or thought provoking.
- worldsayshi 9y ago> and likely ecosystems that currently exist Well if that's part of "Earth" then "Earth will be fine" is a lie.