5 ms·
After 12 years and endless fights with Google, HubPages finds a buyer
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- modi15 9y agoFrom the article: > "Paul and I are aligned because we both agree that mom-and-pop or small publishers no longer have a sustainable business," Heckman said in an interview. "It's over." This is the biggest reason Google needs to be reined in by splitting it apart.
- jlgray 9y agoSince they're talking about small publishers having trouble keeping up with google SEO updates, is there a reasonable way to actually break up google search?
- modi15 9y agoThe problem is not SEO updates. The problem is that there is only Google and no one else. Google, under Eric Smidt,start prioritizing big/branded sites over mom-and-pop. Nothing wrong with it - their search, their choice. The problem is that because they have overwhelming market share, there is no other choice left for smaller sites, but to shut down. They have overwhelming search market share not just because of search algo, but because they own the hardware that powers it, they own the browser which delivers those result, they own the analytics which tells them more about you and they own the ads on every site you go to. A startup should have the right to compete with Google - even if they dont build their own browser, even if they dont build their own analytics, even without the huge hardware farms and even without the ad engine that powers google. Once we split Google up, these network effects go away. Smaller startups can compete with Google on a relatively better footing. There can be more than one search providers and hopefully some of them can favour smaller shops as opposed to bigger brands.
- Angostura 9y agoWhat does splitting up Google actually mean? Forceable divestment of image search? Forced to spin off Maps?
- modi15 9y agoI have commented on one possible strategy here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16046871 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16046871 TLDR; cap number of employees for big tech
- rplnt 9y agoMany companies already "outsource" internal IT, support, testing, finances, HR, ... to virtual companies sitting in the same offices, just to make public numbers nicer (any unexpected cost is hidden from investors by paying premium). Wouldn't this be possible across tech teams as well? To meet some cap rules?
- modi15 9y agoMight be ok as long as the virtual company is independently owned. Nothing stops them from selling the same function to other companies also. That being said, I havent completely thought through this strategy - it might require additional regulation to work or there might be a better approach altogether.
- Godel_unicode 9y ago> Nothing stops them from selling the same function to other companies also Other than the exclusivity deal that they would have with Google and all the non-compete and NDAs they would have to sign.
- briandear 9y agoSo what about non-tech companies? And what makes a ‘tech’ company? Ford Motor Company is a tech company by pretty much any definition but one of their assembly line employees produces much less cumulative value than a Google engineer. So you will tell Ford to shut down assembly lines to meet some arbitrary cap? That’s going to make manufactured goods either skyrocket in cost or, result in companies like Google or Ford just moving outside the US. And what’s the benefit to the consumer of a broken up Google? Will I get a better search engine? Is the current one most people use somehow broken? Or is this all just philosophical? Meaning.. is there a startup right now that can’t compete because of Google? Is Google actually preventing them from building infrastructure, hiring people or doing really whatever they want? Remember when Apple was born? HP and IBM were juggernauts. But a new innovative company eventually dethroned the both of those companies. Actually Apple dethroned every single company since Apple is the most valuable company on the planet. And it started in a garage going against the ubiquitous Big Blue. We don’t need to break up anyone — we need people reading this to start building some real shit. With all the effort put into crypto currencies and other such trendy nonsense — how many people have tried to build and market better search? How many people are actually trying to solve hard problems that people care about? Honesty, nobody in the real world cares about Bitcoin. Google has a “monopoly” because it seems like nobody is trying to make something better! If Google search were actually bad but we were still forced to use it, that would be an abuse of a monopoly position. However, Google actually works pretty good most of the time. It literally works better than any other search engine I’ve tried. So, for that reason, we break up the company? That’s ridiculous. How about putting that effort into making something better? Breaking up the leader just because they are literally too popular? That’s crazy. Didn’t some ridiculous juicer raise tens of millions of dollars? Didn’t Mattermark waste $17 million or so just to gather startup data? Is there nobody actually trying to compete with Google? My point is that the problem isn’t Google; it’s the attitude that Google can’t be beaten. ANY company can be beaten — it doesnt take the government, it takes motivated people.
- Godel_unicode 9y agoYou seem to have an encoded assumption that smaller mom-and-pop businesses are desired by the market and are being crowded out. I don't think that's true, I think the average consumer doesn't especially care about the size of the corporation they're dealing with. In my experience (and yes, obviously there are the Patagonia exceptions to this general statement), people care about price, quality, convenience, and then ethics. In that order.
- maxxxxx 9y agoProbably true as far consumer attitude goes. But in the long run it's healthier to have many small players. I think the fact that Google, Facebook and Apple are so dominant is already killing a lot of innovation.
- fixermark 9y agoWhy is it healthy to have many small players? Larger companies have the resources to put experts on hard problems. They also have the vested incentive (since they have more to lose if they fail) to handle things like security correctly---I trust Facebook and Google to use security and authentication best-practices much more than J. Random Startup, for example.
- walkingolof 9y agoThe best example is gaming, imagine no-indies, you would have to chose between an NBA Game, the latest Quake and a Driving game each year, the next year, same thing but with more polygons, that is "safe" AAA games that publishers bet on, they do not create games like Fes, DwarfFortress or EvE.
- fixermark 9y agoGaming is a totally different ecosystem to what Google builds. I want something very different from my entertainment than from my information-seeking and business services.
- 9y ago
- AznHisoka 9y agoI have never ever found any single HubPage useful at all. Yes, small publishers struggle in Google. And some of them produce very useful content that should be more visible. HubPages isnt one of them though.
- dazc 9y agoI have found over the years that it isn't difficult to get useful content to surface on Google; the problem is that a lot of content isn't useful and is merely an SEO play.
- conductr 9y ago> a lot of content isn't useful and is merely an SEO play wikiHow.com is an example I always see ranked high in search results but the content is 99% garbage. Given high number of "how to" searches the world sees, I'm surprised Google keeps them so highly rated.
- neya 9y agoI used to be an avid HubPages fan. At its peak, it was mildly useful, kind of like instagram where you'd be able to discover new, useful projects/places/things and what not. During its time, AdSense was the craze, everybody wanted an account. Since AdSense was invite-only, application based, (don't know if it still is), the main criteria was to have a website/weblog with some useful content. A LOT of people, many even in my circle used HubPages to get their AdSense accounts approved. The process was simple - Open a hub, write a couple of useful articles, submit it along with your AdSense application and BINGO. Approved (for most, not all). Over time, slowly, HubPages started positioning themselves as a "get rich quick" scheme. This was especially suitable for them because they would also share your revenue from your AdSense account (60-40? I'm not sure). There were a LOT of affiliate products out there claiming to help you get rich quick with AdSense and HubPages. They allowed this nonsense to grow like a snowball. Now, I also made some money with their platform. Not too much, maybe about $100-200 in 2 months. I did try to scale my earnings, but realized the real guys who were getting rich were the ones who were teaching me (with courses, books) on how to get rich. Around 2008-2009-ish if I'm not wrong, HubPages became the hub of Spam. And then Google hit everyone hard with their algorithmic changes. It hit everyone really hard. Even some of my quality hubs disappeared over night. Ever since then, I learnt two lessons: 1) Don't rely 100% on someone else's (free) platform to host your content. Use your own or pay for it. 2) If someone teaches you how to get rich, you can be 100% sure he/she's getting rich because of you. I never looked back at HubPages since then. Today, I logged in and wiped out all information about me. Just had a look around and seems like not much has changed since I last left them.
- dh-g 9y agoGoogle wasn't fighting HubPages, just spammy SEO.