7 ms·
An 8-tube module from a 1954 IBM 705 mainframe: it's a key debouncer
- S_A_P 9y agoAre any 705s running today? I feel like the cost of keeping it up would be prohibitive. I’m also curious as to what tubes are used here.
- creeble 9y agoA few for mining Bitcoin, I think :) I hadn't heard of Eccles and Jordan before this article; I had previously believed that the flip flop was invented by Eckert and Mauchly. Good to know!
- dogma1138 9y ago5865 and 6211 are mentioned in the article there were probably a few more types tho.
- dfox 9y agoThere certainly isn't any still running 705 which serves useful purpose. In fact they were probably all replaced by 7080s and then 360s in sixties as 7080 is software compatible and specific 360 models have some support for running 7080 software. Also the software that ran on these machines is probably simple enough that it got rewritten for more modern machines cheaply.
- kens 9y agoI don't think there are any original vacuum tube computers still running. There are working replicas of the Colossus, ABC, SSEM and (almost complete) EDSAC. As far as tubes, the 700-series circuit manual [1] shows mostly dual triodes: 6211, 5687, 5965, 6350, 6072, 6528. Also 6136, 6197 pentodes. And probably a variety for special cases (e.g. power supply, core). [1] http://www.piercefuller.com/library/700circ.html http://www.piercefuller.com/library/700circ.html
- yborg 9y agoI was kind of amazed at the poor soldering across the board on this module, I wonder what the failure rate was on these things in actual use. I suppose the high heat load kept the joints flexible at least.
- keithpeter 9y agooxidization over the years? May not have been as tarnished looking when built.
- Jeema101 9y agoA lot of old point-to-point wiring and soldering does typically look kind of terrible compared to modern day electronics, probably because it was assembled by hand by workers just trying to crank stuff out out as fast as possible.
- dboreham 9y agoReminds me that my Dad told me he worked at Ferranti in the early 50's building "logic modules". I noticed one on display at the CHM in Mt View [1] and sent him a picture. He said he thought it looked the same as the units he built back then. His soldering was always pretty top-notch though. Ferranti was a military contractor so had some experience with reliability. [1] http://www.computerhistory.org/revolution/early-computer-companies/5/109 http://www.computerhistory.org/revolution/early-computer-com...
- crististm 9y agoI'm sorry, but are we looking at the same pictures? The soldering looks more than OK. For example, the solder used is just enough that it takes a pleasant concave shape on the terminals.
- softbuilder 9y agoWhen I look closely that work actually looks fine. Solder flow is reasonable and I don't see cold joints. The only true WTF was where a resistor had been ripped out for whatever reason. Also it's unclear whether they had flux-core solder yet and they are essentially soldering in 3D. (Former electronics assembler here.)
- lighttower 9y agoThe article mentions that government and business rented these machines. Does anyone know what the actual use cases were? I wonder how they justified the enormous cost to a Dilbert type manager in the 50s. Wow.
- quickben 9y agoI vaguely recall reading there were only a handful of companies offering computing at a scale, and none had the breadth of IBM. So, monopoly?
- qubex 9y agoAn antitrust suit was filed under the Sherman Act on 17 January 1969. It went to trial on 19 May 1975. It was eventually withdrawn on 8 January 1982 (what a coincidence).
- jonsen 9y ago"Engineered primarily to handle business data, the 705 could analyze millions of bits of data to determine the optimum location for a retail store; simulate the entire operation of an oil refinery; handle a huge billing operation in minutes; furnish inventory production control reports; or make up a 50,000-employee payroll with millions of deductions.": http://www-03.ibm.com/ibm/history/exhibits/mainframe/mainframe_PP705.html http://www-03.ibm.com/ibm/history/exhibits/mainframe/mainfra...
- toomanybeersies 9y agoOne of my flatmates (roommates to you Americans) works for a payroll company. It takes them over an hour to run the payroll for 5000 people due to terribly written SQL queries. It's like we've gone backwards. Where and when did we go wrong?
- Spooky23 9y agoSame as they do now... money! One of my mentors was a statistician who got into IT while transitioning a large state labor statistics department to computerization in the 70s. They replaced 2000 clerks and tabulating machines with 1 mainframe and a 4 year project. Ditching the building lease and tabulator maintenance paid for the project!
- jonsen 9y ago"This signal goes through two inverter circuits, creating a sharp output." The two inverter-tubes share a common cathode resistor. This provides positive feedback from the second inverter to the first. The circuit is called a Schmitt trigger: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schmitt_trigger https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schmitt_trigger
- raverbashing 9y agoAnd today you get 6 of them in a small package like in the 74XX derived families (74AHC14 for example) And that's when you're doing a not so streamlined circuit, and can't have them inside your ASIC or something, if you can it gets even smaller
- kens 9y agoFootnote 12 in the article goes into details on the Schmitt trigger.
- bane 9y agoHa! I didn't know what a debouncer was, and then I read this blog and wondered if there's still a version of them in modern hardware and then watched this video https://youtu.be/D23FbGFrVuo?t=699 https://youtu.be/D23FbGFrVuo?t=699 which specifically discusses the way the default DOS keyboard driver has a built in debouncer. What a weird coincidence in one day.
- jacquesm 9y agoEvery keyboard has one, every microcontroller reading pushbutton inputs will have one. There is one in your mouse.
- bane 9y agoThe impression I got from the DOS video is that the debouncing function may have just been moved over into software?
- swimfar 9y agoThat's how it's often done with Arduinos: https://www.arduino.cc/en/Tutorial/Debounce https://www.arduino.cc/en/Tutorial/Debounce
- vilhelm_s 9y agoThe guy in the video is confused. He says > The default keyboard handling on a DOS PC are meant for typing. So any time you hit a key there is a debounce before the key is allowed to repeat continuously, usually on the order of a quarter second to a half second. What he is describing is the keyboard driver autorepeat feature, if you hold down a key for a while the driver will generate a sequence of virtual keypresses. This is just a software convention, it's also possible to read the state of the keys directly (pressed down or not) instead of treating them in terms of key-press events. Using the word debouncing for this is incorrect. Debouncing happens on a millisecond time scale, it's due to the key actually physically bouncing.
- jacquesm 9y ago
- userbinator 9y agoTo understand how the inverter works, when the input (pin 2) is high, the current through the tube pulls the plate (pin 1) low. Conversely, when the input is low, the electron flow is blocked and the resistors pull the plate high. Note that "high" and "low" here are quite different from the usual digital logic conventions of high=+V, low=GND; in this case, high would be near GND while low is a negative voltage. The circuit manual PDF gives low=-30 and high=+10. A lot of other early transistor logic families operated with such "unusual" (for today) signal levels too. The other notable characteristic of tube circuits is the high resistor values --- this is because they operate at low current (in the mA range) but high voltage (hundreds of voltages). Contrast this with transistor logic which is relatively high current and low voltage. One amusing component I found in the tube module was "Vitamin Q" capacitors. Those are actually very desired by audiophiles, so it's odd to see them in a digital circuit. They're paper-in-oil capacitors and "Vitamin Q" was Sprague's trade name for the proprietary oil they used.
- kens 9y agoA lot of other early transistor logic families operated with such "unusual" (for today) signal levels too. One wacky thing in IBM's transistor computers is that they would alternate NPN and PNP gates. This avoided an extra transistor in each gate to shift the voltage level back. So you'd end up with one gate using +12V/0V logic levels and the next one using +6V/-6V. This technique was used in three different transistor logic families, each with their own voltages. So there were 6 different transistor logic levels, plus other miscellaneous logic levels (e.g. 48V relays). IBM's old computers were a crazy collection of different voltage levels.
- lisper 9y ago> transistor logic which is relatively high current Huh? The gate resistance of a FET is hundreds of megaohms, so the input current is measured in nanoamps. That doesn't seem like high current to me.
- averagewall 9y agoTransistors in TTL logic use mA of input current because they're bipolar, not FET transistors.
- vilhelm_s 9y agoQuite different from a modern key debouncer circuit like http://zipcpu.com/blog/2017/08/04/debouncing.html http://zipcpu.com/blog/2017/08/04/debouncing.html . The modern FPGA circuit first passes the input through two latches to synchronize it to the system clock, and then has a digital counter to add a delay to rapid bounces. Here the delay is analog, and there is no clock input: the output digital signal is still completely asynchronous. I wonder if they needed a second module to synchronize the signal and avoid metastability issues, or maybe that doesn't matter at the low clockspeeds they were using?
- Bromskloss 9y ago> The modern FPGA circuit first passes the input through two latches to synchronize it to the system clock, and then has a digital counter to add a delay to rapid bounces. What about debouncing with a low-pass filter, followed by a Schmitt trigger?
- sehugg 9y agoIn a similar vein, old arcade games might debounce their coin detectors with two latches synchronized to, say, HSYNC/128 -- effectively giving a debounce of a few msec.
- dfox 9y agoThat depends on environment you are working in. Digital debouncer in FPGA (or PLC for that matter) will involve some kind of digital timer as you cannot easily build simple RC low pass filter in such environment. In discrete logic debouncer designs with RC-filter that are quite similar to this tube circuit are still widely used and to some extent the modern designs are more similar to this when the schmitt trigger is realized as input of some MCU/FPGA and only external parts is the RC filter in contrast to tradditional discrete logic solutions which usually placed the filter between two schmitt trigger gates. By the way adding such external RC-filter (or even just series capacitor across the contacts) is quite cheap and quick fix for worn-out rotary encoders on various devices when existing (usually software) debouncing logic stops to be sufficient.