3 ms·
I'd ask that in its reverse formulation too: if density is the answer, why is affordability in the US roughly inversely proportional to density? Induced demand
by majormajor 9y ago
I'd ask that in its reverse formulation too: if density is the answer, why is affordability in the US roughly inversely proportional to density?
Induced demand, or something with a similar effect, seems to apply to housing at least as much as it does to traffic.
And before we dismiss it entirely as "coasts are more desirable than landlocked middle America," let's take a look at both various coastal cities of varying density in California[0] and various less-desirable (Houston is technically coastal, I suppose, but not in the "good weather" or "pleasant" way) Texas[1]. San Diego is cheaper than SF or LA, but also much less dense. Fort Worth is cheaper than Dallas, but also much less dense, and pretty much right next door in the middle of a bunch of flat land.
Maybe we should start knocking down a bunch of non-affordable housing, run off the people with enough money to move away, and watch that affordability go up? ;)
[0 ] https://www.apartmentlist.com/rentonomics/california-rent-report-rentonomics/ https://www.apartmentlist.com/rentonomics/california-rent-re...
[1] https://www.apartmentlist.com/rentonomics/california-rent-report-rentonomics/ https://www.apartmentlist.com/rentonomics/california-rent-re...
- closeparen 9y agoYou could reach for mysterious counterintuitive induced-demand effects in the housing market. Or you could observe that creating six-figure jobs, recruiting people from around the world, and paying them relocation expenses to come to your city, absolutely does "induce" demand for housing beyond any shadow of doubt 100% of the time. If Bay Area governments were as NIMBY about desks as they were about beds, we might not be in this mess. Now that we've built the desks, we need the beds to go with them. (Or burn down the desks? The sheer comedic value of a government on an explicit job-destroying program might be worth it).
- austenallred 9y ago> if density is the answer, why is affordability in the US roughly inversely proportional to density? Because affordability is inversely proportional to demand, and higher-demand areas tend to have more dense housing.
- majormajor 9y agoRight. And more dense areas draw more business which draws more people which draws more business and also increases price more and more... so density isn't a cure by itself, it's part of the cycle that causes the problem we're trying to fix. The same way "add another lane to the highway" doesn't fix traffic.
- nerfhammer 9y agoDense cities are the one weird trick to human civilization itself. China has seen unbelievably explosive growth in its cities and has also seen 1 billion people lifted out of poverty during exactly the same time period. Coincidence? People flock to cities because they can get paid five times more than they could back in their home village – they're not cavorting, scheming millionaires. Trying to strangle your cities because cities are bad is the dumbest thing you could do in terms of economic growth other than than trying to strangle trade on the theory that those scheming foreigners are going to take all of our money away. I'm sure downtown Shenzen is more expensive today than it was when it was a small fishing village. Would the world be a better place if it had been kept as a small fishing village?
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThe Chinese property bubble makes the USA property bubble look tame in comparison. At least rents are cheap ($1000/month rent is about $1 million to buy). Density doesn’t fix anything if many apartments are speculative investments and not worth the effort of renting out (because rents are low anyways compared to the appreciation).
- majormajor 9y ago> other than than trying to strangle trade on the theory that those scheming foreigners are going to take all of our money away. Wait, you don't think China has been doing this too? --- The US has had decentralized economic booms in the past; even China's current one is based around several cities and regions, and China continues to build outwards, not simply make Beijing and Shanghai ever denser inside the same radius. They do it at a higher density than we do in the US, sure, but other than that the strategy doesn't seem completely unfathomable - I think the Chinese-style answer to the Bay Area is less likely to be "make SF denser" and more "move a bunch of development to the East Bay or Dublin or something and make new companies start up over there." Expanding on what I said in a separate comment (sigh, I was headed to bed, maybe after this one), we are currently in the US letting many of our cities die while putting a ton of eggs into NYC/SF/etc baskets. I don't think further density in just a few places is going to fix anything price-wise or have any superior outcomes than reducing those bottlenecks would.