9 ms·
Australia's first electric aircraft has begun test flights
- Aardwolf 9y ago"Australia's first electric passenger plane takes to the skies" Well, one passenger, more like a sports plane than an airliner. Still very awesome :D
- scoggs 9y agoVery cool, right? I had a brain fart when I read the title on the front page thinking it was a self-driving electric plane, for some odd reason, and my heart skipped a beat. >It costs about $3 an hour to run the plane's engine, one-tenth the cost of a fuel engine. This sounds really great and at only €65,000 ($78196.30USD) it sounds like a steal that will scale nicely once it can carry the 5+ passengers it intends to. Someone in the comments mentioned it also sounds like a great idea because there will be many less moving parts. The plane also switches to more of a glider-mode once I imagine it's at altitude. A silent ride sounds kind of peaceful when I think of the drone of a normal plane.
- chrismorgan 9y agoWhere’s the €65,000 number coming from? I found http://www.flypipistrel.com/price-lists/PIPISTREL-ALPHA-ELECTRO-12-2017.pdf http://www.flypipistrel.com/price-lists/PIPISTREL-ALPHA-ELEC... which suggests €159,000. That datasheet also says 700 cycles to 75% battery capacity, rather than the “about 1,000” of this article. The $3/hour figure doesn’t seem to me to match the other numbers, either: 60kW for takeoff and 20kW for cruising; let’s ignore takeoff (it’s rounding error) and just call it 20kW. 20kWh for $3? At residential rates, 20kWh will cost more like $5. But I don’t know what commercial rates are for electricity; maybe they do get power that much cheaper than residential persons.
- chrismorgan 9y agoFurther to the running costs: if replacing battery cells worn out by 700 one-hour-flight cycles costs €12,000 (again citing http://www.flypipistrel.com/price-lists/PIPISTREL-ALPHA-ELECTRO-12-2017.pdf http://www.flypipistrel.com/price-lists/PIPISTREL-ALPHA-ELEC...), that’s €17.14/hour, which is over AU$26. So if you consider that to be a “fuel cost” (seems reasonable to me), then your “$3 an hour to run the plane's engine” has multiplied by ten—so much for “one-tenth the cost of a fuel engine”! (Yes, to make the comparison fair we need to factor engine maintenance costs into it, which can reasonably be expected to fall in the electric motor’s favour, but I don’t care to speculate how it may balance out this matter of the battery cost.)
- goodcanadian 9y agoPrice of electricity varies greatly depending on where you are. My residential rate is about $0.13/kWh, so completely consistent with the article.
- chrismorgan 9y agoInteresting. I was going off my experience in Victoria, combined with quick searching for Perth which showed about the same rates, then subtracting the appropriate N% for paying on time (a pricing model that I wish was illegal—expressing it as penalties for overdue payments would make life much easier) which generally gets it down to 20–25¢/kWh. 13¢/kWh is much lower than I’ve ever seen in Australia, not that I’ve looked all over the country.
- aphextron 9y agoThe plane is a Pipistrel Alpha Electro [0]. Designed and built entirely in Slovenia. Kind of a weird/misleading article as it presents the plane as Australian. [0] http://www.pipistrel.si/plane/alpha-electro/overview http://www.pipistrel.si/plane/alpha-electro/overview
- mey 9y agoAdditionally I'm not sure I would call a 2 seater, a "passenger plane".
- badosu 9y agoI wonder if there'd be an increase or loss of carbon footprint compared to gas, when most of electricity produced in Australia is from coal?
- jfoucher 9y agoCoal power plants are roughly as efficient as an internal combustion engine (around 40%) and considering the power transmission losses, charging losses, electric engine inefficiencies and so on, any electric vehicle has worse overall efficiency than the equivalent gas vehicle. Electric vehicles only make sense from a pollution reduction point of view if the power is generated from renewable sources.
- yeukhon 9y agoSecond this. This is a common misconception a lot of consumers do not know.
- olfox 9y agoYou would find it very hard, if not impossible, to run an ICE car at 40% efficient for normal driving. The same can not be said for a coal plant. So if the coal plant averages 35% and the ICE car averages 25%, that leaves some room for a coal-driven electric car to be more efficient. The conversion from grid power to mechanical power only needs to be over 70% efficient. If anything, that sounds easy to beat. Any counters?
- jfoucher 9y agoI we say all three of: charging, motor controller and motor are about 90% efficient, that's already 72% efficiency from grid power to mechanical. So maybe not that easy.
- olfox 9y agoWhile a 90% efficient motor is quite good, a 90% controller and a 90% charger is not. I would expect them to be closer to 95%. But I have to back down from easy, according to [1], some Tesla owners charge their vehicles at 80% efficiency and not the ideal 92-98%. I imagined that would be a problem at those energy levels, apparently not! Anyhow, there is nothing inherently worse about fueling a central ICE to pump out electricity to EVs than directly fueling an ICE car. Larger ICEs tend to be more efficient, especially so for diesels. If you add the savings by the regenerative charging enabled by electric motors, it becomes even more favorable to electrify cars. We need a lot of batteries though! [1] https://forums.tesla.com/forum/forums/charging-efficiency-0 https://forums.tesla.com/forum/forums/charging-efficiency-0
- magicbuzz 9y agoArticle gives you the idea that it would be taking pax to Rottnest Island (a popular tourist destination) but it's only registered as a 'recreational' so the only ppl going to Rottnest would be pilots themselves or a non-paying pax. Payload is 200kg so that is basically two people and one suitcase. 30 minutes reserve might be enough for short hops but I've just finished reading various articles written over the years by Richard Collins (who writes a lot about safety) and he states that he always had a hard rule of a one hour reserve. Still, the operating costs are crazy cheap. If they made a plane that had 3 hours range (2 hrs flying, 1 hr reserve) at 100+ knots with more payload, I'd be interested.
- bobsil1 9y agoTesla is driving (heh) battery energy density up.
- dogma1138 9y agoNot really, also while Tesla does work on batteries it’s more Panasonic which makes he batteries for Tesla, LG chem and the likes that actually work on that.
- bobsil1 9y agoTesla drives down cost via scale, it is driving energy density for downstream segments: EVs, drones, e-planes, et al.
- dogma1138 9y agoIt doesn’t work like that there are more “denser” batteries than what Tesla uses, their density isn’t that impressive while they benefit from it its not something they are driving. P.S. Drones use LiPo batteries.
- bobsil1 9y agoThey're driving down mass-market LiIon specific energy cost ($ per Wh/kg) via Gigafactory. No?
- TillE 9y agoAre there denser ways to store electrical energy? Hydrogen fuel cells maybe? Seems like you need something much lighter than lithium-ion batteries to even begin to fill the role of passenger planes.
- speeq 9y agoHere are some comments from Musk regarding electric aircraft: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yx3auTD85Fw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yx3auTD85Fw
- ratsbane 9y ago"I'd love to do it... but I think my mind would explode."
- kevincox 9y agoHydrogen fuel cells would also make refuelling much faster. In the video they claimed an hour recharge time for the small plane. While you can get more parallelism as you add more batteries it still seems like making it much faster would be beneficial.
- Hasz 9y agoIt seems like battery swapping would be a viable alternative here. The packs are only ~17kWh
- labcomputer 9y agoProbably not as much as you'd think, though. Cars powered by compressed natural gas take longer to fill than gasoline-powered ones[1]. I can't find it right now, but Edmunds did a long-term test of a natural gas Honda Civic. One of the persistent complaints was long fill times at public high-pressure stations. Natural gas has about 4x the energy density of Hydrogen, so the problem becomes even worse.
- seanmcdirmid 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pepijndevos 9y agoFunny remark about it being silent. In the text they mention that it's silent when it's gliding. Well, duh... in the video they say it's just silent. If you look up a video on youtube, you'll hear that the propeller still cause a lot of noise. So it's only more silent from the ground.
- Shivetya 9y agoAn interesting idea, my question is how high can you fly before temperatures lower the efficiency of the batteries? Let us assume a pressurized battery compartment to eliminate the air pressure issues, anyone familiar with the energy costs to keep cargo areas relatively stable? That might be equivalent for a battery compartment.
- mveety 9y agoWell on pressurized aircraft the cargo areas are generally inside the pressure vessel so temperatures will be similar to the passenger areas. Also the batteries will be producing heat when in use, so I would imagine cooling would be a bigger issue, especially when the plane is baking in the sun at the airport for the whole day in the summer.
- totalZero 9y agoI look forward to the day when solar panels are efficient enough that an aircraft can appreciably recharge its batteries while gliding.
- chrismorgan 9y agoI looked for a figure and found this suggestion for sunny days: 800W/m². If the plane uses 20kW while flying, this would mean you’d need 25m² of 100% efficiency solar panels to fly without draining the battery. 10.5m wing span, depth uncertain but looks to be under a metre, and we’re not even halfway there. The fuselage isn’t suitable for a solar array. The tail, maybe a bit. Verdict: ignoring solar panel mass and fragility, you could probably already design something that would get you another five minutes during your hour of powered flight time, but I think you’d have to change things up a lot to increase it much beyond that. I think if you were trying to do such a thing seriously, you’d try to increase wing and body top surface area. Note that the plane can regenerate 2–5kW while gliding, making the propeller act as a windmill. (Source: https://www.avweb.com/videos/Video-Pipistrel-Alpha-Electro-Aero-2015-223855-1.html https://www.avweb.com/videos/Video-Pipistrel-Alpha-Electro-A..., https://www.avweb.com/videos/Video-Flying-Pipistrels-Electric-Airplane-224345-1.html https://www.avweb.com/videos/Video-Flying-Pipistrels-Electri.... Other interesting details in those too.)
- totalZero 9y agoSome numbers from the conventional-engine version: http://pipistrel-usa.com/models/alpha-trainer-tech.html http://pipistrel-usa.com/models/alpha-trainer-tech.html The wing area for this aircraft is 9.29m^2, and the glide ratio is 17:1 at 74mph. Let's say you fly for an hour and then glide through a descent of 12,000 feet (ceiling is 18,000 at max weight). That gives you about 90 minutes of solar absorption time. Assume we only fly at noon on clear sunny days to get 1kW/m^2 of solar energy (nice round number). That's 13.9kWh of incident energy on the wings. If we can capture that at 25% efficiency -- today's best commercial cells are around here, although about twice the efficiency has been achieved by researchers -- it's 10.5 minutes of additional powered flight, or about 3 minutes of climb. (I think that 3 minutes of climb yields an added 3660 ft of altitude or 11 minutes of glide.) 4kW from propeller generation during the glide phase yields another 6 minutes of powered flight. I agree with your conclusion for this particular aircraft's geometry; it's not enough to sustain flight indefinitely. Still, other solar aircraft have demonstrated that sustained solar flight of manned aircraft is possible, and one such aircraft, Solar Impulse 2, has even circumnavigated the globe (albeit interrupted by a few stops along the way).
- kylehotchkiss 9y agoThis is really exciting. I wonder if batteries will ever be able to power a 50 passenger aircraft, without having to extend the wings out too much to fit more batteries/lift for the extra weight. I can't see the 15 hour, 400 passenger flight planes going with batteries in our lifetimes but it's cool to see things starting to go that way.