10 ms·
The best patent ever
- napierzaza 16y agoWhoa, meta. We should do a patent like this every day.
- stcredzero 16y agoIt's patents all the way down.
- DarrenMills 16y agoCan you even patent the process of fighting someone for patent infringement?
- oiuytghyuj 16y agoYes - IBM already did it http://www.geeknewscentral.com/2007/10/22/the-ibm-patent-troll-patent/ http://www.geeknewscentral.com/2007/10/22/the-ibm-patent-tro...
- notmyname 16y agoLooking at the independent claims, it seems like this is a patent on reverse engineering (with a computer!) something, then getting a patent on it, and finally licensing that patent to the owner of the system that was reverse engineered.
- cwp 16y agoI wonder if this could be used as a Gödel patent. If you had a patent on patent trolling, it could be a weapon for patent reform: go around suing patent trolls. Either you win, in which case trolling ceases to be a viable business model, or you lose, setting a precedent for the argument that patents on business methods aren't valid. Either way, you tie up patent trolls in unproductive litigation, force them to argue against the current state of the patent system, and put a spotlight on the ridiculousness of the status quo.
- jacquesm 16y ago> Gödel patent I think you just coined a term.
- SandB0x 16y agoBetter copyright it!
- blahedo 16y agoTrademark, really.
- stretchwithme 16y agoWhy not patent the trademarking of copyrights?
- torial 16y agoI think the problem with that is prior art has already been established :-/
- Vivtek 16y agoI dunno - doesn't prior art have to be published?
- stcredzero 16y agoDo court records count?
- pbhjpbhj 16y agoPrior art has to be extent in the public domain before the priority date. Court records count, they have well established dates which makes them good. Disclosure of an invention in public, outside of the allowed uses in the US, will also invalidate a patent.
- 16y ago
- kljensen 16y agoThat is a patent application. It has not been granted.
- sbov 16y agoHow do you tell from the page if a patent has been granted?
- chc 16y agoA patent application says "patent application." A granted patent says "patent."
- uuoc 16y agoListed midway down the page is a "Serial Number" field. In the case of this application, it is 741429. At the top of the page is a "home" button. Click the home button and then select "Advanced search" underneath "PATFT: Issued Patents". In the "query" box, enter "apn/" and the serial number, i.e., "apn/741429". Click search. Five titles appear, none of which is anything close to this patent, so it looks to not have been granted. If you really want to be sure, go to the main homepage: "www.uspto.gov", and pick "2 search" under "Patents". Then pick "Patent application information retreiveal (PAIR)". Then pick "Public PAIR". Answer the capacha, and then put the series and serial numbers into the lookup box (i.e. 11741429), leaving the radio button set for "application number". Click search. If it had issued, on the next screen under "Patent number" and "Issue Date of Patent" you would find both the number and issue date. In this case, no values, so not issued. If you want to know more you can pick the "Image file wrapper" tab and look through the documents that make up the patent application. This one is still being prosecuted, but has not issued as a patent.
- damncabbage 16y agoNow that's a user-friendly website.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago
- Finster 16y agoBy Halliburton even... LOL
- dctoedt 16y agoFrom the patent application's detailed description: "[0012] The inventor and the assignee of this patent [Halliburton Energy Services, Inc.] have no intention of applying the techniques described herein offensively but instead intend to use the patent defensively to discourage patent trolls and the like from extortionist practices." (Disclosure: The attorney of record is a friend of mine.)
- ultrasaurus 16y agoI'm happy to see the word trolls embedded in a legal document. But the claims remind me why patents tend to be useless to actual innovation "The method of claim 63 where filing the claim with the patent office includes:filing the claim with the United States Patent and Trademark Office. " -- not only is that obvious, but it's repeated several times. (I'm sure these guys write better patents than I do, I just hate the metric that we use for "better")
- jbooth 16y agoWell, if you have years of effort put into something which can be copied easily, as is the case with mechanical inventions, drugs, or cryptography/compression algos (yes I think those actually make sense as patentable), that's one thing. Most software is the opposite -- copying it and applying to your business would often be more effort than inventing your own. So the patent system is exactly backwards for us.
- DennisP 16y agoBruce Schneier has written that patents are useless for cryptography. You can't trust an algorithm until a lot of cryptographers have beaten on it, and they don't bother with patented algorithms. Patenting your algorithm just dooms it to obscurity.
- pbhjpbhj 16y agoLater claims add specifics. The patent office is general and can clearly refer to any patent office (WIPO, EPO one of the OAPI offices, etc.) whilst this claim is specifically for inventions before the USPTO. Why do that? Well if there's prior art that knock out the antecedent claims but doesn't include this specificity then you still get a patent. Also for infringement purposes I think more damages can be extracted for things which are specifically claimed as opposed to generally claimed (depends on jurisdiction). Finally it helps prevent someone else from getting an addon to your invention patented - "our invention is the anti-patent invention but with the innovation of doing this before the USPTO, were awesome like that". I don't see how claim structure like this has any bearing on innovation?
- pierrefar 16y agoLet's not forget the patent application of patent trolling: Generating royalty revenue using intellectual property http://www.freepatentsonline.com/y2006/0200399.html http://www.freepatentsonline.com/y2006/0200399.html
- bugsy 16y agoWow!
- openfly 16y agoThis is bloody brilliant. I mean I know my comment is supposed to be meaningful or something on here. But I'll be damned if I have got to say it. This patent is a total wingasm.
- cadr 16y agoI always thought "Method of exercising a cat" was the best patent ever http://www.wikipatents.com/US-Patent-5443036/method-of-exercising-a-cat/Page-2 http://www.wikipatents.com/US-Patent-5443036/method-of-exerc...
- bitwize 16y agoThe Slashdot joke "I patented the act of patent trolling" ceased to be funny a decade ago. Actually trying it makes it funny again.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Rod 16y agoInterestingly I could not find this patent application at http://www.google.com/patents http://www.google.com/patents
- lizchanning 16y agoThis situation is an example of why the USPTO is swamped. It's not a granted patent -- it's an application; in fact, it's been rejected twice. After each rejection, the attorneys have called and spoken with the examiner, then requested a re-examination. The current state is that the agents are awaiting a response to their last request for re-examination (click Image File Wrapper): http://portal.uspto.gov/external/portal/!ut/p/c5/04_SB8K8xLLM9MSSzPy8xBz9CP0os3h3cz9XEzcPIwMLvyALA08jF39LE2cjQwMLU6B8JG55dxNKdBuYEtAdDnItftvxyYPMB8kb4ACOBvp-Hvm5qfqR-lHmCFPcff3dgKa4ebh5BxgZG7gb6UfmpKYnJlfqF-SGRhhkBmQEOioqAgBVda8T/dl3/d3/L0lJSklna21DU1EhIS9JRGpBQU15QUJFUkNKRXFnLzRGR2dzbzBWdnphOUlBOW9JQSEhLzdfRzdORTRGSDIwR01PRjBJMkZIRktQMjMwRzIvNVpkTkExNzg4MDAzMi9zYS5nZXRCaWI!/ http://portal.uspto.gov/external/portal/!ut/p/c5/04_SB8K8xLL...
- uuoc 16y agoThat is a patent __application__, not a patent. The distinction is quite critical.
- sfall 16y agowhere is the prior artwork?
- mkramlich 16y agosummary: applying for a patent on patents bonus points: assignee is Halliburton