4 ms·
I think a more apt example is this. It's definitely bad to live in a society where violence and robbery are common. We'd rather be without those things. But i
by lordnacho 9y ago
I think a more apt example is this.
It's definitely bad to live in a society where violence and robbery are common. We'd rather be without those things.
But if everyone spends money on bodyguards, that ends up in GDP.
In a comparable society where violence and robbery was not common, you would use the money for other things that are definitely preferred over giving it to bodyguards, security camera shops, locksmiths, and so on.
So measuring GDP in the way we do is defective; it gives near equal figures for both societies when clearly one is better than the other.
- dragonwriter 9y agoEveryone knows GDP (and all other existing economic measures) are imperfect, limited tools that don't capture all meaningful variations. That's not a meaningful criticism of using GDP at all, or of using it as the headline measure of economic performance. To validly criticize using GDP as the headline measure, you need to show not merely that GDP is flawed, but that there is an alternative measure that can be practically calculated that is on-balance better at capturing the overall picture. To validly criticize using GDP at all, you need to go further and make the case that there is no purpose for which there is not a better measure available. “GDP doesn't capture the whole picture” is an easy but meaningless criticism.
- naravara 9y ago>To validly criticize using GDP as the headline measure, you need to show not merely that GDP is flawed, but that there is an alternative measure that can be practically calculated that is on-balance better at capturing the overall picture. Why? Maybe we should be more humble about what metrics can and can’t do for us. Maybe we should admit that many of the things that matter to us are subjective rather than avoiding the difficult questions by fixating only on things that appeal to positivists?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Why? Because if it's the best tool we have for a purpose, then it's the right tool for that purpose even if it's not the platonic ideal of a tool for that purpose. > Maybe we should be more humble about what metrics can and can’t do for us. Not only do I agree with that, I've made the same point elsewhere in this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16082943 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16082943
- kaycebasques 9y agoAre there any GDP alternatives or variations that attempt to give more weight to socially-positive output and less weight to anti-social output?
- ferongr 9y agoWhat is "socially-positive" output and who gets to decide that?
- naravara 9y agoWhatever consensus based decision making body your society uses to engage in collective action.
- emiliobumachar 9y agoWell, that would make it hard to impossible to compare different societies, or the same society at different times. Even if we ignore corruption and bad incentives, values change.
- naravara 9y agoSo change the metrics with them. Cross comparisons are certainly not that valuable if the metric you’re using to compare is motivating people to engage in maladaptive policy.
- mch82 9y agoUmair Haque proposed an option in his HBR essay “Betterness: Economics for Humans.” He uses the analogy that GDP is like the RPM gauge on a car, hard to use without the context of a speedometer. He proposes new measures to supplement GDP and help indicate if real wealth is being created. Not sure how these ideas have developed since 2010. https://www.amazon.com/Betterness-Economics-Humans-Kindle-Single-ebook/dp/B006K5K5GI https://www.amazon.com/Betterness-Economics-Humans-Kindle-Si...
- fjsolwmv 9y agoGDP is an enshrinement of the Broken Windows Fallacy of economics. It completely miscounts externalities as benefits.
- Alex3917 9y agoThis isn't exactly a new idea. This is from the early 90s: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0q-lEATP-9Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0q-lEATP-9Y
- Godel_unicode 9y agoBut why are you hand waving away the compounding GDP value of those other things?? Buying things which allows for employment and investment to invent yet other things is pretty obvious capitalism 101. Safe societies have a value which shows up in GDP long-term, see also spillover benefits.
- coliveira 9y agoThe biggest flaw of GDP is that governments around the world try to maximize it. And, as we see in many cases, making it bigger doesn't necessarily make it better. Take education for example: you can have free schools and free universities for everyone, bringing zero additional GDP. Or you can have for profit schools and universities that will be afforded only by a few, but with big GDP impact. Another clear example is given by the USA: nationalizing health care would be great, but it would also reduce the GDP because of destruction of the for-profit industry. In this case, however, lower GDP could bring better health outcomes for most people in the country.