8 ms·
Highlights: > 1. In terms of total returns, residential real estate and equities have shown very similar and high real total gains, on average about 7% per yea
by crazygringo 9y ago
Highlights:
> 1. In terms of total returns, residential real estate and equities have shown very similar and high real total gains, on average about 7% per year. ... The observation that housing returns are similar to equity returns, yet considerably less volatile, is puzzling.
> 2. We find that the real safe asset return has been very volatile over the long-run, more so than one might expect, and oftentimes even more volatile than real
risky returns.
> 3. ...our data uncover substantial swings in the risk premium at lower frequencies that sometimes endured for decades, and which far exceed the amplitudes of business-cycle swings.
> 4. Comparing returns to growth, or “r minus g” in Piketty’s notation, we uncover a striking finding. Even
calculated from more granular asset price returns data, the same fact reported in Piketty (2014) holds true for more countries and more years, and more dramatically: namely “r >> g.” ...globally, and across most countries, the weighted rate of return on capital was twice as high as the growth rate in the past 150 years.
- capisce 9y agoSome more highlights: > In terms of total returns, residential real estate and equities have shown very similar and high real total gains, on average about 7% per year. > The data summary in Table 3 and Figure 2 show that residential real estate, not equity, has been the best long-run investment over the course of modern history. > Although returns on housing and equities are similar, the volatility of housing returns is substantially lower, as Table 3 shows. Returns on the two asset classes are in the same ballpark— around 7%—but the standard deviation of housing returns is substantially smaller than that of equities (10% for housing versus 22% for equities). > Predictably, with thinner tails, the compounded return (using the geometric average) is vastly better for housing than for equities—6.6% for housing versus 4.6% for equities. This finding appears to contradict one of the basic assumptions of modern valuation models: higher risks should come with higher rewards. Seems the way the real estate market works has caused a big drain both on economic growth (as investments have gone into real estate rather than more productive products), and on economic equality. So a Georgist land value tax does seem like a pretty good idea.
- ttul 9y agoReal estate returns have been juiced by government policies for decades. The interest deduction, government backing of mortgages, and implicit guarantees of mortgage backed securities. Aka the cost of buying a house to the consumer is lower than it should be on a risk adjusted basis.
- cryptonector 9y agoThe cost to the consumer of buying a house is probably higher than it would be without these incentives, actually, because it ends up causing more money to spill into real estate. It's the same with college costs: every additional dollar of federally subsidized loans made available to the public adds a dollar to the cost of college, almost necessarily so.
- zimablue 9y agoYou've mixed up two things here I think. Returns vs Cost of buying a house. The point is that the government subsidies make the profits on buying real estate high, which leads to high prices. So both are true: "high cost of buying a house" "high returns on real estate" Obviously they can't be true forever, the upper limit I guess is the ability of the lower classes to rebel divided by their tolerance of being priced out of their own land.
- cryptonector 9y agoI was... responding the last sentence of the parent. All economics and human societies, really, are bubbles. Very, very long-lived bubbles. Obviously growth on Earth is ultimately limited, so yeah, these very long-lived bubbles cannot go on forever. The real trick is to predict when any one bubble will burst!
- kbutler 9y agoThe grandparent was describing the long-term vs short-term effect of broad subsidies. The short-term effect of a subsidy is a reduced cost to the consumer. If subsidies are generally and persistently available, this reduced perceived cost increases demand, causing increased prices. The ratio of price increase to amount of subsidy (and thus whether the consumer or producer benefits from the subsidy) will depend breadth of the subsidy and on elasticity curves of supply and demand. Then there's the increased demand because the subsidy increases ROI. further increasing prices of the fixed input (land/existing housing) to the good (living space).
- OscarCunningham 9y agoDoes 4 mean that the stock market is become larger and larger relative to GDP? That seems unusual. Can the ratio get arbitrarily large, or will it have to level off?
- crazygringo 9y agoYes, essentially -- this is a central idea of growing societal inequality, that economic growth gains are accruing much more to the rich (who own stocks and real estate) than to the working class (real wages not increasing). Whether the ratio is now unusual, or how large it will get, is a subject of intense speculation with many real-world consequences for society, and especially to what extent law and government policies are responsible for it or can mitigate it (e.g. capital gains tax vs income tax).
- valuearb 9y agoWhat do you think pensions, IRAs and 401Ks are invested in?
- stevenwoo 9y agoYou have a point but this is mitigated by the fact that most Americans have very little saved for retirement, just eyeballing the numbers it appears a tiny percentage of people are able to put away a substantial amount for retirement. http://time.com/money/4258451/retirement-savings-survey/ http://time.com/money/4258451/retirement-savings-survey/
- valuearb 9y agoThis article is very poorly written. First, how much you have saved should be directly related to your age, and they only touch on that in the second half of the article and only in way too big groups, ie not in any precise way. Secondly, they don’t differentiate between married and unmarried. Two married 55 year olds with $300k each in 401ks are in better shape than individuals. As is someone with zero saved married to someone with $1M saved. Also, they don’t include pensions and other defined benefit plans. That’s s substantial difference. If you are a school teacher two years away from getting $50k a year at retirement, you might not feel sane urgency to save. and most importantly it ignores home equity. Paying off your home creates huge savings. I have a friend who paid off his $800k home by age 50, he would have answered that he has near zero retirement savings. He retired at 60 and built a million dollar home, no mortgage. Lots of people pay off homes by early retirement. Finally, social security iften undercuts both the perceived need for big savings, and the means to do so. I’m paying in $9,000 per year right now, if i wasn’t i’d certainly contribute more to my 401k.
- justin66 9y agoI can't load the pdf but I'm surprised by the notion that real estate and equities have provided the same return over time. It's not what the Case-Shiller indices have shown.
- pascalxus 9y agoi assume that they must be treating housing strictly as an investment, ie renting it out. In that case it sounds almost plausible: you get about 4.5% return in rent per year, plus an inflation matched housing value increase of roughly 2.5%, which gives you about 7% which matches the stock market.
- vasilipupkin 9y agoexcept, you don't get 4.5% return in rent per year, due to depreciation
- FabHK 9y agoThe analysis is explicitly in terms of total returns, ie returns from change in price and from intermediate cashflows (dividends, rental income). Edit to add: Total return = capital gain + yield
- FabHK 9y agoI'm wondering what a realistic total real return is for purposes of investment/retirement planning. Seems to me that 7% is too aggressive, and one should work with about 4-5% or even less (given slower demographic and productivity growth).