9 ms·
I was given new hands for Christmas
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoI guess it's not really the point, but I'm intrigued to know how a lawyer can spend $260,000 on a gift for someone they don't know. This also reminds me of reading a story about the olympics style event organised for disabled veterans. The article included a conversation between an Afghani amputee and a british counterpart: " One day at the games, Azimi, whose lost hand was replaced by a 25-year-old hook, saw a British athlete with a prosthetic leg and asked him what it cost. The British athlete didn’t know. “You have that leg and you don’t know how much that costs?” Azimi asked him. “Maybe $50,000 or $60,000,’’ the British athlete responded. “Our government pays for that.” Asked about the disparity between the first- and third-world teams, U.S. team captain, retired Army Capt. Will Reynolds, said he was appalled. “I’ve got eight (artificial) legs — more than I need,” said Reynolds, a leg amputee who was enjoying a moment’s rest with his son watching the U.S. team practice wheelchair volleyball, after winning medals in cycling, track and field. “Some of the legs I can’t even wear. And to know there are other servicemembers out there wearing stuff that’s not serviceable is unacceptable.” https://www.stripes.com/news/no-coach-training-or-prosthetics-for-afghan-team-at-invictus-games-1.409471 https://www.stripes.com/news/no-coach-training-or-prosthetic...
- ataturk 9y agoYou don't realize how much (some) lawyers make, I guess. There was a guy in TX who threw his daughter a $6M wedding. I bet he could pick up the tab and just not buy another Aventador or forego some other idiotic luxury. The issue of the 1% or better the .01% outrunning everyone else is very real. Glad she got her hands.
- BonesJustice 9y agoThe attorney, Mark Holden, is apparently Chief Legal Officer for Koch Industries, so I'd imagine he's quite well compensated. That doesn't diminish the generosity of the gift, mind you, but it's not as if he was a solo tax attorney or something.
- pnutjam 9y agoI'd be surprised if he paid the rack rate either, but that does not diminish the generosity of his gift. This is how all people should act. Making the world better one stop at a time.
- asdjasldkjkljd 9y agoKind of bullshit if he was able to circumvent a "rack rate" and someone without hands wasn't.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoI think it goes beyond generosity. I think it's natural for people to care about what happens to each other, even between strangers. And it's just as natural to want to do something about it. The story you quote exemplifies this- it's only uman for the US team captain to be upset in the situation. The reason why these natural tendencies to stand by each other are being eroded left and right in western societies, is probably too big a conversation for now, but my concern with that is what moved me to post this. So, you know, I apologise for a bit of subtle socialist propaganda :)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 9y agoAnd for very poor people there is the soda bottle prosthetic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yvev6shNvSg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yvev6shNvSg https://makezine.com/2009/02/05/plastic-soda-bottle-prosthesis/ https://makezine.com/2009/02/05/plastic-soda-bottle-prosthes...
- RickJWagner 9y agoAmazing generosity, and an incredible story.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoSee, if socialism was more accepted in the US, anyone could get new hands. Even the veterans who lost limbs and sanity who everyone loves and respects but nobody wants to give money to because that'd be socialism.
- vinceguidry 9y agoOne could argue that in a socialist regime, companies such as the one that made her hands couldn't exist. This is a great, heartwarming human interest story, and should drive a lot of attention for the company, but getting insurance companies to actually do their jobs should be the public interest driver here.
- teekert 9y agoYou may call it socialism, you could also call it capitalism without cancer (like lobbying).
- simion314 9y agoIn a pure capitalistic model I only can see how things would converge to the maximum profit possible and not to the best for society possible, you need some lay that considers the people and not the money. Why is paying x% tax to go to the health budget such a controversial thing?you still have private hospital and doctors that compete with public ones and you still have a choice, the only issue I see doing this requieres some solidarity and maybe this sentiment is missing in a diverse country like US.
- teekert 9y agoI consider a free market and personal freedom very important. I also prefer not to see lepers in the streets, nor do I prefer to see people with cancer suffer more because they can't pay for treatment. I also like to see the streets safe and well maintained. Finally, I like to live in a society where every kid can go to every school/university. For all this I gladly pay taxes, so I vote for a government that aligns with my world view. Am I a socialist for wanting this? I don't think so. I feel the market should be free and hardly regulated. Tax systems should be simple and fair, without loop holes for the super rich. I think banks should die if they take too much risk (and not be kept alive by the people in some strange overly socialistic way). I think the power should be with the people and not with corporations (which means with wealthy people). I'm a capitalist but I'd like to rid it of the cancer it has been growing lately.
- intralizee 9y agoAs a transwoman I haven't been able to afford any surgery. I'm hopeful that eventually society realizes luxury & cosmetic are just added terms to discriminate against people suffering.
- jacquesm 9y agoThere is a bit of a difference between being transsexual and having your limbs amputated as the result of an armed robbery.
- thinkpad20 9y agoShe never claimed that they were equivalent. The disparity in quality of health care for transgender people in this country is well-documented and stems from many of the same reasons as the situation described in this article.
- vinceguidry 9y agoThe problem with that logic is where does it end? Should anyone who wants anything from anyone be able to claim it?
- fzeroracer 9y agoThe same could be said of any medical treatment. I've known people that believe drug addicts deserve zero treatment because it's all their fault. Same with people that did something stupid and got severely injured. 'Where does it end' isn't much of an argument. Instead we should be asking how should we determine where the line is and I believe the answer is simple: If it can be determined that it would result in a significant QoL increase then it should be covered in most cases. A transgender person receiving hormone therapy or reassignment therapy is an example. A victim who lost their nose in an accident and wants to mend their face is another.
- vinceguidry 9y ago> If it can be determined that it would result in a significant QoL increase then it should be covered in most cases. I don't argue that there shouldn't be a line. It's just a very fine one with lots of edge cases.
- epicide 9y agoOver the next few weeks, I watched my hands turn black and shrivel up. As a software developer and musician, but especially as a human, this is my nightmare.
- Something1234 9y agoThis should the worst nightmare of any human. It completely removes any ability to be a productive member of society with the loss of both hands. It ruins them and just completely removes any possibility of a good quality of life without a prosthesis.
- sushisource 9y agoIt is totally awful, but I wouldn't say you can't be productive. Speech-to-text is good enough now that you could substitute it for typing. It won't be as fast, obviously, but that's not an insurmountable obstacle.
- jdtang13 9y agoThis is not true at all. This is just a pessimistic exaggeration.
- Something1234 9y agoI don't think it's overly pessimistic. How about you try to open a doorknob with your fingers taped together.
- epicide 9y agoHe didn't say it was easy. He said it's overly pessimistic. I would tend to agree that "It completely removes any ability to be a productive member of society" is not only quite a stretch, but pretty insulting.
- erroneousfunk 9y agoI think it's incredible that her health insurance didn't cover electronic prosthetics. The hook prosthetic is just a simple open/close grabber tool. Imagine trying to navigate through life with two grabbers. The modern myoelectric prosthetics offer way more functionality and freedom. You can use a computer, dress yourself, drive a car, and feed yourself (of course the author can't do all these yet, it does take time to learn). You can't do this at all with hooks. I fractured/dislocated multiple wrist bones two years ago and it wasn't life threatening but I would have had diminished functionality without surgery -- insurance covered it no problem. My hand is great. How the hell does it make sense to fix a wrist in order to allow someone to do the activities of daily living but it doesn't make sense to give them a common commercial prosthetic in order to do the same thing?
- TheBeardKing 9y agoThis is why the entire health insurance market doesn't make sense. Right now, as a healthy person, how am I supposed to weigh the impact of every potential health issue in my life? I'm sure she could've purchased some cadillac plan to cover it, but without experiencing that and with such a minute chance of an accident like that occurring as a teacher of all things, why should she ever buy it? Or even know to look for that kind of coverage? Who can price the repercussions of going without some medical procedure or medicine without ever having experienced that situation? I can understand car, boat, our house insurance and can easily replace those tangible items, but how should I price the risk to my health?
- adventured 9y agoHealthcare is heavily rationed in socialized medicine systems. That's why wait times are so extreme in Canada, and doubled from ~1990 to 2015. Rationing is the same exact thing as what you're talking about. They're choosing who gets what medical access and when. If you're 92 years old and you want an extremely expensive surgery or treatment in Canada, and it's only going to prolong your life by 18 months, you are not going to get that treatment, period. The same applies in France and Britain. Rationing is a required tenet of socialized healthcare. I'm not saying all rationing is bad, however pretending that under socialized healthcare it's just a free-for-all, is flat out wrong. A very recent example of the rationing squeeze: "N.H.S. Overwhelmed in Britain, Leaving Patients to Wait" "Cuts to the National Health Service budget in Britain have left hospitals stretched over the winter for years, but this time a flu outbreak, colder weather and high levels of respiratory illnesses have put the N.H.S. under the highest strain in decades. The situation has become so dire that the head of the health service is warning that the system is overwhelmed." "Some doctors took to Twitter to vent their frustrations publicly. One complained of having to practice “battlefield medicine,” while another apologized for the “3rd world conditions” caused by overcrowding." https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/03/world/europe/uk-national-health-service.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/03/world/europe/uk-national-...
- emilfihlman 9y agoAnyone know what was the reason her hands died? Inadequate oxygen supply? Couldn't they have just oxygenated her blood in the hands?
- logfromblammo 9y agoIt wasn't necessarily inadequate as much as it was inconstant. There was a dip due to the lung damage, but then there was reperfusion afterward as a result of medical treatment. Sometimes, when tissues are deprived of oxygen, they undergo apoptosis when the oxygen is restored, not when they are deprived. This is why people who undergo heart attacks are sometimes rapidly chilled to core hypothermia. The cold discourages their tissues from committing suicide when their power comes back on. Her extremities might have been saved by putting them in ice baths, but it is very unlikely her physicians would have been aware of the potential problem and quick enough to respond appropriately. Their primary concern was likely maintaining sufficient oxygen to her brain and vital organs.
- pavement 9y agoOkay, time to add another entry to the list of terrifying trauma complications. Adding it to the subgroup that includes compartment syndrome. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compartment_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compartment_syndrome
- tptacek 9y agoUnpleasant as this is, it's worth pointing out that the superlawyer who bought the hands for her, Mark Holden, is almost certainly the same Mark Holden who sits on the board of directors for Americans For Prosperity and runs the public sector legal division for Koch Industries. It's generous indeed for him to spend $200,000 on prosthetics for a stranger, but this story would be more heartwarming if he wasn't at the same time working to strip millions of people of their health insurance, which is what AFP is zealously trying to do.
- abtinf 9y agoIn addition to down-voting your comment, I've taken the unusual (for me) step of flagging it for the following reasons: off-topic, flamebait, and introducing politics into a non-political story.
- ohazi 9y agoExcuse me, but this story was political from the very beginning. She was shot multiple times by a petty criminal wielding a firearm. As angry as one might get at the insurance company, it's even more infuriating that this is still a passably common occurrence in the US. This shouldn't have happened in the first place, and the reason it did is entirely political.
- tptacek 9y agoAs is your right. But note that a pretty straightforward reading of this story says that it is political, and, at any rate, it's not entirely clear what it's relevance to HN is, so you might want to flag the entire story as well. That's what I did.
- nawgszy 9y agoI have no such privileges but I fail to see why you would use them here. Off-topic, yet directly tied into a main player in the article? Flame-bait, because it calls into attention the fact that this feel-good piece is easily seen as applauding a man who deserves no such graces? Introducing politics into a non-political story, even though a main actor in it is part of an unscrupulous political machine which shouldn't be ignored? Questionable decisions by you, in my opinion.
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoI've always been quite fascinated by prosthetics and cybernetics. I would be willing to trade most of my biological body parts that have limited lifespans for self-healing synthetic replacements.
- Jemmeh 9y agoThe unfortunate thing is currently prosthetics are much less nimble than real hands. I'd want to see a lot of improvements in that tech before I'd see them as a replacement. In the article she mentions she's had them for a year and is still learning to use them and struggles to do some things.
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoAbsolutely. I’d reckon you can do a lot of gross motor skills with existing prosthetic, but fine motor skills are a long ways off. I haven’t been keeping up with self-healing materials either, but I am certain they are also in a nascent state.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoIt should be noted that we are still a very long way from creating a useful replacement for our olfactory system, our digestive system, our circulatory system and our reproductive system, among other things that make life worth living.