13 ms·
Christopher Nolan: The power of people and why 2001 should be preschool viewing
- nabla9 9y agoThe inability of adults to get totally absorbed into experiencing a movie (or a book) is a clear obstacle of enjoying the experience. Allowing the experience to wash over you without analyzing it while experiencing gets harder. Getting 3d or perfect reality virtual reality hardware is not going to fix that. If you can do it as an adult, 2001 is great and Inland Empire from David Lynch is amazing. Inland Empire speaks directly to the unconsciousness and goes past of any explanation. You walk out from the theater wondering what happened. It's like you have been injected with something. The experience that lingers has no explanation.
- elcapitan 9y agoI don't think adults have an inability to get absorbed that way; I think they still get that when they watch more "traditional" blockbuster movies. The problem is this mental division between what is perceived as commercial and fun, and what has to be seen as art. Basically, once people realize that something is very different from the baseline of normal movies, they will start to get into art+interpretation mode and spoil the pure experience. Christopher Nolan is probably one of the people who really manage in all their movies to keep the balance between those two worlds.
- saiya-jin 9y agoI agree - we went with fiancee to watch latest Star Wars few weeks ago. I don't recall the last time I enjoyed a movie in cinema so much, was drawn into the story 100% of the time, not a single blip that would distract & make me come back from being right there in the story. It didn't happen with any previous SW movies, in fact maybe this was unique experience. For both of us. I didn't question logic of anything (which I usually do), everything just clicked and hummed along the story. When I checked IMDB, I couldn't wrap my head around why it's rated so low and first 50-100 user reviews gave it either 1/10 or 2/10 and kept repeating how disappointing it is and how it is a worst movie in cinema history. Didn't bother to check their arguments, I enjoyed it profoundly and I still smile when remembering those moments. Maybe I was in right mental setup for it, but that would be valid for both of us symmetrically. In fact, as writing this, I recall once I watched Apocalypse Now, and somehow, for some reason, it felt very similar. I saw it before, and I saw it after this, but it was never so intense, so 'right'
- baud147258 9y agoI never though about it, but thinking about the last movies I've watcher, I agree that the mental setup/mood at the time can have a great influence on how much I'd be drawn into a movie.
- thorin 9y agoI love 2001, but Inland Empire was almost too much for me, I'm pleased I went to see it though. From Lynch watching Eraserhead or Mulholland Drive (heavily influenced by Ingmar Bergman's Persona) were much more pleasurable. After leaving an afternoon screening of 2001 directors cut I felt like I'd been taking acid. I really respect Nolan as one of the best modern filmmakers, creating blockbusters with integrity is a big ask.
- amasad 9y agoI haven't seen Inland Empire yet. I discovered David Lynch in the last 5 years and it's taking me a lot of time to get through his movies because it takes a whole lot of processing to really understand every one of them. It creeps into your psyche and sometimes your dreams. And for me it takes time to muster up the energy to put myself through another one of those experiences. Eraserhead was a trip, I still haven't totally figured it out. But in terms of pure cinematic enjoyment Blue Velvet would be my favorite. Now that I hear other Lynch fans talk about Inland Empire I'm really excited to watch it.
- arethuza 9y agoI find Frank Booth utterly terrifying - I think he reminds me of some unpleasant characters from the high school I went to.... :-)
- thorin 9y agoI wouldn't try to understand them completely, he is an artist and transcendental meditator. Try to appreciate them as painting not as a narrative and I think you'll enjoy them even more. Inland Empire is really a fan film in my opinion and should/can only really be watched which an existing knowledge of his background works.
- ajmurmann 9y agoI believe to have read Lynch himself say that Inland Empire doesn't have a deeper interpretation that makes sense. As far as I remember it's even largely made up of footage from other projects.
- vlozko 9y agoI think the inability largely stems from the manner in which we consume our content nowadays. How many movies or TV shows have you watched recently on Netflix using your laptop from your bed lately? Nolan has always been a big proponent of the movie theater experience. So much so he was against the idea of having a ~$50 monthly pass the allowed you to watch in-theater movies at home.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoOverconsumption is the one issue, distractions from phones and such another, and IMO so is advertising, which over here would cause a break from immersion every half an hour or so, and in the US every ten minutes. Can't watch a movie like that. With that in mind, the Netflix binge is a good example of how immersion is still very much a thing.
- emodendroket 9y agoI can't think of a more disagreeable way to watch something. Not one time. I do read in bed though.
- bedane 9y agoNo idea about virtual reality hardware, but some chemicals will definitely help a lot
- andyjohnson0 9y ago> Allowing the experience to wash over you without analyzing it while experiencing gets harder. I agree, and I didn't realise the extent to which this was happening with me until a few years ago, when one of my children got interested in performance magic. Because he was young, I went to various magic conventions and meetings with him, and listened to a lot of people talking about the practice of magic as well as its technical aspect. Turns out, a big preoccupation of magicians is how hard it is to get people to just watch the magic without them being distracted by trying to figure-out how its done. If anything, its harder for magicians than film directors because what they do clearly does merit disbelief. Anyway, I learned that it really is ok to just watch a difficult film and experience the feelings that it produces without picking them apart. As an analytical person this was both a relief and a learning experience for me. (Also, 2001 is an excellent film.)
- RHSeeger 9y agoI had that problem with magic a long time ago, when I learned a fair amount about it (a friend of mine is a magician and I learned while he did, though only casually). I had to retrain myself to watch a performance with the intent to just enjoy it rather than try to figure it out as it happened. Ignoring the how and just enjoying the what makes it a lot more fun.
- maroonblazer 9y ago"Upstream Color"[0] by Shane Carruth, the writer and director of "Primer"[1] is another example of this kind of filmmaking. He aspired to create a film that you could watch in the same way one listens to albums/CDs over and over again and discover something new with each listen.[2] [0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5U9KmAlrEXU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5U9KmAlrEXU [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3nj5MMURCm8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3nj5MMURCm8 [2]http://www.indiewire.com/2013/04/interview-shane-carruth-talks-trying-to-make-the-perfect-album-film-with-upstream-color-99842/ http://www.indiewire.com/2013/04/interview-shane-carruth-tal...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tootie 9y agoI've seen 2001 at least 10 times in my life and I love it to death, but I got to see it in the theater once and it was like I'd never really experienced it at all before. You can't appreciate the incredible sound design until it's absolutely filling the air around you. Not just the music, but the klaxons and the moments of dead silence.
- teh_klev 9y agoI've seen it in the cinema a couple of times over the years, and you're right, it's a truly amazing thing to experience; previously I'd only watched on VHS or on the BBC. It wasn't until the blu-ray release came out that I felt the same experience and immersion in the film as I did with viewing in a theatre.
- badwolf 9y agoDefinitely agree. I got to see 2001 in the theater on 70mm film. It was simply beautiful. Deafeningly loud, eerily silent, and brightly beautiful.
- icebraining 9y agoYeap. Never had the chance to see 2001 in a theater, but I've watched Apocalypse Now after having seen it on a TV, and it was a whole new experience. The helicopters scene was overwhelming.
- arethuza 9y agoI saw Apocalypse Now in our high school film club when I was 16 in 1981/82 - was completely blown away by the introduction.
- pwthornton 9y agoI wonder how much of this is because we are increasingly watching movies at home or on portable devices with lots of distractions around us? I've seen 2001 in 70mm a few times in recent years in a nice theater (and I'll see it again when it comes back), and it's very engrossing in a dark theater with no technology. You can let the entire film and all of its implications just wash over you. You can't get up, nor can you check your phone. You have nothing else to do other than just be in the moment. This is harder to do at home. People should see more seminal movies in theaters, and I wish more theaters showed them. I live by American Film Institute's theater in the DC area, which is how I am able to see all of this stuff, but many other people do not. I think it's a big miss that more theaters don't show older movies year around.
- NoGravitas 9y agoMy local art house showed the 4K restoration of Night of the Living Dead just before Halloween. It was a really fantastic experience, and I think you're right that more theaters should do this.
- mattbierner 9y agoFor what it’s worth, the first time I watched 2001 it was on a 3.5 inch phone screen. Still blew me away
- npsimons 9y ago> Allowing the experience to wash over you without analyzing it while experiencing gets harder. "It's not over-analysis when every stray thought about the film has to be quashed lest you realize how stupid the movie is." -- Howard Tayler
- vanderZwan 9y ago> It’s become very fashionable in the last couple of decades to forget what good government can do, what good union organizing can do. The idea that benevolent capitalists will just take care of us and the people on top will magically distribute wealth and happiness and security to us little people … no. It’s time we wised up. Strength comes from community in all things. Dunkirk is one of those stories. This reminds me of something that Hany Abu-Assad, a Dutch-Palestinian film director[0], once said in an interview. He was asked how it is possible that from countries like Iran, with its oppressive regime, we get such amazing directors as Abbas Kiarostami, who created beautiful humanising movies. After a brief moment of contemplation, Abu-Assad answered "society is stronger than the system." > Would you say “Dunkirk” is your most hopeful film? > Well … yeah. “Interstellar” is pretty hopeful. But then again, the whole world has ended. There is that. [Laughs] Funny how one can interpret that both as "doesn't sound very hopeful to me", and "the more impossible the odds are that were overcome, the more hopeful the message inherently is". WARNING: INTERSTELLAR ENDING SPOILER BELOW What makes Interstellar especially tricky here is that on the one hand, saving humanity (and presumably as much other life as possible) from extinction when the entire planet is dying is about as big a challenge as it gets, and therefore makes the film feel very hopeful, but on the other hand the ending also implies that the universe is predeterministic, and that can be viewed as the opposite of hopeful. [0] http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0009463/?ref_=tt_ov_dr http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0009463/?ref_=tt_ov_dr
- amasad 9y agoHow does the ending imply that the universe is predetermined? I might've missed that. (It's also not surprising if it did because it's modern scientific dogma that the world is deterministic. Even if you take into account quantum uncertainty, as Hawking points out, it is determined probabilities. ).
- Cthulhu_ 9y ago(moar Interstellar spoilers) Well in the end of the movie it turns out that the future humans built the tesseract (I believe it's called) and the wormhole, leading the humans to survive and in the future built the tesseract and the wormhole, leading the humans to survive and in the future built the tesseract and the wormhole... you get the idea. It's a time travel movie, and the whole thing becomes a paradox - if the humans didn't survive they wouldn't have developed to be able to make wormholes and time travel magic, but they did survive because of time travel magic. So which came first? It's a paradox. One explanation is that there was nothing that actually came first but everything just happened as it should and there was no other way it could've happened, thus, predetermination. But yeah, time travel paradoxes, fun stuff.
- pvsukale3 9y agoChristopher Nolan is the Elon Musk of hollywood except he completes his projects in time.
- brynjolf 9y agoWow what an insult to Nolan. Why would you hate on him like that?
- touristtam 9y agoHow do you infer insult from this remark?
- misnome 9y agoI suspect it depends on whether you view Musk as an unparalleled world-changing genius, just a good businessman with an instinct for good fields to invest combined with a talent for hiring the right smart people, or an overhyped hack who got lucky (anecdotally my personal feeling is that most people on HN seem to fall into these categories with ratio 5:1:3) Either of the last two could conceivably be considered an insult given the difference in jobs, and creativity and control inherent in the task of directing.
- JohnBooty 9y ago2001 is the most polarizing movie I've ever experienced. People either absolutely love it or hate it. Except my wife. My wife may be the only human being on Earth to not feel one way or the other about it. (I absolutely love the movie, but I'm not going to argue with you if you find it a bore. I totally get why some would feel that way)
- pjc50 9y agoIt's visually beautiful, ahead of its time, but the pacing makes it extremely hard to watch today.
- auggierose 9y agoI guess we have a different understanding of what "extremely hard" means.
- foobarian 9y agoThe pacing made it extremely hard to watch for me back in the day when it came out as well ;-)
- kbouck 9y agoI feel the pacing, particularly in the HAL scene with long pauses between words, dramatically builds up the suspense.
- mmjaa 9y agoI agree with you, but then I think the same can be said of movies such as "Close Encounters of the Third Kind", wherein the pacing was awesome back in the day, when you had to actually be somewhere to watch a movie, but now when everyone can stream to their own private space, 'tis a bigger challenge. I watch a lot of 70's movies with this slow, boring pace ..
- dragonwriter 9y agoThat's probably not primarily a factor of needing to be somewhere to watch a movie as much as it's a factor of changing expectations set by other media: the effect was frequently commented on as early as the 1980s, and widely attributed to, among other media factors, the impact of MTV and music videos.
- RobertRoberts 9y agoI loved movies as a kid and I felt 2001 was such a classic I made my family watch 2001 last year. (every kid should know what "Dave" refers to in a calm computer voice) Here's the comment's I got. "There sure is a lot of music" "This looks like a computer game" "Those are aliens!" (a blip of crystals in the sky during the transition for Dave, little genius) "They were happy about making tons of colors instead of a movie" "They sure like red and green" "Creepiest movie we've ever seen. It was boring, boring, boring, then scary." "I should have known as soon as the monkeys, stupid, stupid." (from patient wife) (I wrote all these down right after the movie)
- brazzledazzle 9y agoWhenever I get this reaction from my kids about something classic I feel indignant but most of all I feel old. Changing tastes in pop, trends and fashion can do that but the rejection of highly regarded things hurts the most.
- emodendroket 9y agoI'm 29 and loved 2001, for what it's worth. It's not really just age, I don't think. I remember showing college friends Hard-Boiled (the John Woo film starring Chow Yun Fat) and they all got bored and stopped watching. Meanwhile I'm wondering how anyone could find a scene where there's a shootout involving guys on motorcycles with machine guns not to be simulating enough. I guess the mind of the cineaste works differently. On the other hand, I watched High Sierra recently and the pre-Bullit notion of a car chase scene was, uh, less than thrilling.
- ryandrake 9y agoUgh, I hear you. That B-word is what really grinds my gears, and frankly makes me a little frightened at how society's tastes are seemingly permanently changing. Anything that doesn't have continuous in-your-face stimulation nowadays is boring. Nobody can tolerate a movie anymore if it has any "slow" parts. Everything has to be a Vin Diesel explosion-fest. Nobody can sit through a full 60-70 minute CD unless every song is 130BPM+ and full volume. Nobody but me even buys full albums anymore really, it's just 2 minute blips on iTunes. My own 5 year old daughter can't even make it through any of the old Disney movies that are specifically made for kids because as soon as the action slows down and the characters start talking, her mind wanders off and she wants to go do something else. We've lost the concept of sitting down for the sole purpose of enjoying a single work that is more complex than a 3 minute YouTube clip.
- pjc50 9y agoInteresting on Dunkirk; I was skeptical of why someone would make a war film in the present day, but it sounds like his intention in expressing what it means to people is good. On this subject previously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15004843 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15004843 , me Britsplaining the meaning of Dunkirk.
- arethuza 9y ago"I understand you showed “2001” to your children when they were very young, like 3 or 4?" That makes me feel better about my son seeing "Return of the King" 6 times in the cinema when he was 5. Mind you - he does now want to become a movie director... :-)
- matthew349hall 9y ago6 times!? I mean it's such a good film but it's like 3 hours long!!
- gallerdude 9y agoI think Christopher Nolan is the best all-around modern director. His movies are huge critical hits: most of them are in the IMDb Top 250 (most directors would be happy to have one film up there). His films are also huge box-office hits, which means that the audience, not just movie nerds, like his movies. I think the distribution for films is bimodal, one huge peak for box-office/mass-appeal hits, and another smaller peak for critical hits/film-nerd-appeal hits. Nolan would be right in the center between these two distributions: he pushes cinema forward while keeping it accessible to all.
- tootie 9y agoPeople keep saying Hollywood is dead and they don't make movies like they used to and I think the exact opposite is true. The median level of quality of Hollywood films is absolutely better than ever and the number of masterpieces per year seems to keep increasing to the point that I can't keep up.
- unfamiliar 9y agoWhat were the "masterpieces" this year (2017)?
- gallerdude 9y ago* Dunkirk * Baby Driver * Lady Bird * Blade Runner 2049 * Logan * The Disaster Artist * The Beguiled * ...
- icebraining 9y agoIMDB isn't really a good meter of critical opinion, its score is based on the opinion of its users. Rotten Tomatoes is the one that aggregates opinions of the critics. That said, his movies usually get 80%+, which is pretty good.
- forgot-my-pw 9y agoRotten tomatoes just aggregates how likeable a movie is. A more accurate aggregate scoring system will be like metacritic.
- debacle 9y agoMany people can't handle the pacing of older sci-fi movies. I remember watching the Andromeda Strain with my wife when we were teenagers. She said it was the most boring movie she had ever seen.
- ajmurmann 9y agoThat is completely true and at the same time terrifying. What does that say about how our brains have changed? Maybe it's not a problem, but if it is a problem I'm afraid it might be a big one.
- debacle 9y agoI think it's a conditioning thing. I don't like some modern movies because it seems like every scene is meant to be a money shot. You have to build atmosphere to tell a story.
- DerfNet 9y agoI enjoy a slow burn, but 2001 for preschoolers? Might work for nap time I guess.
- ctchocula 9y agoI watched Tarkovsky's Solaris a few weeks ago. The pacing is very slow, but the long silences are calming like reading and evokes a certain mood. It's a nice change from non-stop action Youtube clips and Twitch streams.
- indubitable 9y ago> That’s outstanding. And that’s the thing. It’s become very fashionable in the last couple of decades to forget what good government can do, what good union organizing can do. In my opinion this is missing the problem. Government, in a democracy, is decided by the masses. I think people, as individuals, are generally quite intelligent. But I also think people, as groups, are quite stupid. Mob mentality is very much a real phenomena and it's something we've not come even remotely close to growing out of. Similarly for tribalism. In the instance he's referring to (film critics associations boycotted Disney after Disney blacklisted writers from an influential publication, leading Disney to rescind the blacklisting) you had a very small and very well informed demographic working together. That has very little to do with the democratic process. Most people do not know much about any given topic, and so when you query the masses on anything the majority opinion is going to be heavily influenced by marketing and 'propaganda.' What people do or think is not really based on reality, but who presented their argument in the glossiest case. So to bring this theoretic into the practical. Imagine you ask people about a certain hotkey issue, in most recent times perhaps it would be Trump's tax plan. Many people would have extremely strong opinions one way or the other. Now ask people to actually describe, without handwaving, what the plan actually was. People, for the most part, are going to be completely ignorant. We, collectively, form strong decisions about things we don't even know the basic fundamentals of! I don't know how this can change in practical terms. It's the nature of a democracy. But that just kicks the can to another problem. If we can't come to informed decisions on an individual policy, how are we supposed to be expected to come to informed decisions on candidates using every resource available to make us believe that they are who we, collectively, want in office? As tools and technologies for directing the masses in one way or another become ever more effective, this disconnect between reality and mass opinion is only going to increase.
- fongelias 9y agoI wonder what he hopes his children will take from it. I know he says its just something you experience, but there is also a lot of meaning behind the movie, and I wonder if he saw something specific in it that he believes is a valuable lesson for his children at 3-4
- waivek 9y agohe wants his kids to be astronauts and they say no because they know it annoys him lol
- TausAmmer 9y agoI would say that my childhood would be lost if it was not for the fact that I did not had any TV. Or more correct to say is that children now do not have childhood as people had 30 years ago. Rarely you will see someone who know the trill of climbing 40m high tree(age of 7). Swimming in lake while thunderstorm rages around you. Grabbing red coal with hand. Eating baked stolen potatoes in middle of forest where you got lost. Making an failure of bow to hunt. Starting a fire, then living the consequences. Giving no shits about drama and other people's feelings. Slicing up toad to see what is inside. Running from crazy animals. Crossing the voltage wires for shits and giggles. No child died in our village from these bullshits, just got smarter. Movie will do that for you and tell you how to feel. They will provide you with fake imagination and experience.
- icebraining 9y agoWe're awake for over 5400 hours each year. There's time to defy death and still watch a 30m TV show after dinner.
- teh_klev 9y agoI love Nolan's films, the first one I saw was Memento when it came out. I was quite blown away. Interstellar is (by a country mile) the film that really does it for me, and is the one I'll watch two or three times a year. The strange thing about Interstellar is that after having watched it the first couple of times, every subsequent viewing gets me fairly emotional. I never ever shed tears when watching films, and I've seen a lot of movies in my 51 or so years on this planet, but this is the one that gets me welling up inside and a bit teary eyed. So well done Mr Nolan you've managed to crack a fairly hard (film) nut.
- eduren 9y agoINTERSTELLAR SPOILERS The scene where Cooper comes back from the time-dilated planet and has years of messages to catch up on really makes me emotional. McConaughey really kills it in this movie.
- teh_klev 9y agoJeez that scene is truly heart wrenching. I wasn't awfully keen on McConaughey films previously, but you're right, there's something about this role where he knocks it out of the park. I then watched Dallas Buyers club, he nails that as well.
- wufufufu 9y agoMy problem with Dunkirk was all the stranded and starving soldiers looked like Versace models with fresh 2018 haircuts and Burberry topcoats.
- kaycebasques 9y ago> It’s about the idea of community, what we can achieve together, as opposed to this cult of individuality that we live in right now. Whether you’re talking about Silicon Valley billionaires or politicians, I think we’re living in an era that over-prizes individuality at the expense of community. It’s the Silicon Valley billionaire as opposed to the union. We’ve steered too far in one direction. We need to be reminded of the potential of what we can do together. Said the universally-acclaimed multi-millionaire Hollywood blockbuster director in his interview for LA Times That said though, I like the message and also respect the man and his work. That just struck me as a little hypocritical :) although as a storyteller I suppose he is in a position to change narratives like that
- padobson 9y agoIt’s about the idea of community, what we can achieve together, as opposed to this cult of individuality that we live in right now. Whether you’re talking about Silicon Valley billionaires or politicians, I think we’re living in an era that over-prizes individuality at the expense of community. This seems terribly relevant. And it's interesting coming from a director - the leader of creative communities behind the camera while commercial success often depends on the individual standing in front of it.
- npsimons 9y ago> And it's interesting coming from a director It's incredibly interesting to me, coming from this director, as I class him as one of the best, up there with Kubrick, and I also will discriminate on movies based on directors and screenwriters more than any other factor, because that's how I have found quality.
- mikepurvis 9y agoA good director has a chance to salvage bad everything else— no one else does. Stars with good taste can be a signal (think Tom Hanks), but that's a measure of potential rather than the final product— once they're on board, they don't really control that much beyond their own performance.
- mrec 9y agoI can't think of any case where a good director has made a good movie out of a bad screenplay. At best they can distract you with style and spectacle, e.g. Gladiator.
- Retric 9y agoIf I wanted quality, I would read a book; movies are all about style and spectacle.
- mikepurvis 9y agoI can't supply a specific example, but I'm thinking of writer/director types like Joss Whedon, JJ Abrams, Bryan Singer, who are able to understand the larger story elements and at least work within the individual scenes to excise the worst dialogue, give characters meaningful and believable motivations, etc.
- dboreham 9y agoI thought the headline was confusing and hard to parse, and sure enough when I click through to tfa I see "2001" is quoted. Strictly, the film is titled "2001: A Space Odyssey".