5 ms·
Poll: Ban Valleywag?
Several users have suggested we ban Valleywag, not for anything in particular that they write about, but because their articles are always such deliberate linkbait. I personally agree. In 99% of Valleywag articles, the most interesting thing is the title. But I don't want to be accused of censorship, so I thought I'd ask for opinions first.
- daniellord 19y agoEven the most scathed and unpopular of opinions, when allowed expression, can add value to discourse provided they don't commandeer and dominate the dialog. Perhaps a voting-based moderation would give us a pre-viewing filter we can use to decide to leave some posts un-viewed? Or a tagging system like Slashdot's? Censorship by a central authority disturbs me--it is a slippery slope and place too much power in the biased hands of a few. Didn't most countries get rid of monarchies and divine right for a reason?
- andrewparker 19y agoI think banning them is playing into Valleywag's game. They want to be banned. That just increases their "brand equity" a controversial gossip rag. Perhaps they'll receive less traffic in the long run, but I'm sure they love the publicity of this meme.
- jakewolf 19y agoAnd ban all sites that use interstitial ads. Actually, I'd ban those before Valleywag.
- mechanical_fish 19y agoI voted yes, as an application of my "PG should run his own site" principle... and because Valleywag links have often struck me the same way. But I will play devil's advocate for three seconds, just for the hell of it: Are the conversations engendered by any previous Valleywag articles worth keeping? Just because the articles are inane or linkbaited doesn't mean that all the comments are as well. Good discussions can arise from all sorts of random sources. And eviscerating bad articles can be a fun sport, provided you don't get carried away with enthusiasm. Okay, the three seconds are now up. And I, myself, can't remember any good Valleywag-inspired discussions, so... off with their head!
- noodle 19y agoi'm personally kind of indifferent on their specific articles. but imo, if you do ban them, you'll get a lot of "why ban vallywag and not XYZ"? its a slippery slope. unless there are already similar sites that are banned. if so, ignore me, i'm a noob.
- staunch 19y agoI don't think it's that slippery. There's only a few sites out there that are pure bottom feeders. Valleywag and Dailymail.co.uk are the only two that come to my mind immediately.
- Xichekolas 19y agoI personally avoid anything by Guy Kawasaki because it all just seems like contentless fluff self-promotion, but not sure he is quite Valleywag quality. ... and I wouldn't advocate banning Guy either. It's a personal thing. But it would be nice if I had a blacklist that I could just add his domain to.
- mattrepl 19y agoFor the same reasons, shouldn't TechCrunch stories be banned?
- mullr 19y agoTechCrunch actually bothers me more. I don't recall ever being pissed off that a ValleyWag story wasted my time.
- fallentimes 19y agoI feel the opposite. I can't remember the last Valleywag story I've read that I would forward or recommend to a friend.
- huhtenberg 19y agoWould it make sense to give them an initial score of zero instead ?
- webwright 19y agoPeople can use their own judgment-- I can generally summon the sense to NOT click on a link to a Valleywag article because I know it's linkbait. It's a slippery slope. Linkbait abounds. (I voted no)
- tandaraho 19y agoRather than explicitly banning Valleywag or other particular sources, it might be more useful if PG can leverage his influence in this community by adding to the posting etiquette thread from a few weeks ago (right after the rush caused by TC) regarding the type of content that is the aim/target of this space. A simple disapproval/opinion by PG should weed out 80-90% of these posts from getting generated.
- shabda 19y agoNo, this is the promise of social news. Good things bubble up, uninteresting get dumped. If its not blatant spam, or totally irrelevant don't ban them.
- vlad 19y agoThe premise that social news sites must degrade over time?
- xlnt 19y agoBanning stuff isn't a solution to the problem of disagreement about what links should be posted here, or a solution for people who have conflicting ideas in their personality about what links they want to click on.
- APLonDrugs 19y agoDon’t rely on the tyranny of the democracy. Use this as an opportunity to build a framework based on principle and apply it across the board. When you build constitutions, you have to do it in private, with great minds and based on timeless principles… and weight in fact the true nature of man. In Freedom,
- huhtenberg 19y agoHmm .. looky, looky .. 1-point comment from a single use account and yet not only it was quoted in TechChrunch cover of the story, but it was also remarkably fit for propagating whatever point Arrington was making. Does it smell fishy to anyone else ? http://www.techcrunch.com/2008/04/11/hacker-news-considers-banning-valleywag/ http://www.techcrunch.com/2008/04/11/hacker-news-considers-b...
- rms 19y agoIt was at zero points when Arrington posted it.
- jsrfded 19y agoBanning a single site feels good, but is a short-term band-aid on the moderation system. Better to identify the factors in valleywag stories that are undesireable and find a way to target them generally - to raise the editorial quality here across the board and leave behind the dross. As others have pointed out, Valleywag doesn't have a monopoly on linkbait titles and thin follow-through.
- dood 19y agoAgreed, I think the important thing is raising quality across the board. Two possible solutions: a) stop people voting for crap b) get the community to filter out crap. I don't have any good ideas for option a), and I dislike reddit-style downvoting for option b) since it has the same problem of people upvoting bad stuff, just in reverse. One idea which could work for b) is a digg-like 'bury' option (i.e. a 'this is crap' button) - but only in tandem with a high karma minimum for being allowed to use it, and some statistical cleverness for deciding when a post should be buried. But I'm terribly enthused with this idea either.
- b3eck 19y agoHow about time-regulated voting for a)? ( see http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=147383 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=147383 ) Presumably, people who go on an impulse voting spree do it without much thought and would be greatly discouraged by periodic voting prevention, whereas those who take the time to make thoughtful votes and comments wouldn't mind the regulation as much.
- sc 19y agoI like idea "b", though maybe it's more of a "flame warning" button: i.e., the authenticity of this article/domain is suspect, so be warned that it may just be flammable material. Really, I don't think we should be necessarily banning content, but rather encouraging the community at large to post worthwhile material for itself.
- ubudesign 19y agoI don't think freedom of speech would apply here so yes if Valleywag is causing problems then ban, put on notice or anything that would fix it... but there should also be some set of rules, guidlines that everyone should know about to make the ban fair.
- wehriam 19y agoI think the existing voting system is adequate to determine if a Valleywag story is worthwhile.
- cperciva 19y agoI voted for "No, don't ban them", but I don't particularly like Valleywag stories. Rather, I think the whack-a-mole approach of banning individual problem sites is a bad idea. I've said this before, and I'll say it again: Users who post garbage stories should be more accountable. Make posting a story cost a few points of karma, so that people who repeatedly post stories which don't get voted up end up without any karma. The specific problem of linkbait titles might also be helped by allowing users to "un-vote" a link which they previously voted up.
- dood 19y agoI think a karma cost for posting stories is a really bad idea. Firstly, it would not solve this problem since Valleywag stories tend to get lots of upvotes. Indeed, it would encourage posting link-baiting stories, since they also tend to be karma-baiting stories. Secondly, it would stop people from posting borderline, but valid stuff. I often don't post things I'm unsure people will like, but many times posts that seem borderline to me end up getting loads of upvotes. With a karma cost for posting, people would simply not post these kinds of stories. A karma cost for posting is a recipie for encouraging lowest-common-denominator stuff.
- cperciva 19y agoValleywag stories tend to get lots of upvotes. In that case, the "let's ban valleywag" approach is even more wrong. The problem of "garbage gets voted up" is one which ought to be solved long before the problem of "people submit garbage".
- dood 19y agoI agree, thats pretty much what I was getting at. I favor a systemic solution, not banning sites. The problem isn't that people submit bad stuff, its that the community upvotes it and has no ability to filter it.
- rms 19y agoI'd like to see tagging support in the software. I think that would go a long way towards helping. It just might be a long time before someone implements it...
- andres 19y agohow about a feature where a user can ban certain domains from showing up in their results? or a spam filter tailored to each individual user...
- dcurtis 19y agoYou asked about censorship and then deleted an article on the front page a few days ago that had some interesting comments. It was a stupid article, to be sure, but did you have to completely delete it? There's no "send to second page" button in the moderation options? My feelings: Do not ban any content, ever. Only delete things after they are submitted if they are off topic or ridiculously stupid. Instead ban the users who vote those stupid things up, or diminish their voting "worth". Sometimes, I like reading Valleywag stuff. It's certainly on topic, even if it's linkbait or pure lies. It's the comic, tabloid, side of the industry we're in. Maybe you can add a tag that says "tabloid" next to the Valleywag domain instead of downright banning it. This is a pretty good article from Valleywag: * http://valleywag.com/378444/did-you-sign-googles-noncompete-good-youre-fired http://valleywag.com/378444/did-you-sign-googles-noncompete-... * http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=160603 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=160603 Why would you want to censor that? If you have to ask about being accused of censorship, something is seriously wrong. Also, using a poll like this is extremely ineffective. The mob is, as a whole, foolish. I imagine a ton of people are clicking "yes" simply due to a negative reaction to Valleywag, rather than understanding that censoring Valleywag may start a trend here that could get out of hand...
- rms 19y agoIn the profile there is a showdead option -- if you set it to yes, you can see stories and comments that have been marked dead by an admin. By generally, I agree, banning Valleywag is a slippery slope, or, at least, it doesn't help to solve the broader problems of social news this site faces.
- hooande 19y agoIt sounds like the problem isn't Valleywag, but whoever is submitting articles from Valleywag (that is, if I'm properly understanding how news.yc works). If people stop submitting them, then the problem will go away right? We should just make it known that it is not socially acceptable for people to submit worthless articles to our community, no matter what site the articles from come. If someone submits something from Valleywag, heap scorn upon them! But if someone is voting for it, then someone likes it. Appealing to the lowest common denominator (no offense) is part of democracy.
- hooande 19y agoAnd for the record, the poll seems like it has some bias in the wording. I wish the second option said something more neutral like "No, don't ban them; I don't think it's necessary". Right now it has kind of a "No, don't violate my civil rights; I like the terrorists" feel to it.
- chengmi 19y agoNo, don't ban them; It's not going to solve anything.
- mattmaroon 19y agoI have to grudgingly vote no, only because I think they have a good article on the front page here right now. I generally dislike them. Now if you were to suggest banning any Ask News.YC posts with the word recession in the title...
- kashif 19y agoWhile yau are at it dailymail.co.uk please...
- schammy 19y agoYou ban one site, you'll have people knocking your door down to ban others. Just let it be what it is. Agree that VW is linkbait but I enjoy reading it anyways :P
- thomasswift 19y agoCustom ban filter. I was thinking about posting a feature request of something similar but I didn't. Like this huddlechat / campfire business over the last couple of days, i wanted to strip out that content.
- rickmb 19y agoAs with any social app, banning sites/users/apps that aren't deliberately damaging (like spam, trolls, whatever) is basically saying your system isn't working, and you can't be bothered to change it. It's like 'fixing' a bug in software by simply suppressing the error messages. It will come back to bite you in the ass.
- dejb 19y agoI certainly hope this poll isn't decided by a simple majority. Imagine how many things would get banned if it only required a simple majority vote. Things should not be banned without an overwhelming majority of people thinking it is necessary.
- pierrefar 19y agoI don't think they should be banned, and I have this as a systemic fix: allow individuals to filter out sites they don't like to see in the new or home page lists. This will contain the "Valleywag submissions" to the people who really like them and vote them up. With this data in mind, you could then say that given that x% of our members have filtered out a site, we should block their submission. x could be defined in a number of ways and tweaking that will be another discussion. Pierre
- menloparkbum 19y agoWhat are the stats for valleywag articles? I don't recall seeing any on the front page for quite some time, aside from the latest one about the google noncompete. There are a lot of other linkbait articles that float up to the front page. The "businesshackers" guy comes to mind. There have also been a number of completely vapid articles recently, such as the "to be a programmer, you need these 10 things: 1. text editor..." article. I can only hope these are linkbait for some SEO scam network; the thought that these articles are written and upmodded by actual hackers is too depressing. Anyway, at least we know Valleywag is a "real" site which sometimes has humor or interesting gossip. The other linkbait sites that make it to the front page truly have nothing to offer. The current moderation scheme deals with Valleywag just fine. If you must ban, there are other sites which seem to be a higher priority.
- iamelgringo 19y agoI'm very much in favor of banning Valleywag. They picked up a comment that I made on HN about a friend of mine at Yahoo. They picked up my one comment, and turned it into two articles about Yahoo's attitude towards the Microsoft merger. They also posted information that personally identified my friend as the source of the information. Granted, it was my mistake to begin with in posting that here, but I tried to make it right. PG edited the offending comment for me, and I wrote Valleywag asking them to remove the identifying information for fear that my friend might loose his job in the upcoming layoffs. Not only did they not remove the identifiying information, but they were really nasty to me about the entire affair and I though needlessly hurtful. My friend did get laid off. I don't know if it had anything to do with the article or not, however. I don't think it did, and either way, he's doing rather well for himself consulting. So, while I do have some issues about quality of the content over at Valleywag; I have bigger issues about the editorial process there. If they can take a random post from an online forum and turn it into two articles about Yahoo's attitude towards Microsoft in the takeover process, all of their content is suspect in my opinion. My opinion is that the majority of their content has a gossip rag/tabloid feel to it, and I would love to see that removed from the Hacker News listing. I see no reason to reward their trollishness with traffic from Hacker News, even if 15-20 people vote up a post linking to them.
- edw519 19y agoWow, iamelgringo, that's a scary story. Not just the valleywag thing, but the whole "information" angle. Sorry to hear about your friend. Glad to see that things are working out for him. I have made many comments about my experiences, but in "loud mouth restaurant mode", without names and places. Isn't that one of the purposes of this board, to learn and share with each other? I often wonder if a sleuth" went through my posts, they could figure out names, dates, and issues. I'm not sure what they would do with that, but your experience, along with with HN's increasing popularity, gives one food for thought.
- iamelgringo 19y agoThanks. Yeah. There's a lot of players in the tech world that lurk on this site, even if they don't post. I mean, Arrington, D Shah, P Buchheit and obviously PG post fairly frequently. I'm sure that O'Reilly has someone lurking here, if not reading Hacker news himself. I have no doubt that a number of angel investors and VC's read up on HN users just to find out what's bubbling among the next group of founders. Paul early on said that one of the reasons that he made the site was to be able to get to know founders and applicants and have a bit of reference material before they apply. I'd guess it has at least a little bearing on their YC application screening. I could be wrong. All that to say, is... Post intelligent, well reasoned comments and interesting articles. Avoid trolls and flame-baiting. Avoid posting things that you might regret later. People are reading what you post.
- anupamkapoor 19y agoedit: did you miss an option "auto post to reddit" ?
- wavesplash 19y agoPaul, Leave Valleywag alone. They're just a symptom of a bigger challenge. Let's fix the moderation system so we can squash any obvious linkbait.
- petercooper 19y agoThe wording of this poll is unfair. I don't think they should be banned, because that's censorship, but I don't necessarily "like seeing" Valleywag stories on News.YC. However, that's why I have a mouse, eyes and a brain.. I can "censor" stuff in my head, just like many other humans. Clearly some people here lack that facility, which strikes me as odd.
- rapind 19y agono soup for vallywag
- ivankirigin 19y agoI don't think an automated ban is a good idea. Hopefully the weighting system will count those voting the VW stories up with less weight.
- pg 19y agoOk, we'll try banning them for a while.
- indiejade 19y agoThank you. Even though it seems to do what it aims to do well, its ultimate goal == to sell advertising by creating sensationalist headlines and feeding the egos of people who have (or who nurture through Valleywag mentions) a grotesque vanity complex == is hardly original or noteworthy. Most hackers go out of their way to _avoid_ spotlight, so I think for the most part Valleywag is just digital GIGO. Occasionally almost humorous, but GIGO nonetheless.
- andreyf 19y agoRight now the poll is 55% in favor of banning. Banning an entire organization is rather unprecedented, so I'd suggest we wait for a bit more of a consensus before going ahead with it.
- pg 19y agoIt's not unprecedented. There are other sites that are banned, mainly because they spammed us or consist mainly of linkjacked content. I only asked this time because users occasionally vote up Valleywag stories.
- ingenium 19y agoThey aren't spamming new.yc nor does it consist mainly of linkjacked content. I can understand that people have problems with some of their content, but then just don't vote it up. It's as simple as that. To ban a site entirely that does have some legitimate content simply because you don't like it is a very bad precedent to set.
- Xichekolas 19y agoCould you just add the ability to blacklist domains on a per-user basis? That way I could personally blacklist valleywag.com and nytimes.com if I wanted to, while others could enjoy their linkbait if they wanted. Blacklisting would simply not show me stories with given string in the url.
- ilamont 19y agoValleywag sometimes goes too far, but the writers are often willing to tell the ugly truth about technologies, even if no one wants to listen. For instance, Valleywag was one of the few blogs to question the Second Life hype a few years back, while practically every mainstream media publication was gushing about all of the great business potential there. Valleywag also highlighted some of the negative goings-on with Wikipedia under Jimmy Wales. Yes, some of the revelations were merely titillating but it also pointed to first-person accounts of alleged financial wrongdoing. The media has an important watchdog role, and Valleywag's coverage, as flawed as it may be, sometimes goes where other reporters and bloggers fear to tread. Let it remain on Hacker News.
- andreyf 19y agoValleywag seems like a good candidate - but do we want to get into the mindset of banning an entire site? This seems like an emotional and short-sighted decision. What about the hypothetical 1% of Valleywag articles that is interesting? Why not find a way to prevent linkbait in general?
- dbreunig 19y agoThese are inadequate options. The issue isn't whether you like to see them on News.YC, it's do you want to start banning people. Yes, I don't like seeing them on YC. But no, I don't want to ban them. Come on! Isn't this a democratic news site front page is voted on by readers!?! This vote is absurd. I think a better idea would be to institute negative points to submissions, not just comments. That way, the handful of people needed to make news frontpage worthy can be rejected by the masses tired of Valleywag. If you have to ban sources on your democratic news site, you're missing the point.
- Mistone 19y agoi'm no fan of the rag - but censorship on a social site bothers me more - do like it dont read it - seems simple enough.
- omfut 19y agoYes. Ban Them.. They dont add any value. All their articles are sleezy and just a waste of time. I wonder why cant they come up with some decent stuff worthy of talking.
- cglee 19y agoInstead of outright banning, can we do something like this: 1. maintain a list of controversial sites 2. every time someone attempts to submit a link from that list, s/he'll get a warning message stating that should the moderators find this submission lacking, 5 karma pts will be docked. No appeals will be allowed. This is the risk of submitting from a blacklisted site. And only users above some karma threshold can submit from the blacklisted sites. This would still allow possibly useful information from those sites, but also punish irrelevant submissions.
- thomas 19y agoIf they are getting voted up, doesn't that mean we shouldn't ban them?
- hsuresh 19y agoI'm guessing these decisions need not be static. if in future their content improves, im sure we can turn off the ban.
- hackerdan 19y agoBan Valleywag Review of valleywag on yelp http://www.yelp.com/biz/valleywag-com-east-palo-alto#hrid:esqhWcX7C_u_k0S1mx9ElA http://www.yelp.com/biz/valleywag-com-east-palo-alto#hrid:es...
- msfthater 19y agoI think we might miss interesting things if ban particular news sources. And so, I might end up visiting them more just to ensure that I don't miss any news. To the gentle(wo)men iamelgringo, thanks for telling us that valleywag is a bunch of aho* but that has no correlation with reporting.If people find that valleywag reports are made up, lack substance, people will choose to not go there despite it being posted on hacker news. You want to give the choice to the end user (me and you) to see that valleywag article or not. Why restrict choice.
- schuhmacher 19y agoban those assholes
- aaronblohowiak 19y agoI signed up just to vote on this. I appreciate your candor and community engagement. Thanks!