12 ms·
You’re Descended from Royalty and So Is Everybody Else
- rzzzwilson 9y agoCharlemagne is one of a handful of kings who gets awarded the post-nominal accolade “the Great.” His early life remains mysterious and the stories are assembled from various sources, but it seems he was born around 742 B.C. So, Charlemagne was born around 742 B.C.? Doubt it!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- voyager2 9y ago"Charlemagne marked it by giving Leo one of the great medieval relics as a thank you—the Holy Prepuce, better known as Jesus’ foreskin." Not unless he had a time machine.
- frandroid 9y ago> but it seems he was born around 742 B.C.
- corpMaverick 9y agoSeems like they fixed it.
- gumby 9y agoMakes sense: since he noticed the calendar counting backwards he hung around to collect the holy foreskin and then waited until the Popes evolved and became powerful enough so he could give it to them. It’s the simplest explanation.
- QAPereo 9y agoOh it would be, but we’ve known for centuries that the holy prepuce was actually... According to an unconfirmed 19th-century source,[14][15] in the late 17th century the Vatican librarian Leo Allatius wrote an unpublished[16] treatise entitled De Praeputio Domini Nostri Jesu Christi Diatriba (A Discussion of the Foreskin of Our Lord Jesus Christ), claiming that the Holy Prepuce ascended, like Jesus himself, and was transformed into the rings of Saturn. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holy_Prepuce#Literary_allusions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holy_Prepuce#Literary_allusi...
- macintux 9y agoWas he born at all? Maybe 742 B.C. has a grain of truth! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phantom_time_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phantom_time_hypothesis
- skywhopper 9y agoCharlemagne [...] your ancestor. I am making an assumption that you are broadly of European descent, which is not statistically unreasonable but certainly not definitive. That's a disappointingly exclusionary way to open an otherwise interesting article that attempts to convey the interconnectedness of humanity. It's also a good example of putting too much weight into statistical "reasonableness" when making generalizations about your audience. Even if the expected audience is just native-English-speaking countries, you've excluded millions of potential readers. The article is mostly about Charlemagne, so fair enough to frame the intro using him, but "he's your ancestor, unless you are a statistical anomaly"? I find that depressing.
- noxToken 9y agoLiterally the next sentence: If you’re not, be patient, and we’ll come to your own very regal ancestry soon enough. I get what you're saying, but finishing the opening paragraph puts that possible exclusionary feeling down rather quickly.
- Pigo 9y agoIf this depresses you, you may need to talk to somebody about it. I feel left out every time I open Twitter, Facebook, or turn on the radio, but I get over it.
- coldcode 9y agoWe are also all African descendents; it's only a question of how far back.
- Finnucane 9y agoWe are all everything, more or less. We know that even in fairly ancient times there was trade between Europe and Asia and Africa, which likely means trading genes as well.
- spodek 9y agoAnd fish.
- to_bpr 9y agoThis is essentially factually untrue at this point. [wrong-link]
- kens 9y agoI think you're misinterpreting the article you link to. Among other things, note that Morocco is in Africa.
- canoebuilder 9y ago7.2-million-year-old pre-human remains found in the Balkans New hypothesis about the origin of humankind suggests oldest hominin lived in Europe https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/05/170523083548.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/05/170523083548.h... Europe was the birthplace of mankind, not Africa, scientists find http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2017/05/22/europe-birthplace-mankind-not-africa-scientists-find/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2017/05/22/europe-birthpl... Edit: In response to pharrington, I seem to be rate-limited. "All that high-falutin' garble that was not only missing the point, but only in service of that lame dig at the end? come on man... In my understanding, the point under discussion here, starting with to_bpr, was that the evidence is starting to shift away from the "Out of Africa" theory. And yes that is true, the evidence is starting to shift away from it."
- jsharpe 9y agoConversely, the remaining 80 percent are the ancestor of everyone living today. To nitpick, this is not necessarily true. You can imagine a person who had exactly one descendant, who had exactly one descendant, and so on, to the present day. This person would be the ancestor of only one person living today.
- pelario 9y agoThe point is, although your example is possible, the probability of this happening is pretty close to zero.
- Retric 9y agoIt's still effectively possible for someone to only have 1 kid that had a child that had a child etc. Each link could have multiple children as long as none of those descendants had children that survived to the present day. This becomes more likely if you include genocides that may have quipped out large swaths of someones descendants. You also have rather insular groups where a few thousand people may be largely segregated from the rest the world. That's not going to be particularly stable over hundreds of years, but you only need 1.
- lyso 9y agoBut as you go back in time, it becomes increasingly unlikely. At some point it is so unlikely it can be disregarded. And the point of the article is that point is closer in history than you might expect.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoNot genetically in that spot but doing family stuff discovered that I'm on a very out there part of my family tree (male decendent wise) four generations of only one son :-). It reminds me that improbable isn't a good defense.
- cantrip 9y agoThe statement isn't saying that they're everyone's direct ancestors, just that if 20% of people alive 1000 years ago do not have any current ancestors, that means that the remaining 80% are the ancestors of everyone else alive today, including lines with single descendants.
- cs1717p 9y agoSomewhat off topic, but I have often wondered if this sort of phenomenon could also occur within 'timelines' (as in the multiverse concept): As the article mentions, initially our ancestry is basically linear -- one mother and father, two grandparents per parent, etc. But the further back we go, the more our lineage begins to resemble a mesh web with certain ancestors reappearing at other points. Could the same happen with the flow of time? Say we were to go back 10 years, maybe there is only a single possible 'timeline' between now and then. But is it possible that the further we go back, there are multiple 'nodes' which cross over, much like ancestry? Is it possible there were two, or more, say, 1900ADs, which then every e.g. 1915 was descended from, splitting again into different timelines before recombining, in much the same manner as biological descent? Largely off topic, but an interesting thought experiment.
- pedrocr 9y agoThe convergence at a later time sounds highly improbable. The total state of the universe is so large that this would only work if there was something forcing the timelines to converge and never by chance.
- cs1717p 9y agoI guess it would work if there is some kind of force that leads some timelines to go out of existence or converge back towards heavier nodes, something like a neural network structure.
- travisjungroth 9y agoI've always enjoyed the thought that there are multiple universes, and there are two opposing forces at play. Chaos causes the universes to drift over time. Another stabilizing force tends to bring them back together in the most efficient way possible. This stabilizing force is felt by us as experiences of fate, or a sense (or lack) of belonging. It's not that there's a preordained destiny, but a consensus among universes that you are either in or out of.
- valuearb 9y ago8% of chinese men descended from Ghengis Khan? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Descent_from_Genghis_Khan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Descent_from_Genghis_Khan
- shkkmo 9y ago8% with a perticular genetic marker, but the data from this article would seem to indicate that all Chinese are descended from Ghengis Khan if any of them are.
- hateful 9y agoI prefer the Wait But Why article on this subject: https://waitbutwhy.com/2014/01/your-family-past-present-and-future.html https://waitbutwhy.com/2014/01/your-family-past-present-and-...
- romanovcode 9y agoMuch better article indeed because of very simple and intuitive illustrations/graphs.
- simonebrunozzi 9y agoAs a side note, his new (first?) book is just out.
- freedomben 9y agoI really resonate with his story about asking Nana about her history. My grandparents died several years ago, and just a couple years back I started to actually care about my family history and wanting to know more. I asked my dad a bunch of questions, and I was quite disappointed at how many of his answers were variants of: "Your grandma would know this, but I'm not sure. I was too young #{['to care', 'to remember', 'to understand'].shuffle.first}" If your grandparents are still alive, I completely second the author's advice to talk to them about the family history. I'm in the process of recording podcasts (for family use only, never to be released publicly) with my parents while they still have sharp-ish minds. Assuming the AI apocalypse doesn't wipe us out, I think my kids will really treasure this, and their kids maybe more so.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nitwit005 9y agoYou might not have missed as much as you think, as I tried this with my grandmother. She actually insisted on telling us the family history. Unfortunately, the moment I started asking deeper questions like "And where was he during the war?" she didn't know, even for close relatives. I basically got her story. My father made her sit down and tell us who the people in the photographs she had were, writing in the names on the pages they were glued to. She got about 50% of them, but given the bias toward more photos close family members, I think she could only identify about 25-30% of the people.
- legitster 9y agoGrowing up, I heard the same anecdote 10+ from all sorts of people: "I'm descended from the guy who fell overboard on the Mayflower!" I concluded pretty early on that the claim must be either dubious, or that any claims of ancestry become uninteresting past your grandfather. Heck, if we are going back to pre-Colonial ages, the pool of people I am related to is likely in the millions. For a world that was much, much smaller than it is today. It seems so weird to me that people want to just follow occasional threads and tell you how special they are.
- spiznnx 9y agoIn the article, if you go back to 1000AD, you're descended from literally every European alive who has any descendants at all. I think that's a much more interesting claim than the headline.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoGrandfather seems to be cutting it off a bit early. Even 10 generations ago you have a maximum of 1024 ancestors. Assuming 30 years per generation and that all of your ancestors were already in the US, you would be descended from at most about one out of every 400 people in the US at that point. In reality it's probably an even lower portion because there are probably people who show up multiple places in your family tree and the bulk of the US's immigration happened after that.
- jimmytucson 9y agoI read something while researching my DNA results that made me realize how little my ancestors have to do with me. Maybe somebody here can tell me if it's actually true. You share about 0.5^n percent of your DNA with each member of generation n, where n = 1 are your parents, n = 2 your grandparents, and so on. The explanation that was given to me is that each of your parents contributes 50% to your genes. Depending on which of their parents' genes they gave you, you share anywhere from 0 to 50% of your DNA with each of your grandparents, but for simplicity's sake let's call it 25%. The point is, most of the people we're trying to find out more about through ancestry websites and DNA tests are barely related to you. Searching for your great, great, great grandfather from the old country? Fine, you only share about 3% of your DNA with him.
- jankotek 9y agoNo, your ancestors were distant relatives, 2nd cousins etc...
- rev_bird 9y agoGenetics has something to do with my interest in genealogy, but honestly the direct familial connection is what is so interesting to me. Sure, I never met my great-great-great grandfather, and his genes probably have a negligible effect on my life now, but it's fun to think about his connection to me: My dad was really close with his grandfather Henry, who died when my dad was 12. Henry, in turn, had been very close with HIS grandfather, John, who died when Henry was 12. John fought in the Confederate Army for four years, got shot twice and stabbed once, including at Gettysburg. My thoughts and beliefs have been greatly shaped by my dad, and I'm positive my dad is who is is at least partially because of his relationship with his grandfather. Carry that backward, and I'm only three degrees removed from a soldier in the Civil War -- it's not impossible to think, completely independent of genetic inheritance, that some of my personality quirks or principles worked their way straight to me from someone who was born in the 1840s.
- clw8 9y agoIt's always fun to think about how the cute little family traditions you grew up with might have originally just been the quirk of an ancestor from 200 years ago.
- sandworm101 9y agoBeing descended from royalty is less about genetics and more about the rules that govern inheritance amongst european houses. What matters to European royals is first son to first son. Drop all the bastard lines (Fitzroys). Then drop all but a few female lines. Those with no sons can stay (ie the current QoE). Don't try to democratize an elitist and unfair system by suggesting we are all participants. Something like half of Asia is genetically related to Genghis Kan. That doesn't mean he would have ever considered them family. But given the genetic car crash that is european monarchy (google "Hapsburg chin" or Haemophilia in the UK royals) I don't want to be related to any of them. >> You are of Viking descent, because everyone is. No. The real vikings (not the TV ones) were almost universally blond or red-headed. If you are black, your ancestors were not vikings any more than my ancestors were Zulu warriors. The genetic lines merge further back than the existence of these named groups, making us at best related to them, not descended from.
- rev_bird 9y ago>If you are black, your ancestors were not vikings any more than my ancestors were Zulu warriors. This seems to be disproving a statement the author didn't make. He was specifically talking about people of European descent.
- mjmahone17 9y ago> No. The real vikings (not the TV ones) were almost universally blond or red-headed. If you are black, your ancestors were not vikings any more than my ancestors were Zulu warriors. I'm confused why you think "blond or red-headed" has anything to do with whether you have any viking ancestry. Just because my father is blonde does not mean I am. And the point of the article is that our lines merge much sooner than we intuitively believe. If you are black in any society that has had a mix of European and African ancestry more than ~200 years ago, you are almost certainly partially of European descent. Unless somehow all of your 200+ descendents avoided any sexual contact with any colonial. If you're of Western European descent, you are almost certainly of Viking (i.e. Danish/Norse) descent: they spent centuries pillaging and colonizing different areas of Europe (including England). Therefore, if you're black in the Americas, you're almost certainly descended from both Vikings and the ancestors of the Zulu (considering the Zulu were a kingdom from the 19th century, so you're right, it's unlikely everyone with European ancestors, or even everyone with African ancestors, is). If you're from any country that was a European colony more than 300 years ago, this is likely true, too. And remember, cross-continental trade is old. People from the African continent have been having children with people from the European continent for thousands of years.
- nyrikki 9y agoFunny enough the right information was available and accessible that made it trivial for me to follow my direct lineage back to Charlemagne Of course being 42 generations removed, he is only 1 of 4,398,046,511,104 potential direct ancestor paths back at that level. That number made me realize that we don't have branches in a family tree, we have laurels in a family wreath.
- falsprofet 9y ago2^42 is a number so large, it seems highly unlikely. The world population today is only 2^33. There might be - must be - multiple paths leading to the same person, for many persons. In any pedigree.
- excalibur 9y ago> A thousand years ago, we Europeans share all of our ancestry. Triple that time and we share all our ancestry with everyone on Earth. We are all cousins, of some degree. I find this pleasing, a warm light for all mankind to share. I've always found it mildly disturbing, to know that anybody you could possibly mate with is related to you somehow.
- ouid 9y agothat's a pretty harsh thing to find disturbing, given that you're the product of 4 billion years of incest.
- 1stranger 9y agoWell we also constantly mass-murder our cousins (cows, fish, pigs, etc.) So not sure mating is more disturbing. Well unless you're talking about cows.
- jotm 9y agoAnd our actual cousins (all the wars). So not sure what's more disturbing.
- pessimizer 9y agoThe vast majority of your recent ancestors' matings were within the village or between neighboring villages. You're the result of dozens of generations of cousin-mating, and a few generations of not-cousin-mating.
- Proven 9y agoThe. “You’re descended from common criminals and so is everybody else” also holds true. I don’t wanna know...
- improbable22 9y agoYou're more strongly descended from royalty (or at least nobility) than this. Because rich people had more children for most of history, and thus their offspring tended to displace those of the poor. For instance, if the top 10% have four kids each, and the total population barely grows for 5 centuries (not implausible numbers, from memory) then this isn't a small effect. If this sounds interesting you should read Gregory Clark: http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/07/science/07indu.html http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/07/science/07indu.html https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Farewell_to_Alms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Farewell_to_Alms
- ataturk 9y agoThat is provably false--plenty of non-aristocratic farm families had lots of kids. This is hokum of the worst order, also, there's no way people of other ethnicities have any relationship to European nobility.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoThe poor traditionally have much larger families. But counting surviving children, perhaps the rich make out ahead in the end?
- improbable22 9y agoNo, this is not true. Or rather, it's true today (in the west) but this is historically very unusual. We actually have surprisingly good records of such things, and digging them up demolished lots of commonly held beliefs. For instance Peter Laslett (The World We Have Lost) did exactly this for England.
- irrational 9y agoWhen did the change happen? For instance, my sixth great grandparents were farmers in the mid west (Missouri). They had 12 children of their own. So, for my family, the poor having fewer children than the rich probably would have happened farther back than the late-1700s/early-1800s.
- freedomben 9y agoThis timing is apt for me, as my sister just recently emailed to tell me we are descended from Charlemagne :-)
- bra-ket 9y agoif you're interested in this check out the coalescent theory, a very elegant mathematical model of population genetics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coalescent_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coalescent_theory The Coalescent, from a book by John Wakeley: http://www.faculty.biol.ttu.edu/olson/Molecular_Ecology_and_Evolution_files/Wakeley_06_Chapter_3.pdf http://www.faculty.biol.ttu.edu/olson/Molecular_Ecology_and_... a good intro to population genetics by Hartl & Clark: https://www.amazon.com/Principles-Population-Genetics-Daniel-Hartl/dp/0878933085/ https://www.amazon.com/Principles-Population-Genetics-Daniel...
- bentrevor 9y agoIt's not quite on-topic, but I was a little surprised that the article didn't mention that Christopher Lee recorded two metal albums about King Charlemagne: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlemagne:_By_the_Sword_and_the_Cross https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlemagne:_By_the_Sword_and_... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlemagne:_The_Omens_of_Death https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlemagne:_The_Omens_of_Deat... . He has a great voice for narrating a metal album, even though he recorded them when he was 80-something years old.
- StanislavPetrov 9y agoInteresting article, but the part about everyone having a common ancestor 3,400 years ago is questionable, at best. Recent studies have shown that some populations have been isolated for 10,000 years or (much) longer, such as aboriginal Australians. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/jul/19/dig-finds-evidence-of-aboriginal-habitation-up-to-80000-years-ago https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/jul/19/dig-f...
- Udik 9y agoThought the same. However, consider that it requires a single person of european descent mating with a single person of aboriginal descent to give to the offspring all european and aboriginal ancestry up to a few hundred years earlier. If the offspring mates again within the aboriginal population it starts spreading this ancestry. In a few hundred years it might have spread it to the whole population (even if not a single european gene is actually still present in the dna). The point is: we consider ancestry a purely additive mechanism; in fact at each generation the amount of dna actually received from a specific ancestor halves, so that you can be of european, or asian or african descent and yet have practically no genes from that side.