11 ms·
And some people still aren’t sure if there is other life beyond Earth. :) That's entire galaxies. Not just stars, and that's just the observable universe. We
by Razengan 9y ago
And some people still aren’t sure if there is other life beyond Earth. :)
That's entire galaxies. Not just stars, and that's just the observable universe.
We are still being surprised by the lifeforms we observe here on Earth, and the environments and conditions they can thrive in (including the outer hulls of our spacecraft), and we still have yet to discover and catalog all the life on our planet. Life may even come in the form of "artificial" constructs that build, learn, teach and reproduce on their own, created by "natural" life somewhere then set free into the cosmos.
How, when given the evidence of practically infinite planets out there (considering that almost every star may have at least one planet, and there are even rogue planets [0] that don't orbit any star, and that asteroids and comets or even dense nebulas could also harbor life), can we even consider the possibility that this is the only planet with life?
This game is Big, folks: Even if 90% of all planets had life there would still be billions if not trillions of them without any life, and the incomprehensibly vast distances (including voids, like the one our own galaxy is near or inside of [1]) between them may mean millions of years before life from one planet encounters life from another (which is good I suppose; every species would have some room to expand into at their own pace.)
And of course, not all intelligent civilizations will be "successful."
We will either die out on our home planet or expand.
We may not encounter other life for hundreds or even thousands of year after we develop interstellar travel, or the life that we encounter may turn out to be mundane and eventually unexciting (I mean, imagine being an spacefaring species discovering us; planetlocked and still collectively figuring many basic things out.)
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogue_planet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogue_planet
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milky_Way#Environment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milky_Way#Environment
- coldtea 9y ago>How, when given the evidence of practically infinite planets out there (considering that every star has at least one planet, and there are even rogue planets [0] that don't orbit any star), can we even consider the possibility that this is the only planet with life? For the "rogue" planets, it's easy -- we can be pretty sure they don't have any life. For the others, we'll believe it when we see it.
- Razengan 9y ago> For the "rogue" planets, it's easy -- we can be pretty sure they don't have any life. Why? Even if you assume all life requires heat and/or light, a rogue planet could produce heat/light from geothermal or other chemical activity. A rogue planet drifting through certain nebulas might have more surrounding material for the processes of life to work with. The life on a rogue planet may even be "artificial", say a colony of self-sufficient, self-replicating AI machines that originated elsewhere, but otherwise in-differentiable from "naturally-evolving" life.
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> A rogue planet drifting through certain nebulas might have more surrounding material for the processes of life to work with. Keep in mind that nebulae are in reality less dense than industrial-grade vacuum. From the point of view of a rouge planet passing through one, it's pretty much still empty space.
- Razengan 9y agoWhat about the regions of nebulas that are about to coalesce into stars? Wouldn’t they have some kind of protostellar “stuff” at point that makes the region more active than the rest of the average nebula? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_cloud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_cloud
- jobigoud 9y agoWe don't know the probability of life arising from matter. We haven't replicated that emergence yet. If that p is something like 1/10^100 due to some compounding factors, we are alone in the observable universe.
- agildehaus 9y agoYou'll never know that value with any certainty as there may be multiple ways life could emerge from non-life on Earth (not just one) and ways it could emerge on other worlds that we could not know.
- millstone 9y agoThis is an equally excellent argument that aliens speak English.
- rbanffy 9y agoIf the universe is large enough, with enough inhabited planets, it's very likely some alien, somewhere, speaks perfect English. At the same time, it's extremely likely we never encounter them.
- jules 9y agoFor very large values of large enough that is always true. Even on the condition that they use the Latin alphabet and have exactly the same set of words and exactly the same set of meanings of words, there are still n factorial ways of assigning a meaning to each word. For n=1000 words that is already gigantic. Even if there is a civilisation that speaks English words on every planet in the observable universe, the probability that any one of them assigns the same meaning to words practically zero.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- b3lvedere 9y agoInfinity is fun :) It reminds me of that (totally wrong) quote in The Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy that the population of the universe is mathematically zero. The Universe is a very big thing that contains a great number of planets and a great number of beings. It is Everything. What we live in. All around us. The lot. Not nothing. It is quite difficult to actually define what the Universe means, but fortunately the Guide doesn't worry about that and just gives us some useful information to live in it. Area: The area of the Universe is infinite. Imports: None. This is a by product of infinity; it is impossible to import things into something that has infinite volume because by definition there is no outside to import things from. Exports: None, for similar reasons as imports. Population: None. Although you might see people from time to time, they are most likely products of your imagination. Simple mathematics tells us that the population of the Universe must be zero. Why? Well given that the volume of the universe is infinite there must be an infinite number of worlds. But not all of them are populated; therefore only a finite number are. Any finite number divided by infinity is zero, therefore the average population of the Universe is zero, and so the total population must be zero. Art: None. Because the function of art is to hold a mirror up to nature there can be no art because the Universe is infinite which means there simply isn't a mirror big enough. Sex: None. Although in fact there is quite a lot, given the zero population of the Universe there can in fact be no beings to have sex, and therefore no sex happens in the Universe.”
- inventingwithmo 9y agoI realise I'm arguing against a work of comedy, but: > But not all of them are populated; therefore only a finite number are. There are infinities of different sizes
- b3lvedere 9y agoOf course. Of course. You are totally right. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=23I5GS4JiDg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=23I5GS4JiDg
- SideburnsOfDoom 9y agoMy understanding is that the infinity of "all integers greater than zero" and of "all integers greater than zero and divisible by 2" are in fact infinities of the _same_ size. The same would apply for "divisible by 100" or "divisible by 1 million". This would apply to the fraction of worlds that are populated, whatever fraction of them are.
- millstone 9y agoMe, I think there is no life beyond Earth. > How, when given the evidence of practically infinite planets out there (considering that almost every star may have at least one planet, and there are even rogue planets [0] that don't orbit any star, and that asteroids and comets or even dense nebulas could also harbor life), can we even consider the possibility that this is the only planet with life? Who gives a shit? If our spaceships landed on a distant planet populated by a vast hyper-intelligent civilization of decidedly not-alive robots, would we shrug, say "no life here," and head home bored? Maybe life isn't what we're looking for? Maybe chemistry is not so poor that it has to repeat itself by re-creating something that we would consider to be alive. Maybe the non-living things are vastly more interesting. Maybe finding distant life is like visiting a distant country and finding a McDonalds. Maybe "let's find life" is just a failure of imagination. It's SETI, not SETL.
- laumars 9y agoOne could flip your argument and say defining life as purely organic is a failure of imagination. The thing about searching for "life" over "intelligence" is that life doesn't necessarily need to be intelligent for it to be interesting. I also think the SETI example you've made is a tad unfair because their process dictates that their search be for intelligence (crudely put, radio transmissions). Whereas when you're visiting a planet, you can observe a wider scope of life as it need not be intelligent (as we can perceive anyway) for markers to be identified.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- millstone 9y ago> One could flip your argument and say defining life as purely organic is a failure of imagination. That's right! So how would you define life? Or the meta-question, why bother? We gain nothing from figuring out what's "alive" and what has "merely" a rich complexity. "Search for life" is a category error. > The thing about searching for "life" over "intelligence" is that life doesn't necessarily need to be intelligent for it to be interesting. If something is interesting, why do we care if it's "life?" Anything we find is likely to operate on some scale vastly different than what we're familiar with. We won't even agree on whether it's alive. > Whereas when you're visiting a planet, you can observe a wider scope of life as it need not be intelligent (as we can perceive anyway) for markers to be identified. My hope is we'll find markers that are clearly weird and that aren't evidence of life but maybe something more and weirder that we don't understand. Isn't that even more interesting? Why hope to find life, when we know life is already possible?
- saiya-jin 9y agomankind has been extremely lucky with our environments, among others: - Jupiter & Saturn pick out most of the comets, so we encounter massive reset only very rarely - thanx to hitting other planet long time ago, we have a spinning molten metal core inside planet generating magnetic shield for all nasty radiation - moon gives us tides & stability - our sun is just the right size and age to be stable - we're located at quiet part of the galaxy, which itself is pretty stable I think some primitive life (ie stromatolytes equivalent) can exist on many places, simply because it happened on our planet very early when it was very violent place to be - so random arrangement of matter into self-reproduction is feasible. But to evolve into specialized multi-cellular organisms took more than billion of years, a step that might not happen at all. And to create an intelligent life is another massive step up (or accident). There is Drake equation to manifest it, but basically all variables in it can be anything including 0, so it's kind of useless. So from my perspective there are couple of options: - universe is too young (if you consider average star age compared to estimated universe age), so we're one of the first sentient arrivals, others are behind in evolution - we're just not interesting enough to be contacted by superior races - just look at the news, I wouldn't blame them. We're 'meh' category at best, although most like to think of themselves in very different perspective - we're fucking alone, weird random anomaly (by far the most scary option of them all) There is a wonderful TV series from BBC called Earth: Power of the Planet, which explores this topic to great details, highly recommended!
- raverbashing 9y agoEarth was lucky but Mars and Venus (now) have been unlucky. Mars lost its magnetic field long ago, but it had one once. Venus, well, it's an acid rain oven but it could have been different. Both could have had conditions for life (as we know it) once.
- dom96 9y agoYou're assuming that all life will be like ours. This is a safe bet, but there could be very many ways for life to exist.
- tome 9y ago
- Cthulhu_ 9y ago> And some people still aren’t sure if there is other life beyond Earth. :) Until we actually observe it, no, we can't be sure; the probability of it existing is high simply due to the sheer amount of dice rolls there are in the universe, but the likelihood of us observing it is low. We already know there is and was no intelligent life in our solar system besides what's on Earth; there's still hopes of finding traces of microbial life on Mars and maybe that ice moon. But unless we get a signal from far away (what the SETI project has been scanning for for decades now), we'll not find evidence of alien life in this generation. I also doubt humanity will find a way to travel fast enough to get to another solar system within a human lifespan. If we do, it'll probably involve bending the fabric of space-time and the Great Old Ones will return from Beyond the Observable Universe and will start eating us.
- Razengan 9y ago> We already know there is and was no intelligent life in our solar system besides what's on Earth We do not know all that was on Earth. We wouldn't have known about dinosaurs if we didn't chance upon their remains, and we only recently learned that they had feathers. There is probably no way to know everything that has happened on this planet. – And that brings another facet of the point in the GP: It's not just the distances between different planets that hinders life from meeting other life; even life on the very same planet is prevented by vast periods of time from ever encountering each other.
- hanbura 9y ago>I also doubt humanity will find a way to travel fast enough to get to another solar system within a human lifespan. The next solar system is only four lightyears away. Given the will to break nuclear test ban treaties we think we could develop nuclear pulse propulsion drives that achieve about 10% the speed of light. Even after accounting for acceleration and deceleration that gets us there in a human lifespan. Granted, even at that speed generational ships make a lot of sense, and the selection of targets is still somewhat limited. But we can get to our neighbouring solar systems in "reasonable" time if we want to, with very doable development effort
- deleted 9y ago
- piquadrat 9y ago@ASmallFiction had a beautiful, succinct take on this recently: "Are we alone in the universe?" she asked. "Yes," said the Oracle. "So there's no other life out there?" "There is. They're alone too." https://twitter.com/ASmallFiction/status/946608733982822401 https://twitter.com/ASmallFiction/status/946608733982822401
- zeristor 9y agoA nice way to think about it.
- cs1717p 9y agoWhile, of course, it is technically possible, it seems very reasonable to infer that we may be in a small window in which we haven't connected to other intelligent life. In just 100 years we have gone from being barely able to fly at all, to being close to becoming a multiplanetary lifeform. The evidence becomes more and more every day that life is not a one in a trillion miracle but a natural product of certain environments. To assume we will never have contact with other lifeforms seems like a huge jump.
- dghughes 9y agoI like that it makes sense. I'd say there certainly is life out in the Universse and it's quite possible there is intelligent life. But the distances are so large that we will never meet any other intelligent life before our own civilization vanishes.
- gfodor 9y agoIt's extremely odd that we don't see autonomous probes from other civilizations that are used to monitor and disable technology that exposes existential risk to them. (For example, runaway AI would jeopardize all life if it were to expand at light speed.)
- Razengan 9y agoCan you imagine the likelihood of detecting such probes? Can we even detect any of the probes that we ourselves have sent out, without knowing exactly where they are and how to communicate with them?
- kowdermeister 9y agoMaybe if they are advanced enough to send those probes specially if it's for _their_ defense then it's pretty well cloaked and small?
- V-2 9y ago> How, when given the evidence of practically infinite planets out there [...] can we even consider the possibility that this is the only planet with life? Human minds aren't good with very large numbers. What seems "practically infinite" to us - isn't, really. The number of all planets in the universe is said to be in the ballpark of 10^24. Meaning (obviously) if you keep on dividing it by 10, in just 24 steps you get down to 1. Meaning if there are 24 factors crucial for life to evolve, and each has a 10% chance of occurring - it's actually quite likely only one planet would win on this lottery. (At a given point in time, that is - that's another aspect of course). Or 12 factors, but each with a 1% chance. And suddenly it doesn't seem like a number big enough to warrant certainty claims... Basically it is the "wheat and chessboard" problem in reverse. You start with a huge pile of planets, but once you start splitting the pile, it shrinks very very fast. Personally I'm not sure either way, and I think being sure (either way) is just naive. I believe there is microbial life out there, and I accept a slim chance we may actually discover it - say, over the course of the next few centuries - but I'm sceptical about the existence of intelligent life, and even if it did exist, I see the chances of any contact to ever occur as zero.
- Razengan 9y agoWe don't know all the factors under which life can exist. Even the lifeforms that we do know of, occupy a very broad spectrum in all metrics, existing at all sorts of extremes. We even have evidence of life we have never seen, will never encounter, and may never even have conceived as being possible to exist without that evidence: the enormous dinosaurs.
- gilleain 9y agoHowever, all the life we know of is part of the same Earth system. Just because some extremophile exists in a freezing desert or boiling pool does not necessarily mean that the same environments on other planets would have those organisms. Life on Earth evolved and spread under specific conditions - our gravity, sun brightness, geology, magnetic field, large moon, etc etc. It then spread to all possible environments on the planet and evolved to live there. Unfortunately, it could be that the 'growth conditions' for life are quite specific even if - once it gets going - life can evolve to more general environments.
- vanderZwan 9y ago> That's entire galaxies. Not just stars Ehm... sorry to be a bit pedantic, but the distinction between the two has no effect on your argument here. Either way there are ten times as many environments in which stuff happens. Also, as b3lvedere's comment points out elsewhere, you really shouldn't trust gut instincts when it comes to reasoning about infinities. Unless you're a mathematician specialized in the subject, you're pretty much guaranteed to be wrong about them. (having said that, I'm also more inclined to believe that there's plenty of life out there. I'm not as hopeful about complex life-forms escaping planets though)
- sudhirj 9y agoAny estimations about life outside Earth only become viable once we understand the factors that gave rise to it first, and their probabilities of occurrence. If the total probability is less than 10^24 (say) we might expect life elsewhere, but if it's 10^100 probably not. But either way, gut feel and intuition about this are pointless - by the anthropic principle, we're speculating about the possibilities of life only because we're already winners of the lottery - almost like someone lucky enough to win a lottery twice or thrice in a row wondering why it doesn't happen to everybody. Either way, I actually think that the Dark Forest principle applies heavily in the universe (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dark_Forest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dark_Forest) - no halfway intelligent civilization should assume the intentions of any other civilization are benign until proven to be so, and will always take steps to either hide themselves or shoot first and investigate later.
- Pigo 9y agoThere's always so much guesstimation and wishful thinking going on. It makes sense though because we see this magnificence and want explanations. It's frustrating because we learn so much about what we don't know, and worse, how much we'll probably never be able to know.
- elorant 9y agoUntil a flying saucer lands on my yard I have to assume there is no life in Universe.
- jdtang13 9y agoI'm tired of hearing these types of extremely confident lay-assertions about life beyond earth. It's true that the number of planets is incomprehensibly large, but it could also be true that the probability of a particular planet developing life is incomprehensibly small. In physics and chemistry, there are some odds that remain so extremely small even when you roll the dice many many times. Stop using "incomprehensibility" as an argument since it can go both ways.
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoLet’s talk numbers. There’s 250 billion stars in our Milky Way galaxy. Our local supercluster has 100,000 galaxies in it. Previous estimates were that there are 100-200 Billion galaxies in the observable universe and this article suggests the figure is 10x as much as that. The Kepler telescope has been discovering planets around nearby stars for a while now, and the impression we get are that at least half of the stars seem to have planets around them. With 250 Billion stars in our galaxy and 200 Billion galaxies or more just in the observable universe (also cosmologists believe the actual universe is larger than the observable universe by an unknown amount), that leaves us with somewhere in the neighborhood of 25 Billion trillion (that is, 25 Billion * 1 trillion) planets in the observable universe. 100 Billion + worlds just in our galaxy. We also believe that the laws of physics are the same across the universe and that water and other basic elements are abundant throughout the universe. So to me it seems like even with extremely remote probabilities of life existing, to me it seems most likely that there would be lots of planets where life started.
- jdtang13 9y agoNice intuition. Too bad intuition has nothing to do with quantifiable numbers. "Extremely remote probability" is a human idea that you have in your head. It has nothing remotely scientific in it. There's an extremely remote probability that the atoms in your body might teleport to the Great Wall of China. How much are you willing to bet that it happens?
- lhkdfsakhljd 9y agoso about 2^75? That means I only need to identify 75 independent things on earth that have a 50-50 chance of ocuring on another planet. I need to identify less things as long as I find something with long odds. - Dense enough to hold an atmosphere - far away enough from the star - close enough - right star ... ect Carbon life is probably the only life possible, maybe silicon. Carbon just has way to many things going for it (especially the bootstrapping process - try randomly creating something that behaves like a transistor vs. an amino acid). But what I think is the crux of the matter is that it's all irrelevant: what the numbers suggest is that life elsewhere is probably irrelevant to the human experience < we're necessarily too far apart for our light cones to intersect.
- mabbo 9y ago> can we even consider the possibility that this is the only planet with life? Yes, we can. I don't personally think life is all that rare in the universe- we agree there. But I think it's perfectly fair that it's possible we're alone. It's really a question of how many unlikely events lead to us existing and how improbable those events are. People always start with "Let's imagine only 0.1% of planets have conditions for life! How rare that must be!". But is 0.1% a fair estimate? What if the true number is 1E-20? Or 1E-40? 0.1% is easy for humans to understand and think about so we always start there. Then apply the same reasoning to the jump from single-cell life to multi-cell life, to the odds of become larger animals, the odds of becoming intelligent. We don't know what the odds are, so we always use odds that sound low but are actually quite large. Just like humans are biased towards not seeing how big the universe is, you (like everyone else) are biased towards using probabilities in the realm of human understanding. That is just as wrong. The question isn't how big the universe is, it's the comparison of how-big to how-unlikely.
- QAPereo 9y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter https://www.haystack.mit.edu/hay/staff/jball/etiy.pdf https://www.haystack.mit.edu/hay/staff/jball/etiy.pdf Dark Forest The tyranny of ‘c’
- truantbuick 9y agoWhen we talk about something so big that it might as well be infinite, we call it "astronomical". We've all heard the awesome facts: we know we're an invisible dot in our town; we know the town is an invisible dot on the planet; we know the planet is an invisible dot in the solar system; we know the solar system is an invisible dot in the galaxy; we know the galaxy is an invisible dot in the universe. But, as impressive as that all sounds, that's describing scale with exponential growth, but exponential growth pales in comparison to combinatoric growth. The number of ways you can arrange 100 people is far greater than the number of estimated atoms in the universe. And not _just_ greater, greater in a way that is difficult to explain. A drop in a bucket? No. A drop in the ocean? No. All our metaphors are physical, and so they're inadequate, but let's just it's beyond all that. Of course, that doesn't mean the probability of other intelligent life is best assumed to be of a combinatoric nature, but let's get ahead of ourselves and let our awe of the universe's size cloud our judgement. It's far from infinite, and silly to assume intelligent life is certain.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- uhtred 9y agoIt makes me excited and happy to think of other life out there, waiting to meet us. But sad that I will probably not be around to witness it.