15 ms·
After beating cable lobby, Colorado city moves ahead with muni broadband
- 0xfeba 9y agoBut what can people do in non-compete areas? Places where legislation already exists preventing municipalities from doing just what Ft. Collins has done?
- Retric 9y agoLegislation can change. This is the kind of thing you want to gather grass roots level support for.
- danesparza 9y agoRun for office in the municipality and overturn the legislation (or support candidates that support overturning the legislation).
- rayiner 9y agoMove out of Tennessee, Virginia, etc? The municipal broadband bans are mostly in southern states you might want to leave for other reasons. (If you live in Virginia--Maryland is just across the border, and we're better in every conceivable way.)
- interknot 9y agoAs much as I dislike Northern Virginia, I'll have to disagree with you about Maryland. Chattanooga has municipal broadband, and they even provide service to places within Georgia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPB https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPB
- rayiner 9y agoThat only covers a small portion of the state. 28% of Tennessee has access to fiber, versus 61% of Maryland.
- mileycyrusXOXO 9y agoIn 2015 Fort Collins voted to overturn the legislation preventing competition. In 2017 another 17 municipalities in Colorado did as well.
- rayiner 9y agoThat’s a weird way to phrase it. Colorado voters didn’t vote to “overturn the legislation.” The law itself provides for referendums where voters can approve municipal broadband.
- pc2g4d 9y agoSue the state?
- delinka 9y agoDIY. Build your own network. Why does the municipality have to get involved (beyond permitting and approvals...)?
- grahamburger 9y agoIt's surprisingly feasible (in some areas) to start an ISP on your own using wireless equipment. I've been working with companies doing that for about 15 years and recently started writing http://startyourownisp.com http://startyourownisp.com to help people interested in getting started.
- username223 9y agoAs a small gesture, you can walk over to your neighbor's place, knock on the door, and offer to split the internet bill in exchange for the Wifi password. Sure, the service will still suck, but it already did, and this way you will pay half as much for it.
- 0xfeba 9y agoNot a bad idea... Could just get a directional antenna for a separate router to isolate their network(s).
- aaronchall 9y agoMonopolized ISP services are ripe for local disruption. Is the future of Internet Service Providing going to be a service of local governments? What about co-ops?
- TallGuyShort 9y agoIf local governments are the future of ISP services, I'm not sure we'll have made much progress at all on the anti-monopoly front.
- JadeNB 9y ago> If local governments are the future of ISP services, I'm not sure we'll have made much progress at all on the anti-monopoly front. It seems to me that this is real progress; or do you mean "this just replaces the private monopoly with a government monopoly"? Even just moving a monopoly from private to public hands seems to me like progress. Comcast, for example, doesn't need, or particularly care about, my vote, whereas local government does.
- fetus8 9y agoI think you're right, by moving the monopoly over to the local government, my vote now influences how the service works in a way that I can't control with Comcast. Living in Fort Collins and trying to help this get passed and put in to action has been great to see, but watching Comcast fight back has been quite disheartening considering the quality of service they provide. I am more than ready to give the City my money every month instead of the money hungry POS that is Comcast.
- TallGuyShort 9y agoThat's funny, I live in Fort Collins too, and they already take a large chunk of my money and despite my votes and my dissatisfaction with how they spend it now, they seem to be changing about as fast as Comcast's customer service is known to be.
- 9y ago
- danschumann 9y agoI'm really glad to see a public option. I still want companies to have the option to compete, but a public option, IMO, is the best bet against the monopolies.
- rch 9y agoIt makes sense for the city to provide fibre and let co-ops, non-profits, and corporations compete for subscribers. The city shouldn't have to manage the Netflix appliance, for instance.
- samfriedman 9y agoLongmont, CO also has municipal (gigabit) broadband. At the first attempt, telecoms spent $200,000 to stifle the measure. In 2011 it was tried again, and despite $400,000 in spending by telecoms the measure passed. [0] Now in Fort Collins, the cable lobby outspent the city $900,000 to $15,000 on campaigning and still lost. [TFA] I wonder if anti-municipal campaign spending by the telecoms will continue to increase, and just how far they will go before cutting their losses and trying to defeat these plans some other way. [0] https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/11/19/longmont-internet-service/19294335/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/11/19/longmo...
- blakesterz 9y agoIt's not clear to me from that USA Today article... what the cable lobbies spending that money on? Advertising aimed at residents? What do those ads look like? Or is it just "lobbying" (bribing) the local officials?
- anderspitman 9y agoAdvertising is definitely a big part of it. A common angle is to release commercials basically saying, "we shouldn't be spending government money on fiber when we could use that money for [insert emotionally-charged need that could be improved in literally every town in existence]"
- losteric 9y agoEventually those companies will have to start lobbying for those alternative public investments - the emotional argument is far more effective when <emotionally-charged need> is on the same ballot.
- ajbourg 9y agoIn Fort Collins, 2b was a ballot measure. Most of the money went to advertising. I had a hard time finding direct examples online, but this article (http://www.coloradoan.com/story/news/2017/11/01/fact-check-fort-collins-broadband-ads/821222001/ http://www.coloradoan.com/story/news/2017/11/01/fact-check-f...) does have a picture of the many mailers received by some voters. (I lived in Longmont when the second vote happened and can confirm many similar mailings as the article)
- rayiner 9y agoSo here in Maryland, the state and county governments are building a fiber network to plug gaps in the state's coverage (most populated areas of the state have competition between fiber and high-speed cable). It's a great idea. That said, requirements like these make me nervous: > > The city intends to provide gigabit service for $70 a month or less and a cheaper Internet tier. Underground wiring for improved reliability and "universal coverage" are two of the key goals listed in the measure. > Building a citywide network is a lengthy process—the city says its goal is to be done in "less than five years." Contrast with how Stockholm built its network: https://www.stokab.se/Documents/Stockholms%20Stokab%20-%20A%20Blueprint%20for%20Ubiquitous%20Fiber%20Connectivity%20FINAL%20VERSION.pdf https://www.stokab.se/Documents/Stockholms%20Stokab%20-%20A%.... A company was created by the city to own the dark fiber. The company was not given any build-out directive, and it took 18 years to cover 90% of the city, building out in a demand-driven fashion. The upside is that the approach is sustainable. Stockholm's utility has never received public money, isn't subsidized by a utility monopoly, and operates at a profit. It doesn't depend on changing political moods or public priorities. Freedom from the municipal government is a big advantage. Look at what's happening right now with DC's and New York's subway systems. Once very good, they've been overcome by public-sector mismanagement, and are facing enormous maintenance and upgrade backlogs. The fact that this is run by the power company isn't all that comforting. Municipal governments have enormous influence over local power companies, and our electrical grid is in pretty poor shape too.
- shijie 9y agoIsn't the Stockholm fiber company you mentioned an inherent monopoly, then? Assuming that they're the ISP as well? Or can independent ISPs run their service on the fiber owned by this company?
- abbe_k 9y agoI'm pretty sure the fiber company only owns the fiber and takes a fee from ISPs for using it, they are not an ISP themselves. This means most customers can choose between a lot of different ISPs. At least it is that way in a lot of other places in Sweden.
- 9y ago
- msla 9y agoI hope I'm being overly-suspicious, but I always wonder: Who are they going to buy transit from? An ISP they just denied a profitable monopoly? It would be the simplest thing in the world, it seems to me, for the ISPs in the region to refuse to sell bandwidth to the city that just beat them.
- taoistextremist 9y agoI'm not too savvy on this stuff, so correct me if I'm wrong, but couldn't they build out to the nearest internet exchange point? I thought those were typically open for anybody to hook up to.
- ajbourg 9y agoTransit providers are usually _much_ more competitive than last mile.
- burkemw3 9y agoI have read here that the commercial market has competition [0]. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15926613 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15926613
- monocasa 9y agoTier II last miles like Comcast weren't going to give them transit anyway.
- rch 9y agoThere is a meeting about this in Boulder next week as well: https://www-static.bouldercolorado.gov/docs/Study_Session_Boulder_s_Broadband_Initiative-1-201801021108.pdf https://www-static.bouldercolorado.gov/docs/Study_Session_Bo...
- ryannevius 9y agoIt's also in the works in Estes Park. It appears that the whole Front Range is interested in at least having these discussions.
- scoggs 9y agoColorado blazing the trail again for the entire country? I like it.
- 0xf8 9y agoThese municipalities are the unsung heroes fighting the good fight. True Champions. I hope it is the catalytic butterfly that ends the telecoms' monopoly and abuse.
- Someone1234 9y agoHonestly Municipal Broadband should be built out as an Open Access Network[0]. They're currently facing a lot of lobbying from the existing broadband monopolies because they're building direct competition to them, this is an unnecessary fight. Particularly when their ultimate goal is just to get fast high quality internet. Build it as an OAN instead and let CenturyLink, Comcast, Charter, etc, lease it. But also let new smaller players lease it too. Instead of fighting the big guys, get them onboard with this plan. The big guys won't LOVE it because they still lose their monopolistic stranglehold, but at least you aren't using public revenue to push them out of the market. You're using public revenue to create a road that any business can use for an equal fee. In any regard your local citizens get: Faster internet, more choice of ISPs, and perhaps lower prices due to more competition. Let citizens be the "king maker" by choosing their own ISP. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-access_network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-access_network
- cdubzzz 9y ago> The big guys won't LOVE it because they still lose their monopolistic stranglehold, but at least you aren't using public revenue to push them out of the market. You're using public revenue to create a road that any business can use for an equal fee. I really can't imagine the response from larger incumbents being any different if this sort of format were being proposed. Why accept any competition at all when you can have none or almost none?
- mikestew 9y agoWhy accept any competition at all when you can have none or almost none? Because that won't last forever. One top-level comment here lays out how much money the incumbents spent to defeat such measures, and they still lose. Incumbents such as Comcast appear to be so hated that the only thing keeping them in place are monopoly deals written years ago. IOW, they are not going to get widespread public support. Without public support, they rely on cronyism and old regulatory deals. They would do well to at least have a plan for how they would fit in this new world order (and I would be shocked if they didn't), if for no other reason than to not be caught off guard when the tide changes.
- mparr4 9y agoGood luck, Fort Collins. I'm from Burlington, Vermont. We had municipal fiber. Great speed and prices and amazing customer service. Unfortunately, due to mismanagement and some shady borrowing from the city, the utility was sold last month as mandated in the settlement of a suit by Citibank, marking the end of our experiment with municipal broadband. Fort Collins is 4x the size of Burlington. Hopefully the larger customer base means they'll be able to avoid some of the financial struggles that we faced.
- AngeloAnolin 9y ago"Unfortunately, due to mismanagement and some shady borrowing from the city" That alone spelled its doom, not the premise of it being established as a public internet utility. With financial institutions having a stranglehold on the government, they could effectively choose (negotiate?) which sort of payment would be beneficial to them long term. A public internet utility sold to them makes the most sense as this means an actual steady flow of income and customer base.
- rgbrenner 9y agoCiti doesn't sound like the bad guy in this case.. BT borrowed from Citi for the buildout. Citi was told 40% of payments to BT were not from tax receipts, and were available to service the loan. Then when it became clear the buildout wasn't going well, the mayor decided to allocate $0 in the city budget to service the loan, and declared that all payments, no matter the source, were tax receipts(ie: payments from BTs customers were tax receipts now).. and therefore Citi would receive nothing because in their interpretation of the loan agreement, only non-tax revenues would be available for loan payments. Where in that is Citibank doing the wrong thing? Is Citibank wrong because they wanted to receive more than $0 from BT? And casting this as Citibank's fault directly conflicts with the fraud investigation, illegal borrowing from city bank accounts, etc. There was clear mismanagement by BT, bad forecasts for subscriber numbers, and no more funds available because this occurred during the financial crisis in 2008 (prompting the illegal borrowing from the city).
- 9y ago
- qwertyml 9y agoYou guys are role models for the rest of the country and the world. Keep going. All the best.
- MechEStudent 9y agoThe important question: How much money was it worth to Comcast? They have a population of ~136k, comprising 60,503 households. If each currently pays $100/mo for a cable bundle and all abandon them for fiber (a gross over-estimate), that is $72.6 million per year of lost revenue to Comcast. It is, however, $72.6 million of returned value, or something more than about 10% of the $620M/year total city budget. If my town voted to net-reduce its total burden to me by 10% or so, that would be very appealing. If they only returned half of that, it would still be substantial. If they dispensed with the "evil" of the regular garbage "fees" and price hikes that modern cable monopolies love, it would be worth 100% of the price.
- matt_the_bass 9y agoThis is a very interesting way to look at it. The question is how to make “average Joe” understand that logic.
- gnopgnip 9y agoEach subscriber is worth $1000-$1500 by traditional accounting methods. The number of active accounts could be substantially less than 60k though. Alameda CA is a similar sized city and they had ~15k subscribers when they sold the municipal cable and internet to Comcast for $17 million.
- bwb 9y agoI really hope Boulder gets this soon... I am jealous of Longmont!
- caspercba 9y agoThis is a bad bad idea. We have plenty of Latin American examples showing how this ends. A very inefficient company with many employees, a powerful trade union and many customers without service. I know, it feels good to have these services as public, but at the end of the day it is not a better service, and it gets more expensive with time. Good luck though.
- delinka 9y ago"...but at the end of the day it is not a better service, and it gets more expensive with time." So...just like the monopoly incumbents?
- delinka 9y agoEliminating legislation against municipal broadband is certainly a good thing. But I'm curious why some enterprising residents haven't created a company to do what a Public Open Access Network would do: build out the infrastructure, and lease it to anyone wanting to provide internet service to the covered area. There's nothing requiring only the municipalities themselves to do that, right?
- bickfordb 9y agoOne problem is getting right of way to run cable on poles and underground conduits
- yohann305 9y agointernet should use the water model. You can get a decent internet speed provided by the state just like tap water and if you need a faster internet, you can pay as you go just like you'd buy bottled water. What's your opinion?
- orthecreedence 9y agoNot sure how water is set up, but I think municipalities should own the network infrastructure and rent/lease it out to private companies. This keeps the city from having to run a business, instead they just maintain the infrastructure (like pipes/roads) and let the private companies duke it out themselves. This is always how I had it in my head, but apparently there's a name for it (Open access network): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-access_network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-access_network
- c3534l 9y agoI hope the telecom industry comes to regret their lobbying and bad business practices.
- deevolution 9y agoMunicipal broadband only goes so far in terms of protecting citizens from throttling, am i right? If you need to access a website hosted on a server outside your municipal broadband network, will those packets be throttled as they pass through various datacenters controlled by monopoly ISPs?
- matt_the_bass 9y agoThis is a really good point. There isn’t really a “free” backbone that connnects all these separate networks. There are private backbones who could filter at their interfaces if they chose to.
- gnopgnip 9y agoThere is more competition between transit providers so this is not an issue. If Level 3 starts throttling certain services, you can switch to Cogent or Hurricane Electric. It is only a problem for consumers because of the high cost of last mile access.