10 ms·
Serial Swatter Bragged He Hit 100 Schools, 10 Homes
- johansch 9y agoI could actually imagine things being better if proof-of-identity was required for a phone number. I really don't want IP access to run by the same scheme though. How do these swatters fake phone numbers?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoYou can specify the number you want to appear to be coming from when terminating a SIP connection, depending on where you're connecting to the network. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID_spoofing#Technology_and_methods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID_spoofing#Technology_...
- johansch 9y agoSo the solution is to regulate the assignment via phone numbers via VOIP providers. Which I perhaps, naively assumed was already happening. WTF?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoAlready regulated, considered legal. Next move would be to propose legislation through a US congressional rep and move it through Congress. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID_spoofing#Legal_considerations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID_spoofing#Legal_consi...
- johansch 9y agoEdit: Ah, after reading more from that link you provided; the issue is stuck in your dysfunctional government. I'm so confused right now. Does the US not have a central agency that allocates phone numbers and operators? Does that agency not have the ability to shutdown operators who don't follow the rules?
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> Does the US not have a central agency that allocates phone numbers and operators? Yes. https://www.neustar.biz/ https://www.neustar.biz/ > Does that agency not have the ability to shutdown operators who don't follow the rules? Long story. TL;DR Spoofing DIDs isn't illegal. See my Wikipedia link above what is and isn't considered illegal. > Edit: Ah, after reading more from that link you provided; the issue is stuck in your dysfunctional government. Yes.
- johansch 9y agoThat's extraordinarly retarded.
- johansch 9y ago"0 points" Ah, well, Jingoism is an american word. I guess I just thougt the crowd here could agree that it's retarded to not have a political policy against fake VOIP numbers.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago"Retarded" seems to be a considered a derogatory slur in these times, which could explain your downvotes. https://www.google.com/search?q=retarded+slur https://www.google.com/search?q=retarded+slur
- johansch 9y agoThanks, but I somehow get the feeling that it's more about not wanting outsiders telling them how to solve problems they know they should have solved a long time ago by themselves.
- eric_h 9y agoI suspect that your feeling is incorrect - your word choice has significantly fallen out of favor for use in civilized discourse, at least in the United States. Beyond that it added very little to the discussion, which is often a reason for a down vote around these parts.
- falcolas 9y agoLong story that I’m not fully familiar with short: the phone system suffers from the same trust issues that the internet does. That is, it wasn’t designed with things like adversarial users in mind. EDIT: Am I incorrect in this statement? I'd love more feedback.
- johansch 9y agoWell, then, fix it.
- falcolas 9y agoSure thing. Let me switch industries, learn a completely new skillset, and rise to a point of power where I can affect such widespread (cross-state and company) changes. Shouldn't take more than a few months. /s
- johansch 9y agoWell, I do agree. I shouldn't take more than a few months to fix this. I don't live in the US, but I get the feeling something is terribly wrong with the way you're handling such a basic thing as a phone call, be it VOIP or not.
- SilasX 9y agoRight but in this case it was unproxied VoIP, right? It should be easy (in the sense of not requiring a forced universal protocol upgrade, I mean) to at least protect against this kind of attack — a caller from an LA IP claiming to be in Kansas.
- delinka 9y agoThe same way telemarketers fake phone numbers. More surprising to me is that the deeper routing data (as in, the real source of the call, which the phone company necessarily has) is not available. I understand that you want to allow anonymous tips, but it would make sense that if the caller ID data is faked (i.e. the purported number's exchange doesn't match the source), then the data should be made immediately available.
- johansch 9y agoSeems like a lot of people here really want VOIP to be anonymous/unregistered. You know, so that the nazis can't get you if they seize power. But they also seem loath to acknowledge this desire, particularly in this context.
- jMyles 9y agoAnonymous / unauthenticated calling to emergency services is a good feature to preserve. Reacting as though they are credible enough to warrant deadly force is not.
- johansch 9y agoSure, but that only works so far. Even a european-style police force would eventually snap if they had to do 100 break-ins to combat ongoing crime if 99/100 calls were fake. Both issues need to be addressed.
- TheGrumpyBrit 9y agoSurely if 99/100 calls were fake, that should reinforce the idea that a fake call is a possibility, and ensure that police are less likely to react with deadly force unless a threat is proven.
- jMyles 9y agoA reasonable, mature, and just society will pay very little attention to this person, but pay very much attention to the vulnerability that this person has irresponsibly disclosed.
- walshemj 9y agoSo why are you down playing the deaths this person has caused
- gknoy 9y agoI think the GP's point might be that the problem is not so much that someone called SWAT on people, leading to their deaths, but rather that the response infrastructure of our current police sytems leads them to enter a residence with what turns out to be excessive force. SWAT was originally intended to be used for "special" situations, and increasingly (over the past few decades) has been the go-to tool for many police-citizen interactions. If I were playing video games, and my front door exploded and the entryway were flashbanged, my first response would probably be relatively instinctive (get up, maybe to see WTF is happening in my house), and it's _very probable_ that such responses would make the breaching officers fearful enough that they'd shoot me. I don't have any weapons in my house, have no intention of resisting any police action, but the fact that I might stand up out of my chair, or move, or who-knows-what could easily be misconstrued. In the article, they said that the man had "reached for his waist" -- I literally do that every time I get up from my computer chair. I'd much rather that the police did some kind of surveillance first ("oh, hey, looks like a dude playing video games ..."), and verified that the situation matched the emergency described in their dispatch. This isn't intended to detract from the badness of the SWAT-ter's actions: I hope that (if he indeed caused this) there's some serious consequences. However, it would have been a lot more difficult to cause such mayhem if the police were less trigger-happy.
- maxxxxx 9y agoSWAT teams don't seem to take into account that this situation is highly confusing, especially for innocent people. Following orders may be difficult for most people. A while ago I got T-boned at an intersection. I wasn't injured but clearly very confused. When a cop asked for my driver's license I gave him my credit card several times and simply couldn't process what he was saying. I can imagine if guys with guns broke into my house at night screaming I would also not be able to behave correctly.
- walshemj 9y agoThat guy has so destroyed his life swatting the fed means he's going to be a person of interest for life to the TLA's
- jasonmaydie 9y agoI'm still surprised that police would go shooting up a place without even verifying that the situation they are supposed to be handling even exists.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI would really like to see a discussion how different police forces in different countries would handle this. My guess is that German police would first stay outside and look at the situation. I doubt they would go straight in. The American attitude of going straight in seems in line with high speed chases. I think in most countries these would be viewed as too dangerous. Does anybody anything about strategies of different police forces?
- Theodores 9y agoIt is the strategy of the swatter, not the police to focus on here. In Germany they might be more cautious however there will be situations where they have to proceed immediately. So you could be swatted for drinking a beer in some Arab state (notionally) but not in Germany. Therefore the swatter has to up his game to 'they have lots of cocaine that could be flushed down the loo' or, if that does not work, the threat could be a nuclear bomb dropped on baby's head or something else that takes it up to 'swat level'. This would not be possible if the police were to turn up unarmed, as would be the case in the UK where they would have tasers and body armour. The UK police do make big mistakes with firearms - sometimes politically motivated mistakes to give a bigger impression of terror than there actually is. The Brazilian guy that got shot on the underground was a notorious incident, plus there were the London Riots in 2011, sparked off by a police and guns problem that went wrong. In the UK there are firearms officers only a few minutes away in places like London, most of the police force know as much about guns as they know about Scandinavian poetry. Which is good. If the police need to get the guns out they can, there is no need for every officer to be armed. In many ways it is better, not least because only a small amount of officers have to use guns and they can dedicate the time required to be good at what they do, or the best they can be. Meanwhile, in America where every policeman, woman and dog is armed to the teeth, there is not the same level of specialisation, the whole force have to be trained to some standard that is not likely to be as good as the sharp shooters of London's police. This also applies to equipment, in America the police force needs more guns that Europe's armies need. So are those millions of guns going to be as good as the small handful of guns owned by London's police? Say you wanted to add video recording to every gun, so it recorded black box style, to not miss anything. You could update a few hundred guns with that capability a lot easier than you could if updating a few million guns. It is not hard. In the UK when Tony Blair was around then if you swatted someone as 'al-qaeda' then - if they had the beards right to be stereotyped - then the police would go in guns blazing. The credible threat would be bomb making, but even then it would rely on the fear of those times to be taken credibly. Plus the dark politics of the time. The police in the UK do drugs raids at dawn - or other times of day - where there is no polite entry. You could get someone swatted for that but only if they were known to the police and actually dealing drugs on the premises could you get the full raid. Here there are no guns, they cover the exits to the premises and then use the 'big key' to break down the front door. The goal is to then make sure they can get the drugs before they are hidden/disposed. Guns are not needed for this even though guns definitely exist in the world of class 'A' drugs. The police do have their riot gear on and this is partially bulletproof. Also very heavy so not operationally that convenient. Would an American police officer have the 'bravery' to burst down a house and go in unarmed, i.e. not gun first? There is a thought.
- cantrip 9y ago> Over 20 schools and homes > Homes I'm about 10 now > Schools I'm at about 100 Is no one going to reference the typo in that admission? Isn't it possible he meant to say 10 schools?
- watertom 9y agoSeems like a pretty effective method for terrorism. I'm afraid of the police because they are essentially unchecked and usually their behavior is rubber-stamped. The simple fact that they charge into a situation without ANY reconnaissance highlights exactly why I'm afraid of the police. The thought of them showing up at my house because "someone" called the police is actually a terrifying thought. An organized group calling in SWATTING situations around the country would create a serious level of fear.
- epicureanideal 9y agoI certainly don't encourage it, but an organized group calling in a huge amount of swattings, so much so that it becomes a regular occurrence, might actually be a way of reducing the danger in swattings and reduce police aggressiveness. If each police force responds several times to this kind of prank call, it would hopefully demonstrate to them the need to change their operating procedures. Unfortunately several dozen or more innocent people might be killed or wounded before they realize their rules of engagement etc. need updating.
- userbinator 9y agoso much so that it becomes a regular occurrence According to the post, it already seems pretty regular --- this one only made the news because someone was killed.
- jMyles 9y ago> an organized group calling in a huge amount of swattings, so much so that it becomes a regular occurrence > I certainly don't encourage it Why not? This seems like a very reasonable, sober approach to testing this problem. If SWAT teams can't pass this test, they need to be put on pause until they can be repaired. I mean, we do this sort of pentesting for things as trivial (at least by comparison) as bank accounts and health records. We're talking about people being murdered in cold blood here. I damn well think that a SWAT team needs to be able to demonstrate that it can survive a falsified report without murdering somebody.
- izacus 9y agoHrmf, in a society where police doesn't shoot innocent unarmed people swatting as a concept doesn't really exist - it's called "prank call" and while it's still a rather serious crime, it's something that's solved by a fine and a strong talking to. Policemen killing unarmed innocent people is the problem that really needs solving - how the hell can innocent people be killed by policemen and not a single person in police chain of commands gets jailed? Why wasn't a single head of police removed from post and why aren't training approaches being reevaluated?!
- jadell 9y agoYou are correct in everything you wrote, except for one thing. > Policemen killing unarmed innocent people is the problem that really needs solving No, policemen killing unarmed innocent people is a problem that really needs solving. But it isn't solved yet. Until it is, swatting someone should be considered an act of violence. The person calling in the swat is doing so specifically because of the potential for violence, and they should be punished accordingly. Stopping the police from shooting unarmed and innocent people is the long term solution. Until that is in place, there needs to be consequences for those who would exploit police violence for their own ends. These are issues that can be worked on in parallel.
- izacus 9y agoI would honestly say (although I'm not from US) that preventing the police from murdering any innocent person is of paramount priority over pretty much anything. Stopping the police violence shouldn't ever be a "long-term solution". Punishing the caller after all won't do anything to save more people - police killings are happening at alarming rate with swatters or without. It'll just satisfy your lust for revenge which doesn't really do anything. Just consider the rising amount of jailed people in US and comparatively low change in crime rate. Use brain to solve problems, not your first emotional response.
- jadell 9y agoAnd not being from the US, I think you're ignoring the reality of how large a problem "preventing the police from murdering any innocent person" actually is here. It shouldn't be, but it is, and we have to work in the world we live in, not the one we wish for. In the current reality in the US, calling the police about a violent crime underway will provoke a violent response. The caller certainly knows this. We should absolutely be working very hard to change that, but until it changes, trying to hand wave it away by saying, "it shouldn't be that way," ignores reality.
- gech 9y agoWhy don't we employ the NSA to provide value here, by tracing back the few swatters that are responsible for the majority of these events? We know they have the capability.
- bb88 9y agoPersonally, while I feel it's not pre-meditated murder, I do feel like it's involuntary manslaughter. I would like to see him get 10 years minimum without access to a phone or outgoing communications.