6 ms·
Chemists provide theoretical interpretation to understand chemical reactions
- isoprophlex 9y agoIs it me or is this article especially poorly worded? It took me a little too much effort to figure out what this figure caption even means: > Negative ions typically have a geometry that is very close to the transition state of the corresponding neutral reactions CH3OHF anion is prepared and de-ionized with laser light. It dissociates into methanol and F radial, under very slight changes of the involved molecular geometries...?
- nickelbox 9y agoIt does seem to be rather poorly written, e.g. the next paragraph > they actually don't follow Newton's Law, they follow Schrodinger's Law so that theory is what we call quantum mechanics. The quantum mechanical interpretation tells scientists a lot of insights.
- QAPereo 9y agoPhys.org is a roaring dumpster fire, and frankly the domain should never show up on HN. If it’s on phys.org, they found it somewhere, and that original source will be far better than the half-assed version on phys.org. Actual original paper... https://www.nature.com/articles/nchem.2804 https://www.nature.com/articles/nchem.2804
- maxerickson 9y agoThe content at the phys.org link was written by the University of New Mexico press shop (see my other comment).
- QAPereo 9y agoAnd? HN deserves better... click on the DOI link at least and submit that, not this garbled secondhand trash.
- maxerickson 9y agoMy point is mostly that the problem is larger than phys.org. UNM itself is the source of the lesser article. That phys.org just aggregates material available elsewhere is also an additional reason not to link it. It's suggested to link original articles (in a different sense than you are using) in the submission guidelines.
- QAPereo 9y agoYou’re certainly not wrong, and the endless parade of press releases and aggregators of press releases are indeed, terrible. Having said that however, I’ve never come across a site as popular and worthless as Phys.org (edit: in this space at least). The AAAS, iiie and other maintain decent aggregators, or the original is best.
- curlcntr 9y agoI can relate to their enthusiasm. For a pchem thesis my advisor was seeing unexpected experimental results and asked me to try explaining from first principles. I started with Schrodinger's equation, let the math do the work, and wound up with a fairly reasonable match. Looking back on it now, perhaps I had a few too many free variables (J Neumann – “with four parameters I can fit an elephant…”). In any case, to me, it was so cool to see how such a fundamental equation connects to very complex experimental processes.
- comicjk 9y agoComputational chemist here. The phys.org article is a pretty bad rendering of the original paper. The "theoretical interpretation" described in the headline is nothing new. The actual scientific advance described in the paper is an experimental (not theoretical) technique for measuring transition states of molecules, involving making them very cold so the transition states last longer. This lets us verify some quantum mechanics predictions, but we already had a lot of verification. Calculating small-molecule reaction paths via quantum mechanics has been a standard part of theoretical chemistry for decades. We can do it at a very high level of accuracy using millions of CPU hours, or at a passable level of accuracy using thousands of CPU hours. Big molecules are still a challenge because the scaling of the accurate methods is very bad (N^4 or worse, where N is the number of electrons!). These calculations are something that quantum computers could theoretically do much better than classical ones.
- maxerickson 9y agophys.org just aggregates university press releases: https://news.unm.edu/news/unm-chemists-provide-theoretical-interpretation-to-understand-chemical-reactions https://news.unm.edu/news/unm-chemists-provide-theoretical-i... The author info from that link: Steve Carr Supervisor, Communications University of New Mexico
- crocal 9y agoThe article is poorly written but your comment is very clear. This looks totally fascinating. Is there some kind of introductory book you would recommend (graduate level)? One burning question that I would like to ask you is if computational chemistry has ever predicted reactions that had not been discovered before? That would be more than awesome.
- tomjakubowski 9y agoFormer/failed/flamed-out computational chemist right here. I can't give a recommendation, because I forgot which book I used way back when, but the answer depends somewhat on whether you're interested in "large" or "small" structures. Each will use different techniques. Molecular mechanics, which is interested in simulation of big biomolecules and the like, ignore quantum mechanical effects, or use a hybrid of quantum/classical mechanics, because the structures of interest are large enough the QM effects can be approximated away. Other subfields of computational chemistry use only QM, with some approximations to make the programs tractable.
- mike741 9y agoare there non-theoretical interpretations?
- elcritch 9y agoThis title has to be one of the most genericized-press-release titles posted on HN. Almost every other experimental chemistry paper would technically fit this title! Makes you feel for the copy writer trying to write a title for some complex chemistry paper during the holidays. Despite the bland press release title, it’s a pretty interesting experimental chemistry research and the original paper reads well. It’s surprising how clear the (apparent) transition peaks are in the graph data. These reactions occur on such incredibly minuscule timescales it’s amazing to see it so clearly! Interesting: > The PES is fit using the permutation invariant polynomial–neural network (PIP-NN) method [49]. This caught my eye as I recall reading some earlier attempts at NN based polynomial fitting in QM models, but this sounds more advanced. Does anyone know if generalized neural net methods for fitting the potential energy curves are common in QM modeling now? If so, are there limitations to the method that’d prevent adopting it for fitting polynomials in other applications?