4 ms·
Sophomoric essay on the importance of selecting music. Artists make the music. The importance of DJs is overblown. Being a DJ is a trade skill, you work clubs f
by sitkack 9y ago
Sophomoric essay on the importance of selecting music. Artists make the music. The importance of DJs is overblown. Being a DJ is a trade skill, you work clubs for money, your name shouldn't be on the music. Wub Wub pause build.
- rpdillon 9y agoYou may be right. The DJs I really like are also artists/producers (Armin van Buuren and Gareth Emery are on my mind as I say this). That said, I feel bad diminishing the work that went into, for example, Laserface[0]. I didn't attend the NY show, but the set was, for me, amazing[1]. [0]: http://laserface.garethemery.com/ http://laserface.garethemery.com/ [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3gb2gmmTjx8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3gb2gmmTjx8
- sitkack 9y agoIt is important work, part of the ensemble of the delivery, but not the bulk. We also shouldn't let the skill of the outliers paint the flock.
- NovaS1X 9y agoI think good modern DJing includes production in the mix. A lot of the best DJs I know also produce their own music. However, I don't think a DJ is un-important. I think of a DJ like a film-editor. Sure, the editor does not do any of the acting, lighting, or cinematography, but they have immense control over how the film is delivered to the audience, and having a good editor is as important as having a good cinematographer or director. To really control a large crowd in a meaningful way, you can't just throw on a playlist on shuffle, the DJ needs to "edit" the whole set to fit the night.
- na85 9y agoI could make the same (fallacious) argument about web development. Real engineers make the systems and languages that sophomoric code monkeys remix into web sites. React react angular build.
- chillaxtian 9y agoYou would be correct
- dpweb 9y agoThis is remembering experiences about 20 years ago. This is before the modern EDM festivals, in fact before the term "EDM" existed, but I find alot of the music not very different now. House music is very much the same. Just, better sounds now. Much better sounds. There is a skill that the best DJs possess, and its more about the build up and drop that became sooooo common in modern EDM. That used to be saved for a part of the set. Then it became part of every song. First is taste. You have to have good taste. The best club DJs don't just play the popular tracks. They introduce crowds to tracks - and not just the ones they and their friends produced and are debuting. Especially the obscure tracks that are white hot. Second is a feel for the crowd. Coming into a club gig we used to hang out for a few hrs before and get a feel for what the crowd seems to be up for. Tech house, hard, trance vocal stuff, more funky deep stuff.. these are very different styles and even a decent track in the wrong style suited to the crowd can clear the floor. Third, the best DJs would take you on a journey. Over a 60 or 90 or 180 minute set, there's a beginning maybe some interesting tracks, and it builds. Maybe about 1/3 into the set the blazing hot tracks start to drop. Then maybe a deeper journey about 2/3 into the set. Finishing with something very special. This is not the same thing as someone standing there playing music. The best sets are not just a collection of songs. In fact, in small clubs people would often request popular tracks. Not to be entertained. A DJ is not a jukebox. There are skills involved not just related to producing tracks.
- baseten 9y agoA dj never saved your life, and that's alright. My life was never saved in a club. It happened in a muddy field. It happened in a dirty warehouse. There was no bottle service, no valet. I suppose the importance of djs is overblown in the age of the celebrity dj, but there is an underground still out there somewhere.