5 ms·
> The DJ isn’t doing anything there, though. That’s just the breakdown of the four tet remix of Eric Prydz — Opus. He’s just playing it straight. I think that'
by pavel_lishin 9y ago
> The DJ isn’t doing anything there, though. That’s just the breakdown of the four tet remix of Eric Prydz — Opus. He’s just playing it straight.
I think that's the problem with trying to explain this stuff. I don't go to shows like this; to me, a DJ clicking "next" in iTunes is indistinguishable from someone practicing a craft. I just don't know enough, and I think a lot of other commenters in here don't either.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- beamatronic 9y agoA good indicator is no visible electronics other than headphones, turntables and a simple mixing board.
- kev009 9y agoThe easiest way to see authenticity is to seek out producers doing shows. They may play a lot of their own music as well as a curated set of other music. There's an old interview of BT in the 1990s where he thoroughly debunks that he is a DJ even when playing other people's music. He incorporates as much live control and variation as he can handle. BT is a neat guy.. he restored a Fairlight (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairlight_CMI https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairlight_CMI) as well as computers like the IBM PS/2 model 70 to use in his productions so he's a bonafide technologist aside from being a phenomenal classically trained musician. Matt Darey is another that does a good job, invites the vocalists to perform live whenever he can. His radio show is my favorite thing to listen to when doing software development. He's been working with Dolby to incorporate Atmos into new and old productions so he's pushing the state of the art. https://soundcloud.com/mattdarey https://soundcloud.com/mattdarey
- taneq 9y agoI'm a long time fan of BT but the one time I saw him live, it was 3AM in a prime DJ slot and he just wanted to show off his turntablism. Which was technically great, but it was 3AM and we just wanted some banging tunes.
- empath75 9y agoThe hard part isn't clicking 'next', it's picking the songs.
- nradov 9y agoIf the output is good then why does the equipment or technique even matter?
- toast0 9y agoAt the very least, a nice transition between tracks is a skill. Part of that is selecting compatible tracks, part of it is getting the timing right, tweaking speeds, picking when to switch. I usually listen to recorded sets and shows, but I imagine people like live sets for the same reason they like live music: you can see the magic happen, there's a shared experience, and there's some amount of crowd interaction with the performer. Sure, most of the magic happened earlier, when the tracks were recorded, but there's still some magic left. I think there's more to a DJ than an old school film projectionist switching projectors between reels, but maybe the future is premixed sets so nobody has to sit in the booth.
- deadmetheny 9y ago>I just don't know enough, and I think a lot of other commenters in here don't either. That's not going to stop people from pretending they do. DJing well is hard, and it's obvious that most people in this thread have never attempted it before.