8 ms·
For people who don't know what this is (like me), they have a good FAQ explaining "Proof of Stake" vs "Proof of Work": > In proof of work (PoW) based public b
by dmix 9y ago
For people who don't know what this is (like me), they have a good FAQ explaining "Proof of Stake" vs "Proof of Work":
> In proof of work (PoW) based public blockchains (e.g. Bitcoin and the current implementation of Ethereum), the algorithm rewards participants who solve cryptographic puzzles in order to validate transactions and create new blocks (i.e. mining). In PoS-based public blockchains (e.g. Ethereum's upcoming Casper implementation), a set of validators take turns proposing and voting on the next block, and the weight of each validator's vote depends on the size of its deposit (i.e. stake). Significant advantages of PoS include security, reduced risk of centralization, and energy efficiency.
https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/Proof-of-Stake-FAQ https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/Proof-of-Stake-FAQ
- ehsankia 9y agoWouldn't sites like Coinbase which "hold" a huge amount of stake, basically have a huge control over these currencies?
- stouset 9y agoYes, but the simplistic version of the argument is that any entity with such a large stake would be inherently incentivized to preserve the value of the currency and act in good faith. My intuition is that this is a risky proposition. If an entity can benefit themselves $x by making a bad-faith transaction, but it only costs them $y such that $y < $x, it’s rational to do it even if the costs to others are orders of magnitude greater. As a concrete example, if Coinbase double-spent a transaction for $10m and had enough stake to make the network accept this, would it necessarily devalue the currency through loss of trust by enough to make this unprofitable? Is this true for all possible actions by a 51% stakeholder?
- konschubert 9y agoIf somebody holds 51% of the capital in bitcoin (In form of 51% of the mining hardware), he can mount a 51% attack as well.
- papermule 9y agoWouldn’t it be much less than 51% in practice since a lot of Bitcoin is in hardware or non-custodial wallets?
- amadeuspzs 9y agoNo, 51% refers to the active mining pool (who package and validate transactions) vs 51% of the currency itself.
- dukeflukem 9y agoHe certainly could, but that'd be stupid right?
- SturgeonsLaw 9y agoDepends on their intent. It would be silly for an actor who wishes to maintain the value of their holdings, but if their goal was to destabilise the currency, it provides an attack vector.
- exclusiv 9y agoExactly. Like anyone with a ton more at stake if it succeeds like the banking system.
- Sir_Substance 9y ago>Yes, but the simplistic version of the argument is that any entity with such a large stake would be inherently incentivized to preserve the value of the currency and act in good faith. This logic is, as you say, simplistic. Anyone with such a large stake can cash out, and then use their former large stake to fabricate an alternative chain in which they did not cash out, forking the blockchain at the block just before they cashed out. Commonly proposed defenses against this (checkpointing) are limited because when new nodes enter the network, they are in a naive state where they do not know who to trust. In a proof of work system, the entire blockchain can be validated by a naive node. Fraudulent blockchains could be constructed and fed to naive nodes, but they would be obvious forgeries because they would have to be constructed at lower network difficulties in order to generate blocks faster than the real network and become the longest chain. In a proof of stake system, people who formerly had stake in the system can simulate fraudulent alternative histories forked at the point before they cashed out, and feed those histories to naive nodes. If enough naive nodes accept the alternative history, it becomes the accepted chain. The possibility exists that these former stakeholders might use some of their cashed out money to start up many nodes in the cloud and feed their alternative chains to those nodes. The only real way to defend against this is to have trusted nodes coded into the protocol provide bootstrapping data to naive nodes. Once you do that, your network is no longer trustless. Read more here: http://www.cs.cornell.edu/~iddo/CoAslides.pdf http://www.cs.cornell.edu/~iddo/CoAslides.pdf
- rrggrr 9y ago> Anyone with such a large stake can cash out, and then use their former large stake to fabricate an alternative chain in which they did not cash out, forking the blockchain at the block just before they cashed out. A trade this large is likely to crater the currency before it can be filled in the absence of trade volume so large its practically impossible for one stakeholder to act in the manner you describe.
- inimino 9y agoBut if the theory allows the attack, even if it seems impractical, there is likely to be a practical attack that is slightly different.
- ajhurliman 9y agoThey can't stake that ETH because their users may want to pull it out. Staking it means that you make it unavailable for use, and if you try to break the rules while staking you lose it. They could probably stake some of it though, as long as there's no bank run situation.
- JoshTriplett 9y ago> They could probably stake some of it though, as long as there's no bank run situation. If there was even a hint that Coinbase was pulling any "fractional reserve" stunts, they'd lose the massive amount of credibility they have over less reputable exchanges. Reputation is the primary advantage Coinbase has.
- polyomino 9y agoCoinbase does not have a good reputation. Have you been to /r/coinbase?
- ithinkinstereo 9y agoIt's relative; CB's reputation is sterling compared to the other exchanges.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoThe standard answer for where to refer people to so they can buy or sell some coins without even a hint of shadiness or fly-by-night is Coinbase. That doesn't mean that they're perfect, or that nothing ever goes wrong; it means that they're the highest-reputation exchange available, and that their primary selling point is that reputation. Also, people happy with something post about being happy far less often than people angry with something post about being angry, because the latter have a problem/grievance to solve.
- jpatokal 9y agoWe're using different definitions of "reputation" here. Coinbase has a good reputation in that, unlike Mt Gox, it appears to be run by adults and is highly unlikely to get massively pwned or do a runner with your money overnight. But it also has a bad reputation in that their support is abysmal and/or overloaded, and if you run into any sort of trouble with transactions, ID verification etc, it tends to take a very long time to sort out.
- jzoch 9y agoNot only do you need to "stake" your eth for ~a year or so (as is currently proposed), but if you do not act in good faith you burn your entire stake. This incentivizes you to act in good faith. With PoW, you act in good faith since the cost to 51% the network is very high when measured in compute power and electricity, but can be done multiple times and the cost may be worth the end result. The cost here would definitely not be worth it and would not be repeatable.
- GordonS 9y agoWho decides whether you've acted in 'good faith'? Could this mechanism be abused to burn perfectly valid stakes?
- runeks 9y agoThe idea is that, if a staker refuses to include a proof (digital signature) that it has staked on multiple chains, or double spent coins, the network will fork the chain to a new one which includes this proof. How the network will reach consensus on then following this new chain is not clear to me.
- ojr 9y agoCoinbase was operating at a loss last time I check, it's not like they can stake their user's ether funds. Also, the Ethereum addresses they create are intended not to be used for smart contracts
- aphextron 9y agoSo what’s the tradeoff? Is this strictly superior to PoW?
- antome 9y agoWay more energy efficient, but the "centralization" problem just shifts from the mining hardware, to the amount of currency you have. It assumes the majority of stakeholders act in good faith.
- masklinn 9y ago> Is this strictly superior to PoW? No. It's more efficient and simpler, but it requires a somewhat trusted network of good-faith actors. Think of a git repository where the "core team" decides which commit is the new master by signing them, if a quorum (could be 51%, could be 66, whatever) agrees on a commit, it's the new master's HEAD. That's what a PoS is.
- loginx 9y agoThe more you own, the more you get to own, but it's totally less centralized, guys!
- cyberpunk0 9y agoYeah that's pretty much just business as usual monopolistic capitalism. Not in the spirit of decentralization at all
- IIAOPSW 9y agoI'm going to piggyback on your comment to present my unified theory of blockchain proof systems. Start with proof of work. Now imagine that the vast majority of the cost is in the computers and the electricity is basically free. You've just derived proof of stake. Start with proof of work. Now imagine that the vast majority of the cost is in the electricity and computers are basically free. You've just derived proof of burn. Start with proof of burn. Now imagine that each burnt coin gets evenly redistributed to everyone as a dividend. You're back at proof of stake. Start with proof of stake. Now imagine there's an amount of time that you must lock coins away to engage in stakeholding. Now set that time to infinity. You're back at proof of burn.
- na85 9y agoI don't really understand what point you are making.
- heroprotagonist 9y agoI think that's why he called it a 'piggyback'. If it resulted in a lot of conversation, I think it would commonly be referred to as a 'hijack' comment. He just responded to the top comment to try to get people's attention on some unrelated matter.
- raverbashing 9y agoBut is there still a blockchain? How is it secured?
- masklinn 9y ago> But is there still a blockchain? Yes. > How is it secured? By the consensus of the stakeholders. Think git and signatures (blockchains are basically a degeneration of that), people agree what master is by signing the "master" commit, then everybody goes from that. The proof of work of e.g. bitcoin is trust-less, but if you have trust (because you're working with a small group and you have legal regs or whatever) you don't need it, you just need a predefined quorum of stakeholders to agree.
- raverbashing 9y agoNice, thanks for explaining, this makes sense.