6 ms·
> Do men on Instagram contend with this many half-naked dudes and their butts all the time? I really want to know. I really feel for this comment, as women are
by saurik 9y ago
> Do men on Instagram contend with this many half-naked dudes and their butts all the time? I really want to know.
I really feel for this comment, as women are hyper-sexualized and we have a broken culture of stuff that optimizes for the male gaze, and so this is a common complaint.
But this isn't about sexuality, this is about insecurity. These specific ads are only showing skin so they can hit a weak spot in the viewer and break them down to buy stuff.
The same patriarchal cultural BS about what it means to be a real woman also exists as a pressure against men, it just leads to a different set of insecurities.
Example: I feel insecure about losing my hair. I still have hair... and it shouldn't really matter?... but it is thinning :/; and, when I think about it, it makes me sad.
(edit:) To be clear, I mean the kind of "sad" where every time I see myself in a mirror and every time I wash my hair and even if my hair falls a weird way, it hits me. It is an ever-pervasive "insecurity" in my life that I fight with every day, and where I am dreading what it will be like in another two or three years :/.
I manage to forget about it a lot, or even get to a place where I look at myself in a mirror and am like "this is fine... I don't mind how I look today, so I am happy"
But like, one day, I decided to research products and procedures designed to prevent or hide hair loss. I spent hours on it. I didn't end up deciding to do anything.
But the Internet remembers. The Internet now knows that I have an insecurity, and people with an insecurity are profitable. People like me are why ads make money :/.
So now, every few damned days, while going through my Instagram "stories", I am given a sponsored interstitial ad for hair loss prevention products and services.
Fuck you, Instagram.
- askafriend 9y agoThe advertising industry will find a way to do that regardless of the medium - whether it’s Instagram or whether it’s a shitty blog with AdSense on it. Your criticism should probably extend to the way the entire advertising industry conducts it’s operations and that’s a massive discussion with an incredible amount of nuance that we probably couldn’t do it justice here.
- jbrennan 9y agoYeah, it’s too prevalent. We best not talk about it.
- askafriend 9y agoNo, we can talk about it - my point was that the conversation is probably more easily had in person or via blogposts where guard-rails can be set so people don’t talk over or past each other. When the topic is so vast, it’s more useful to have specific debate than to have armchair musings back and forth. It’s just more difficult of a conversation to be carried out in the latter form.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoDo some online mattress shopping. Load different mattresses into your cart and abandon. Etc, etc. The internet might not forget that you care about hair loss, but the mattress stores will outbid the hair-loss companies.
- patcon 9y agoOh god. I appreciate your comment, but something about this advice gets me. Is this sort of thing what _literacy_ is now...
- cinquemb 9y agoYeah, I share the same sentiment. Learned a bit more about online ad bidding dynamics, but will continue to browse the internet with JS/cookies disabled by default as well as spoofing info on every request from user agents related to what api's are available with my custom build on a fork from firefox nightly.
- manicdee 9y agoSo you are attempting to evade tracking by being uniquely identifiable?
- cinquemb 9y agoThe information is "real" in that it is information that has been collected from a sampling of browsers of users from over the internet, or particular subset from local users connected to a nearby public network(s). As long as I'm not logging into something that would personally identify me, for all intents or purposes, I might as well be any number of the people around me connected to a network that I sampled. So even if I enabled javascript/cookies/etc, at worst I would be delivered a sampling of the ads the people around me (or the data that I sampled) were being sent. I'm also, not on facebook/instagram/twitter etc, so I avoid the downsides of the social media bubble all together. If I "need" to use such services, I'd just create a dummy account, and discard it after. It's not so much to evade tracking (although it can be effective in some instances), but to dirty the waters/avoid the feedback loop from tracking via ads delivered or the parasitic choices (or lack their of mostly) of others who just do nothing and jump head first into the next available skinner box. Not like it would be impossible for a nation state actor to move against me.
- rayiner 9y ago> The same patriarchal cultural BS about what it means to be a real woman also exists as a pressure against men, it just leads to a different set of insecurities. I think that's a false equivalence. I'm hoping not to lose my hair, but I also kind of don't give a shit. I didn't grow up with society telling me how important it was to "look my best so I feel my best!" How often do you think Bill Gates thinks about his liver spots? John McCain probably hasn't thought of his hairline in decades. Because society really does not give a shit what men look like, unless they're in one of the few fields where looking good is part of their job. The closest correspondence is maybe with the focus on guys being good at sports. Yeah, that kind of sucked in middle school, but it's been two decades since anyone cared whether I could make a basket. Heck, even if I was great at basketball now, nobody would give a shit.
- saurik 9y agoI agree. My point was not that it is equivalent in scope (as the kinds of insecurities we foist on women are just brutal), but that I don't think that we would expect to see it come up as simply "half naked men". I am also "overweight" (at the borderline for being clinically "obese", even), but it isn't something that haunts me every day and makes me question if I will ever be valued as a person again when I look in a mirror the same way we do with women.
- MollyR 9y agoMaybe to you, but the younger generation is different. My cousin is a psychiatrist at a college, who has wishes there was a cure to baldness because so many young men become suicidal from balding. The social media generation values looks very very highly.
- nostrademons 9y agoThe closest correspondence is men being financially successful, along with all the skills and status symbols that entails. Notice that we're providing free content marketing for an organization whose value proposition is "we'll help you get rich". Men are not immune at all.
- 9y ago
- throwaway2016a 9y agoI don't know about Instagram because I don't use it but I'm a guy and I've looked up a dumbell or two on Amazon and read some articles about getting fit and consequently I am actually often hit with ads featuring men with perfect abs, great pecs, and huge arms and legs. As an slightly overweight guy with no abs and skinny arms (what is now called a "dad bod"), while I do not personally feel insecure seeing these ads I can see why people would. I feel like the general response to woman being objectified has been to even the playing field by also objectifying men. "Oh? There are too many woman butts in movies? We'll fix it... lets start showing lots of male butts too." With that said, only one of those ads I feel "sexualized" women. Most of them were less racy than the Macy's catalogs I used to sneak a peak at when I was 6 before the Internet. I only see completely non-sexual fitness and clothing ads in this article.
- tomc1985 9y agoHow are you going to sell bras without showing some skin? I'd imagine fit and look, as seen on a real person, are paramount in driving purchases.
- chillacy 9y agoFor that matter, the packaging on men's underwear is pretty sexualized too... always made me feel weird buying it. I just want comfortable underwear :<
- user5994461 9y agoShowing ads with a similar body, age and colour to the user might drive sales better.
- Spivak 9y agoThis already happens to an extent but with sex, age, race, and lifestyle taken into account but it's usually still a conventionally attractive model. You're absolutely right that it increases sales.
- user5994461 9y agoI am pretty sure that showing repulsive models would drive sales down. So, stuck with showing okay looking models, at worst.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoI was in highschool when a girl commented to me, "You are going bald." The next couple of years were rough, but eventually, I just owned it. Sure, I'd probably rather have hair than not, but it is what it is. Now in my very early 40s, my beard is more grey than not. Apparently hair doesn't like me. Now I see people with hair all the time in commercials, and in real life. Doesn't bother me. But if I were targeted over and over by ads trying to make me feel bad about being bald, and just go get hair plants already, well...I would not like that at all.
- cannonedhamster 9y agoHell don't even get into the bugaboo that things like Propecia and Rogaine do to make it hard for some men to perform. That right there should be a warning on the damned side of the bottle. Want to talk about something that gives two people body issues, that can be crippling.