7 ms·
The 3DO: The birth of my cynicism
- vidoc 9y agoIt's not just well written, it's actually quite ballsy too as I am currently acknowledging to myself how I would never ever have the courage to come clean and come up with a blog post explaining how I bought the Atari Jaguar in the 90s, and ended up basically in the same situation.
- tsunamifury 9y agoAtari Jaguar, 3DO, Neo-Geo, and WebOS and other assorted platform failures along with the successes of OSX, Android, iOS, Xbox, psx, and nintendo left a strong imprint on why and how I develop software platforms. I learned you can’t just promise radical new opportunities, you have to have them ready and usable on launch day. This allows users to buy in on day one and be generally happy. Then this motivates third party developers which then snowballs into more users and then the platform achieves takeoff velocity. Ultimately all successful platforms are a collective ecosystem experience, but they start just between the user and the first party developer. Teams like Occulus are falling down the same trap as 3DO, promising lots of new expertise’s but demonstrating little to no day-one practicality.
- monksy 9y ago> promising lots of new expertise’s but demonstrating little to no day-one practicality. That exactly describes why I can't stand the MVP trend.
- tsunamifury 9y agoProperly practiced, the MVP concept should narrow your product direction to achieving pretty much only the day one practical functionality, with any promises beyond that being cut. But practically I see that many can’t quite get there and end up with real functionality promised down the line and useless features delivered in an mvp.
- bbarn 9y agoThe V is for viable, but too many people seem to never get past the M.
- monksy 9y agoOh no, they totally get the minimal part.
- DiThi 9y ago> Teams like Occulus are falling down the same trap as 3DO Did you try any game like Lone Echo? It's so good it's the only game I broke my "not buying exclusives" rule with (I have a Vive). I paid for about 30-40 VR games in Steam, so it's not exactly a 3DO. It's spelled Oculus, by the way.
- detcader 9y agoThis sort of story just happened en masse with Destiny 2 players. The game ($60) as a social multiplayer space kind of hit a dead end after everyone beat the campaign, with further milquetoast content gated behind DLC and loot boxes (all paid of course) The whole thing of children being socially incentivized to invest huge amounts of money in devices that might fail for fear they'll be out of the loop with children slightly richer than them is a huge bummer. This problem doesn't really exist for TV, movies, books, and card and board games. I'm starting to wonder if PC and mobile gaming really should win out against Nintendo and Sony, morally... Another good personal story about how we interface with videogame: https://www.polygon.com/2017/7/12/15958318/the-5000-decision-to-get-rid-of-my-past https://www.polygon.com/2017/7/12/15958318/the-5000-decision...
- stinkytaco 9y agoThere was a time when card games were about how much money you had rather than how good you were. Many games have introduced rotation, which has helped, but it's still an ongoing investment in the game and it's still a few hundred just to be competitive on Magic night at your local shop. But they did find the balance point that seems fair. I think video games haven't found that yet. I'm really torn on DLC, game expansions and the like. On one hand, $60 for a new game every year is lots when I could spend $25 on a game I already enjoy. But on the other, it's an excuse to limit content up front in order to milk users. I think it's a matter of perception and companies that find a fair balance will be successful.
- 2muchcoffeeman 9y agoContinuously buying booster packs is only a problem only with games like Magic. There are lots of card games where you just buy a base set and an expansion now and again. And the vast majority of board games don’t require constant investment.
- slantyyz 9y agoI bought Dropmix for my niece for Christmas. It's an NFC-based card game made by Harmonix and Hasbro. It's actually an interesting music mixing game that works really well... but.. While it comes with 60 cards, the biggest criticism that I've seen about the game is how expensive the booster kits are and how they are packaged. To get all aspects of a song, you may have to buy multiple booster packs. I get that the song rights are built into the cost, but they cost as much or more than individual songs do off iTunes, and one card usually has only one part of a song (i.e. vocals, guitar, percussion, etc).
- et1337 9y agoSome video games are great. Video game culture is... not great. I think this guy is upset with the culture and companies in gaming rather than the games themselves. Surprised he didn't say anything about loot boxes.
- detcader 9y agoHe did say that many games are great on their own. But isn't it an inherent feature of console gaming itself, that young people need to invest tons of money to keep up with their peers, taking on the potential risk of the console's failure?
- toast0 9y agoSo, I think there's a couple ways to look at it. If you have (nearby) friends who play, and you're dealing with physical games; if you get a console around when they do, you can share newer games and reduce the risk of buying terrible games at full price. You'll probably buy some of the great games at full price so you can do multiplayer games though. If you don't hang out with people who play, you can just buy a year late, and get the benefit of lower prices, more finished games, and a clear indication of what's cool and what isn't. You might miss out on online features/community, but that really depends. Was it stupid to buy the 3DO for $700? Probably. But, it wasn't much more than the Neo Geo home console, and the games were probably cheaper?
- cortesoft 9y agoI don't quite follow the point the author is trying to make. He had an experience where something he paid a bunch for turned out to be nearly worthless, so now he hates all video games? But not really, he just doesn't like the industry? It sounds to me like he is just cynical in general. I am mid-thirties, have been playing video games since the 80s, and still love them with the same enthusiasm as when I was a kid. Sure, I play a lot less. I don't have nearly as much time, with a full time job, a wife, and a kid. It is still my go-to free time activity, though. My buddies, married with children themselves, and I play together online one night a week. It is our way of maintaining our social bond through families and living far apart. We are closer because of games than we would ever be otherwise.
- falsedan 9y agoThis is typical gonzo-style new games journalism which was popularised on the Insert Credit forums, Brandon Sheffield’s pre-Gamasutra gig. The main thrust is to share the thoughts and feelings you had when experiencing some game-related event in prefence to a logocentric review.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI took it as a story about his journey to maturity. As a young lad he saw only one aspect of gaming, the part that focused on entertainment. As he got older he saw more of the 'cost' of that entertainment, and it was summed up by taking the majority of the video games he owned and their consoles and selling them, to buy one super console, only to have that choice turn out to be shockingly expensive. He not only saw the 'value' of his console drop more than 90% he saw that he had 'lost' a bunch of things he cherished (his collection) which he would still have had he kept them. The economic reality that he had essentially sold his 'collection' for $50 really affected his self image. And rather than say "Gee, that was stupid! I sure learned my lesson!" he finds he has to take it out on the video game industry that 'tricked' him into giving them all of that personal wealth in exchange for what was now perceived as crap. Some people don't recover from that sort of shock, some do. Hopefully at some point the author will forgive himself for allowing his love of the vision that 3DO presented to cost him so dearly.
- kodablah 9y agoWas just reading about the 3DO because I was gonna write an emulator. Wikipedia and others point to steep price tag, the spec-only-third-party hardware approach, and that they didn't collect many royalties from the games as the reasons for the downfall of the 3DO. But as I looked around and read, it seemed they were super proud and stingy with the tech (expensive devkits iirc), and the tech was about 2 years too early and just a bit before the 3D revolution that came with 5th gen consoles.
- MBCook 9y agoThere’s just no getting around the price. It was (inflation adjusted) $1200 plus games. Remember when gamers were upset the PS3 was $600 even though it was also a Blu-ray player? Remember when the Xbox One tripped out of the gate because it was $500 and not $400 like the PS4? $1200. There were other mistakes. You’re right development was expensive. It wasn’t as powerful as the PS and Saturn that came later much cheaper (the Saturn was also considered too expensive at $400... which was $300 less than the 3DO). They didn’t have pre-built franchises to lean on like Mario or Sonic. But MAN was it expensive.
- slantyyz 9y agoIt didn't have Mario or Sonic, but looking back, you could argue that it laid the foundation of next generation of EA (like 'em or hate 'em) titles. FIFA and Road Rash were vastly better on the 3DO than they were on 16 bit machines at the time. I remember being in awe of how great FIFA was on the 3DO, and the 3DO version of Road Rash was easily my favorite version of that game. If I'm not mistaken, Need for Speed was first introduced on the 3DO. I remember there being quite a few good games on 3DO (mostly from EA and Crystal Dynamics), including what might have been the closest thing to an arcade version of Super Street Fighter 2 turbo. But yeah, the 3DO was ridiculously expensive. Having said that, so was the Neo Geo home console. I had a few friends who were really into the SNK 2d fighting games at the time, and they'd be plunking well over $100 per cartridge.
- MBCook 9y agoIt was affectively EA’s console, they tried to support it well. And it was obviously WAY more powerful than the 16 bit machines. NeoGeo at least had an argument, it was literally an arcade board you could buy at home. To the group of gamers who wanted that stuff there was a strong reason for it to exist and an explanation for its cost. If they had gotten a couple of killer titles maybe it could’ve done better. Or if the price had fallen faster before the system was declared “dead“ by the public. But by the time that happened it was just too late. $700 was three SNESes and a game or two at the SNES launch price. But this was three years later so you could probably buy a few more games. It was just an obscene amount of money, especially for what was still considered a “kids toy” until more into the PS2 and XBox.
- perfmode 9y ago> It really is kind of irresponsible and sort of dumb in a way to buy a console really early in its lifespan. But maybe that's what it is to like things. Being a little bit dumb - believing in something, even when maybe you know you shouldn't. So true.
- Pica_soO 9y agoIt would be interesting if this could be quantified into a hard number- the damage hype does to the overall market, by disillusioning players.Seems marketing is not a victimless crime after all.
- brians 9y agoThe author shows us how he felt, and tells us “this is what it’s like to like things.” But that doesn’t seem right at all. I like reading books, and I like watching some shows and playing video games. I’m not invested in owning them, or in the community experience of watching what everyone else recently has. This is what it’s like to define your identity by what you own and by what you participate in. Like a Cubs fan, maybe—you can do that, and you can care about winning, and you can care about having popular opinions, but maybe you should pick one of those three.
- sametmax 9y agoReading the title I though it would be talking about 3D0, the team behind Heroes of Might and Magic, and how they screw up the HOMM3 steam remake because they lost the source code. I could have related since it's one of my favorite game ever :)
- cdevs 9y agoOn the other end of this emotional spectrum I have always loved watching games evolve with me and what you think is now the best is kids stuff compared to what comes next. Mortal kombat and doom enraged parents at the time and now the stuff we can render at 60+ frames a second would blow people away in the 80s. Part software evolution and part hardware coming together each year to push the envelope, more sprites, more triangles more pixels more frames. I can afford whatever system I want now but when I was a kid a 180$ sega was like winning the lottery.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y ago> now the stuff we can render at 60+ frames a second would blow people away in the 80s It has blown away people who got started on '80s hardware. In particular, I'm pretty sure that Jeff Minter has made comments specifically saying how amazed he was at the sheer per-pixel computational power on the Xbox 360.
- mmjaa 9y agoI remember a time when the only way to play video games on my computer was, if I programmed them myself. Like, there literally wasn't any other way .. the system I'd chosen to hang my chops on (Oric-1/Atmos) wasn't that well supported by the nascent industry at the time, and so .. it was either write my own shit, or forget about it. So, I grew up a coder. While, in the meantime, my C64- and Amiga- using friends, with all their amazing software choices, didn't have to do anything but consume, consume, consume. And, eventually, "upgrade to a Nintendo" for their gaming needs. See kids, this is what happens when you ship computers that no longer have development tools/compilers/REPL's onboard! Seriously though, I think the "3DO Moment" for me was when I realised I always preferred to spend time with computers if there was a compiler onboard, or some other way to build software for the thing. Anything less is just a door opener.
- zmonkeyz 9y agoFor $750 bucks you did get an arguably perfect version of SF2 Super Turbo. For my friends and I that was amazing.