12 ms·
Guys, unless you are really hot you are just wasting your time on Tinder
- iothetiger 9y agoEven if you are really hot you are wasting your time.
- j_s 9y agoThe methodology shows the position of power that companies collecting data inevitably leverage: Tinder doesn't supply any statistics or analytics about member usage so I had to collect this data myself. The most important data I needed was the percent of men that these females tended to “like”. I collected this data by interviewing females who had “liked” a fake Tinder profile I set up. I asked them each several questions about their Tinder usage while they thought they were talking to an attractive male who was interested in them. Lying in this way is ethically questionable at best (and highly entertaining), but, unfortunately I had no other way to get the required data. Netflix's recently released (Dec 29) Black Mirror season 4 episode 4 "[explored] Tinder and Siri-like technologies": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hang_the_DJ_(Black_Mirror) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hang_the_DJ_(Black_Mirror)
- sulam 9y agoPut yourself in situations where the people you’re attracted to have to spend a fair amount of time talking with you. Initial snap judgements can be overcome after a few hours of interaction. You probably won’t be able to date a celebrity this way (although if you live in LA and work in the film industry, I will adjust my probabilities) — but you can absolutely meet and date attractive people that way. (Why’d you edit out your question? I thought it was interesting!)
- j_s 9y agoThanks, I briefly considered consulting the HN hive mind for alternatives that were not "wasting [...] time" but chose to avoid going off the rails as coming anywhere near "dating tips" often has here in the past. Didn't mean to leave you hanging like that... I guess I need to spend a bit more time before clicking 'add comment' on rising stories. My personal recommendation sounds like a specific subset of yours -- meet people by volunteering, expecting to learn from rejection as the initiator. In-person interaction can overcome the specific shortfall that is the primary topic of this discussion - getting/giving(!) a chance orthogonally to attractiveness. The volunteering bit provides a framework for shared direction and is beneficial well beyond meeting strangers (don't volunteer solely to start relationships!). This comment covered some caveats: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16041801 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16041801
- british_india 9y agoGuys: unless you are model, focus only on your career success. Everything else will not win the attention of the ladies and is a waste of time.
- jschwartzi 9y agoI wonder if the results hold when you're a man looking for other men? I've heard anecdotes from queer friends that online dating apps give them tons of potential dates and hook-ups. I've personally had more success with women that I've met in person, but when I've looked for men on Tinder I've been much more likely to get a match than with women.
- raguuu 9y agoMen with men act like... Men would imagine in it happen with girls, but actually happening. My gay friends at least explain it me this way.
- dawhizkid 9y agoProbably true...I'm gay and have ~2500 matches on Tinder while being pretty discerning (I swipe right maybe 10% of the time). Also agree that if you are just looking for a "hookup" being gay makes it many times easier to do that. Being gay these days pretty great, for many reasons. Almost all of my perceived downsides I felt growing up w.r.t social stigma/discrimination have been mostly eliminated in my day-to-day.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yodsanklai 9y ago> I wonder if the results hold when you're a man looking for other men? I had a gay roommate who was very active on Grindr. He was reasonably attractive. Essentially, he could meet another man within an hour if he wanted too.
- grindr124 9y agoIf you are a guy with a less then average looking face and a hot body on Grindr for example you will get tons of messages to filter through. Just post pics of your body with your face somehow concealed. You will then get tons of messages each time you open the app where you can connect with the hottest prospects. It's interesting as once those hot to attractive guys connect and chat with you a human connection is made and hooking up, becoming friends or becoming occasional sex buddies is highly likely. Of course you need to show your face, so just send your best pics of yourself. I would say Im about average looking, but can take some above average looking pics.
- ellius 9y agoAnecdotally, I don’t think this is true. I was married just before Tinder became a thing, but I have several friends in their mid-to-late twenties who did and still do use it. I know three people who used it to meet their future wives, all of whom are maybe slightly above average attractiveness, and one friend who is frankly very far below average, but has slept with dozens of women (I believe over 50 at this point) by using it. I’m not suggesting any of that is good, bad, whatever, but there are at least four counterexamples all of whom I’d say were happy with the results of using it.
- nasredin 9y ago>It was determined that the bottom 80% of men (in terms of attractiveness) are competing for the bottom 22% of women and the top 78% of women are competing for the top 20% of men. The Gini coefficient for the Tinder economy based on “like” percentages was calculated to be 0.58. This means that the Tinder economy has more inequality than 95.1% of all the world’s national economies. 95%? So there's still a chance! Men are not going to give up that easily. No citation needed. Also his sample size of 27 and self-reporting makes this not very rigorous(?).
- yodsanklai 9y agoI noticed that tinder-attractiveness is very relative. I have virtually no chance to find a date on Tinder in France whereas it's reasonably easy in NYC. And in some places in Asia I'm hugely popular. Overall, regular dating sites always work better than Tinder. I think it's because Tinder is more for casual encounters and a woman can afford to be picky if that's what she's looking for. The supply of men looking for casual encounters is far superior than the demand.
- foepys 9y ago> I have virtually no chance to find a date on Tinder in France whereas it's reasonably easy in NYC This has most likely has nothing to do with Tinder itself but with being from a different country. Especially the French accent is very appealing to American women and being tall (which, as a Westerner, you probably are) is a big plus in Asia. You could walk into any bar and meet women.
- jokoon 9y agoI live in France and I agree, dating apps seem to have a very bad reputation with women here. Surprisingly, I met an American woman, who was here to study for 2 months. She landed 4 days before we met. She was way, way out of my league, both in attractiveness and social class. My English helped a lot. I also met several South American women too.
- carlob 9y agoRe: NYC vs France. I'm gonna assume you're a heterosexual male. NYC is one of the worst market for heterosexual women, because 1. they outnumber guys by a significant amount 2. NYC is very gay friendly, so homosexual males are overrepresented. I have personally observed this difference even in meatspace.
- CommieBobDole 9y agoI'm a little suspicious of the way he keeps referring to men as "men" and women as "females" in the same sentence.
- bonniemuffin 9y agoIn general the word "females" makes me think of Ferengi and redpillers in a very off-putting way, but maybe it's normal in the academic econ literature.
- CamelCaseName 9y agoDefinitely not. I was chewed out on two separate occasions in my Econ undergrad for using "men" and "females".
- NelsonMinar 9y agohew-mahn fee-males
- Chris2048 9y agoAnd this language policing reminds me of antifa extremism in an also off putting way - but why mention if if not to speculate on a potentially insulting label?
- mpfundstein 9y agoYou may overthink something here
- CommieBobDole 9y agoMaybe - could just be an oversight; he definitely uses the neutral "males" and "females" in most of the article. But the whole men/females usage seems to get a lot of representation among men who have novel theories about interaction of the sexes in general and how women should be required by law to have sex with them specifically.
- Spivak 9y ago
- zimablue 9y agoThis is just empirically false, I'm wondering where they made the error. Are they excluding the way that the algorithm matches people? So that if you're in the bottom X% men you're eventually only shown to corresponding bottom X% girls, so that it doesn't feel like you have the low success rate that you would do vs the general population.
- matt-attack 9y agoTheres an algorithm on Tinder? I thought it simply connected people who mutually approved of/liked each other. What more is there?
- bichiliad 9y agoThat's true, but I'm sure there's also an ordering algorithm that optimizes for engagement (i.e. it'll show you people with high scoring profiles first if you haven't been on the app in a while)
- dsr_ 9y agoSample size is 27 responding women. Unless the universe is made up of 3000 women, the error bars are huge.
- kerpele 9y agoAs far as I know men behave the same way and thus this article comes across as misogynous as it tries to portray women as being unfair or something.
- ravenstine 9y agoOne of the problems with Tinder is its nebulous ethos. Is it a dating app or is it a hookup app? It seems to pretend that it's both without committing to either one, which muddies the water and I don't think that works terribly well. Tinder is brilliant in that it focuses entirely on vanity, ego, and lust, far more so than any of its predecessors. Thus, it has taken a large portion of the dating market away from sites like OKCupid, which had virtually nobody on it in the LA area when I last used it nearly a year ago. Once upon a time, I was an overweight nerd with no money, yet I somehow got dates through OKC. Those days are long gone. The only alternative I can recommend is real life. Nothing beats it, and it's the only way you can know you aren't wasting your time. Go to meetups and actually talk to people and figure out how to improve when you screw up. Being able to get to know people, even if they don't end up being dates, is pretty awesome. It means actually having to grow as a person, but I would bet on a higher success rate than with any dating app/website. All dating apps I know of are a joke. Bumble is hilarious because it actually makes an existing problem worse and sells that as a solution; women don't want hundreds of messages from random penises, and they're very unlikely to initiate a conversation.(i don't blame them) Match, Chemistry, PoF, and all those old-school sites are borderline scams that charge a fortune. Match will send you daily emails telling you how many likes(is it "winks"? i can't remember now.) you're getting, but none of that seems to manifest on the site itself. It's the ol' bait and switch.
- k__ 9y agoYes. I'm using dating apps for over 10 years now. Dated 3 women via them. In "real life" I found 12 in that time. But I still do it, every few years I get some nice surprises :)
- mathattack 9y ago3 dates in 10 years? With that kind of yield, I would’ve given up much sooner!
- k__ 9y agoWell, like I said I met about 1.5 women a year and most of them for >1 years so it was okay.
- MollyR 9y agoIsn't it just supply and demand. I know very few women on tinder, but most of my single guy friends are on it.
- nilkn 9y agoI don't think it's this simple. There are actually many women on Tinder. The reality is women are creeped out by many men on dating sites and apps. If you don't believe me, go talk to some women and ask them about their experiences. Or go read the /r/creepypms subreddit, which isn't just concerned with online dating but shows you what women have to deal with online. This pushes them towards only interacting with the most attractive and witty men who create a sense of safety. Whether that sense of safety is false is up for debate, but I do think this is what drives a large amount of inequality in online dating. Men are generally not scared of or creeped out by women they interact with online, so their standards online are closer to their standards in real-life.
- brazzy 9y agoNo idea if it's true, but a commonly heard thing is that most women are on Tinder not with the intention of ever meeting someone via it, instead they (consciously or subconsciously( use it as an ego boost.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoFrom experience, I'd say this is undoubtedly true, but a large number do want go meet and go out.
- foepys 9y agoI also know two women who do exactly that. No man I know is on Tinder etc. for boosting his ego. The odds are incredibly stacked against men, even if the male/female ratio is even.
- empath75 9y agoThis article comes across as extremely creepy and catfishing people on social networks for ‘research’ is not okay.
- draw_down 9y agoMmm, I don’t think I am “hot” but I meet plenty of people from it.
- evilturnip 9y agoI feel like the methodology has a lot of flaws that makes the error bars so large as to make the actual numbers in this study useless: 1. Small sample size 2. Inactive profiles 3. These apps actually adjust the profiles you see based on your attractiveness level. I know they at least categorize attractiveness because I've had this experience when Bumble seemingly had a bug where I would suddenly get a ton of profiles that were clearly super-attractive people, then get a bunch of profiles that were clearly the exact opposite (no profile images, dark or random pictures, and :ahem: not so conventionally attractive people). However, the general point stands: The majority of women will like a minority of men on these apps. As such, as a man, if you want to make this work for you, the basic strategy is to get as highly attractive pictures of you as possible (professional if you can) and pictures of you doing various interesting activities (as opposed to just vanity shots). Then, keep swiping right and follow up on all matches. But don't make this your only source of meeting women, as others suggested, spend a lot of time in places where you can meet women in real life.
- T2_t2 9y agoSo you have an issue with his methodology, and then propose... anecdotal evidence? Hmm...
- shironineja 9y agoThis is why we need Hang the DJ.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoI find it interesting how many people on this site accept the natural gender imbalances between men and women when it comes to dating, yet don't believe these differences extend beyond relationships into things like career choice or leadership seeking tendencies. Why do you think this is?
- darpa_escapee 9y ago> yet don't believe these differences extend beyond relationships into things like career choice or leadership seeking tendencies What evidence can you provide that would lead someone to believe this?
- forkLding 9y agoThis is a shameless plug, but I created an IOS dating service based on your facebook friends, close mutual friends and soon to add people around you within 100m radius and you would meet at events so basically operates as similar as to people you would actually like and meet in real life, later on will provide searching people capabilities instead of swiping. Please do check it out if you're interested and provide feedback. Anything is appreciated! Heres the appstore link: appsto.re/ca/SfGTib.i
- cdcarter 9y agoI just warn you to remember the downfall of "People you may know" ... if there's somebody that I have 500 mutual friends with, theres a good chance I know them and am not a friend for a reason.
- forkLding 9y agoYep, understand. Thanks for the feedback. Its more about actual intimacy because harder to find a connection using Tinder because communication is first about building up intimacy whereas people you may know tend to have more of an earlier connection.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoAny guy who complains about their attractiveness being the limiting factor is relying too much on that. I've got a friend who is a handsome guy but is not "hot" and he's basically a hobbit, but he's gone on half a dozen or more dates trough Tinder and has no problem matching and talking to women because he's a funny and considerate and talented guy and it is obvious. If you're having trouble with matches, maybe you aren't very interesting, or you don't signal it in the right way. Quit complaining and get to work.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoIt doesn't specify that "attractiveness" is limited only to physical appearance. It defines attractiveness based solely on what portion of women swipe right, so by that definition your friend would probably qualify as above average attractiveness.
- _greim_ 9y agoThis seems to go against the popular notion that men tend to value visual signals of attractiveness, whereas women tend to value non-visual signals of attractiveness. It's been a long time since I took Psych 101. Does anyone know, has this idea ever been discredited, from a statistical standpoint? I guess the discrepancy could also be caused by selection effects, i.e. what kind of people use Tinder, and/or what frame of mind are they in when they use it.
- pedrosorio 9y agohttp://www.ehbonline.org/article/S1090-5138(17)30315-X/fulltext http://www.ehbonline.org/article/S1090-5138(17)30315-X/fullt...
- rflrob 9y agoThe sheer conventional-ness of that idea makes me doubt it (but I don’t know of any data one way or the other), but the article doesn’t strongly contradict or support the idea that women tend to be interested in “non-physical” attributes. There are visual signals of wealth/socio-economic status that you can send with a picture as well. All you need to posit is that there is some kind of attractiveness signaling you can do with a photo, and then the next step (not taken here) is to figure out what that is.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Researchers at Griffith University in Queensland examined what factors most influenced female attraction to males and found that physical strength reigned supreme. "After surveying 150 women, they concluded that they could almost predict how attractive a man was based on three things: how physically strong he looks, how tall he is and how lean he is..." http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/love-sex/women-stronger-men-attraction-looks-muscles-weak-study-dating-a8105976.html http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/love-sex/women-stron...
- expertentipp 9y agoDoes Tinder catalyze any real life hookups at all? At best it's an awkward chat. Over here it's simply fake profiles (I'm a man, looking for a woman). Various creeps, scammers, "researchers" fishing for god knows what. The profiles are insolent - one profile photo no description, photo of a computer screen, "I'm lost, new in the city, show me around" descriptions. It's quite obvious that there is no woman behind the profile. The few "real" profiles are oftentimes connected with Instagram profile - coverage of the person's gym/professional activities, the profile is basically part of person's online brand/presence and in this case the real life hookup is not the goal either.
- thirdsun 9y agoIn my experience it definitely leads to dates, hookups and relationships. While there will be the occasional fake profile or someone who tries to boost their instagram account, it‘s rather rare in my area and easy to distinguish from users with actual dating intentions, regardless of how serious they are.
- chillacy 9y agoI've met plenty of couples who met on tinder, so it does for sure. If you're having a bunch of awkward chats, I dunno, look up some example chats on reddit and see if that's different than what you're doing or if you just perceive all chats as awkward.
- expertentipp 9y agoI hope women look up the chats on reddit as well and will know how to proceed!
- evo_9 9y agoI have an idea for a new twist on a dating site that I don't have the time/energy to write... if anyone is interested in working on this PM me and we can discuss. Bonus if you live in Denver/Boulder area.
- Chris2048 9y agoHow will anyone know if they are interested if you don't write it?
- evo_9 9y agoSo people can’t be bothered to pm me yet I should toss out a side project idea I can just as easily crank out in my own should I decide too? And I’m downvotes because I prefer to keep this private? Fucking unreal.
- Chris2048 9y agoYes. What does the fact you could do it on your own matter? You can't be bothered to even describe your idea. Why should anyone care to pm You? You never said you wanted to keep it private, you explicitly said your couldn't be bothered to describe it...
- chillacy 9y agoIt's definitely a filtering strategy that scammers use to filter out all but the easiest to dupe (hence why Nigerian Prince scams are so obvious). http://www.businessinsider.com/why-nigerian-scam-emails-are-obvious-2014-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/why-nigerian-scam-emails-are-... By making the opportunity purposefully vague, only those who are extremely open to the opportunity (or desperate) would send a PM. Not sure if it ever works, but the internet is a big place.
- mirimir 9y agoBut here's the thing. You don't actually want relationships with people who are choosing based on appearance.
- ThrowAway3456 9y agoBut everybody is...
- orasis 9y ago“the bottom 80% of men (in terms of attractiveness) are competing for the bottom 22% of women and the top 78% of women are competing for the top 20% of men.” Female sexual selection is a powerful force that creates the male dominance hierarchy.
- nkkollaw 9y agoMy friends have a lot of success on Tinder. Both guys use it to find one-night-stands, and women to find friends with benefits or one-night-stands. It is definitely not a dating app where you'll easily find someone to marry, but like anything else.
- jhiska 9y ago>Tinder doesn't supply any statistics or analytics about member usage so I had to collect this data myself. The most important data I needed was the percent of men that these females tended to “like”. I collected this data by interviewing females who had “liked” a fake Tinder profile I set up. I asked them each several questions about their Tinder usage while they thought they were talking to an attractive male who was interested in them. Lying in this way is ethically questionable at best (and highly entertaining), but, unfortunately I had no other way to get the required data. Unreliable conclusions derived from unreliable "data" that was obtained unethically (and probably illegally; did the pictured guys knew their picture was being used?). We're back at "my guess is as good as any other".
- poisonarena 9y agohere in Colombia it is a really only a vehicle for prepagos(prostitutes)..
- lilfatbitch 9y agoIt's time to let yourself learn the truth https://youtu.be/5tuf59ex-U0 https://youtu.be/5tuf59ex-U0 It's time to give up
- firethief 9y ago> I have to assume that in general females find the same men attractive. I think this is the biggest flaw in this analysis, but currently there is no other way to analyze the data. This seems like little more than an exploration of the ramifications of that massive assumption. It would only take a small amount of variation in preferences to make the concept of a "top 20%" inapplicable.
- mclightning 9y agoIf you are worried about wasting your time, go for Tinder Gold. Then you don't need to swipe anymore. Just pick from who likes you.
- Schiphol 9y agoOn the other hand, if you are a woman Tinder is an unbeatable proposition.
- IdontRememberIt 9y agoThese figures really depend on the region/country and the class age. In some class ages (older) and region/country (more conservative), the figures tend to go in favore of the men.