9 ms·
Keynesian Economics Is Hot Again
- qubex 9y agoI read economics at the very epicentre of Keynesianism (LSE) in the heady years in the overheated run-up to the Great Recession (1999-2003), but I must say that there was no sense of his teachings being in any way obsolete: in some sense, there was a critique of his orthodoxy (I remember an accurate quip to the effect that The General Theory of Employment, Interest, & Money was not general, nor a theory, but a collection of cobbled-together maxims and heuristics), and there was the not unreasonable notion that his observations needed grounding (e.g., with agent-based modelling), but Keynes’ status had not been called into question. If anything, in fabled Third Way Cool Britannia, there was a concerted effort to confirm his relevance in the face of apparent success of the neo-classicists. Time bore him out, of course, and the Austerity policies that set in right thereafter pretty much have served as confirmatory particle-accelerators of the economists’ creed.
- tarikjn 9y agoI believe it is a bit too early to declare it a success. Can we exclude that it is not accelerating rising cost of living and economic inequality, and the general weakness of the middle class? Also, what is top-down imposed austerity with no option of bankruptcy? To me it is also a form of Keynesianism. The general consensus is that things are headed in a better direction for Iceland or Detroit than they are for Greece.
- qubex 9y ago”Austerity with no possibility of bankruptcy” doesn’t strike me as anything doctrinarian, really. As for declaring it a non-success, and bemoaning, the supposed death of the middle class, you couldn’t be more wrong: it might be faltering in the West, and we might observe a local pressure upon the middle class, but in the Far East (China, India) the latter is very much ascendant.
- lifty 9y agoAre you suggesting that the rise of the middle class in the Far East was caused by monetary policy? If you do, then I would have to disagree with you. It seems to me more likely that it was caused by the increase in global trade and the massive transition of the means of production from west to east.
- qubex 9y agoYes, I am — and that growth of the Eastern middle class is itself a (probably involuntary) product (or side-effect) of monetary policy of the net importers (the West): in a protectionist context, globalism wouldn’t have taken hold, and ”Factory China” wouldn’t have arisen if protectionist paradigms had been dominant.
- Nokinside 9y ago'Keynesian' is not strongly tied to Keynes the person or his thinking or writings. Keynesian's have buried Keynes long time ago. Anti-Keynesians are still carrying his corpse around. Neo-Keynesian theories formulated and grounded Keynes's ideas better than he did and the field moved on. Today New classical macroeconomics and New Keynesian macroeconomics contribute methods to each other. 'Keynesian' today is just tendency or general direction. If you want to spot dead ends in the economic thinking, you must look at schools who study the teachings of the founder and never improve upon them ('X said', 'X thought') Keynesian economics is not one of them.
- qubex 9y agoQuite true. Modern ’Keynesians’ took his imprimatur and ran with it, they did not fossilise themselves upon the dicta of the Great One. That’s why it remains relevant today (at least in some guise or another) and why it incorporates methods the totemic founder would have never even contemplated (agent-based modelling, behaviourist economics, and globalisation).
- cmurf 9y agoGalambosians. Anarcho-capitalists. More extreme by far than anti-government libertarians. http://www.harrybrowne.org/articles/Galambos.htm http://www.harrybrowne.org/articles/Galambos.htm
- tim333 9y ago>Anti-Keynesians are still carrying his corpse around. The thing I've seen more is Keyenes ideas got adopted by left wingers and used as a justification to expand government and then the anti-keynesians react against that. The actual Keyenes was quite capitalistic and his ideas are not incompatible with small govenment.
- conanbatt 9y agoThe Great Recession is 2007-2009. Also we have to bear in mind Keynes was a free market ideologue, and said taxes should be at tops 25% of GDP. Keynes truly helped model how to get out of recession, but he did not know the danger of government not being able to go back to a smaller state. Hayek and Friedman were more confident that it was a bad path.
- dnautics 9y agoCan you give an example of one of these austerity policies? So far as I can tell, no country after the great recession has decreased their soverign debt load (as in, budget surplus, not deficit reduction). Moreover, an austerity policy is terrible for the working class if you choose to direct it at social services instead of directing it at greasing cronies, which so far as I can tell is what every country that has undergone "austerity" has done.
- asar 9y agoWhenever I read longer articles on macro economic theories it feels like torture. Overly complicated explanations, the urge to model every event and attach a probability to it. A while back this was on the hn frontpage https://aeon.co/essays/how-economists-rode-maths-to-become-our-era-s-astrologers https://aeon.co/essays/how-economists-rode-maths-to-become-o... Definitely put things into perspective for me.
- thisisit 9y agoOne problem I have with economics is the tendency to proclaim proof after just one data point and that too in hindsight. Just like this particular article is doing. It proclaims people doubted government can simulate growth and now recession has proven them wrong. Isn't it in hindsight and just one data point?
- qubex 9y agoThe real problem with economics (as perceived by somebody that first studied applied mathematics, and then macroeconomics, and then went into management) is that it styles itself an annex of mathematics, but lacks the invariants necessary to construct the deep symmetries typical of physics or other hard sciences. We literally have nothing to work with other than those superficial relationships econometricians can measure and somehow boost into statistical significance.
- dnautics 9y agoHave you seen economic equations from, say an econ 3XX class? There's variables all over the place, under a fraction, inside an exponent, with zero regard to dimensional analysis or what meaning conversion constant ought to have (or the numerical tolerances of those equations). Then you take a derivative of that formula.
- qubex 9y agoYes I have. Your observations are not universal but pretty common. The whole field is littered with a hodge-podge of cobbled-together numerical coincidences fetishised to the level of universal truths. It can be quite embarrassing when one sits down and tries to actually do defensible, provable mathematics. That is why I eventually migrated towards management (of the family firm, not coincidentally). Much of macroeconomics, at least most of it prior to the agent-based models now being produced and analysed, is notionalism.
- acd 9y agoEconomics is a science where the researchers often assume how the world works as opposed to measure how things works in reality. Economics is sometimes dressed up with mathematics but it is still a soft science. In other sciences such as mathematics and physics you have to prove how things works. You cannot just make up an arbitrary model and say this is how we think it works. Consumer credit is created by keynesian now abundant that is owned by richest percent. Thus many the middle class are now debt slaves to the rich percent. This also goes for house pricing which is what caused the last economic crisis. Keysnian economics does not take into account that printing new money, the new money does not directly go into salary inflation, it goes to factory automation. Factory automation decreases the price of goods and are thus deflationary. Software is also automation which again will have a deflationary force. One robot replaces on average 5.7 humans. To sum it up Keysanism make the richest one percent richer and most everyone else poorer. The way Keysnaism does this is by central banks printing new debt out of nothing that the richest percentage then owns. Whats the next bubble Keynesian economics is going to create trillions of Hedge funds that may burst or subprime auto loans?
- forapurpose 9y ago> You cannot just make up an arbitrary model and say this is how we think it works. Perhaps it's meant as hyperbole, but that doesn't happen in economics. Models are not arbitrary, but the result of years of hard work based on generations of research. And then the models are tested and retested against reality. Some problems, such as economics, are important to solve even though the universe does not make it easy for us with an abundance of objective data. 'Why are food prices rising worldwide' is a bit more complicated than 'why does one body fall toward another body of greater mass', but it's just as important.
- qubex 9y agoI’m an applied mathematician turned macroeconomist: what you accuse in your first two paragraphs is true, but it is not for want of trying. We just lack the invariants and symmetries that physicists luxuriate in. We literally have nothing more to work with than what statistics can measure, typically as ambiguous time-series with dozens of aggregate variables subject to wide observation errors and biases. It’s pretty awkward, and we’re very much aware of it.
- unholiness 9y agoMacroeconomics novice here. From what I can tell, these two economic theories rely on competing assumptions. Keynesian economics is the theory that results from assuming the size[0] of an economy will closely follow the amount of aggregate demand. Neoclassical economics is the theory that results from assuming the size of an economy will closely follow the amount of aggregate supply. In microeconomics there is no such duality. Rather, there is an understanding that supply and demand are each elastic with respect to one another. We measure this and reason amount markets while thinking about two explicit quantities: the elasticity of demand and the elasticity of supply. The two numbers (and the ratio between them) will tell you a lot about the effects that various conditions will have on a market. My question is: Is there a corresponding concept of e.g. "the elasticity of aggregate demand" in macroeconomic theory? If so, could articles like this be made more objective by providing concrete measurements of this figure on some time scale, rather than subjectively stating things like "Keynesian economics is hot again"? If not, what prevents or complicates the existence of such a quantity? [0] Please correct me if I am misusing this or any other economic terms and concepts
- BenoitEssiambre 9y ago>If not, what prevents or complicates the existence of such a quantity? I'm not an expert either but this type of thing is incredibly hard to measure not only because of the constantly changing external forces from changing governments, technological progress, "animal spirits" etc., these things alone would make it nearly impossible, but there is also the role of money creation and very imperfectly run central banks around the world destabilizing things even much more. Think of it like trying to measure demand elasticity of bitcoins, it seems to be changing by the minute. Anyways, this whole discussion seems like a straw man to me. How can they pit keynesianism against neoclassicism and gloss over monetarism and the importance of money and central banks? Few serious economists will defend neoclassicism as a main causal factor of recessions at this point. Comparing descendant theories of Keynesianism with descendants of monetarism would be more appropriate.
- petilon 9y ago>> the size of an economy will closely follow the amount of aggregate supply I find this hard to understand. Consider your local McDonalds franchise. According to this theory, if the franchisee makes more Big Macs (i.e., increases supply) the economy will grow. We know that's not true. More customers aren't going to walk in the door just because the franchisee made more Big Macs. Given that he wasn't turning away any customers to begin with, the franchisee can't make more Big Macs until more customers start walking in the door. Stated another way, supply does not drive demand, it is demand that drives supply. This 'neoclassical economics' is balderdash that has been used to give tax cuts to the wealthy, under the guise that such tax cuts will increase supply which will then grow the economy. It won't. It is demand that drives supply. If we must use tax cuts to drive economic growth then give those tax cuts to the middle class, and raise minimum wages, because the middle class will then use the extra money to buy more Big Macs.
- quantumofmalice 9y agoWe seem to lurch back and forth between Keynesian and Chicago School economics, without hearing about things like Georgism[1] or Distributism[2]. The cynic in me says this is because the financial elites are comfortable with either option. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributism
- beaner 9y agoIt seems like a tug of war between the capitalists and the government. They each adopt and promote the economic theories which they think justify their actions and desires.
- conanbatt 9y agoMilton Friedman was georgist on taxes: he was in favor of land value tax. Who else is in favor of LVT? Stiglitz, Krugman. Wait, left and right economist agree on LVT? "You might see disagreement between economists, but if you were to put a varied group of people and a set of economists in the same room, you will soon find that its everyone against the economists" -~ Milton Friedman
- arca_vorago 9y agoThe guy who basically said profit should always be a companies goal regardless of the social, environmental, or political costs? I think keynesianism is part of the problem, not the solution.
- BjoernKW 9y agoI think it never really fell out of fashion, nor has it ever been properly implemented. Keynesianism consists of two elements: 1. Stimulating growth when organic growth is low. 2. Paying back the debt taken on to be able to do #1 when organic growth is self-sustaining again. Politicians usually only consider #1 but conveniently forget about #2 because it doesn't suit their motives. This probably also is why conservatives and libertarians criticise Keynesianism as a leftist ploy to further big government and the expansion of the public sector. Keynesianism implemented properly and without ideology is a reasonable strategy.
- CalChris 9y agoKeynesianism a feedback control loop. Neoliberalism is an open loop. Do you save money for a rainy day or do you spend it like a drunken sailor?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dnautics 9y agoThe assumption is that the feedback control loop is timed correctly. And the second assumption is that the natural system of economics doesn't have it's own feedbacks. If you wire a feedback control loop even slightly wrong you can wind up with positive feedback instead. Moreover the feedback control comes at a cost. What if the cost is "the rich get richer and the poor get poorer"?
- lkrubner 9y agoPaying back the debt taken on to be able to do #1 when organic growth is self-sustaining again. This happens automatically when growth is strong. Even if the nominal debt keeps growing, it shrinks as a percentage of the GDP, so long as the growth of the GDP is faster than that the growth of the nominal debt. So for instance, in the USA, between 1945 to 1980, the national debt shrank from 98% of GDP to 33% of GDP. The USA ran budget deficits in many of those years, but it didn't matter, because the nominal growth of the GDP was much faster that the growth of the debt.
- wjossey 9y agoHighly recommend http://www.econtalk.org/ http://www.econtalk.org/ regardless of preference between Chicago or Keynes. While the host is of a Chicago bent, the interviewees come from across the spectrum. I've been a regular listener for almost a decade now, and it's a joy every week.
- misterbishop 9y agoThis is only happening because self-aware socialist movements are starting to find a broad appeal. Paul Krugman discredited himself as a politico by spending the last 2 years staning for Hillary Clinton. In the process, he had to argue against many of the policies he built his career advocating.
- bassman9000 9y agoThe Great Recession changed a lot of minds I bet it did. Old study from UCLA: http://newsroom.ucla.edu/releases/FDR-s-Policies-Prolonged-Depression-5409 http://newsroom.ucla.edu/releases/FDR-s-Policies-Prolonged-D... Two UCLA economists say they have figured out why the Great Depression dragged on for almost 15 years, and they blame a suspect previously thought to be beyond reproach: President Franklin D. Roosevelt. After scrutinizing Roosevelt's record for four years, Harold L. Cole and Lee E. Ohanian conclude in a new study that New Deal policies signed into law 71 years ago thwarted economic recovery for seven long years. Edit: missed an important quote "Ironically, our work shows that the recovery would have been very rapid had the government not intervened."
- ianamartin 9y agoHere's a simple formula to help with all of this: macroeconomics = survivorship bias
- teboowo 9y agoWould you mind explaining this?
- pipio21 9y agoFor me this is economics propaganda from a mainstream economics info company, as biased as you could be. Keynesianism is simply the idea that the people in power could avert crisis doing terrible things like printing money, which is what QE (quantitaive easing) and negative interest rates is. Of course the people in power love to have all the power. Those people love taking automatically economic resources from you(and billions of other people) and doing things like traveling the world in their private jets fighting "climate change". I personally know those guys. They believe you should not overpopulate the world having kids, and that you should always use public transport, while they use multiple mansions and private jets consuming more energy and generating more contaminating in a single move than thousands of families do in an entire year. But they believe they are special and they could do it. Because they are luminaries. Keynesianism is the dogma based in Keynes that justify, the 0.1 percent automatically taking 3 or 4 percent of the wealth of the world every single year in order to "save the world". We have not lived yet the consequences of printing that much money. Debt has grown exponentially and this can't be sustained and it will stop. This is propaganda for us letting them double down.
- notthemessiah 9y agoYou've got a cartoonish view of Keynesianism. Where did you get it from?
- jazzyk 9y agoI think he is talking about "Keynesians", who use Keynes as theoretical cover for their statist/elitist policies. For example, Keynes advocated that governments spend the money that they HAVE (saved from budget surpluses when the times are good) to help the economy recover from a recession - and it is not a bad idea, per se. The problem is that the US government has never had a surplus in recent history (save for one year 20 years ago). Hence money printing.
- petre 9y agoThis has never worked. The government was never able to control economic cycles, although they advertise as such.
- snomad 9y agoThe fundamental unacknowledged problem with Keynes is it relies on natural rate of inflation, which only happens with population growth. See Japan's continual stagnation despite endless amounts of inflationary policies. The 4 main econ drivers for the US over the next 20 years - China's ascension to number 1 world economy, pension and social security debt and lack of funding, the toll of automation and the gig economy, population growth (or lack thereof) in the US and other major allied nations. We will embrace keynes as solutions to those problems, because that is what those in power know and are comfortable with. The fact the 2008 crises didn't end in 1930s like depression will all but assure them they are right. The question is whether or not that was a one-off lucky "save" largely successful because of the global coordination that went along with American policies (China, Japan, and Europe), and if so, will that global coordination be done for future economic crises, which seems unlikely to me based on the totality of global history.
- pwaai 9y ago> China's ascension to number 1 world economy My gripe with this is that people seem to take this as a fact that hasn't even occurred with almost 100% certainty that it will happen. A lot can go wrong in 20 years. So far, all economies that challenged US in the past mysteriously gets IMF'd, pulling the rug out of a credit bubble that they help create by twisting the arms of the central banks that are supposed to be free from this kind of interference: This documentary about Japanese central bank is eye opening to just how much grip the US hegemony has, one which I fail to see China being able to emulate anytime soon because of the hostage situation that US allies are finding themselves in. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p5Ac7ap_MAY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p5Ac7ap_MAY The theory that states Sadam was whacked because he started to accept euro instead of the petrodollar standard makes an awful lot of sense.
- cryptonector 9y agoJapan did not get IMF'ed, as you put it. They simply did not liquidate, liquidate, liquidate. Instead they just extended-and-pretended. Surprise! It didn't work. IMFing is real, but also only really applicable to smaller economies. All it really is is a bailout of bad-creditors disguised as credit to bad-debtors, leaving the latter in worse shape in the end and without having helped them with immediate problems at all. This only works when the amounts in question can be ponied up by taxpayers in the IMF member countries without causing too much political trouble. When the amounts involved are large enough (e.g., in the case of Japan in '89) this just doesn't even get proposed, not least because there was very little external bad-credit to bailout! We saw some of this game played intra-Eurozone, but in the European case the taxpayer was going to have to bailout the banks no matter what, whereas in the Japan case the problems were entirely domestic. The idea that Bush went after Hussein because Hussein's reserve currency preferences is utter hogwash. Iraq's economy back then simply wasn't remotely big enough to move that needle and lacked the potential to for decades longer. Moreover, if Iraq preferred the euro then, why not now, and where's the damage to the dollar?? The answer is that it does not matter what choice of reserve currency Iraq, Iran, or Saudi Arabia (say) prefer -- it would have made zero difference in 2003, as it almost certainly didn't. Bush had no shortage of reasons to go after Hussein -- no need to reach for conspiracy theories about that!