7 ms·
To Serve Man, with Software
- tonyrice 9y agoThat brought tears to my eyes. Ever since I can remember I've felt deep inside me that it is my duty to help others and do everything I can in me to make change in this world. That I must show others the same. Sometimes this can feel like more weight on my shoulders than I bargained for. Sometimes it helps rise me up and reminds me to always keep moving forward. I can't help to ask myself though, is this just something software developers have inside them? For myself I understood this pretty well, but I can't help to maybe think this isn't just software developers that have this everlasting feeling to serve man.
- hux_ 9y agoIt's called faith. Faith that tomorrow will be a better day. Faith is hard work. People aren't taught well what it is, how to produce it and how to hang on to it when it's most needed. Doesn't matter which geography/culture/religion you are from, understanding how faith is generated in self and in others/what it takes to preserve it under stress is fundamental to doing the hard stuff.
- jackstraw14 9y ago> People aren't taught well what it is, how to produce it and how to hang on to it when it's most needed. I don't know about you but I don't see many signs of unselfish faith anywhere these days, at all. I think where I get hung up on what exactly faith is, is somewhere around when someone says it's some "something" that can be summoned, and when I look it up on wikipedia it's something produced on demand by enlightened individuals who catch on at some point. There's one problem that's been fairly rampant in America for over a century: no one is enlightened anymore, and no one can give any convincing reason that their vision of faith, or just simply what got them through the hard times, is useful to you. Is today's world anything like what the people who built it intended when they set out a few decades ago? Are their sources of faith still useful, and if they're not, well then who's selling the faith fodder these days? i.e. if faith is what everyone needs, then you have to look first at why it's fallen out of favor to the point where it needs a sales pitch. Why people give a shit about more things than ever before, and why none of them involve the fundamental component to doing the hard stuff: a good reason why.
- xkarga00 9y agoWhat is unselfish faith? Can you describe how do you perceive faith as a concept?
- hux_ 9y agoYou have to see it in the fact that people try. Jeff Atwood did not have to write this article. The guy has an establised rep. Is working on a well known project. He does not have to say anything. He knows as soon as he opens his mouth, about an issue which no one has a great solution for, he is opening himself up to unneeded attack. But he does it anyway. That's what I see. That people like him are around. And they will try. That's what gives me faith. Faith does not guarantee happy endings or heroes and that is why it is hard. So think about faith. Again and again. About how to produce and sustain it. People underestimate the value of doing that and develop misguided notions about rituals/imagery/narratives that have evolved in all people to produce faith. To tackle the hard stuff.
- pcunite 9y agoDonald Trump is basically a comment section running for president There is this really big world of people who don't think like you, know that history repeats itself, recognized before you were born that software can enslave, and that are aware that serving man would be something that would allow for his own autonomy. Serving man with software would then be about creating the independence of man from you while still allowing you to be you.
- donatj 9y agoThis. You’re not serving man by discounting half the population. Period.
- GiorgioG 9y ago> The truth is that it's been hard to write because this has been a deeply troubling year in so many dimensions — for men, for tech, for American democracy. American "democracy" isn't any more troubling in 2017 than 2016 or any other year before that, it's just that his party has effectively very little power. If he means Trump is still POTUS, then he's right. He's vehemently anti-Trump: https://blog.codinghorror.com/im-loyal-to-nothing-except-the-dream/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/im-loyal-to-nothing-except-the... As for men/tech, I'm not sure why it's a surprise to anyone that the type of (alpha?) male that winds up in a position of power (and/or money) would abuse and misuse it for sexual predatory behavior. This has gone on for most of human history. A very small sample of randomly chosen examples from our recent past: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2167013/Sexual-predators-police-abusing-power-target-victims-investigation-warns.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2167013/Sexual-preda... http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/sexual-violence-in-world-war-ii-new-german-study-looks-at-rape-trauma-60-years-on-a-585779.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/sexual-violence-... https://www.veteranstoday.com/2014/05/03/sexual-and-predatory-magnitude-of-the-allied-forces-after-wwii-part-ii/ https://www.veteranstoday.com/2014/05/03/sexual-and-predator... Learning that these types of things happen frequently != epidemic or that somehow 2017 was the year of the sexual predator.
- Tharkun 9y agoWhat makes you say that he's discounting half the population?
- josinalvo 9y agoNot one word about automation? We're frequently automating away jobs, in a way that makes capital more productive and shifts the balance of power from worker to capital. It is unclear that the gains in productivity we might cause are good for those who are in the lowest hungs of the ladder. This is what worries me.
- Symmetry 9y agoIn the end all the material progress our civilization has experienced since the Industrial Revolution has been due to increased productivity. Wages for workers can never go higher than worker productivity without the business employing them going out of business. Historically workers have received half of the returns to productive capital and that doesn't seem to be changing. However, recently the return to rents on land have gone up drastically and so capital's overall share of national income has gone up. But that's not a problem that can be solved by making workers less productive.
- fwip 9y agoWages for workers can increase faster than productivity if the business has a large fraction of fixed or non-labor costs. Also, hasn't the productivity->wage ratio decreased in the past few decades? I've seen charts that seem to indicate that, but I suppose the timeframe could be cherry-picked or otherwise misleading. e.g: http://www.epi.org/publication/understanding-the-historic-divergence-between-productivity-and-a-typical-workers-pay-why-it-matters-and-why-its-real/ http://www.epi.org/publication/understanding-the-historic-di...
- marcosdumay 9y ago> hasn't the productivity->wage ratio decreased in the past few decades? We have been in a productivity crisis in the past few decades. AFAIK, nobody knows if it's because we are measuring everything wrong, because people are reluctant to adopt more productive habits, or because modern engineering completely failed on that front. But whatever is the cause, expect to see lots of noise and complex behavior on anything that touches productivity.
- epberry 9y agoI'm not sure it's important to debate whether software itself is _good_ or _bad_. It just is; a means to an end. We should of course debate whether the applications we build are good or bad. Many on this site consider Facebook to be bad (I don't really agree). On the other hand most people probably consider software which lands planes, drives cars, ensures accurate accounting, etc. to be good.
- ff_ 9y agoI used to think that tech was only "means to an end", and in general "ethics-less". But then I read "Do Artifacts Have Politics?", and changed my mind. Everyone in tech should read this: https://www.cc.gatech.edu/~beki/cs4001/Winner.pdf https://www.cc.gatech.edu/~beki/cs4001/Winner.pdf
- jondubois 9y agoI hate the quote "Software is eating the world" because everyone keeps referring to it as though it's ingenious but in 2011 that fact was already pretty well established... It's like if someone said "the sky is blue" or "it is raining right now". If anyone less powerful than Mark Andreessen had said it, nobody would reference this trivial phrase. With this kind of attitude, I'm surprised that people are not quoting Mark Zuckerberg for saying “OK, I'm gonna take off the hoodie" because it carries about the same amount of information.
- amarkov 9y agoI think you're underestimating just how many people believe the opposite. I wouldn't be surprised if something along the lines of "you know, it's great we have tech for our toys and Facebooks, but what really matters is making real stuff" is a majority opinion.
- caminante 9y agoI think you're saying something different re: values. Parent's saying the trend has already been in place (and true) for significant time. According to a survey[0] from Pew Research, "Americans are roughly twice as likely to express worry (72%) than enthusiasm (33%) about a future in which robots and computers are capable of doing many jobs that are currently done by humans." [0] http://www.pewinternet.org/2017/10/04/automation-in-everyday-life/ http://www.pewinternet.org/2017/10/04/automation-in-everyday...
- abraae 9y agoI love Jeff's way of thinking. I watched a YouTube video where he explains that he identifies a particular form of conversation - for stack overflow it is Q&A - and then hones in and builds a perfect environment where such conversation can take place. Discourse is an awesome offering too,I hope that commercially it can lead a long life.
- cdoxsey 9y agoIt's been my hope that the russia story and Google and Facebooks realization of the technology they've built has been used in ways they never intended, might stand as a sober reminder about the reality of evil in the world. People recognize evil in, say, Isis, Nazis, or a school shooter, but usually accompanied with that recognition is a distancing from the act - a way of saying "I'm not like them". And I'm not saying you are. But evil is insidious and pervasive. It affects everything we do. And that definitely includes software. I worked for a company that had a help chat room, where users could ask a support person questions about the product. It was publicly accessible from a link on the website, basically a slack room. One day we notice two teenagers had hijacked the room in the middle of the night and were using it for an erotic conversation. That's fairly mundane, but what if they weren't teenagers? What if one of them was underage, and we had accidentally facilitated a child molester? And this happens everywhere. I heard about a kid who got cyberbullied with scratch (scratch.mit.edu) because it allows you to share content with other users? Do you think the makers of scratch ever imagined that they'd play a hand in some middle-schooler committing suicide? (fyi, they actually police this stuff) I've built financial research sites, ad optimization software, phone calling apps, operational and monitoring tools. I think all that software has been mostly helpful for people, but I also recognize that it played a part in nefarious ends as well. Everyone's hands are dirty.
- christophilus 9y agoI've been thinking about this lately, as my current software platform is sometimes used for purposes I really don't like. And I've been considering moving to work on some Etherium applications, since I strongly believe in a decentralized web. But the decentralized web will certainly enable unsavory characters to do evil things. In the end, we build things for the purpose of serving others, but can't really beat ourselves up when those things are misused. If I was an automotive engineer, I wouldn't like the fact that creeps were using my cars to kidnap people or as getaway vehicles or the like, but it doesn't mean that I'm complicit in those things. I think software-- for the most part-- is a lot like that.
- QAPereo 9y agoBy the same token if you specialized in armored cars that could outrun police and were invisible to radar, you’d have no right to be shocked by who ends up using it. You’d protect diplomats and people in dangerous parts of the world... and cartel kingpins, dictators, etc.
- mastazi 9y agoFrom the article: > I'm ashamed of much that happened, and I think one of the first and most important steps we can take is to embrace explicit codes of conduct throughout our industry. I think that there needs to be some sort of internationally recognised - and legally binding - code of conduct, something like a hippocratic oath for software developers.
- dlgeek 9y agoI think the ACM Code Of Ethics is probably the closest, though not yet legally binding: https://www.acm.org/about-acm/acm-code-of-ethics-and-professional-conduct https://www.acm.org/about-acm/acm-code-of-ethics-and-profess...
- luord 9y agoI feel that "Tron" has the most primordial and crucial advice for any developer: "Fight for the users". We should always keep that in mind and as the top priority.