18 ms·
Spamnesty – A Bot to waste spammers' time
- shurcooL 9y agoFrom glancing over some conversations, it looks like the bot is mostly talking to other bots. That said, I think it’s nice to be able to reflect the same attack vector upon the attackers to make the attack less efficient and hopefully less attractive.
- mjs 9y agoMany of the replies seem like they involved at least some human effort, although it would be nice to be sure--I wonder if there's some way to introduce some spammer-appropriate text captcha into the exchanges?
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> That said, I think it’s nice to be able to reflect the same attack vector upon the attackers to make the attack less efficient and hopefully less attractive. If it's just bots replying - which honestly doesn't actually seem to be the case - I don't think it's going to make a big dent in their efficiency. It might backfire, though, and just cause more garbage traffic.
- StavrosK 9y agoI think that's mostly because conversations in the home page are sorted by frecency right now. That naturally favors bots, because they respond more immediately.
- qrv3w 9y agoIt is mostly - but there are some where its obvious the spammer gets frustrated: "I believe you must be a fool or an idiot to think am here to play games." - Spammer [1]. [1]: https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/meqpscxa/ https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/meqpscxa/
- maxyme 9y agoI love the use of the subdomain and email sp@mnesty.com to hide the name from spammers. But won't human spammers eventually figure out what mnesty.com is and stop responding?
- StavrosK 9y agoSure, but the goal is to waste their time a bit, you can't fool them forever anyway.
- kevin_nisbet 9y agoTrue, but also being a bit more random where it's not trivial to filter the bot on the spammers side would make it just a little bit harder to ignore.
- StavrosK 9y agoThat's true. Unfortunately, it's not trivial to add more domains, as you'd need to own them all (to add DNS records for sending and receiving). I wanted to accept donations at some point, in the form of pointed DNS records, but realized that I couldn't do that without owning the domain, as if the domain lapsed or was transferred, Spamnesty wouldn't know and it would keep sending email from that domain, to no avail.
- robryk 9y agoYou could check if the MX records still point at your service, or, better yet, send a test e-mail to that domain every so often and see if it reaches your service.
- StavrosK 9y agoIndeed, but it's added complexity and I'm not sure how many people would bother setting the DNS records I asked for. I might try it at some point, though.
- scottmac13 9y agoThis is the email version of when Telemarketers call me and ask to "speak with someone in the house between the ages for x-y" to which I say, "sure just a sec", then put the phone down on the desk and walk away.
- lisper 9y agoYou're lucky that your spam calls come from a human. All I get is bots calling to tell me I've won a free cruise.
- arawde 9y agoI've found that if I don't recognize the number, I answer the phone and don't say anything. If no voice comes over the line within 5-10 seconds, I hang up.
- sergers 9y agoI have heard of these automated systems wait for a sound before it logs you as reachable for further annoyances. If I do answer, I stay silent even muting my phone. Usually call just hangs up. I get the cruise every few months, from a spoofed local numbers. As soon as I say hello, the automated recording went off. I had a friend who liked playing around, and drafted fake PayPal confirmations and western union statements as proof he sent the scammers money. They were confused why they didn't have his funds asking him to triple check recipient info and resend, which he would send another fake confirmation. They would eventually catch on cussing him out after weeks
- StavrosK 9y agoIsn't there a registry where you can opt to not be disturbed there? We have it here and I signed up, and calls eventually stopped. I also love terrorizing spam callers with "give me your name and company name, this call is illegal". They usually get flustered and hang up.
- lisper 9y ago
- kl94 9y agoI have the feeling that all of this is going to finish bot against bot.
- superasn 9y agoWell done. It does get the spammers frustrated. I remember reading about a similar thing[1] where instead of emails it was automated telephone replies and the scammers were cussing at the bots and generally super confused. It did also manage to flood their phone lines making their call center useless for a while. [1] https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/bj8wg4/we-talked-to-the-hacker-who-flooded-alleged-irs-scammers-with-robocalls https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/bj8wg4/we-talked-...
- jdietrich 9y agoSome magnificent genius has created the perfect bot for hooking predatory telemarketers. "Lenny" is a slightly confused elderly man with poor hearing. He wanders off topic, he isn't sure what you just said and he is absolute catnip for crooks. If you haven't heard a call to Lenny, you're in for an absolute treat. This call from a tech support scammer lasts an exhausting 31 minutes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJTxkPLVxrc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJTxkPLVxrc https://www.reddit.com/r/itslenny/ https://www.reddit.com/r/itslenny/
- Tempest1981 9y agoVery well done. And the ducks -- hilarious! Now how do you scale and vary this enough, to prevent suspicion? That's the next step. Near the end (28 min), it felt like the caller was probing with "can you hear me" to collect Lenny's canned responses. Would it be better to hang up earlier to avoid suspicion?
- jdietrich 9y ago"Lenny" is only 21 short recordings, stitched together into a crude sequence. It's a remarkably unsophisticated trick on a technical level. It wouldn't be difficult to produce dozens or hundreds of Lennies on quite a small budget. Tweak the script a bit, get someone on Fiverr to record it and you've got a new and unrecognisable Lenny MkII.
- LV-426 9y ago
- chrisabrams 9y agoI read some of the conversations on the site; it’s quite interesting that the boys managed to have the same conversation over and over almost in the exact order.
- matteocontrini 9y agoThis remembers me of rescam.org
- thescribe 9y agoI have been using this site for about a month on every piece of spam that tells me to write back. But, I have not gotten any responses. How are they even making money if they don't respond to clearly interested potential customers?
- laurent123456 9y agoThis website has been around for a while (it's the seventh time it's posted here) so it's possible spammers have blacklisted the domain by now.
- StavrosK 9y agoOh wow, seventh? I think it's the second time I see it. Didn't I only build it a few months ago? EDIT: Oh huh, it's been more than a year: https://www.stavros.io/posts/spamnesty-waste-spammers-time/ https://www.stavros.io/posts/spamnesty-waste-spammers-time/ How time flies.
- repsak 9y ago‘Nigerian Prince’ Email Scammer Arrested in Louisiana - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16035183 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16035183 ;-)
- zackify 9y agoAdd support for SMS and it’ll be perfect.
- brightsize 9y agoWhat sort of support?
- zackify 9y agoI get text messages from scammers
- nhooyr 9y agoI love it.
- alpb 9y agoIt looks like in many cases [1] it's confusing the threads? Subjects and discussions start changing after a few messages in many threads I looked at. [1] https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/vkeezpyz/ https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/vkeezpyz/
- brightsize 9y agoI see this all the time and have assumed it's related to difficulties correlating outbound messages (to the spammer) with responses. Also within a message thread the service sometimes fails to respond to the most recent email from a spammer. An example thread showing both issues: https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/caabzkyg/ https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/caabzkyg/
- StavrosK 9y agoThe failure to respond is because I set a limit, it stops after a few tens of messages to avoid endless loops with bots. The other messages are because it gets put into a list and just gets spammed, as far as I can tell.
- pwaai 9y agoHad a good chuckle reading through the chat logs, but it would be interesting to see the results using NLP to formulate new nonsense questions aimed at the spammer. The spammer side seems to also employ some level of bot automation, and its like two bots going at each other with the occasional broken english comment showing confusion and frustration....this is truly golden.
- StavrosK 9y agoMRs appreciated, but please make them in multiple short, self-contained pieces
- nicksergeant 9y agoHmm. Tried it and the email bounced back with: “554 Recipients' domain disabled”
- honest_george 9y agoSame here, in Gmail.
- draugadrotten 9y agoSame here, Office365.
- barbs 9y agoSame here, also Gmail. Maybe it's overloaded right now?
- StavrosK 9y agoUnfortunately, Mailgun is throttling the domain due to large rates of mail. All we can do is wait the ban out, I'm afraid.
- wyclif 9y agoLooks like you need a new domain provider; this is a show stopper.
- StavrosK 9y agoI would agree, but I make liberal use of the free limits so I can't complain much. I don't really want to spend too much money running Spamnesty.
- srett 9y agoAre you able to easily detect whether your account is currently blocked and add some warning to the front page? Would make it easier than just spamming sp@mnesty.com until the mails don't bounce anymore...
- Animats 9y agoThat's a cute idea. But I wonder if the system is mis-matching messages and replies.[1] How did a spam for fake Ray-Ban sunglasses turn into someone wanting app development? [1] https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/cturvzsr/ https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/cturvzsr/
- malka 9y agoI'd bet that it is an IT company in India that had a compromised email server that sent spam. The mails look kinda legit, except for the first one.
- StavrosK 9y agoI was curious about that too and checked, but couldn't find anything. It goes by the X-Reply-To (IIRC) header and they matched.
- a12jun 9y agoI saw www.rescam.org on here a while ago, definitely worth a visit!
- phantom_oracle 9y agoAs someone else mentioned here, the only risk is that spammers will blacklist mnesty.com . There should be some type of domain rotation (or you can test spoofing, just to see if spammers use the same anti-spoof software everyone else does), just like how spammers do so. As an aside, kudos for using gitlab instead of github.
- StavrosK 9y agoI love Gitlab, I put most of my projects there these days and mirror them on Github.
- jdietrich 9y agoIf and when that happens, someone can pick up a suite of cheap domain names. Thanks to the proliferation of generic TLDs, you can register a domain for less than a dollar per year through a legitimate registrar.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoSo it would be hilarious if you connected the spam asking for manuscripts[1] to the fake manuscript generating code [2]. We would end up with bot published journals. [1] https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/cjubnfdx/ https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/cjubnfdx/ [2] https://pdos.csail.mit.edu/archive/scigen/ https://pdos.csail.mit.edu/archive/scigen/
- StavrosK 9y agoOh God, I have to do this now.
- evo_9 9y agoWhat we really need is something like this for the phone scammers, particularly the "IRS" scam I've been getting regulars calls from most of this year.
- haldora 9y agoSomeone made a call bot called "Lenny" to fool telemarketers, which uses recorded messages. They put up their call logs on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLduL71_GKzHHk4hLga0nOGWrXlhl-i_3g https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLduL71_GKzHHk4hLga0nO...
- kebman 9y agoHahaha, that was hillarious! I wish there was a bit of voice recognition too, because then this bot would be unbeatable! There should also be a few more variations, but then it seems more than enough to get the seller/scammer enganged for quite some time.
- sorokod 9y agoForwarding from gmail to sp@mnesty.com results in 554 Recipients' domain disabled
- leeoniya 9y agooldie but goodie: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cIVfrBFc5og https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cIVfrBFc5og
- breakingcups 9y agoI once made something very similar, back then it was called an autobaiter by the scambaiting community. It would actually figure out what kind of scam the spammer was pulling and adjust its script in kind to pretend to play along with the scammers script. I should dig that up again.
- dgellow 9y agoOP here. Just to clarify, because I see a lot of congratulations. I just shared the project, I'm not the author. Based on the GitLab project, the author seems to be @stavros: - https://gitlab.com/stavros/Spamnesty https://gitlab.com/stavros/Spamnesty - https://twitter.com/stavros https://twitter.com/stavros - https://www.stavros.io/ https://www.stavros.io/
- StavrosK 9y agoYep, that's me!
- gkya 9y agoNice idea, kudos! One curiosity though: I read a thread from the ones listed on the homepage and the signature of the Spamnesty emails said Mnesty LLC. If that's constant in every message the service sends out, wouldn't it be quite easy for the spammers to filter them out? Wouldn't you rather randomise sender details, including the signature?
- StavrosK 9y agoThanks! There's only one sending domain, so it would be incongruous to randomize the signature, unfortunately...
- Terretta 9y agoYou may want to add a keyword check if the spammer starts sending you back bounces: https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/bkpeczav/ https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/bkpeczav/
- StavrosK 9y agoGood idea, added, thank you.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gthinkin 9y agoThis is really cool. I tried building a similar project last year using an LSTM, but never ended up deploying it. I wonder what James Veitch would have to say.
- UltraFlynn 9y agoEmail isn't free. It seems like it is but actually it takes significant resources to process all the spam. Using a bot to create more traffic is pointless and wasteful. Yours sincerely, A guy who runs the mail transfer agents for an email security provider and has to deal with this every day.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoCool. Stop the spam and I’ll quit spamming you back.
- UltraFlynn 9y agoWe do. That's exactly what we do. But honestly the volume of spam is massive already.
- nikodunk 9y agoJust read through this one https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/ecfrqrps/ https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/ecfrqrps/ – and was laughing stitches. Great job!
- rafi_kamal 9y agoThe whole conversation gives me cringe
- StavrosK 9y agoOh wow, it really gave them the runaround there. I love the link to the forever-loading page, I forgot I had added that.
- luord 9y agoThis is the best thing I've seen in a while. That they host the code in gitlab is a nice touch.
- ris 9y agoI note the fake replies are quite limited & repetitive. It would be extremely interesting to see if deep Q learning could be used to develop more realistic replies. "rewards" would simply be getting more (and faster) responses.
- JetSpiegel 9y agoThis is one of the best: https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/mbvnmrbc/ https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/mbvnmrbc/
- squarefoot 9y agoGreat idea! Wasting spammers time is one of the very few ways of making them effectively lose money. Still the project needs some pseudo randomization in order to fool basic research. Some of the messages I read contained the sentence "I am a bit busy now, but I am definitely interested. When can we talk?". If one searches for that sentence in quotes Google returns four pages of references to Spamnesty. A slightly more clever spammer would sense the trap in minutes. I'm not aware of any program capable of add some entropy to a sentence maintaining its semantics and readability (save for insertion of random errors), but one could use a translator in different languages. Say English->German->Russian->Spanish->Polish->Danish->English, then send the resulting string as a reply. The above string for example becomes: "Now I'm a bit busy, but I'm definitely interested. When can we speak?" which (almost) fools the search. Almost because the 1st page still contains a couple references to Spamnesty due to the above sentences strong similarity, but they're well buried together with other completely unrelated stuff. BTW, pairing this with a personal assistant stripped of any access to personal information/property/devices (such as an hypothetical open source cloudless one) and instructed to ask for details on every possible part of the offer, one could make the perfect weapon against phone telemarketers as well.
- wybiral 9y ago> A slightly more clever spammer would sense the trap in minutes. Spammers are going to develop anti-spam filters :)
- amelius 9y agoI guess spammers make most money from the lowest IQ percentiles on the internet. Therefore, we only have to develop AI that is as smart (stupid) as those people, and spammers won't be able to tell the difference.
- novafaen 9y agoSeem this is already a battle of bots (example; half way through this post https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/btenqyem/ https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/btenqyem/) both parts are sending a random mess to each other.
- StreamingMeeMee 9y agoI guess they were a bit overwhelmed - I'm getting "554 Recipients' domain disabled " when forwarding to them.
- nkkollaw 9y agoThis is great, but I feel like it's wrong that regular people think they have to step in to fight spam. After all, these messages benefit actual companies. I receive many spam messages from American companies that are legit. Why can't governments do more to fight spam? It's illegal after all (at least in Italy and I'd guess Europe), so how come companies get away with it?
- StreamingMeeMee 9y agoI guess they were a bit too successful - I'm getting "554 Recipients' domain disabled' when forwarding msgs to them.
- a12jun 9y agoLet's just hope the scammers don't start using AI/NLP to generate the emails they send to us....
- systematical 9y agoTried forwarding three emails, got this: Message not delivered There was a problem delivering your message to sp@mnesty.com. See the technical details below, or try resending in a few minutes. The response was: 554 Recipients' domain disabled
- deviationblue 9y agoInteresting, but is there something for spam callers? It's not enough to block them or report them.
- snowpanda 9y agoI'd pay some serious money for this. In case someone's looking for an idea.
- throwaway2048 9y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/itslenny/ https://www.reddit.com/r/itslenny/
- peterburkimsher 9y agoI look forward to sending many emails your way! Spam is a daily problem for me. I can't use auto-filters, because I live in Taiwan and most emails written in Chinese are flagged as spam. That includes important messages from my bank, colleagues, and landlord. Eventually I gave up using auto-filters, and I now manually delete ~50 spam every day. Being able to do something useful with that will make my spam-sorting a little less mind-numbing.
- 05 9y agoHave you considered registering your own domain and giving out personalized emails to everyone? E.g. from_blahbank@mydomain.tld? That way, you could rotate most often leaked prefixes regularly without disturbing other recipients.
- raverbashing 9y agoEven better if you can filter by domain is received emails Blabank alias only gets email from their domains, anything else goes on the trash
- peterburkimsher 9y agoI use Mailnull extensively, but I still get a lot of spam directly to my Gmail address that I've had since 2005.
- scoot 9y agoHa, my comment from earlier today [1] reposted as a top of front page post. It's like when you say something funny in a group setting which only one person hears, and instead of asking you to repeat it for everyone, they repeat it loudly themselves like it was thier joke! :) Edit: Heaven forbid that you should point out that HN is sometimes just like Reddit! Downvote away, I have no interest in MIPs†. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16035487 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16035487 †Meaningless Internet Points
- jg12345 9y ago<sp@mnesty.com>: host mxb.mailgun.org[54.210.206.63] said: 554 Recipients' domain disabled (in reply to end of DATA command)
- peterburkimsher 9y agoI just tried to forward a lot of spam messages, and got the response: 554 Recipients' domain disabled Reporting-MTA: dns; googlemail.com Received-From-MTA: dns; ----------@gmail.com Arrival-Date: Sat, 30 Dec 2017 20:49:25 -0800 (PST) X-Original-Message-ID: <02D8BE6D-6DEF-4FC9-9AC5-6BC6E7A44EAE@gmail.com> Final-Recipient: rfc822; sp@mnesty.com Action: failed Status: 5.0.0 Remote-MTA: dns; mxb.mailgun.org. (54.69.170.70, the server for the domain mnesty.com.) Diagnostic-Code: smtp; 554 Recipients' domain disabled Last-Attempt-Date: Sat, 30 Dec 2017 20:49:27 -0800 (PST)
- golfer 9y agoSame here. Hopefully it gets fixed, I'd love to try this out.
- aendruk 9y agoTracked at https://gitlab.com/stavros/Spamnesty/issues/81 https://gitlab.com/stavros/Spamnesty/issues/81: > Unfortunately Mailgun has disabled the domain due to rate limits. All we can do is wait […] I think it's just the HN effect that got it to send too many messages at once.
- useranme 9y agoI liked the idea of increasing the amount of time a spammer expends over their email. I didn't like the idea of having to manually forward the email, manually remove personal information from the body of the email, and sucking the recipient into watching the conversation unfold live. Because it increases the amount of time a recipient expends over a spam email.
- newscracker 9y agoI tried this when it was new, and saw two issues with it. Firstly, it uses western names as the responder, which may not be the best case everywhere — ideally the person submitting the email should be able to specify a name to use. Secondly, the mnesty name and Mnesty LLC wouldn't seem believable to many (human) spammers either, depending on the region. I didn't get responses for many emails I submitted — my guess is that the spammers thought it's a waste of time (which is also good, but not frustrating them enough).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- b0rsuk 9y agoHonestly, why don't we get insider / whistleblower posts here on HN ? I understand spamming is quite vilified among most techies, but someone is doing the spamming. Is it because the bulk of spamming is done using very unsophisticated ways ? We get anonymous posts on pretty much all other topics.
- sparaker 9y agoWith all the emails ending with "CEO, MNesty, LLC" I doubt you'll be able to fool anyone
- toufique 9y agoLOL! Best use of chatbots yet!
- lamby 9y agoHm, I'm getting: <sp@mnesty.com>: host mxb.mailgun.org[54.186.217.87] said: 554 Recipients' domain disabled (in reply to end of DATA command)
- juanmirocks 9y agoThis could easily be one of the “smallest” things to have the greatest impact. Looking forward to reading statistics on how much this software takes in % of total spam time and saved money.
- Xeoncross 9y agoReading some of these emails it's apparent it's not a person responding. This is simply two bots email each other. https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/aatajahd/ https://spa.mnesty.com/conversations/aatajahd/ Looks like for some spammers, the game is already up.
- defanor 9y ago> Spamnesty is a way to waste spammers' time. If you get a spam email, simply forward it to [email protected] Maybe it would be more appropriate to show email there, since it's intended for spammers as well.
- mvindahl 9y agoGamifying this kind of thing would be intriguing. I'm imagining some server that would work like spamnesty, i.e. you could easily let it handle your spam. But I'm also imagining the possibility of registering as a bot creator and plugging in your own algorithms. API-wise it would be super simple, much like creating a chatbot for Slack, but the logic could be as advanced as one would like. The server would then score the algorithms on established metrics such as "average number of responses" or what one might dream up. There would be leaderboards and stuff. It would all work nicely until the spammers start creating their own bots to keep our bots busy. Bots would keep inane conversations going forever. Then, I presume, Skynet.
- dickbasedregex 9y agoCory Doctorow's story about spam bots being one of the last things alive: https://craphound.com/overclocked/Cory_Doctorow_-_Overclocked_-_When_Sysadmins_Ruled_the_Earth.html https://craphound.com/overclocked/Cory_Doctorow_-_Overclocke...
- yuanotes 9y agoHahaha. The funniest conversations I’ve read this year!!! Poor spammers. LOL
- mrandish 9y agoThis is the greatest thing! Thanks to the author(s) for doing it.