16 ms·
Adderall Risks: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- apostacy 9y agoI really, really wish there was more discussion of this. This is something that is very present in my life and the lives of people I have worked with, but nobody talks about it. The two things that really stick out for me are the existential implications of taking a pill that rewires your brain, and the inevitable intersection of that with one's career choices.
- fny 9y agoI don't take adderall, but I'm not too convinced by the concerns listed here. The drug seems far less risky than alcohol on all counts, and I'm pretty sure all amphetamine users are aware that their playing with some sort of fire. I think the compelling question is why people feel so compelled to take a pill to sell their souls to a rat race? Seems like an almost Huxleyan Prisoner's Dilemma to me.
- astrange 9y agoIf you're "ADHD" it affects having fun just as much as working - imagine you can't finish a book and you can't hold down a conversation with a stranger long enough to start dating them. There are pretty universal subconscious skills medication improves here.
- Klathmon 9y agoThis is what I have to explain to people, my ADHD doesn't only apply to things I don't want to do. Things like not being able to watch a movie, or even play some video games without missing huge parts of the story, or sitting through a conversation with a group of friends trying to constantly "catch up" to a topic that I missed a few minutes ago, or trying to be self aware enough to not change the subject on people too quickly because my mind has already changed topics twice during their conversation. I love reading, and it's almost 100% out of the question when I'm not taking my medication. Somewhere around the 5th time of re-reading a paragraph trying to remember where I trailed off only to realize that I just did it again makes it really not a great experience. Even the worst case scenario of the medication severely increasing my chance of heart attack, stroke, or Parkinson's wouldn't make me stop taking it, because it's given me a life. And I would rather live a shorter happier more fulfilling life than a potentially longer one.
- vincentriemer 9y agoI had held off getting tested for ADHD because I was convinced I was just lazy and didn't like schoolwork but once I noticed I couldn't play a single videogame for more than 15 minutes at a time and had to do something else, I got myself tested and ultimately diagnosed. I still remember the first day I took the medication, it was like somebody finally turned off a white noise machine in my brain and I could finally do all the things I've wanted to do.
- solarmist 9y agoThis. This was exactly my experience. I texted my wife after my first dose that I heard someone having a conversation near me and that I could hear them, but I didn't know what they were saying and I didn't care. This was a revelation for me.
- ryanianian 9y agoSame - for me the leading indicator of having "true" ADD is the inability to concentrate on the things I _want_ to do. I recently chatted with a shrink who said that ADD patients typically _can_ focus on the things they want to do but struggle with the things they don't want to do. I strongly suspect he's mistaken - I don't know a soul who finds it easy to focus on filing their taxes (except sadistic accountant-type friends). Nothing is more frustrating than having all the "motivation" and desire and curiosity for a task but none of the "ability" to make it happen.
- fny 9y agoI should have clarified: I'm talking about "abusers" here, not those who genuinely need the drug.
- pfisch 9y ago>I think the compelling question is why people feel so compelled to take a pill to sell their souls to a rat race? Seems like an almost Huxleyan Prisoner's Dilemma to me. I think people just want to be their best selves. They want to accomplish their goals and they use tools to accomplish those goals. I mean everyone carries a cell phone and I feel like those modify your life and thinking patterns a lot more than taking adderall does.
- reitanqild 9y agoBoth stimulants and cell phones can be extremely useful for ADHD users. Cell phones: Possibility to carry a calendar - with alarm. Stimulants: Lowers the threshold for "interesting" so you don't fall asleep/have to do "something"/etc. (Yep, multiple alternatives exist here.)
- heymijo 9y ago"I think the compelling question is why people feel so compelled to take a pill to sell their souls to a rat race?" There seems to be an implicit assumption in your question that refers to adults. What about the growing number of people, diagnosed and treated as children or young adults before they really have an agency in the matter? Some U.S. based statistics on diagnoses for different <18 year old groups: https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/adhd/data.html https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/adhd/data.html http://www.wnd.com/2013/04/radical-increase-in-kids-prescribed-ritalin/ http://www.wnd.com/2013/04/radical-increase-in-kids-prescrib... https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/slaits/nsch.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/slaits/nsch.htm
- kazagistar 9y agoI know we like to think of them as not having agency, but we can still give teens and preteens choices. I know some kids who the medication helped, some who grew out of needing it when they grew older, and some who had strong side effects and stopped taking it after a few weeks. But they most certainly did have that choice.
- ryanianian 9y ago> I think the compelling question is why people feel so compelled to take a pill to sell their souls to a rat race? This seems pejorative. The reason why many take "a pill" isn't to sell their soul, it's to do the work they want to do but are otherwise incapable of doing. You may consider this work that they want to do to be "rat race" work, but that's just your judgment of their desires.
- 1a2a3a4a 9y agoFor what it’s worth, for me, the main impact of adderall is on a second to second level, not whether I can concentrate for 12 hours straight. When I’m not on medication, I have a lot of short term memory loss and sudden changes in train of thought. The impact of this was that I would sometimes “wake up” and have no recollection of how I got to where I currently was, I continuously lost everything, and had trouble with math word problems that were described over long paragraphs. My parents actually originally went to the doctor because of the stress caused by always losing things.
- fahayekwasright 9y agoAdderall is for the weak and undisciplined. There’s no substitute for learning how to work hard.
- kanishkdudeja 9y agoI felt extremely sad on taking Adderall and other similar stimulant medications like Ritalin. Maybe the sadness effect would have gotten less with continuing the medicine, but overall, I didn't feel like taking drugs since they cause a lot of other side effects like insomnia. Now I've been able to control my ADHD successfully. Atleast upto the point that it has stopped affecting my life and career so much. a) 0 sugar in diet. Not even fruits. b) Try to sleep for atleast 8-9 hours a day. c) Drink lots of water throughout the day d) Exercise and no junk food. e) Have got an accountable job. Leading a software team so I know that procrastination will hurt me in the long run, so forced to do stuff on time.
- y4mi 9y agoHow do you get enough vitamins without any fruits? Are you just using supplements?
- kanishkdudeja 9y agoI take fruits which have no/negligible sugar like Amla, Lemos, Avocados. Once in a while, I do take supplements. But on the whole, I try to live a more natural life, with as less drugs/medicines as possible. Even for milk, I drink raw milk and not processed milk.
- n4r9 9y ago> 0 sugar > I drink raw milk You'd have to drink milk in tiny quantities; I'd be astonished if raw vs processed makes a difference if so.
- kanishkdudeja 9y agoI mentioned raw milk not in reference for "0 sugar". Just mentioned normally that I try and keep away from processed food, drugs, medications etc.
- KitDuncan 9y ago
- astrange 9y ago> There are occasional claims that magnesium or some other substance can help reverse Adderall tolerance. I went to a particularly expensive Silicon Valley psychiatrist who did of course immediately put me on Adderall, but also put me on NAC supplements to "avoid tolerance". It's been okay, they're cheap, never bothered not taking them to experiment. I can confirm feeling better after eating foods with magnesium, mostly because they're good for you. BTW, if you're on amphetamine+guanfacine you need to avoid all of caffeine, sugar, and alcohol. What a bummer.
- sigotirandolas 9y agoAFAIK the best evidence is for NMDA antagonists reversing tolerance. In fact magnesium is a a NMDA antagonist, but it a very weak one. I have read about people using memantine or something more potent to reverse tolerance, but I would be very wary about using potent NMDA antagonists regularly given what we know about them.
- png_hero 9y agoHmmm, never heard of adding NAC. And do you supplement magnesium too? Your talking about things I’ve never heard of before, this does sound advanced. Any other things on your stack?
- fragsworth 9y ago> Hmmm, never heard of adding NAC. And do you supplement magnesium too? > Your talking about things I’ve never heard of before, this does sound advanced. Any other things on your stack? The original article mentioned how society has determined it is "not okay for people with already-fine concentration to use it to become superhuman". The way you talk about this, though. Being impressed about someone's "advanced stack" of drugs to maximize their potential. I get the impression you're using it to become superhuman. I'm not sure if I am the only one with this reaction, but I feel like your attitude is kinda offensive and disgusting. How much money have you made by abusing drugs in our rat race?
- png_hero 9y ago
- gcatalfamo 9y agoJust out of curiosity: do you ever stop and think/ask why ADD or ADHD exist only in the US? How could such a condition be so frequent yet only present in just one country?
- andybak 9y agoHuh. Citation needed. I know many people in the UK with a diagnosis.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chesimov 9y agoDon't know about other countries but in S. Africa it also exists. We don't have Adderall as far as I'm aware but I know of people who use Ritalin and say it has improved their daily lives.
- tonypace 9y agoThe Ritalin prescription train is alive and well in industrial Asia. You seem to be basing an argument on false priors.
- Lazare 9y agoWhen you stumble across such a fascinating question nobody seems to be thinking about... ...it's often a sign you've missed some basic facts and need to rethink your priors. And so it is here.
- leadingthenet 9y agoAdderall is very much present in Europe as well. So is Ritalin.
- jglauche 9y ago"We could still have a principled definition of ADHD. It would be something like “People below the 5th percentile in ability to concentrate, as measured by this test.” Instead, we use the DSM, which advises us to diagnose people with ADHD if they say they have at least five symptoms from a list. " I'm in Germany and I've been diagnosed with ADHD-PI lately (I am in my 30s) after seeing a private specialist about this topic. In addition to that DSM test and 3 other questionnaires, they ran a computer test measuring my ability to concentrate which was repeated after a couple of weeks on medication. The test results were very conclusive and I think that is the strongest diagnosis criteria that I have as it's actually measurable. It was actually really hard for me to find a doctor to actually diagnose me. I called several doctors and it was either "we're not taking any more patients because diagnosis takes too long" or "we can't tell you if we can diagnose it, you can't make an appointment here, so come in but you might have to wait half a day". Not to mention that by the time you get to your doctor, un-medicated, you will forget to tell about half of your symptoms.
- plazmatic 9y agoIt's so ridiculous to test a persons concentration abilities without Adderall and compare them WITH Adderall and then use that test to support some claim that it's conclusive you have ADD. ANYONE will score considerably better in such a test. Adderall, and medications like it, improve concentration in all people. The real question: is the gain in concentration worth the potential harmful effects to the individual?
- akvadrako 9y agoThat seems like an odd test. Of course everybody will score better on a concentration test while on medication for concentration.
- russellbeattie 9y ago'Adderall doesn’t “cure” the “disease” of ADHD' This is completely wrong. It treats the symptoms of those of us with severe ADHD, and let's us do everyday things like sit in a theater or an airplane, or enjoy playing quietly with our little children. It's not just about being an office drone spending 12 hours a day in Excel or some cynical bullshit like that, it's about every day life.
- balfirevic 9y agoI mean, I get that we are discussing ADHD here, but you could have at least read the next sentence: > Adderall doesn’t “cure” the “disease” of ADHD, at least not in the same way penicillin cures syphilis. Adderall will give everyone better concentration, and we’ve judged that it’s okay for people with terrible concentration to use it to overcome their handicap, but not okay for people with already-fine concentration to use it to become superhuman.
- russellbeattie 9y agoI read it - the tone of the paragraph is that it's not really medication, but something like caffeine which you can give to everyone and it'll have the same effect. It doesn't work like that. The dose I take would make a non-ADHD person into an obsessive hyper-focused teeth-grinding mess, but it basically just makes me normal. Adderall is real medicine which cures a real problem.
- balfirevic 9y ago> but something like caffeine which you can give to everyone and it'll have the same effect Apparently, that is actually true (not the same magnitude of effect but the same kind of effect - better concentration). And it's not in any way contradictory to it also being a medication. > The dose I take would make a non-ADHD person into an obsessive hyper-focused teeth-grinding mess, but it basically just makes me normal. That is almost exactly what the quote above said. > Adderall is real medicine which cures a real problem. I honestly don't understand how you got the impression that the original article claimed otherwise.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bob_theslob646 9y agoAuthor does a decent job of going through some things, but this statement did not sit well with me. >I don’t think there are good data here, but my intuitions and personal experience is that “addiction” of the sort you get with heroin or tobacco is very rare, at least when responsible people without a personal or family history of addictive behavior take stimulants as prescribed. Most people agree the risk is lower for extended-release stimulants (eg Adderall XR), and very low for Vyvanse. I think that statement is bonkers. Of course they are going to be addicted to the substance if they use it everyday of their lives. My definition of addiction is not being able to stop taking the drug for whatever reason, and feeling some sort of withdrawal. I think for most people that take something daily, it would be extremely hard for them to stop. This is where things get messed up: being chemically addicted to something where the cost of the drug can be astronomical .Yes, I am talking about Shire's Vyvanse. >Shire Plc is a Jersey-registered, Irish-headquartered global specialty biopharmaceutical company... its brands and products include Vyvanse, Lialda, and Adderall XR. The best is that they offer a program the temporarily reduces the price of the drug for a period of time aka you get addicted to it over that time period and then are forced to pay it becuase their is nothing like it until 2023. Yes, I am aware that each state has different insurance options, but starting a company called "Shire Cares" just to spread the belief that they care but really do not is silly. From their website: "Pay no more than $30 for up to 12 prescriptions up to a maximum savings of $60 per prescription.† (https://www.shireregistration.com/vyvanse%20savings%20link)" https://www.shireregistration.com/vyvanse%20savings%20link)" What they do not tell you is after that period ends, the price goes up drastically. With insurance, 30 pills costs "around $286.42 (https://www.goodrx.com/vyvanse https://www.goodrx.com/vyvanse) The last thing I will say is: Where is the data on a drug that annually generates billions of dollars each year? They have 10 million users. You are telling me they could not monitor the habits of 1-2k people over a couple years? Sounds fishy to me. For others who want to learn more about the crazy growth of add/adhd medication sales that very few want to talk about. (http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/15/health/the-selling-of-attention-deficit-disorder.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/15/health/the-selling-of-atte...)
- kazagistar 9y agoI have taken Adderalls twice in my life for longer periods of time, and both times it was no problem to stop. I stop taking it cold turkey, I feel a bit shitty for a week, and then its fine. If anything, it feels less addictive then caffine, which has worse physiological symptoms.
- DannyBee 9y agoThis article confusingly talks about atomoxetine in several places, but atomoxetine is very different than Adderall, in particular, because it's not a stimulant.
- sambe 9y agoThe article itself doesn't, some of the quotes from relevant papers do. It seems likely that studies are often done comparing treatments, and at least one of the quotes has context supporting that idea.
- DannyBee 9y agoNo, it very clearly mixes anecdotes from the papers about atomoxetine with those of amphetamine variants. It also lumps in "adhd drug" risk studies (which include plenty of non-stimulants) into a discussion about adderall and it's variants. Given the papers clearly state that some of these risks/issues are only appreciable for the amphetamine variants (and some only appreciable for the non-amphetamine drugs), this is, imho, a disservice.
- sambe 9y agoWhat do you mean "no"? The article literally never mentions atomoxetine outside of quoted text. It mentions it twice in the contextual part of quotes from papers also dealing with amphetamine variants. There is a single anecdote about atomoxetine. The quote has nothing to do with the drug's action. The point of the anecdote is the researchers' attitude toward the behaviour of young children, in the context of debating their approach to judging side-effects. That is certainly relevant context: the paper in question is also looking at side-effects for amphetamine variants. Strange approaches to behaviour classification likely apply across all the trials involved. Your original comment was that this is confusing. I think it's very clear. I am not left with the impression that results for atomoxetine are being conflated with results for amphetamine variants.
- csjr 9y agoAnyone here had luck with some kind of alternative treatment?
- firebird84 9y agoI was treated both as a child and as an adult. After I quit my adult medication I was a wreck, and ended up going to therapy. It wasn't specifically to address ADHD, but just me in general. I took a break from work, began eating well, sleeping well, and exercising, and I feel like I've gotten a lot better at focusing. My diet became more or less low-carb, and I did strength training. Could those be it? I don't know, but I feel a lot better and am more professionally accomplished than I ever was. There's my anecdote.
- tomjakubowski 9y agoI was diagnosed with moderate ADHD, inattentive type, as a teenager and prescribed adderall. I was also quite depressed, but I hid that from my psychiatrist. The adderall certainly helped me to focus, but the side effects were awful and I stopped taking it regularly. I’ve since been diagnosed with depression and started on sertraline (an SSRI), and very soon after noticed an improvement to my attention, ambition, and ability to complete tasks. It’s not surprising, I guess, but near-constant thoughts of worthlessness/desire to die can make it quite difficult to focus on tasks and generally function.
- triangleman 9y agoQBC (quercitin/bromelain/vitamin c) seems to have a very good effect on my attention span, ability to concentrate, anxiety levels, etc. However it does not go well with coffee, I get a "speedy" feeling I don't like. So unfortunately I don't take this supplement as much as I would like, because I love coffee so much. Other nutritional remedies can be found in "Prescription for Nutritional Healing" by Balch.
- leroy_masochist 9y agoI'd love to see Scott write one of these for modafinil (Provigil).
- saint_fiasco 9y agoSomebody asked him in the comments and he said Gwern wrote a good article on modafinil. https://www.gwern.net/Modafinil https://www.gwern.net/Modafinil
- AJ007 9y agoAny other managers notice that workers on Adderall will spend enormous amounts of time on totally non-productive or completely unrelated tasks?
- dogles 9y agoThis is not necessarily related to the medication. ADD often represents as hyperfocus, to the detriment of the things you should be focusing on. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperfocus https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperfocus
- thrwaway657 9y agoSorry but you're wrong, adderall is known to make people focus on inane things. This happens with ADD too, but it is more exaggerated and pronounced with adderall.
- comicjk 9y agoI do this all the time. I have been diagnosed with ADHD, but I'm not on any medication for it. I think you're confusing the treatment and the disease.
- tarboreus 9y agoI noticed this in college. My adderall-using friends and roommates would take a pill to study for a test, and sometimes that's exactly what they'd do. But sometimes they'd obsessively clean their room or get into a Wikipedia editing war or corner someone and talk their ear off about a pet topic.
- tr0ut 9y agoYes absolutely. Not a manager but I noticed this. I think there is also a state of mania involved. While not on these drugs you have a better sense of what is worth effort rather than this euphoric feeling of doing anything for the sake of it. Adderall and the like are not magic pills that make the most important work/tasks get done first and effectively.
- zschuessler 9y agoIf anyone here reading this needs the motivation or gentle reminder: you might not need Adderall anymore. I've used it to get ahead in software for the past ~8 years. I recently gave it up, but it was hard to realize that it was time. It might be time for you, too. The thing holding me back was fear. Fear I wasn't enough, that I couldn't be efficient. That I would get fired from my high position. Or even if I could make it work, that I still wouldn't get enough done on my startup (which has its own list of fears itself). What finally pushed me to quit was realizing I wasn't as compassionate anymore; it was impacting my relationships. I had three separate people tell me in my coworking space that I look too busy and unapproachable so they never came to chat. I had a SO tell me that I'm emotionally unavailable too often. All within the time span of a month. I'm naturally an optimistic, compassionate person. This wasn't me, and being a robot (as mentioned in the article!) wasn't who I wanted to be, at any cost. Indeed, three days after I quit I felt like a new person. I felt silly, fun, again. I had a week of "brain fog" where I wasn't productive. Afterward my efficiency went back up. Nowhere near the Adderall levels, but to a very acceptable level. So in summary, you might not need it anymore if it's causing you grief. Sorry for the lame motivational things I'm about to say (Taken from the book, Daring Greatly): You are enough. You are worthy.
- jasonlotito 9y agoDo you actually have ADHD? > I've used it to get ahead in software for the past ~8 years No, you don't. At least not from how you are describing your use. You don't take this medication to get ahead. You take this medication to get to an even playing field. To get some control over your life. So yes, if you are abusing drugs, don't. That's generally good advice. Don't abuse drugs.
- textor 9y agoLife is not a playing field full of fun and games, even though you could frame it in terms of game theory. People want to be successful, not to evaluate their "innate" performance against other people. Moral justification for doping is unimportant, because it's arbitrary. In reality, however many competing actors make me miserably insecure by their superiority, whatever is their percentile relative to the general sample, I wish to win, I wish be more than what I am all the same. Please read the article.
- ynonym00s 9y agoA friend of mine who has ADHD takes Vyvanse instead. Does it have similar risks?
- always_good 9y agoSure, it's just [a prodrug to] dextroamphetamine.
- chimeracoder 9y ago(Disclaimer: I've studied pharmacokinetics, though I'm not a pharmacologist) Vyvanse is a prodrug. That means it metabolizes into the d-enantiomer of amphetamine, whereas Adderall contains a 75-25 mixture of the d- and l-enantiomers. (Enantiomers are like left- and right-handed gloves: they have the same chemical structure, but one is the mirror image of the other. Usually two enantiomers will have similar but slightly different effects; occasionally, they can have incredibly different effects - see thalidomide for an example). So, without further study, it's hard to know, but it's likely that Vyvanse has a similar long-term profile to Adderall, because the active ingredient (lisdexamfetamine) metabolizes into the active ingredient that makes up about 75% of Adderall. But, it's possible that the effects described are caused by the l-enantiomer, in which case they won't apply to Vyvanse. It's also possible that lisdexamfetamine itself has its own set of effects which may either cancel out or exacerbate the effects reported by Adderall. To give you an idea of how prodrugs can have different effects from the drug that they metabolize into: Vyvanse does have a rather nasty feedback loop for some people, because amphetamines suppress the appetite, but lisdexamfetamine is metabolized into the active ingredient using the digestive cycle[0]. For some people, this can cause a really wonky extended release cycle, where they have no appetite mid-day (due to the drug) and can't eat enough to metabolize enough dextroamphetamine to get them through the afternoon, resulting in an afternoon crash. After this wears off and they develop an appetite again (around dinnertime), they'll eat, and then the dosage that was supposed to kick in after lunch finally kicks in after dinner, causing issues sleeping. [0] This is intentional, and it's why Vyvanse is marketed as an "abuse-resistant" alternative to Adderall, because it's theoretically harder to extract an acute dosage from it.
- Yvain 9y ago
- skywhopper 9y agoInteresting stuff. I was diagnosed with ADHD 12 years ago (after undergoing testing because I suspected I might). I tried various medications and after several years found that Adderall XR worked best. Tolerance is real, though, and I’ve had to increase my dose over the years, but I take half doses some days and skip when I can, which subjectively seems to help. The symptoms are definitely the sort of thing everyone can identify with to some extent. But I think the key detail in the definition of ADHD is that it’s a “disorder”. In other words, these symptoms are normally distributed but if the combination of them occurs often and causes distress to the patient and/or other people, then it’s real. Two people with exactly the same symptoms but different life situations or jobs such that one experiences distress and the other none should be diagnosed differently. Not everything can or should be reduced to objective ratings. I’d also like to echo the observation that the restrictions and hurdles involved in getting an ADHD diagnosis and in acquiring stimulant medication for ADHD are seemingly designed to vex the ADHD sufferer far more than a neurotypical individual. I used to have to, once a month, call my doctors office to ask for a new prescription, then physically go there to pick it up, physically deliver it to the pharmacy, and then physically pick up the medication when it was available. Which isn’t always right away since Adderall is so commonly prescribed (and because my health insurance has an insane restriction that only covers the brand name—but that’s a different story). That’s three or four steps not required for the vast majority of medication that are each easy for an ADHD sufferer to forget, put off, or otherwise screw up. Laws have changed where I live recently so that I only have to deal with the doctors office once every three months but the physical delivery is still a requirement. Thankfully I live near the doctors office and have a flexible job. Most people aren’t so lucky. So ironically it’s far easier for folks without ADHD to deal with getting Adderall than it is for those of us with the disorder. C’est la vie! Edit: I also wanted to mention that I’ve found that I’m actually much more agreeable and less irritable when I’m on Adderall than not. My family has witnessed the difference and told me as much, and I feel it too. Whether that’s a direct effect of the stimulant or a secondary effect of the behavioral changes it engenders I don’t know but it’s worth noting that the potential personality changes aren’t all negative.
- d2kx 9y agoI started taking Modafinil about 4-5 years ago and my only regret is that I didn't start earlier. I live in Europe so you can forget about amphetamines/adderall basically, only thing you'll get here is Ritalin and even that not as easy as you might think. Modafinil is easy to get on the internet though. If I lived in the US, I would likely be on Adderall I'd guess. It helped me so much that I wouldn't have completed studies and got my current job if I wasn't on it. I know, because I still remember the struggles I've had before (and over time learned that I am not alone, that many, many people suffer from ADHD-PI or ADHD-like symptoms and all think it's just them...). Also, fuck everyone trying to tell people that "eat better, sleep more and do sports" will fix ADHD-PI. You should totally do all of these if you aren't already, but it's not fixing shit. Medication works.
- Jhsto 9y agoI feel like comments like yours are one reason doctors don't like prescribing it. I'm glad you are able to be happy on modafinil, but think about what you just commented: (1) alternatives are hard to get, (2) you have to get your substitution from the Internet without a prescription, (3) once you are on the gear you are able to notice the same deficiency in others, (4) you attribute your success to it and (5) "fuck everyone" trying to speak people into drug-free alternatives. I haven't been to med school, but I can imagine this being a slide they would put into an example profile to stray people from prescribing Adderall et al.
- Yvain 9y agoThe reason doctors don't like prescribing it is because it's not FDA-approved for ADHD. It's not FDA-approved for ADHD because of bureaucratic/economic reasons, AFAIK.
- drngdds 9y ago>"fuck everyone" trying to speak people into drug-free alternatives. It's actually really annoying being told that you don't need drugs to fix your condition when, based on your own experience, you really do
- adderaldecade 9y ago
- rdlecler1 9y agoI was high school dropout turned Yale PhD. I was prescribed for either Adderall or Ritalin for about 20 years starting in my second year of University. The two main side effects I had from Adderall were appetite suppression (which has the bonus side effect of intermitent fasting) and hyper focus. With hyper focus I could work like a machine for 14-16 hours, and would have to remind myself to stop and eat, but I couldn’t turn it off. When it came time to socialize I was still chewing away at my work. I was not present. To break myself from the work loop I would usually have to watch TV or go drinking with friends. The problem with the later is that you start to wake up with the dreads quite frequently, increasing your anxiety level. It also tires you out. I rarely (1-2/month) take Adderall now and when I do I take 5mg (down from 3x 20mg what I was originally prescribed for). Ritalin was a different story. Where Adderall was smooth and almost unnoticeable Ritalin would give you a rush, with effects lasting about four hours. I could take Adderall for my most boating early morning class and sitting in the front row I was excited as seeing a talk by novel prize winners. The problem with Ritalin was the anxiety and crash at the end of the day. Prescribing stimulants to people with ADHD seems artificial. In most cases the risks are low and unless there’s abuse or the potential for abuse I think people should have the right to decide for themeselves what they want to take and how they want to live.
- dilap 9y agoThat's how I feel about drugs in general, but I think society has this weird split of two extremes: any unprescribed, street drug is super dangerous and evil, and any prescribed drug is just just medicine correcting an "imbalance", and is totally benign and fine and good. Madness both ways. You mention getting prescribed in college, as a adult. How would you feel if you had been prescribed as a kid? To me, growing up regularly taking amphetamines seems like it could twist your head pretty badly. Seems very irresponsible to be giving drugs to kids. (I get the pressure to do it if the kid can't behave or focus and you think that's fucking up their life, but honestly, having gone through school, the fault is much more likely to lie with the school & what we expect of kids than the kids themselves...)
- rdlecler1 9y agoI’d avoid perscription drugs for my kids if possible. For me, ADD was a kind of personality trait that affected how I looked at and reacted to the world. It had pros and cons. Adderall helped me deal with the cons when the time was right. I wouldnt try to take that away from my children. Also knowing what I know I could probably be a better parent to children with ADD.
- wolco 9y agoCurious if anyone is using weed flowers or extracts to treat these any related issues? Some strains are known to help focus the mind. I found using some strains help the ability to switch to a new task and focus for a longer period of time. The problem is the next hour after the body needs additional rest.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Zenbit_UX 9y agoI'm pretty sure that ADHD without hyperactivity is ADD.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoNo, the DSM changed it so there is only ADHD, with subtypes of predominantly hyperactive and predominantly inattentive.
- stryk 9y agoAdderall is amphetamine salts. It's f*king SPEED. Laboratory-grade SPEED. (yea, yea methamphetmine is delivered in higher concentrations when being abused, but I don't care Adderall is still goddamn SPEED -- and people give this shit to their kids!) It's not that far off from "meth minus the battery acid." Why on Earth anyone would want to give that shit to their own kids is beyond me, especially since it's often offered as a remedy to one of the MOST over- and mis-diagnosed conditions there is.
- ma2rten 9y agoIn addition to lower doses like you said, effects of stimulates like amphetamines are completely different if taken orally than if they are sniffed or injected. ADHD is one of the most well researched mental conditions. It is real and will cause significant impairment if untreated. Stimulants are the most effective medication in many but not all cases. Comments like that are harmful. However, I agree with you that an ADHD diagnosis should not be given lightly.
- stryk 9y agoI wasn't implying ADHD wasn't real. It very much is real, but unfortunately it seems to have become a sort of "catch-all" diagnosis. It's now more of a common label than it is a medical diagnosis. Isn't it equally as dangerous to not treat the underlying issues or root causes? And when the common 'treatment' for a hyper-active disorder diagnosis is a prescription for Adderall/Vivanse (again, this is speed with a fancy brand name. call it what it is) it's incredibly dangerous -- these are KIDS we're talking about, there's no way we've had enough time to tell what giving this shit to a brain that's still under development actually does in the long term. Then there's the very real potential for abuse -- we're already in an opioid epidemic in the USA do we really need a bunch of tweaked out kids running around?
- ma2rten 9y agoIf there is another root cause then it isn't ADHD. As I already said I agree with you that one should be careful in diagnosing ADHD.
- emodendroket 9y agoIt seems to me like the biggest problem, if I'm to accept that Adderall is as frequently abused as described here, is the same one you have in sports with PEDs: if a bunch of people are on Adderall and establish the "baseline" level of attention you're supposed to have, then "just" being diligent gets you left in the dust.
- ryanianian 9y agoThe article doesn't really describe it being "abused," just perhaps too "easy" of an option for some who really could "just try harder". (By "easy" I mean prescribed or requested with the "sure why not" attitude without reviewing the side-effects which the author lays out pretty plainly.) I don't find the sports analogy very compelling. We watch sports for the competition and the idea that the results are a combination of genetics+work. Hence taking PEDs is cheating in a sports context. But if there's a medication that helps you live your life better (i.e. in a way that's more fulfilling to you) and if taking the medication doesn't impact anyone else negatively, why would you not want it taken as widely as possible? The important thing is to let would-be medication-takers know with full honesty what the side-effects are - this is what the article focuses on most.
- emodendroket 9y agoThe article talks about people's careers being stymied, or people losing promotions to, colleagues whose attention span is longer because they're abusing Adderall. That's the intro. > The human brain wasn’t built for accounting or software engineering. A few lucky people can do these things ten hours a day, every day, with a smile. The rest of us start fidgeting and checking our cell phone somewhere around the thirty minute mark. I work near the financial district of a big city, so every day a new Senior Regional Manipulator Of Tiny Numbers comes in and tells me that his brain must be broken because he can’t sit still and manipulate tiny numbers as much as he wants. How come this is so hard for him, when all of his colleagues can work so diligently? > (it’s because his colleagues are all on Adderall already – but telling him that will just make things worse) > He goes on to give me his story about how he’s at risk of getting fired from his Senior Regional Manipulator Of Tiny Numbers position, and at this rate he’s never going to get the promotion to Vice President Of Staring At Giant Spreadsheets, so do I think I can give him some Adderall to help him through? I don't see the problem with the analogy.
- aidenn0 9y agoI'm fairly severely ADHD, and Adderall does not work for me. As in I was getting psychedelic effects before reaching a therapeutic dose. Ritalin is better, and Focalin better still (same effect as ritalin, lower side effects).
- ryanianian 9y agoIt's surprising how the different medications can affect people with seemingly similar symptoms. Ritalin (and Vyvanse) makes me feel angry and crazy. I've not heard of Focalin, but I may look into it. I've been on varying doses of Adderall for 10+ years and I find it immensely helpful.
- specialist 9y agoI used Ritalin as a crutch after radiation. It helped. Sometimes quite a bit. Recovery time span was 6 months. Now the Ritalin helps less, meaning I barely feel it's effects; so now I'm taking one or two pills weekly. I'd love to have some effective nootropics for improved focus, cognition. Mostly to mitigate aging, grogginess from the chemo, and so forth.
- zachruss92 9y agoI wanted to share my experience with Adderall. I've been taking it for about 2 months now. Some backstory. I was diagnosed with ADHD when I was about 12. I never had an issue focusing in school. I never had any challenges completing my school work and would always complete it before everyone else. I would then get bored and fidget. It got to the point where it was a distraction to others and was brought to my parents' attention. I was then diagnosed with ADHD. I was never given any formal treatment, instead placed in a Gifted program with more intensive work. I have been running my own businesses and consulting pretty much since I graduated high school. I am now 25. Things were going pretty good, except for one thing, deadlines. I struggled actually focusing and completing work. It got to the point where I could be working in my office for 12 hours straight and not actually get anything done. The other major part of it is how it affects my relationships, especially with my SO. We can be holding a conversation and I can completely zone out for minutes at a time and not have any clue what she said because I was in my own head thinking. It is stressful because it gives the impression that I don't care what she is saying, but in reality I have limited to no control over it. This is common from others I speak with who have ADHD. I have tried every management system in the book. None of it helped. I eventually tried Modafinil (I see a few people mentioned it here). I ultimately stopped taking it because I didn't like how it made me feel (restlessness and appetite loss) and I didn't get immense boosts to concentration. I eventually decided that I may want to try Adderall. My doctor was suggesting that I may want to try something for over a year, but I resisted. In my mind Adderall was prescription meth and would "rot my brain". I would be come addicted and it would ruin my life. But things just kept getting worse. My business keeps growing, and so are my responsibilities and deadlines, but I was really struggling to keep up. Finally, I decided to open my mind to taking something like Adderall. After discussing it with my Doctor he alleviated most of my concerns. Ritalin and subsequently Adderall have been prescribed for almost 70 years and he has been prescribing them for decades without seeing "brain rot", withdraw, or anything like that long-term. After more research and discussing it with colleagues I decided to take it. Here are my thoughts and observations 2 months in. * It's not addictive. I take it 1-2x a day when working, and not on weekends. I skipped 5 days of doses over Christmas without feeling the need to take it. * Tolerance. You will get a euphoric effect the first 1-2x you take it, then you don't anymore. You still get the concentration benefits and that doesn't wear off over time - according to my doctor. I don't feel the need to increase dosages. * It has a propensity for abuse. Basically people taking it to stay up for days at a time to study for exams... I can see where people would have the urge to do so, though I do not. * It helps me concentrate. While it's not a magic solution to all of my problems, it makes it easier for me to be able to work and continue working for a long period of time. My productivity the past to months have been more than I ever have in the past 5 years. * It lowers your appetite. I feel like I perpetually ate 30 minutes ago. I need to consciously decide to eat, which I do. * It gives me dry mouth. This is annoying, no matter how much I drink. * It can affect sleep. To counteract this I take mine when I first wake up, then at 12pm I take either a full dose, half dose, or nothing depending on my day. TLDR: It has helped me improve the quality of my life with no real negative effects. If Adderall continues to do so, I will continue to take it.
- nihilum 9y agoCopying in a post from Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/Nootropics/comments/7n2qjz/adderall_risks_much_more_than_you_wanted_to_know/dryyotz/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Nootropics/comments/7n2qjz/adderall... He cited the infamous squirrel monkey study without noting that (a) there were no signs of neural death or neurite retraction anywhere, and (b) reduced baseline dopamine levels are exactly what you would expect as part of the mechanism of tolerance. That study did not establish the existence of neurotoxicity. It merely established the existence of tolerance.
- Madmallard 9y agoI think in many cases the reason people can't maintain focus on programming is motivation, not incapacity. Sounds like bullshit when they say most lose focus after 30 minutes and check their phone. If you're really interested in something you focus on it. Yeah I struggle to focus writing CRUD apps for unsexy products. But I wrote a puzzler game in twenty nonstop hours. I know this is anecdotal but I've seen the same with friends A exercising, B playing videogames, C reading, D playing music.
- valuearb 9y agoI take straight amphetamines, much easier to manage dosing than with Adderal. Been doing to off and on for a decade. Never had any addiction issues, no withdrawal sypmptoms when I skip taking them, and still seems as an effective as usual when i do. I avoid the whole psychiatrist scam and get them from a real doctor.